5 ms·
Personally, I find these miss one of the key points. Today, we can kill everyone off with an exchange of the already existing nuclear weapon inventory. But tha
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Personally, I find these miss one of the key points.
Today, we can kill everyone off with an exchange of the already existing nuclear weapon inventory. But that requires a reasonably large number of people to make mistakes or take action.
We're in the process of killing everyone off by screwing up the natural climate process which requires a large number of people to commit to inaction.
Within this century we will have the means and the understanding for a single individual to craft a DNA based pathogen that can infect and kill nearly everyone on the planet.
These are the three tests for graduation into the club of "long lived intelligent species." Fail any one of them and you don't make it. I call them:
* Action of the group
* Inaction of the group
* Action of the individual
We apparently passed test 1, we're not doing so well on test 2, and we'll have to be a lot better at eradicating hate in individuals if we want to have a hope of passing test #3.
- Erik816 10y agoLet's hope it's a lot harder than you think to reach step three. If we ever reach a point where a lone actor can destroy humanity, we're pretty well screwed. You would have to ensure that 100% of the people with that ability didn't want to use it 100% of the time.
- contravariant 10y agoLuckily the number of people who want to exterminate all of humanity seems to be rather low. Which just leaves the people who want to exterminate part of humanity.
- adrianN 10y agoI'm hopeful that once technology like gene editing that has that potential is so cheap and easy that a significant fraction of the people can do it, the same technology that enables them to create killer viruses also enables everyone else to cure them more effectively.
- arcticfox 10y agoIt's beside the point, but IMO the human species is at almost zero risk of extinction from climate change. Maybe you could find a better example. The worst case would certainly be a calamity, but it would require an immense amount of additional failure for humanity to actually go extinct from it.
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoThere's a difference between biological extinction and cultural extinction. Cultures are incredibly fragile, and the chances of developing current levels of science and technology again if we lost them aren't all that great. As for runaway climate change - it's definitely a possibility. Current models don't try to estimate potential coupling between the effects of methane and CO2. It doesn't seem to be considered likely. But a lot of scientists are already surprised by the speed and scale of climate change, and the fact that we're seeing effects in a decade or two that weren't expected until the end of the century. Worries about runaway climate change may be pessimistic, but they're certainly not unscientific. Considering the stakes, more research would be wise.
- danieltillett 10y agoIf we had loss of technological knowledge (say due to climate change induced conflict), it might not be possible in the future for the surviving humans to re-bootstrap back up to our our current technological level. We have exhausted all the easily accessible minerals and fossil fuels (i.e. those resources that can be extracted using stone age tools). Any break in our current technological systems might make it impossible to recover for 10s of millions of years.
- epicureanideal 10y agoLike the article posted last week titled "this is not a place of honor" about making obvious markers on nuclear waste to last 10,000 years... We may also want to invest in creating some "breadcrumbs" for a future civilization to build up from. Say, a reserve of easily accessible fossil fuel and other raw materials, and some long-lasting guideposts that indicate where to find them.
- hugh4 10y ago> Today, we can kill everyone off with an exchange of the already existing nuclear weapon inventory I'm not convinced we can. For starters, the nuclear weapon inventory is a lot smaller than it was back in the 80s when those sorts of statements were popular. And secondly, as I understand it, it was always a bit of a lie, an estimate based on some silly assumptions (e.g. that everybody in the world lives in cities), which in repetition eventually lost those assumptions. And yes, I agree with the other poster that it's pretty much impossible to kill everyone on earth with climate change. Species-ending diseases I do worry about, but maybe that just means I don't know as much about immunology as I do about nuclear weapons.
- sehugg 10y agoRecent research has shown that nuclear winter after even a limited exchange would be worse than previously thought. We don't know how/if our technological society would bounce back from N billion starvation deaths.
- hoodoof 10y agoThe U.K., U.S. and Russia have already bombed the world with hundreds of atmospheric nuclear weapons in the mid 20th century. In effect there was a nuclear war, it's just that all the bombs were exploded on "friendly territory" like Australia, the pacific islands and Nevada.
- pizza 10y agoHaaS: Humanity as a Service PaaS: Panspermia as a Service "Like Dropbox, but with DNA"
- Dr_tldr 10y agoWhat makes you such an expert on long lived intelligent species? As far as I know, we're all working from the same sample size of one, with a written history and cultural memory that are evolutionarily insignificant. For all we know, it may be the only long term path of survival for an intelligent species is to accept absolute dictatorship of a genocidal/eugenicist bent. I hope it's not, but if the 20th century's taught us anything, it's that any kind of non-evidence based wishful thinking towards an abstract ideal is probably the most dangerous thing.
- adrianN 10y agoThe three points he listed are pretty obvious requirements if you want a long lived species. You don't need a large sample size to know that not killing yourself by failing at one of those three is important.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoA Phd from Trump University? :-) Seriously though, I don't (and did not) make that claim. I merely state my observation that as technology has advanced it has created opportunities for species annihilation that are both "controlled" by our species and do not exist for nominally 'unintelligent' species.[1] That said, I'd be interested to understand how you reason from "the 20th century's teachings" to "absolute dictatorship of a genocidal bent". I would also like to understand the characterization of 'non-evidence based wishful thinking'. Happy to walk through the reasoning behind global thermonuclear war resulting in extinction, and sudden massive climate change resulting in the same. Similarly the reasoning for an individually created pandemic can be traced back to the general availability of DNA printers[2] and the ever increasing understanding of genetics and how one might use viruses modify the genetics of living humans [3]. [1] Trust me, the last thing I'd want to do is get into an argument about what constitutes sentience. [2] http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/05/07/404460240/dna-printing-a-big-boon-to-research-but-some-raise-concerns http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2015/05/07/40446024... [3] https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/therapy/genetherapy https://ghr.nlm.nih.gov/primer/therapy/genetherapy
- Dr_tldr 10y ago