13 ms·
Why Do Islands Induce Dwarfism?
- joe_the_user 10y agoI think regular human size can vary a lot by level of resource consumption - the principle being the larger the mother, the larger fetus and so the larger the resulting adult. Obviously, if a height increase/decrease trend continued for a while, one assumes genetic variations which aided this would be selected for but it seems that the change itself doesn't necessarily need genetic as such. See height increases in Japan: http://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/01/world/tokyo-journal-the-japanese-it-seems-are-outgrowing-japan.html http://www.nytimes.com/2001/02/01/world/tokyo-journal-the-ja...
- liquidise 10y agoI believe the N vs S Korea example supports this theory as well.
- potatote 10y agoFrom my observation, I notice that a lot of younger generation Chinese adults are likely to be taller than their older fellow country people as well. I have many Chinese coworkers and even the female coworkers are at least 5 feet 5 inches or taller (for young male coworkers, they are usually at least 5 feet 8-10 inches). Nutrition certainly plays a big role in determining one's height.
- donatj 10y agoReading this I had a silly thought: "What if we are the 'giants' of old ?"
- Razengan 10y agoWell height variation still occasionally occurs within all populaces everywhere. "Giants" and "dwarves" as a distinct race was probably a drunken glimpse of different looking people from other villages, in a dark wood or the like. A related thought is that if there ever was any other intelligent species on Earth, noticeably different than humans, we wiped them out long ago.
- chillacy 10y agoBut given that in fantasy, all the populations seem to be technically the same species (hence able to breed half-elves, half-dwarves, quarter-veelas, etc), the another likely outcome is that the variation would go away over time
- Aelinsaar 10y agoFor a second I read that as, "Quarter-Veals" and my confusion was total.
- bduerst 10y agoFollowing this thought experiment, it could be that half-breeds are sterile hybrids and can't reproduce, kind of like mules (horse + donkey). Then you wouldn't get genetic normalization. If they have a different number of chromosomes it's likely.
- roywiggins 10y agoHybrid speciation can happen, where the hybrids don't breed with the parent species but do with each other.
- bbcbasic 10y agoWith mules?
- maxerickson 10y agoI guess not really, but a search for "fertile mule" shows lots of resources discussing female mules giving birth. (which I think illustrates the complexity more than it does anything else)
- roywiggins 10y agoNo. Mostly plants. But, there are some interesting animal examples. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_speciation#Known_cases_of_hybrid_speciation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hybrid_speciation#Known_cases_...
- giancarlostoro 10y agoBiblical giants? They were half fallen angel, half human. Not many Christians (and maybe even Jews) believe this, but if you study the context of Genesis 6 and the rest of the Bible anytime it speaks of Noah's flood and judging of angels, they coincide (especially in the New Testament in the book of Jude) then there's the Book of Enoch, which isn't in protestant or Catholic Bibles, but the Ethiopians have it in theirs, and it speaks about how the angels took human wives to themselves. The Liger hybrid species explains scientifically the nephelim (or Giants) hybrid species to some degree, how it can be so massive is explained by the DNA. These are the views of some Christians, but again, assuming Biblical giants, there's a lot of different factors into play.
- moultano 10y agoMan, it would be so amazing if we could somehow attribute ancient stories of dwarfs, trolls, giants, to humans meeting other hominid species that we coexisted with.
- digi_owl 10y agoOr encountered the remains of, as seems to have been the case of dinosaurs becoming dragons.
- jbattle 10y agoAlong those lines ... http://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/mythic-creatures/land-creatures-of-the-earth/griffin-bones/ http://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/mythic-creatures/land-creatu...
- clock_tower 10y agoFrom what I've heard, dinosaur bones tended to be taken for the bones of giants, at least in the Middle Ages. Dragons were much older than any awareness of dinosaurs; most medieval myths about dragons trace back to the draco standard carried by late-Roman cavalry. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draco_%28military_standard%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Draco_%28military_standard%29 .) This, by the way, means that there really were dragons in sub-Roman parts of the Dark Ages world: Wales and Cornwall, for example, where draco-bearing cavalry (including King Arthur's, if there was a King Arthur) were fielded probably until the 600s or 700s.
- hammock 10y agoWouldn't the biggest factor simply be limited resources? The same reason why the average man was 5 inches shorter in 1750 than he is today.
- duaneb 10y agoActually, Foster's rule indicates that predation being the main threat leads to smaller animals, while the restriction of resources being the main threat leads to larger animals. > The same reason why the average man was 5 inches shorter in 1750 than he is today. This is more likely dietary changes than resource restriction—we may not have had industrial farming, but the average person wasn't starving either. But you need access to plentiful, high levels of protein to maximize your height advantage.
- omalleyt 10y agoFoster's rule is actually the reverse of that. Which can be seen intuitively because non-human predators pick off the weakest and smallest of the pack.
- taneq 10y agoThis depends on the size of the animals in question compared with the largest practical size for an animal in that environment. Large animals will get larger, because this improves their chance of fighting back against similar-sized predators (think lion vs. antelope). Small animals will get smaller, because this allows them to evade much-larger predators (think cat vs. mouse).
- jdmichal 10y ago> But you need access to plentiful, high levels of protein to maximize your height advantage. Hence a resource restriction?
- jsprogrammer 10y agoProbably the same reason storms on Jupiter are larger than storms on earth. You can't be bigger than your container.
- Negative1 10y agoIntriguing. I wonder then; does this mean our spacefaring descendants will be smaller for the very reasons outlined in the article?
- Razengan 10y agoDoesn't low (or lack of) gravity decompress the spine or something, inducing a very slight increase in the height of current astronauts?
- zardo 10y agoIts not that slight. 2-3 inches
- MoonUnitZappa 10y agoMany suspect spacefaring will require us to become quite small indeed. It will become ridiculously uncompetitive to drag around a meat body and pressurized environment. Think of something like The Field Circus from Charles Stross's "Accelerando".
- theoh 10y agoSeems like only a tiny crazy subset of humans will ever want to give up the freedoms of having a meat body and being able to move it in a pleasant atmosphere. After all, what's there to do in interstellar space? The idea of turning ourselves into space probes is a dystopian, inhuman proposition.
- happyslobro 10y agoJust finished binge watching The Expanse. There, the first generations of offworlders grow very tall, thin and weak. Clearly, there is a strong evolutionary pressure on them to grow much smaller, and fix their spongy bones. Imagine the difference between a small child and a 7 foot tall weakling with osteoporosis, accelerating at 12 Gs in an emergency situation. Btw, the show was fairly good, imo. Deep, and nearly hard SF.
- oewae6Zo 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- anonemu 10y agoI don't know, Polynesians and Samoans seem plenty large to me.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoYes, but they've been living there for only a few hundred years, or a couple thousand at most. The article was referring to populations living in island environments for much longer durations.
- aab0 10y agoThey also have a very different food, cultural, and military environment than the isolated hobbits would.
- nordsieck 10y agoPolynesians and Samoans traveled between islands, often by rowing.
- sunstone 10y agoImagine the Komodo Dragon on a continent. Yikes!
- UhUhUhUh 10y agoMaybe the principle that height is also proportional to speed should be taken into account?
- taksintikk 10y agoAlthough they are representational of all islands, Tonga and Samoa disagree.
- sushid 10y agoIslands can also induce gigantism [0]. My understanding is that is the microcosm allows certain species to thrive or perish and we see a more dramatic change in size as a result. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_gigantism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Island_gigantism
- gcatlin 10y agoSee also Foster's Rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foster%27s_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foster%27s_rule
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- FuturePromise 10y agoAre there more dwarfs on Manhattan and Long Island? It doesn't seem like it.
- trhway 10y agothe foxes example is interesting as there are foxes everywhere, and the further into the CA or African desert or into Arctic - the smaller the foxes are. Pure thermodynamics - like surface/volume ratio - would suggest otherwise. It most probably has to deal with [lesser] reliability of food availability, similar like in islands case.
- davnn 10y agoWhat's funny is that, for us humans, the whole planet is kind of a big island today isn't it? (Edit: not everywhere ofc) I wonder how large humans will get in a number of generations from now. Found an interesting article about that topic: http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20150513-will-humans-keep-getting-taller http://www.bbc.com/future/story/20150513-will-humans-keep-ge... Looks like we are record holders in height already, let's see how far we can get!
- contingencies 10y agoIdeas: (1) Richest foraging environment may be out in the open on the shoreline. If any other predators are present, or even if there is simply harsh environmental exposure (sun/wind) then a smaller physical size to take advantage of shelter may be advantageous. (2) Mountainous interiors. I believe it is well documented that short people have better luck climbing and descending steep slopes due to a lower center of gravity. (3) Low dietary variation or reliance on foraged protein rather than large land mammals. (4) Safety from predators may lead to a younger age of reproduction, accelerating change.
- xbryanx 10y agoAspects of this island evolution were part of the plot in the marvelously detailed sci-fi book from Kim Stanley Robinson: Aurora. TLDR: Interstellar multi-generation spaceships are essentially genetic islands.
- adamfeldman 10y agoJust finished this novel. Great hard sci-fi space opera.
- ascotan 10y agoIt's the bottleneck effect duh. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_bottleneck https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Population_bottleneck As others have noted Polynesians are huge and didn't turn into dwarves.
- bechampion 10y agoI live in England , this is true.