8 ms·
Welcome to the world of financial regulations! You may have not realised but banks and any financial institutions have been deputised by the regulators to be t
by cm2187 10y ago
Welcome to the world of financial regulations!
You may have not realised but banks and any financial institutions have been deputised by the regulators to be the financial police. They need to ensure that none of their client use financial services to commit crimes or launder the proceeds of a crime, under the penalty of heavy (up to multi billions) fines. Particularly in the US.
I am pretty sure this is what is forcing paypal to do this. And also why I wish good luck to startups who think they will disrupt this massively over regulated industry.
- ckastner 10y ago> Welcome to the world of financial regulations! > You may have not realised but banks and any financial institutions have been deputised by the regulators to be the financial police. They need to endure that none of their client use financial services to commit crimes or launder the proceeds of a crime, under the penalty of heavy (up to multi billions) fines. Particularly in the US. While I fully agree with this statement, PayPal's actions here seem excessive even by the broadest interpretations of anti-money-laundering regulations. Furthermore, AML regulations target a specific set of transactions and/or individuals. "Monitoring all traffic for illegal content" is a vague statement that could mean anything. Illegal where? Illegal how? Edit: I forgot to mention: PayPal operates as a credit institution (ie, a bank) within the EU, so the strict AML regulations the parent alluded to apply to it directly.
- cynicalkane 10y agoIn the US, at least, AML regulations are whatever the regulators say they are.
- mcherm 10y agoI call BS on that. It is true that banks will go a long way to try to satisfy banking regulators. But unless you have some evidence I am simply unwilling to believe that banking regulators can make up any restrictions they like without regard for the actual requirements of federal law.
- lettergram 10y agoComing from a bank (but with limited interaction with regulators), regulators usually try to work within the law. However, I would like to remind you the law is all contradicting and has literally tens if not hundreds of thousands of various laws each one with its own implications. Point being, regulators can justify just about anything. That is why all large banks have an army of lawyers. They then work with regulators to find some middle ground.
- ckastner 10y agoBut unless you have some evidence I am simply unwilling to believe that banking regulators can make up any restrictions they like without regard for the actual requirements of federal law. The actual requirements of federal law are often (intentionally) formulated on such a high level that in practice, the banking regulator does end up specifying the actual rules. Say, for example, a federal law requires that banks "take reasonable measures to impede money laundering". Now what those "reasonable measures" are is usually determined by the overseeing regulator (eg: the SEC). Sure, you can disagree with their assessment, but they'll fine you anyway and then, the best-case scenario is that after X years in court, the fine gets overturned.
- 794CD01 10y agoNot only is that true, it's usually not even the regulators that are making up the final actionable items. Businesses hire independent auditors who need to make sure their clients are well clear of what the regulators would be concerned with, and so push them to go even farther. And of course, once you have passed one audit, the next year's audit will be even more strict, even if the regulations themselves have not changed. The auditors do need to justify their own employment, after all.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoDon't respond to hyperbole to hyperbole. GP was making a vague reference to Rulemaking. You should be willing to educate yourself, not be https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rulemaking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rulemaking
- cynicalkane 10y ago
- Bartweiss 10y agoPaypal seems to have a long and ugly history of aggressive-yet-incoherent legal interpretations. They lock down donations to any unpopular group, and refuse to release already-held funds. They freeze Kickstarter campaigns as soon as someone says the word "fraud", and cause the exact damage they're trying to prevent by tying up all the funds so neither backers nor creators can get the money. They're incredibly capricious, and as far as I can tell have taken the stance that overcaution is always acceptable.
- greenleafjacob 10y agoPaypal has lost tons of money to fraud, and with the margins they have it's not surprising they err on the side of caution.
- dogma1138 10y agoBecause PayPal doesn't want to lose money from customers that use their complaint system or worse through chargeback from the credit card companies. As far as donations for dubious causes goes well if they think that it will either lose them business due to reputation, or worse lose them money if a government decides to freeze those funds they will cut it off. PayPal for the most part is not a fractional lender when you have a 1000$ in a PayPal account PayPal has to reserve the full amount, PayPal isn't protected from a run over by central banks and what limited protection it has is probably performed by underwriters at not the most beneficial of terms. If some one is opening a donation account for ISIS, anti LGBT or w/e you might call an "unpopular cause" and that either causes them a huge PR headache or worse a government decides to freeze those funds they lose a lot of money. This can be complicated even further since while the funds are frozens the users who transferred these funds might be eligible for protection under PayPal's own policies and if not then they can always initiate a chargeback from their own credit card company.
- therealmarv 10y agoyeah. USA. But this is Germany and EU and you violate either PayPal terms or the laws of the country.
- Arnt 10y agoThat doesn't seem entirely clear. For example, Seafile could have said "Files are accessible only to one customer. It is of course possible to share passwords. However, we use geoip to monitor the number of locations used by each customer, and take appropriate action when a customer's set is oddly large. This should effectively block the use of Seafile for piracy." Perhaps Paypal would have said no, but perhaps yes.
- Canada 10y agoI don't agree that Seafile should be under any obligation to do that. If customers want to share files, let them. Storage services shouldn't ever look at what the files contain or their metadata. edit: looks like paypal openly states it won't process for file sharing services who don't monitor content. I guess most services that don't have a high dispute rate...
- Arnt 10y agoLast year I saw a customer (not at Seafile) who accessed our (paid) service from 20 different countries on the same day. Do you think that customer travelled to all those countries on that day? Do you think we were wrong to look for such globetrotting customers? Do you think we were wrong, or Seafile would be wrong, to look for customers who share their account with their hundred best friends?
- gpm 10y agoIt could be a single customer, Tor, proxies, etc exist. Further analysis of usage patterns could rule this out (with very high probability) though. As for 'were you wrong', no, not if you ruled out the above. That doesn't make it something that you should have to do though.
- mathattack 10y agoHave they been deputized into service or pressed into mandatory service? My understanding is that the Know Your Client (KYC) laws are mandatory, with multi-billion dollar fines for companies who violate them. (HSBC has gotten into trouble with this recently)
- ckastner 10y agoCorrect, it's mandatory service. I think what the grandparent meant to say with being "deputized to be the financial police" is that the extent of this mandatory service has become so substantial that financial institutions often are left with the feeling that they are performing work (at their own expense) which feels like work that law enforcement should be doing. It used to be that law enforcement pointed out the bad guys, or even just suspects, to you. Now, you're supposed to identify and report possible bad guys to law enforcement. There's nothing wrong with that on principle, of course, but in practice, every bank must now train some personnel to detect not only suspicious individuals or transactions, but even suspicious patterns of transactions. And that's when you start feeling like you've been deputized -- it feels like you are performing a criminil investigation on behalf of others.
- boldfield 10y agoI worked for a financial services related startup for a while and was involved in implementing KYC/AML protections and AFAIK there isn't any relation between this and those laws. KYC is simply identifying your customers (nothing related to what they are doing) e.g. drivers license info, home address, etc. AML has to do with financial instruments passing through a business' account from customer (a) to customer (b) (in some cases (a) and (b) being the same individual). Given they are processing subscriptions here it seems far more likely that this is somehow related to RIAA/MPAA, or at least a fear of said groups.
- ckastner 10y agoKYC is simply identifying your customers That's the minimum, but it's certainly not all there is to it. Know Your Customer really means know your customer. As one of many practical examples, when dealing with a legal entity such a trust, merely identifying its officers is insufficient -- you must also identify the beneficial owner (BO). Effectively, this means that you have to look through all possible shell companies until you arrive at a natural person.
- kolbe 10y agoI don't know if you want to advertise lack of enforcement so loudly. Your practices would leave you to vulnerable to litigation if one of your customers were laundering money or committing crimes through your service. You've done enough to survive an audit if there have been no issues, but you'd be found negligent if there are.
- Zancarius 10y agoTo be fair, boldfield did say "worked for ... for a while" which implies they're no longer with the company (which might be a story in its own right). Still, it's good advice for others chiming in who may presently be in the same position.
- dogma1138 10y agoIt's not about onboarding/general KYC since this isn't about end users. Paypal does it's own risk assessment for business partners, what I'm pretty sure this is is a simple "classification" case. Paypal classifies the type of business you are and if you belong to certain types of businesses they put some requirements on you based on regulations and their own internal requirements usually produced by their legal department. Paypal has probably seen what happened to file sharing websites like Mega and if you are tagged as a file sharing service they want to ensure that you do everything to prevent it being used for piracy, including being able to audit it themselves and to be able to either put pressure on you or cut off their services if they think they are at too much of a risk. Now I understand that Seafile isn't anything like Mega but It's also not exactly on the scale of dropbox this also means that most likely no one at Paypal really knows what it is, or where they are heading business wise and so they just stick some additional requirements on them. Also (this is true for 2-3 years ago, I don't know if it is still the case) filesharing websties and other sites that you can buy "premium currency" such as various online games, vidoe chat apps (usually porgnography) etc. are the main source of fraud for compromised accounts as far as Paypal goes this on it's own can bring on additional requirements from Paypal.
- zymhan 10y agoThere are well founded reasons for financial regulation. Predatory lending, money laundering, scams, terrorism funding, etc.
- scottmmjackson 10y ago> They need to ensure that none of their client use financial services to commit crimes There are also laws that give financial institutions due diligence obligations to ensure they're not facilitating "unsanctioned boycotts".
- djsumdog 10y agoCrimes. Yes. But payday loan companies and credit cards that charge 29% interest plus hundreds of dollars in feeds to "help people with poor credit" are fine. Supporting US government entities in defense that kill tons of innocent people every day; that's fine too. Self regulating? Man that works so well, especially in 2008. We're going to let you keep doing that too. Weed stores in states where it's legal? Hi it's the DEA. We're confiscating these accounts for you. Here's a fine (at least until later this year, but still only for medicinal marijuana) It's a cluster fuck of bullshit. Of course you can always use a different payment provider, but with PayPal being just so damn easy with very little competition, it's like saying if Amazon removed your eBook, just publish it somewhere else. The trouble is the distribution networks are so big that they become the only means of distribution. If you control 90% of the market and shut down a DropBox competitor, you're choosing which companies succeed.
- adventured 10y ago> Self regulating? Man that works so well, especially in 2008. What self regulating existed in 2008? Banking and finance have been hyper regulated for decades. There are no industries more regulated than those. There was no self-regulating and you won't be able to point to any substantial self-regulating that caused the housing bubble and crash (unless you're talking about the Fed's low interest rate policies). The SEC, Fed, FHA, CFPB, and Treasury were intentionally looking the other way while vast fraud was occurring because all of the voters were getting rich off of housing and stock market bubbles. The Fed was laughing during their meetings about the bubble, you can read the minutes today. Oh yeah, and guess what, housing is higher today than it was at the bubble peak (and so is the stock market mini-bubble today). So are we self-regulated again now? Nope, we're even more regulated now, with all the big banks directly and strictly under control of the Fed; it all has to do with artificially low interest rates, which is universally understood at this point - the Fed now openly admits to creating asset inflation to try to spur the economy.
- Canutesun 10y agoRegulation has done a great job in several industries of concentrating the industries into a few major players, because it is incredibly difficult to comply for new/small companies. Banking and finance is one, telecom is another.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- backtoyoujim 10y agoOne of the highlights to the Banking Secrecy Act update in 2014 is listed in the first spot: - Suspicious Activity Reporting http://www.occ.treas.gov/news-issuances/bulletins/2014/bulletin-2014-60.html http://www.occ.treas.gov/news-issuances/bulletins/2014/bulle...