6 ms·
It's unprofessional to make an adult with potentially years of experience do a nonsensical, high-pressure test in front of an interviewer like a monkey. Whitebo
by smt88 10y ago
It's unprofessional to make an adult with potentially years of experience do a nonsensical, high-pressure test in front of an interviewer like a monkey. Whiteboard interviews are humiliating even if you pass.
Any company that does whiteboard interviews for coders should also have incoming salespeople sell hotdogs in front of the building as a test. Incoming managers can use Barbie dolls to demonstrate how to run a team. Fair is fair.
- ptaipale 10y agoIt looks like walking out was a win-win solution in this instance.
- andy_ppp 10y agoI've always rather enjoyed doing them and at the start I almost certainly have no idea what the answers are; I just assume it's more about thinking clearly and asking good questions so I guess that works better for me than thinking I'm a performing monkey which would probably hinder my performance and enjoyment.
- taneq 10y agoThis is like getting your knickers in a twist over being asked to make a coffee when interviewing to be a barista. "But I have years of experience, why should I just make you a coffee right now in front of you like a trained monkey?" The reason that people do fizz-buzz style tests in interviews isn't to insult you with easy questions. It's because far too many "professionals with years of experience" are incapable of solving the simplest problems. These people will cost your company hundreds of thousands of dollars in combined expenses and opportunity cost, if you let them. It's possible to implement it poorly, sure, but the principle is sound.
- adamors 10y agoA barista would be making coffees as part of their job. Not sure how many programmers code on whiteboards in stressful situations on a daily basis.
- taneq 10y agoMaybe not often white boards specifically (although I've done that too) but does no-one else do pair programming? Code reviews? Emergency group debug sessions to fix a blocking bug? There are many situations which absolutely do require you to be able to perform on the spot and under pressure.
- adamors 10y agoI have done all of those, but by that time I was aquatinted with the people I work with. During an interview you're stressed by strangers and the interview itself. For instance, I interviewed people who froze up simply by being on an interview, putting them in front of a whiteboard would have been torture.
- aedron 10y agoI don't think a barista is asked to make a coffee under supervision during his very first interview either? That would be demeaning in the extreme, in my opinion.
- taneq 10y agoSeriously? What else would you do to interview a barista? You observe their presentation, chat with them a bit to confirm they have some base level of interpersonal skills, and you get them to make you a coffee or two. Why does everyone seem to feel they're far too important to do their jobs?
- aedron 10y agoMy impression is that people come in for a chat about themselves and their past experiences. The guy running the shop can easily tell if they know what they are talking about. If he likes them they are brought on to the team and then evaluated over something like a two week period. How about a chef, a surgeon, a car mechanic, an architect? Are any of these put to the test and asked to practice their craft right on the spot during the interview? If so, my knowledge of the job market is sorely out of whack. If not, why do IT companies consider themselves so important that they have the right to make potential hires run the gauntlet?
- smt88 10y ago> too important to do their jobs Writing code on a white board is not anyone's job. That's the point. It's so different from anyone's job that you're not testing whether they're actually good at coding.
- smt88 10y agoMy issue is not testing someone's coding skills if they'll be coding for you. My issue is that whiteboard interviews are so different from real-life coding that they have no value at all. Instead of whiteboard interviews, completing some actual code while sitting in the office at a real laptop would be a much better way to determine if someone actually knows how to code.
- stevetrewick 10y agoIt would be unprofessional to judge a candidate purely on the basis of their resumè. I wouldn't expect an adult with years of experience to find such a test even remotely problematic. And in case anyone missed it, part of the test is evaluating your attitude and your behaviour when a little pressure is applied. Why do you think it's 'humiliating' to be asked to demonstrate your ability?
- smt88 10y agoBeing tested is totally fine. I have no issue with testing someone's skills. Doing a whiteboard test is not only a waste of time, it's nothing like actual coding. It's both too simple (in terms of skills) and too hard (in terms of environment). Let's take fizzbuzz just as an example. As others have said in these comments, they know great coders who failed fizzbuzz. Fizzbuzz tells you exactly zero about how someone would be at writing code that's readable, testable, and maintainable, which are the most important technical skills. Those are hard skills to master, and they can be tested by interviewers by using a real-world problem. Let the candidate sit by herself for a few hours and work on it. The whiteboard interview also puts someone who is potentially desperate for a job and terrified of being embarrassed in a high-pressure situation, where failure instantly means she's "incompetent" or "stupid". Who can't do fizzbuzz, right? Well I'll tell you: people who aren't super calm in artificial, high-pressure testing situations sometimes can't do fizzbuzz.
- 746F7475 10y ago>Whiteboard interviews are humiliating even if you pass. Stop thinking so highly of yourself. There is nothing humiliating about them. If you get feeling of humiliation from someone watching you work, then you are going to have a bad time working in a team.
- palerdot 10y agoThe original comment exactly describes the problem with the whiteboard situations. Maybe you are an extrovert and can just say something on and on when the interviewer prods you with nitpicking details that does not matter in a whiteboard. But, for others like an introvert, the whole process is like dancing in a circus in front of the people (with each one of them asking you do something at the sametime).
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoLook, I'm an introvert. I despise being treated as a performing seal. I also have no problem with a whiteboard interview. Yes, I'm being made to jump through hoops, but I understand why. It's not just to make me jump through hoops. (If I pick up the vibe that it is just for that, then I don't want the job.) It's so that they can see how I think. But maybe my saving grace here is that I don't fear pressure in that kind of situation...
- 746F7475 10y ago>I despise being treated as a performing seal. This is 100% in your head and about your attitude. Your ego is the problem, nothing else. I'm introverted as fuck, but I realize that this is part of interview process and if you act like a self centered cunt, who isn't willing to do a simple task like writing little code on a board, you aren't worth the effort for most projects.
- deadgrey19 10y agoWhite board interviews are humiliating, especially if the level is pitched wrong. As someone with a career prior to starting grad school I'm sick of being treated like a child in the interview process and being given diddly little graph traversal problems when I used to building entire systems. The problem here is a mismatch in expectations. But the whiteboard interview does have its merits. I have sat on the other side of that table. We took a candidate with years of experience a masters degree from a prestigious university and a very very impressive thesis. We were almost embarrassed to give him the warm up questions. Until he completely utterly failed to complete them. We didn't even get past the warm up questions during the two hour interview. As a baseline measure of competence, it was a pretty good one and we (in a small startup) really dodged a bullet by doing this kind of testing.
- brianwawok 10y agoMaybe, maybe not. Perhaps you missed genius coders who suck at white board fizzbuzz.
- deadgrey19 10y agoI won't give away the details, but the warm-up question should have taken a about 14 seconds for someone with the claimed skill set. They should have been able to speak the code at us rather than use a whiteboard. Think of something like "write a program to sum the values in a 10 element integer array". It was supposed to be a fluff filter so we could get on to higher level architecture/design questions. I felt embarrassed to even give it. On resume alone, this guy was a definite hire. The interview was something else entirely.
- kasey_junk 10y agoI know great coders that have failed fizzbuzz. I've seen it happen in an interview where I was an interviewer, they were my friend, and I did everything in my power to make the process low pressure. Some people just can't deal with the pressure of interviewing.
- 10y ago
- prof_hobart 10y agoWhat's unprofessional about it? I spend a fair amount of my day job drawing up technical solutions on whiteboards - either helping to analyse a problem, or talking people (often people I've never met before) through my thought process. For some roles, this kind of skill is absolutely vital. And if that's the role that someone is going for, then you're going to want to know how good they are with it. It also allows you to see the person's thought process - how do they go about understanding the problem? How do they approach defining the solution? I could be wrong, but I doubt that they'd be looking out for syntax errors on the board - it's far more likely to be communication and structure of thought that they are looking for. My wife is a teacher. When she goes for jobs, she often has to teach a lesson to a bunch of kids that she's never met before, hasn't got a clue what level they are or what they've already been taught, and with a bunch of observers standing at the back taking notes. That's not a realistic scenario for the day to day job as a teacher, and doesn't test a fair amount of the other skills that they need. But it allows them to assess whether the candidate can structure a present an engaging lesson. That doesn't seem entirely unreasonable, and nor does asking someone to talk through a solution on a whiteboard.
- jsudhams 10y agoIt is not about whether this skill is required it is definitely a skill required. Interviewers are expecting the actual exact answer with syntax correctness instead of looking at thought process. Also when you do whiteboard u look for view of audience and in interview it is not the case. Why would interviewers not ask if the candidate is comfortable with whiteboard or a simple paper based or even a oral?
- prof_hobart 10y ago>Interviewers are expecting the actual exact answer with syntax correctness instead of looking at thought process. Are you talking about this specific case or in general? I've sat in on several interviews where someone's been asked to write something up on a board, and we were definitely not looking for 100% correctness. >Also when you do whiteboard u look for view of audience and in interview it is not the case Why not? An interview isn't an exam. It's a chance for both parties to find out if they could, and would want to, work together. I expect them to be two way conversations. I were being interviewed I'd quite happily say things like "At this point, I'd be looking to put caching in. I've used X for this in the past, but does your company have a prefered solution for it?". When I'm sitting in on interviews it's a positive if someone asks me that kind of question. >Why would interviewers not ask if the candidate is comfortable with whiteboard or a simple paper based or even a oral? If you're looking for someone who is good at talking other people through their solution, then you want to see them doing it. I've no idea on what this company was actually looking for, but I wouldn't want a technical lead who couldn't grab a pen and draw up their thinking.
- smilingtom 10y agoDo you know how I know you're in your 20s?