5 ms·
By this logic, wouldn't the most logical thing be for the EU members to all petition to join the United States of America as states (USAE - United States of Ame
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
By this logic, wouldn't the most logical thing be for the EU members to all petition to join the United States of America as states (USAE - United States of America and Europe)?
After all, would this group not have much more influence than even the EU? In addition, there is a strong tradition of subsidiarity in the United States (see states rights).
I think most Europeans would be horrified of joining the United States. Why? Because there is not enough shared identity.
The United States works because the shared American identity is very strong. Even if I live in Iowa, my identity is more strongly American than Iowan. This American identity was forged through centuries of migration and assimilation (i.e. the Westward expansion where people would leave their state to go out West but would still be American) and in fighting and dying together alongside fellow Americans in the various wars over the years.
While the elite of Europe may have a stronger European identity than that of their country of citizenship, what you are seeing with the recent polls and movements in Europe is that for many of the common people, their national identity is stronger than their European identity. This is to be expected as for many of these countries, the national identity was forged over hundreds of years, while the modern European identity is only a few decades old.
Thus, for many people, they see the European identity as seeking to assert primacy over their national identity and they are wanting out.
- return0 10y agoActually , the far right movements in the continent are loudest against immigration from outside europe. Oddly , anti-immigration is a thing that seems to unite europeans at this time.
- throwanem 10y agoIt's funny you should take this particular tack, because this is a place where the United States has already been. We weren't able to resolve the question of which allegiance meant more, by any means short of a rather nasty half-decade-long war that maybe you've heard of. (It's also funny that you should mistake the primacy of modern American national identity as having some other cause but that, but the error is more or less ubiquitous these days, I'm afraid.) And that's what it took to enforce a federal union upon just a handful of states with strictly limited experience - a couple of centuries, tops - of regarding themselves as essentially sovereign but allied polities. In light of that, I've always found it faintly amazing that anyone imagines the EU will endure without resort to similarly drastic measures. (Also that it even came into existence, given how badly things went last time Germany was involved in trying to unify Europe. And people say Americans have little regard for history...)
- rwmj 10y agoIt was discussed by British Prime Minister Harold Wilson: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/wilson-wanted-uk-to-be-us-state-1075874.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/wilson-wanted-uk-to-be-us-...
- lettergram 10y ago> This American identity was forged through centuries of migration and assimilation I think it was forged during the civil war, when "States Rights" essentially ceased to be meaningful. Quite literally, the civil war was started because Lincoln declared he was not going to allow states to leave. Post civil war, after the horrible destruction of the south (in part by Sherman[1]); there was then a ~15 years following the civil war where the U.S. "reconstructed" (or reeducation) of the south[2]. The point being, it was really the centralization of power that removed people from feeling any/minimal association with their state. > While the elite of Europe may have a stronger European identity than that of their country of citizenship, what you are seeing with the recent polls and movements in Europe is that for many of the common people, their national identity is stronger than their European identity. My argument here is that, of course they feel stronger with their current country; their country has not been centralized. I would also argue, that overall the centralization of the U.S. has helped very little and infact has harmed more than provided good. That being said, it might be better than the EU collapse IMO. [1] http://atlantaforward.blog.ajc.com/2014/06/13/was-sherman-a-war-criminal/ http://atlantaforward.blog.ajc.com/2014/06/13/was-sherman-a-... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reconstruction_Era https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reconstruction_Era
- rmc 10y ago> I think most Europeans would be horrified of joining the United States. Why? Because there is not enough shared identity. Also there are many different laws. From US Freespeech uber alles which allows hate speech, to guns, to very low protection of privacy/data protection, to employment rights.
- rmc 10y agoMaybe the USA should join the EU. There already are federated states in the EU (Germany), so it wouldn't be too different. :P
- DominikR 10y agoWhy should the only country in the world that has freedom of speech give that up to join a club of countries lead by unaccountable bureaucrats that no one has voted into power. That's exactly what the EU is. I suppose this will be downvoted, but please take the time and explain where I am factually wrong. Because I can give you many examples why there is no freedom of speech in the EU and why particularly the EU commission is unaccountable.
- anu_gupta 10y agoThe US doesn't have true freedom of speech. I can give you many examples of things that you aren't allowed to say in the US.
- cerbasict12 10y agoI'd love to checkout the examples.
- matt4077 10y agoWell, I'll take the 'unaccountable bureaucrats'. Any proposal by these bureaucrats has to be approved by (a) the directly-elected European Parliament and (b) the national governments, who are legitimized via their national rules (some are directly elected, some by their parliaments). The bureaucrats themselves are appointed by their national governments, in much the same way that national ministers are usually appointed by that nation's head of government (i. e. the British Prime Minister). They also have to go through confirmation & hearings in the EU Parliament – something that goes beyond the standard in most EU states. The last European elections also saw the rise of the 'Spitzenkadidat' system, meaning voters had a very direct idea of who they're supporting as President of the Commission. Note that the head of government is directly elected in only a handful of European nations, namely France among the larger ones. Judging by your name, you're German, where the head of state is also elected indirectly by Parliament and government ministers are appointed. Exactly as it is in the EU. Same, by the way, for Britain. So – examples?
- vidarh 10y ago> the national identity was forged over hundreds of years While that is true for some European countries, for a very substantial part of Europe the "national identity" was invented out of nothing during the romantic nationalism period [1] inspired by Rousseau and Hegel, starting in the late 1700's, but which came to its head in Europe in the late 1800's, coinciding with the creation of several of the modern European nations. For many others, their modern day European nations are much younger than even that. You are probably right that most Europeans identify mostly with their nation, but for large parts of Europe that identity was invented by an intellectual and economical elite in the same way that the idea of a united Europe is being woven together strand by strand now. Whether not it succeeds will remain to be seen, but the very existence of most modern European states is the evidence of how this same state-building exercise has worked in Europe once before.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoCorrect. However, the context for this decision was in regards to Brexit. British and more specifically English identity is probably the strongest national identity in Europe ( French and Swiss identity would be the only other ones that are similar in strength). These ones I mentioned are also some of the oldest identities in Europe British since 1600s James I, English Since at least the Tudors in the 1500s, French Since the Hundred Years' War in the 1400s, Swiss also since the 1300-1400s These counties have around 500+ years of shares identity.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 10y agoBritish identity is extremely weak - even in England, there's been a decades long decline in the number of people who consider themselves British first and foremost. As it stands, a tiny minority in the UK - England included see themselves as only British, and I believe a minority now see British as the most important part of their identity. The only thing "saving" the British identity, is the weakness of the English national identity. That English is one of the oldest established national identities in Europe, I'll buy, but in the last twenty years there's been a lot of agonising in England over how weak the English identity is in many respects. E.g. England does not have an official national anthem (God Save the Queen is the anthem of the UK), or really any day where people celebrate being English. The flag is amongst many English people seen as a bit of an embarrassment hijacked by far right groups and football fans. Unlike the other home nations, England does not have a parliament of its own, and so on. A lot of the rest is tied to a UK identity that has steadily faded after the collapse of the British Empire. In a way the English national identity is in crisis because England let itself become the UK in a way that Scotland and Wales did not, and as a result both identities have been watered down. It's clear that there is still some sort of a cultural identity in England, and wider in the UK, but it is an identity that in most respect appears to be in decline. In a sense I would be more inclined to buy that this perception of the decline is feeding into the fear of the EU in some groups. Few people in most other European nations would be likely to fear the disappearance of their national identity, but the UK has seen the slow slide towards the disintegration of the country itself, and have to face a shared identity that has been steadily weakening for decades, all the while at least in England there is little to take its place.
- jazzyk 10y agoYes, I am always surprised how parochial most of Europe still is. Just came back from vacation in Italy - even in Milan, very few people speak English. Mostly regional wine and food, hard to find Sicilian wine in northern Italy (outside of major cities/big supermarkets). The same applies to France. With the exception of London, Amsterdam, etc. most people in Europe like their local customs, feasts, food. And you know what? I hope they never change - I'd hate for them to become like the US with Starbucks on every corner.
- DasIch 10y agoThe EU has a ton of regulation on foods to protect that. Regional products generally have to made in a specific way in that specific region. Through the EU such products are better protected than any single country could on its own. Pooling these interests within the EU also means enforcing these things through free trade agreements on a larger scale still, so that nobody in Canada (CETA) or the US (TTIP) can produce Champagne for example.
- jazzyk 10y agoI was talking about people in a local town not being interested in consuming, not producing items from other regions/countries.
- atmosx 10y ago> I am always surprised how parochial most of Europe still is. Do the same standards apply to English-speaking nations like US, UK and Australia? Because if they do, these countries are the most parochial of them all. By the way, you could turn Europe a little less parochial by learning Italian. It's a rather easy language to learn.
- jazzyk 10y agoSo if I travel to Italy, France and then Germany, I have to learn three different languages, just so that I can find my way around? What if I want to see all the 40+ countries in Europe? In many northern European countries (and now even in Central/Eastern Europe), most people speaking at least basic English is the norm, not the exception. For the record, I am US-based, but I speak 4 European languages (some better than others), and I always try to use them where applicable.
- DominikR 10y agoI'm an right wing conservative Austrian who is very sceptical about the EU and I'd like our country to leave the EU. But I'd vote for joining the US if I could because I'd like to have the freedoms you have. EU countries generally have no concept of freedom of speech (or generally freedom) like you have in the US. Also Socialism/the Left is strong in the EU (try telling someone that you like Capitalism, you'll be ostracised for it) and I really fear that we might end up here in either a great economic depression or a civil war if it goes on like this.
- mpweiher 10y ago> While the elite of Europe may have a stronger European > identity than that of their country of citizenship, > what you are seeing with the recent polls and movements > in Europe is that for many of the common people, their > national identity is stronger than their European identity. Hmm...not sure that it's an elite vs people thing. I think it's more an old vs young (relatively speaking) thing. For example, I was sitting with my parents and a former colleague of my dad's in Cologne a couple of years ago, and in conversation I mentioned that it only had very minimal practical impact on my life whether the border to France was where it was or across the Rhine, making where we were sitting French. To me, it seemed obvious to the point of being banal. The others were shocked and horrified. And these were not uneducated people, and overall very pro Europe, although from what I read (poll demographics) that also appears to be a factor. Older, less-educated and (sigh) male: pro brexit. Younger, well-educated, female: pro remain. > I think most Europeans would be horrified of joining the United States. Yes. But not because of "shared identity" (or lack thereof). How about: almost complete lack of social democracy as we know it. Medical bankruptcy (though hopefully getting less). 4x the homicide rate, 10-100x the gun homicide rate, a permanent underclass, a plutocracy and a political system that's openly owned by said plutocracy, infrastructure that's laughable, permanent wars (largely fought by said underclass), almost complete abandonment of the rule of law, ... And I lived in the US for a total of 8 years, and there's also a lot to like, and the people are mostly lovely. But I certainly wouldn't want my daughter to grow up there.
- golemotron 10y ago> Thus, for many people, they see the European identity as seeking to assert primacy over their national identity and they are wanting out. What makes the discourse around this so contentious is the that it is easy to conflate this desire to preserve identity with the horrors of racism and nationalism in 20th century Europe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]