5 ms·
Blockchains and Buzzwords
- pipermerriam 10y agoThis author did not do their research. They are likely quoting from a fake letter that is not from the actual attacker. I did not personally attempt to verify the signature, but others did and they report it being invalid. The letter in question can be found here. http://pastebin.com/CcGUBgDG http://pastebin.com/CcGUBgDG The Reddit post where it was submitted to `/r/ethereum` here https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4oo1io/an_open_letter_from_the_hacker/ https://www.reddit.com/r/ethereum/comments/4oo1io/an_open_le...
- jeffreyrogers 10y agoHe wrote > The hacker! Or, at least, someone claiming to be "The Attacker," who wrote this: which makes it clear enough that he knows what he's talking about.
- pipermerriam 10y agoAn invalid digital signature is a pretty strong indication that it is the fake. I'd consider this poor journalism as it gives this letter credibility that it doesn't deserve. My statement was merely to try and point out that one of his quoted sources is likely a fabrication.
- stale2002 10y agoThe fake signature may have been done on purpose. There was another interview with someone who claimed to be the hacker, and that's what he said.
- Dylan16807 10y agoSure, likely a fabrication, but it's being used as a way to explain the schools of thought, not as an actual source of anything.
- chollida1 10y agoIMHO The best part about today's note is this quote about Marissa Mayer > Mayer grew up at Google, a lucrative and founder-controlled company that doesn't spend a whole lot of time worrying about shareholder activism, or shareholders generally. It's possible that Yahoo -- a mess with no controlling shareholder and a new CEO hired from the outside -- called for a different managerial mentality. And yet she was hired to be a visionary, not a bureaucrat, and to turn the company around. It's a tough spot to be in. I think this goes a lot of the way in explaining why she has been so clueless about how to manage shareholders, which as a CEO of a public company, especially one that is attempting to execute a trun around, is really one of the most, if not the most, important job Also I fully support Levine's view on the DAO debacle: > find this all a bit depressing. This is not the future of finance; it is the past of finance. It is a harsh world of naked caveat emptor; it demands the enforcement of trickery just because it was tricky enough to trick people. Consumer protection is a relatively new idea in finance; it has caught on because it is a good idea. I really don't want the future of finance to be caveat emptor. Again IMHO, Reason should come in and trump coding mistakes in financial contracts, if any blockchain startups reason the other way, then I think they've got it wrong. I really hope this gets to the courts as I think this might be the best thing that could happen to Etherium. In the same way that corporations setup in Delaware because the case law is known and well tested, having the courts rule on Etherium contract bugs might actually help the digital currency by giving it a bit of legitimacy and certainty around what happens when things go bad.
- zeveb 10y ago> Again IMHO, Reason should come in and trump coding mistakes in financial contracts That's not reason; it's emotion. A smart contract is pure reason (i.e., logic); if one misunderstands a contract, then the error is one's own, not the contract's. And if others say, 'that's not fair: give him back his money!' then that's just emotion. I'm not downplaying emotion (indeed, I think that as a mover in human affairs it's far more powerful than reason); I'm just arguing for clarity in words.
- crispyambulance 10y agoThese "smart contracts" are utterly new constructs and at this point I think it is fair that someone rudely exploited the system and is now playing "finders keepers". In some sense it is a much-needed learning exercise. Hopefully no single person lost anything more that whatever they're willing to part with in a very-high-risk thrill investment. As far as contracts and fairness goes, Judges DO TAKE fairness into consideration ALL THE TIME. If these smart contracts ever make it mainstream (and that's a big IF), gaming the system through loopholes won't be a sure-thing regardless of how much "pure logic" (smirk) is involved.
- curiousgal 10y agoI found this hard to read and quite honestly gave up midway because of all the excessive quoting.
- mjfl 10y agoCommenting specifically on the DAO part of the article: What's annoying about the Ethereum hard fork is not that they are implementing their own version of consumer protection, it's that they certainly will not take the same action in the future when it's not their own money on the line.
- kordless 10y ago> I find this all a bit depressing. This is not the future of finance; it is the past of finance. It is a harsh world of naked caveat emptor; it demands the enforcement of trickery just because it was tricky enough to trick people. Consumer protection is a relatively new idea in finance; it has caught on because it is a good idea. You can debate how far the law should go in protecting people from the consequences of their own mistakes, but a world in which at least some mistakes are fixable does seem nicer than the alternative. What I find depressing is the ongoing rationalizations around legacy business practices. It is these models that ultimately harm the consumer. Using weakly biased arguments that government or business is responsible for "protecting" the customer is ridiculous, especially in light of recent revelations of corruption in our government and business sectors. It's time for a change and there's not a damn thing you can do about it, Matt.
- rpgmaker 10y ago> Using weakly biased arguments that government or business is responsible for "protecting" the customer is ridiculous, especially in light of recent revelations of corruption in our government and business sectors. I don't think it's even close to funny that someone could potentially have their entire life savings stolen because of some zero-day so luckily, not everyone shares your libertarian utopia dreams. I believe that p2p currencies are here to stay in some form or another but I don't think they will supplant our traditional banking system.
- kordless 10y agoSo I hear you think it is serious that someone could have their life savings stolen. While I would agree with the fact it is a serious matter, I see a dissonance following it where you speak for my "dreams" being a "libertarian utopia". Not only do you imply my political alignment, but you insult my proposal that we might improve our processes by embracing these new technologies instead of low trust legacy systems. In short, I think you are blaming me. I also think you are wrong. I can't speak for others, but my idea of utopia is continued marginal improvement over the performance of the current solutions done with centralized control by starting to decentralize the bits that deal with trusted infrastructure. I don't expect utopia to be perfect. I don't expect it to be functional all the time. The current problems with the DAO have very little to do with the base infrastructure provided by Ethereum. In fact, the hardware Ethereum is running on currently has even less to do with with the DAO. The point being that infrastructure boundaries can be assigned levels of responsibility to them. You want most of Ethereum's code managed by the guys who wrote it, at least for a while. They'll fix stuff where is needed, but their responsibility ends at the service level. The DAO code itself should be managed by other groups responsible for it. Perhaps there could be a third group that insures the investment in a DAO. And another that insures that group, etc. Point being, social structures in place today are probably a good guide for instantiation of contracts that insure loss to errors in the code RUNNING ON TOP OF Ethereum. Ethereum promises immutable data structures for the runs. The runs themselves remain uncertain at some level, given all states of the contracts it issues may not be computable. It may be similar in nature to the dissonance you show in your statements - where some contracts literally get into an argument with themselves. If that happens, perhaps they get a gas tax for wasting other DAO's time with questions that can't be answered in a reasonable timeframe. That is what biases are, after all.
- kmd123 10y agoThe problem is with the expression, the codification of the policy, as implemented in code; not the policy itself. It's the flawed implementation of the policy that the attacker took advantage of. The attacker's justification is self-serving and ridiculous. Given any non-trivial software, especially in a new domain, there are likely to be bugs that can be exploited to undermine the system. And that's exactly what happened here.
- paavokoya 10y agoHacker News is becoming r/ethereum as of late. Getting really tired of everyone trying to rationalize with themselves as to why they bought into an altcoin. Watching the front page throughout the week is like the "5 stages of grief"
- vonklaus 10y ago> Consumer protection is a relatively new idea in finance; it has caught on because it is a good idea. I agree. However, it is to counterbalamce a system that previously protected those taking advantage of consumers and less sophisticated organizations. While this is true in perpetuity, and will be true for alt-exchanges, the difference is that arbitration is well documented and fully known. A consumer will need protection from a large institution with considerable control of the market and considerable resources and influence behind it. There does need to be a way to handle disputes and arbitration, but that is irrespective of the actual granular question of should the DAO get to keep the money? I say no, in that it will serve a great lesson in recklessly launching contracts before having them fully vetted, and also because it would invalidate the entire purpose of the organizatons existance.
- stirner 10y agoThey cite the purported note from the attacker, despite the fact that it was immediately called out as a phony with an incorrect signature.