3 ms·
It seems to defeat the purpose of the competition when they include arbitrary rules like this. All sports include arbitrary rules to try to make them more fun
by dagw 10y ago
It seems to defeat the purpose of the competition when they include arbitrary rules like this.
All sports include arbitrary rules to try to make them more fun for both participants and viewers. Basketball isn't just about seeing who can get a ball through the hoop the most times, car racing isn't just about who can be the first N times around a track etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Bromskloss 10y agoSo, we have established that sports have rules, but why should freestyle swimming prohibit this style of swimming?
- dagw 10y agowhy should freestyle swimming prohibit this style of swimming? The official reason? Safety concerns (from oxygen deprivation) and the fact that people swimming underwater makes for a less spectator friendly sport. There might be some other unofficial reasons, but not sure what they might be. My guess is that the spectator angle is the main reason.
- sanoli 10y agoI don't get people who don't get this ;-) Imagine if it got to the point where the whole 50m fresstyle race was won by reamining underwater full time. Gone would be the frantic flapping of arms and legs making waves and splashes, which is how non-swimmers understand how fast paced the event is, like the running 100m sprint. People gliding like dolphins viewed in underwater cameras is just not as exciting.
- Teever 10y agoSo would this sport be better if we tied lead weights to the athletes ankles?
- Hondor 10y agoWorks in horse racing.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoBasketball is a game, it's like chess, the move "knock the board off the table and punch the opponent" is not part of the definition of the game, and that's fine, games have definitions. But honestly, it annoys me when things like swimming and car racing bind themselves up with rules that amount to "no, do it the conventional way, not the better way". It should be legit to win by innovation.
- Hondor 10y agoI tend to feel the same way but there are often safety reasons. You can't have a popular sport where the winners are the ones who push themselves closest to death. g-forces causing harm to drivers: https://what-if.xkcd.com/116/ https://what-if.xkcd.com/116/ Smaller events also have to allow the competitors to focus on a smaller range of capabilities so they can actually find competent players. Robot and drone competitions come to mind where the equipment is often standardized so they're only testing skills or programming, not being-the-best-at-everything which would end up as "throwing the most money at it".
- dagw 10y agoAt the end of the day sport doesn't exist in a vacuum and the end goal of swimming or car racing as a sport isn't (just) to go as fast as possible, it's to put on an entertaining show that people will want to watch. Much like with any good business, the goal isn't to make the 'best' product at any cost, it's to make the most profitable product that will make your customers happy.
- imtringued 10y agoGround effect was banned because it resulted in too many crashes in F1 racing. www.f1fanatic.co.uk/2007/06/07/banned-ground-effects/