7 ms·
Perhaps European trademark laws are different from the US -- but here, using a trademark to refer directly to the thing which is the subject of the trademark is
by dsr_ 10y ago
Perhaps European trademark laws are different from the US -- but here, using a trademark to refer directly to the thing which is the subject of the trademark is always a legal use.
That's why the Pepsi Challenge can name Coca-Cola directly as the product that people prefer. Certainly Coca-Cola would sue them if they had any legal grounds to stand on, and they do not.
Is OVH using "Ubuntu" to refer to something other than an Ubuntu-sourced distro that they are making available on their servers? Are they substituting an OVH-tweaked derivative and calling it Ubuntu? If so, then Canonical has a plausible case. If not, it's an overanxious, overpaid and undereducated lawyer's assistant writing letters by the hour.
- wodenokoto 10y agoI don't know trademark laws very well, but something like Pepsi mentioning Coca-Cola in their ads is pretty much unheard if where I live.
- pbarnes_1 10y agoCompetitive advertising by name is illegal in most countries. The US is one exception.
- LeifCarrotson 10y agoI found the recent Ford/Chevy "comparison" ad interesting in this regard. In it, they never mentioned the word "Ford", they just had "a competitor's truck", with clearly visible logos. More than most ads I have seen, they very intentionally avoided mentioning what everyone could clearly see. I wonder if this was done so they could sell the ad internationally: https://youtu.be/BTm2F4ysQrE https://youtu.be/BTm2F4ysQrE As an aside, I think it's a little absurd that they're trying to sell their old-tech steel truck as superior to Ford's new aluminum setup. I wonder how they will pivot their pitch in coming years when they can no longer compete with Ford and Dodge aluminum trucks that don't rust, are faster, lighter, and more fuel efficient...
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>Competitive advertising by name is illegal in most countries. // Can you give examples? Referring to a product's origin by using the Trademark is allowed in the UK and under the harmonisation treaties I thought such big issues had been evened out across EU states trademark regulations (so that community trademarks can work).
- Lazare 10y agoThat was my thought too. I don't understand how this is even meant to work. The analogy that sprang to my mind is a store saying they're selling Coke; you have to be able to describe what you're saying. You can't be expected to have a flyer saying "this week only, we're selling the popular cola beverage with the red label for $2 per 2l bottle!"
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- corobo 10y agoLets for the sake of argument say Coca Cola was cool with you changing their formula and selling the result. In this case it would be the equivalent of your store opening up all the bottles of Coke and adding or removing ingredients. They can't then sell the result of their tampering as "Coke". They'd have to give it a new name, Freedom Cola, for example.
- Lazare 10y agoAgreed. I've since seen explanations that OVH modifies Ubuntu which changes the situation hugely.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- patrickaljord 10y ago> Are they substituting an OVH-tweaked derivative and calling it Ubuntu? Yes they are, they are shipping ubuntu with a custom kernel to support their hardware, it also comes with its own set of bugs which Ubuntu needs to deal with when they are reported upstream. So I could understand if they'd want to charge for that.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jwildeboer 10y agoNo. In that case they should demand OVH stops calling it Ubuntu. That would be the good thing to do. Stop people from damaging your brand. But asking money for allowing them to continue this? That just doesn't feel right.
- roblabla 10y agoBut it does. OVH wants to be able to brand stuff as Ubuntu. Ubuntu is unhappy about brand damage and having to deal with ovh's bug. If ovh throws money at canonical, they can hire people to deal with that. It might not make much sense business-wise, but I don't see the problem ethically speaking. OVH is in infrigment with Canonical's branding. EIther they comply with Canonical's licensing, or they stop using the brand.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>they [Canonical] should demand OVH stops calling it Ubuntu // Hmm, if they can franchise and make some money I don't have a problem with that as long as Canonical have some oversight, such as a Canonical specified QC process for OVH to go through before release.
- PeterisP 10y agoThe EU trademark laws are the same in this regard, they don't need a permission to refer to the actual Ubuntu by its trademarked name, it would be a noninfringing nominal use. However, it seems to be about being able to call their modified system as Ubuntu, which is exactly why trademark laws exist - Canonical is and should be the sole authority in deciding if something that's not made by them, but is somewhat similar and wants to be called Ubuntu can be called Ubuntu; they can allow it, allow it if they get paid, deny it no matter what because they don't like you, or allow it under any totally arbitrary conditions. It may be legal to call it "an Ubuntu derived system" or "Ubuntu-compatible OS" or something like that, depending on a bunch of stuff; but if you want to make something that's almost-but-not-exactly-Ubuntu and call it Ubuntu, then it's a very risky decision.
- gonzo 10y ago> That's why the Pepsi Challenge can name Coca-Cola directly as the product that people prefer. Certainly Coca-Cola would sue them if they had any legal grounds to stand on, and they do not. This is literally "nominative use" and is explicitly allowed by US and EU law. You can name your competitor's product. You can compare your product with that of your competitors'. You can't adulterate someone's trademark product and still use the mark to refer to the product.