3 ms·
A good letter if you are a middle-class household without any real problems. But that american dream isn't applicable to everyone. I'd write a very different
by sandworm101 10y ago
A good letter if you are a middle-class household without any real problems. But that american dream isn't applicable to everyone.
I'd write a very different letter for a family struggling with one or more dependant/disabled family members. There, conventional saving can be difficult but also dangerous. A big pile of money or other assets can too easily be attached or lost to a horrible situation.
I'd also write a very different letter for wealthy families. For them, asset protection is far more important than savings. They often spend more energy dissociating themselves from their wealth via trusts and other tax-efficient games than they do actually building savings.
- underwater 10y agoI think it's less about providing bulletproof advice and about reflecting on your own experiences. The children would have experienced the outcomes most of what the letter describes, it's just filling in the blanks. Most people see their own upbringing as an ideal to follow so this is giving a rule book on how to do that.
- caseysoftware 10y agoSince most of these seem to be parents or grandparents letters to their children or grandchildren, they're not supposed to be all-weather advice. If you have kids, you understand the morals and priorities that you attempted to raise them with, therefore you will speak to that shared understanding. If you're trying to say "different people in different situations have different requirements"... Yes, we know that. And?
- Dylan16807 10y agoThe title says "every parent". Explaining why the advice needs to drastically change for certain situations is quite helpful. You should not be so dismissive.
- nedwin 10y agoIf you read the template they link to you would see that it's really a blank slate - more a placeholder for the conversation every parent needs to have with their children around money, relevant to that families reality.
- OscarCunningham 10y ago>I'd also write a very different letter for wealthy families. For them, asset protection is far more important than savings. They often spend more energy dissociating themselves from their wealth via trusts and other tax-efficient games than they do actually building savings. I've always found it weird that so many rich people think this way. They should be less risk averse then other people. If you're rich then you should make yourself a safety net and chase a high risk-reward strategy with the rest of your money.
- maratd 10y agoIf you're winning at the casino, the right response isn't to create a safety net and play riskier games. It's to leave the casino.
- Dylan16807 10y agoBad analogy, because you should always leave a casino. If you can get higher expected returns with an increase in risk, you should probably go for it with the money you can spare, as long as you can spread the risk around multiple fields.
- maratd 10y agoIt's actually a very good analogy. > If you can get higher expected returns with an increase in risk That's not how risk works. You always get higher expected returns with higher risk. That's the point or people wouldn't even consider it. You also get a higher probability of losing everything. > as long as you can spread the risk around multiple fields. Diversification is a strategy for reducing risk. It's irrelevant to this discussion. High risk as a strategy is sound when you have little to lose. Like when you're young and poor. When you're old and wealthy, it is profoundly stupid regardless of what strategy you employ. It is exactly like being in a casino. You have a ton of cash in your pocket, why would you engage in investments where the probability of losing your shirt is high?
- Dylan16807 10y ago