30 ms·
Facebook is wrong, text is deathless
- tracker1 10y agoAs FB has removed and reduced features, including messaging from their mobile web app, I've been using them ever less... I'm not sure they aren't alienating as many people as they're actively engaging, and in the effort to keep the new millenials, they're pushing everyone else away.
- manigandham 10y ago> to keep the new millenials, they're pushing everyone else away. Millennials are the biggest and most active group, and more important to them compared to "everyone else" - they know what they're doing.
- ben_jones 10y agoIn the same vein I don't think it's as much capturing millennials as keeping up with them. It's impossible to predict every upcoming trend, but if they keep themselves nimble through acquisitions and trimmed product offerings they can ride the coattails of instagram/whatsapp type companies into eternity.
- niftich 10y agoI disagree with the original premise that video is superior also, but Facebook is very calculated in their endeavors. They could be: - feature-chasing Periscope/Vine/Snapchat/Meerkat/Twitch/Youtube - enticed by pre-roll ads - planning future Oculus integration, live VR streaming, etc.
- notliketherest 10y agoThis article borrows heavily from an article that Graydon Hoare (founder of the Rust programming language) posted a couple years ago - http://graydon.livejournal.com/196162.html http://graydon.livejournal.com/196162.html
- valleyer 10y agoYou probably didn't mean it this way, but your comment seems to suggest that plagiarism occurred. I think you meant to say simply that the two articles are similar in theme.
- evmar 10y agoIt doesn't seem like Kottke's style to plagarize, but it also seems extremely likely he read Graydon's post before writing this one. Even the phrases like "always bet on text" are the same.
- mfarris 10y agoFYI, the post was written by Tim Carmody, who is guest-blogging on Kottke.org this week.
- toomanythings2 10y agoWell ... uh ... I think ... I think ... uh ... everyone can hear me? ... I'll wait till the guys in the back ... oh and the girls, too, right hahahahahah ... OK ... let's get started... Sure. I know Facebook wouldn't put out videos like that but it seems 80% of all videos linked to do start out like that and that's the quality you're going to get from anyone worth listening to. Even the polished ones, though, blatter on about things I don't care about but I can't skim ahead in the video without worrying I'm skipping something I really do want to hear. Thus, the advantage of text. To the point. Skimmable, both forward and backward with the ability to understand what you are skipping over. Have you ever read transcripts from talks given? Don't you wish someone would have edited out all the garbage talk beforehand? And doesn't your mouse wheel finger hurt scrolling down the page, only to be told "to hear the rest of the video, click here". Now let's talk about the weight of video files ....
- Terribledactyl 10y agoI completely agree there is a lot of garbage in a lot of video content, but if you can take advantage of the audio visual capacity you can get a lot. An example, Just watching a master craftsman do something can reveal a lot of tiny differences in technique that add up to a lot, but may not be written down explicitly.
- the_af 10y agoAgreed, watching someone do something with his/her hands is (almost always) better than reading about it. But consider another scenario: a video of someone showing you how they type some code while talking about it. This sort of videos are unbearable to me, and I don't understand how some people can enjoy them. I'd rather read the code in text form, at my own pace.
- douche 10y agoMy god, I hate coding videos. There is nothing more frustrating than a command-line Linux video. A.) I cannot copy/paste what you typed into your terminal into mine from a youtube video. Give a decent transcript with the steps enumerated.
- fuzzywalrus 10y agoI'm guessing this a pivot that actually is moving away from everyday user generated content as facebook already has become increasingly a news and image-macro aggregator/sharer. Why not video I suppose? I imagine forcing video advertisements pays significantly better.
- dredmorbius 10y agoVideo ads are slightly harder to block. Particularly on mobile.
- partycoder 10y agoUntil now publishing content has had limitations. Now anyone can publish as much content as they want, however irrelevant, and that is becoming a problem: proliferation of irrelevant content (irrelevant from the perspective of the reader). So I think the next challenge is to just be able keep content concise, relevant and affine to your interests. Twitter took a stab at that, but it's not there yet. Having a machine to filter and produce summarized versions of whatever endless feed you are reading, as well as remembering seen entries (a bit like Snapchat) is the next frontier. Another key issue is selective ignorance, biases and such. Only exploring stuff related to your interests can trap people within a detached state with respect to reality.
- rndmind 10y ago>Only exploring stuff related to your interests can trap people within a detached state with respect to reality. This is true. And it is exacerbated by confirmation bias.
- davidivadavid 10y ago> Only exploring stuff related to your interests can trap people within a detached state with respect to reality. That's something I've been casually interested in in the last few months, simply because I have, rather lately, come to understand that I won't ever be able to read all the books I want to read, or see the movies I want to see, etc. However, it seems to me the "problem" or the situation is a little more complex than that. The information you consume will always be a subset of "reality", and how detached you are from "reality" based on what information you consume seems like a quantity that will be hard to measure. For the sake of being somewhat contrarian here, I'm just going to repeat something I've mentioned a couple times: I think that contrary to popular belief, all attempts at giving people a more "balanced" view of reality with a balanced "information diet", all attempts at avoiding the "filter bubble" are completely misguided. The value is precisely in creating bubbles that are as valuable as possible for individuals, by filtering, curating, optimizing the information they consume to maximize the utility they get from it. That possibility seems to me to be largely unexplored today in places where you would expect to see it (information aggregation platforms, recommender systems that are still quite primitive, etc.).
- gumby 10y ago> Human brains process it absurdly well considering there's nothing really built-in for it. That's unclear. The sheer bitrate of reading suggests that it might tap into some deep structures -- hacking some parts of the visual and speech systems, if you prefer. I don't click on HN video links because I find video slow and frustrating way to learn almost anything. Text is so random access -- you can skip over boring bits re-read hard bits, luxuriate in the really wonderful bits...all of which is hard in video. And in fact because the visual channel is so complex, I find reading more multimedia than video -- it's hard to feel cold when watching someone march through the snow, though a well written book can make me shiver with cold, even on a summer day.
- adventured 10y agoIt's a very strange statement indeed to claim that there's nothing built-in for it. We built it around / within our capabilities. It works so well precisely because we built it for ourselves, for what we are capable of. It's almost like they're pretending it spontaneously came from nature (or always existed absent of humans and we discovered it) and we weren't evolved for it but somehow adapted to it. You could insert eg a bicycle into the same premise: we ride them absurdly well given there's nothing built into the brain for specifically riding a bicycle (except there is: balance, grasping acceleration, etc. - we designed them for our use just as we did text).
- rpgmaker 10y agoIn my case I think I avoid HN video links because I know in advance that they will ask me to commit an exact amount of time to it without knowing whether it will be worth it in the end. With text on the other hand, I can easily start to read an article and begin to skim it once I see that it isn't as interesting as I thought it'd be.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Theodores 10y agoI worked in television for a number of years in a technical behind-the-scenes capacity where I would have to flick switches and hit buttons on audio/scripted cues. Sometimes this would take me from the script for what I felt was a long time and I would always struggle to get back to where we were in the script. 'Surely we must have gone through two pages of this double spaced script that only uses one half of the page in a large font?' No Invariably my guess on 'script progress' would be considerably greater than actual progress made. Even under ideal conditions where this was the nth retake and I knew what was coming up I would still find myself over-estimating how many words had been presented to the cameras. Years of experience did not change this, I always over-estimated how much had been read, trying to take into account the 'slow baud rate' didn't help. If you do ever have a transcript of a video play the video and start reading. See how far you get through the video when you have finished reading. Don't make it a race, read as you normally might, taking time out to Google stuff etc. and you will be amazed at how much quicker the printed word is.
- Bahamut 10y agoThere are a lot of people who like communicating through image memes & other short soundbites - I am not one of them. I value text. I like reading deeper insights from people much more than cheap flyby memes or time consuming videos. If communication regresses like that, I'll probably withdraw from using those features. It's simply what I don't want in a social network.
- jasonthevillain 10y agoYes! Exactly. My (optimistic) suspicion is the users will get bored of it and stop looking at the river of crap, forcing them to change directions again.
- l33tbro 10y agoThis is anecdotal, but I've still never watched one of those auto-play videos you see at the top of news articles. It's just so much more efficient to just skim the text below and find the relevant information you were after.
- 0xCMP 10y agoThis will force media companies to do something which they should have done a long time ago. Think of all the videos you ignore on Forbes, WSJ, Bloomberg, etc. because you can't view them muted. Think of all the videos from Buzzfeed and others which aren't of such high caliber but are so easy to consume that you do. This will force those with real content to publish that content in an accessible way. I'm fine with videos, especially muted ones, because if the current trends stay I think they'll be more useful to me and everyone else. Text IS great. But somethings like a presidential speech or a short interview need the visual element. Some things don't need the visual part, but a media company can make it better than without it. The key will be to keeping it short because as others mention in the comments it's very difficult to skip around in videos for what you care about. Most of the videos I mentioned are already pretty short though, so I'm guessing that won't be much of an issue for them to adapt.
- Mendenhall 10y agoI cant stand videos for most information. By the time the video loads and the probably slow speaking individual goes over just the introduction of the information, I could have already read a more informative article/post.
- auganov 10y agoSince I started playing all YouTube videos at 2x speed[0] I enjoy watching/listening to videos much more. Watching videos at 1x is just unbearable to me now. I wish FB added 2x playback too. [0] using https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/improvedtube-youtube-exte/bnomihfieiccainjcjblhegjgglakjdd?utm_source=chrome-app-launcher-info-dialog https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/improvedtube-youtu...
- the_af 10y agoInteresting! I do the same with video lectures from Coursera. For example, Odersky's lectures may be interesting, but boy is he a slow speaker. I simply cannot stand his -- and to be fair, most -- lectures unless I play them at 2X speed. And still, I'd rather read the PDF slides. Video isn't a particularly good way of conveying formal information. Text with graphics is way better.
- manigandham 10y agoVideo is a great way to convey formal information - when that info needs the moving visuals aspect to be clearly presented. Videos of people just speaking text is terrible and the wrong tool for the job.
- maus42 10y agoWell, the best way to accomplish this would be include an animation in the material that's mostly in the written form. Like this: http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/ http://acko.net/blog/how-to-fold-a-julia-fractal/
- 10y ago
- terryf 10y agoI guess maybe I'm too old to understand (38) but to me, reading some text is simply way faster than watching someone read that text in a video... but they are saying the exact opposite. This is completely baffling to me.
- aethos 10y agoNot just you -- video is a real time medium, a 3 minute video takes 3 minutes to watch. Text is at your reading speed, and also a lot easier to index.
- Spooky23 10y agoWell produced video is magic. Think of a movie that was impactful to you -- done well, video can tell a story in an almost magical way. The reality is that the average video is drivel and not nearly as good as a similar written piece. The FB is either living in a reality distortion field or thinking about high quality ad/infotainment content that produces $ for Facebook.
- terryf 10y agoOf course, movies can be beautiful and even enjoyable because of their slowness sometimes - but that is completely different from the online experience, where everything moves extremely fast and there is always an overload of information, so to keep up with it, you want to be able to ingest it as quickly as possible. Exceptions apply of course for long form writing pieces, where the pacing and the wording is as much a part of the content as the content itself. But on facebook ?
- mrweasel 10y ago>Well produced video is magic. Most of us don't realise how difficult editing is. There's a camera in our phones, and uploading to Facebook, Youtube or Snapchat has never been easier, so now we're all film makers. It just that almost no one realise how hard their favourite podcast or youtube channel has worked on editing. Or how many times they redone the exact same bit, to get it absolutely perfect, and watchable. It's easier and faster, to re-read a few sentences, edit the worst bit, re-read and post. There's not really a fast way of editing the worst parts of a video.
- petra 10y agoJust today we had a "children illustrated guide to kubernetes" receiving lots of upvotes(243), and some comments saying it's a much better way to learn stuff. So i'd say text isn't the ideal, it's just a matter of economics that we are surrounded by text all the time, and maybe facebook can shift that. On a sidenote, i'm curious why aren't there aggregators for well illustrated content ?
- ape4 10y agoIs it out of fashion to still want Facebook to die.
- mxuribe 10y agoI'm not sure that I want FB to die totally...I'd prefer they shrink and shrivel up, but not go away totally...I want the decentralized interweb platforms of the future to have something to look at...and for them to remember what they should not be doing. (Can you tell that I'm absolutely in favor of a non-centralized webternet world!?! ;-)
- andrewfromx 10y agoI always sent emails in plain text mode. I hate the idea of sending an entire html doc for a simple text only job.
- bikamonki 10y agoI am the kind that reads thrice before hitting send. It would be too slow/too weird to do that with video or voice notes. Text is deathless.
- combatentropy 10y agoYes, for almost everything online, I prefer text: programming tutorials, the news, discussions like this on Hacker News. Imagine if each reply here had to be an uploaded video of the member talking. For some other things, I prefer a video: how to cook something, how to repair something, how to tie a tie, an interview with a person whom I admire. Even then it can depend on my mood, and if I'm in a hurry I am like, "Oh, just cut to the chase, or put it in a one-paragraph article."
- marxidad 10y agoI think that the only thing that will make text obsolete is synthetic, panpsychic telepathy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- aklemm 10y agoThey're probably thinking of memes and emojis as well. It can't be argued that well-structured text is a strong suit among individuals communicating with Facebook.
- milesf 10y agoThe folks at Facebook are not stupid. This is likely setting the groundwork to ream more bandwidth through their Aquila project https://info.internet.org https://info.internet.org More bandwidth means more money, which means convincing more of the public to invest more in Facebook.
- ivv 10y agoOne way to read it is "people are increasingly preferring video over text, so that's where Facebook is going". I think what it really means is that Facebook sees more ad money in video than in text, so that's where they are steering the ship.
- shiven 10y agoI can't stand video content unless the visual component is absolutely critical to transmission of the idea that is being communicated. I'd take a podcast/audiobook (with playback speed control) over 99% of videos that are shared on HN and a gazillion other sites. The "information density" to "bandwidth" ratio (is there a term for it?) is seldom justified for the majority of video content.
- jonsen 10y ago(Payload.)
- potlee 10y agoMaybe you should have made a video of this?
- mxuribe 10y agoSo would some sort of animated ascii art be considered video or text?
- Clubber 10y agoI just read most of the comments, but I didn't read the article. I was much more interested in the comments. Having said that, if these comments were an audiobook, or a word for word movie script, I'd probably only be through about 5 of them. Words rule! On the other hand, if a picture is worth 1,000 words, a movie must be worth billions! Unfortunately it takes a lot of study of a picture to get 1,000 word out of it. That's a lot of pausing.
- enobrev 10y agoI was first employee and lead engineer at a startup that was primarily focused on video, which eventually got aquired by a very well known video sharing platform. If there's one thing I learned in that 5 years, it's that I don't care much about video. I had every opportunity to find a way to care. I enjoyed creating the technologies that we created. I enjoyed managing the systems we built and meshed. I enjoyed inventing ways to store and retrieve Terabytes of short videos for thousands of people. I even enjoyed building a prototype video renderer in Javascript (which was eventually ported to C). But as far as consumption is concerned, I couldn't be bothered with the vast majority of it. The applications that we built were an attempt to resolve some of this. We were building editing / curation tools to help improve video, and some of the people using our software created incredible things, that I absolutely loved. I especially dislike the trend in the past (5?) years toward programming tutorials in video. Give me a written tutorial. Give me a blog post. Give me a well-commented repo, or at least a poorly commented one with a decent README file. When teaching anything involving a textual artform / profession, give me Anything but a visual / audial medium. I write and read code for a living, and otherwise I write and read about problems solved with code all day. When it comes to programming, video is a square peg in a knife fight. That said, I have an enormous collection of TV shows and Movies, and I have a great deal of appreciation for the medium, in general. One of my close friends is an Editor in Hollywood and I have such an absolute respect for him and the creative sides of his industry. I love to see his work and hear about the intricacies therein. When edited and curated, video is splended. I can dive in and forget the world exists and appreciate nuance and symmetry of visuals, sounds, and ideas. And despite my feelings about programming videos, I know it's possible to learn from video, depending on the subject. I don't want to watch videos of everyone I know doing every day things. I don't want to watch unedited, uncurated crap in real time. Every time a "Live" video link shows up on my FB notifications, I skip it. I don't want to see you live. If I did, I'd video chat with you, or I'd call you up to hang out. But if you want me to take some time out to watch your broadcast, then I expect some planning, editing, and and overall respect for my time. This is video, after all. It's all-consuming. I have to watch AND listen in real time, which means I'm not doing anything else. Asking that much of me requires respect. Of course another benefit of text is that it's so easy to edit. I don't know if you've actually enjoyed reading this post, but I assure you the first version was much, much worse. And if you just skimmed it and ended up here, at this sentence, well there it is: my favorite part about text over video.
- rathish_g 10y agoI work in eLearning and we create a lot of visual content as its easy to convey ideas in video than through text. The cost of video production is at least 50X or 100X more than text and hence, we take extra caution to make sure that it's precise and accurate. What is said in 1500 words is trimmed down to 250 words to create a video. It goes through multiple talents like motion graphics team, anchors etc before it hits the screen and hence it's interesting to watch. Text, caption etc are just there for SEO. Bandwidth is the only constrain, especially in developing nations. And then there are low-quality mugshot videos, which takes less budget than what it takes to present the same content in text. The quality ones will replace text forever.
- aaron695 10y ago> The quality ones will replace text forever And this need to be a startup.
- aaron695 10y agoThis is why it makes me laugh when idiots think the Minority Report interface could ever work. Text will rule for a long while yet.
- arkj 10y agoTemporal disillusions caused by a feeling of being in control. A desire to rush to novel/radical claims with a cloak of pretentious knowledge. Sometimes its such a strain to wade through. And yes, go ahead, downvote.
- sly010 10y agoA lot of us here works with information for a living. Of course, we prefer the leaner, more information dense medium. Facebook is not a platform to communicate interesting ideas succinctly. I apologize for not coming up a better way of saying this, but Facebook is catering for the not-so-sophisticated. The majority of users probably can't scan/process text very fast. Facebook is TV. It wants to be TV.
- muddi900 10y agoYep. TV was revolutionary for advertisements and marketing. The passive viewing makes us more susceptible to them. TV ad revenue is still 10 times the amount for online ads world wide. I have always assumed that all social nedia want to be the new TV.
- Hoasi 10y ago> Facebook is TV. It wants to be TV. It's a great comparison. TV, in many ways is an obsolete medium, and yet it is still efficient and remains popular despite the advent of streaming and other media offering.
- instakill 10y agothis is profoundly insightful. thank you :)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 10y agoThis suggests that video lectures such as offered by coursera could be improved on by providing a transcript for every video lecture. Has this been done by any of the other online teaching institutions?
- Elvewyn 10y agoEdX does that, I just started a course on it.
- Animats 10y agoIt's not clear what Facebook is thinking here. Video is useful for showing what you did, but not useful for communicating what you want to do. Maybe this reflects that people don't plan trips on Facebook any more; they use Instagram for that. One could interpret this as Facebook abandoning communication in favor of being a collection of public scrapbooks.
- salmonet 10y agoVideos can be made to be extremely entertaining and take very little effort to consume. It makes sense that video will be increasingly important for Facebook.
- dandare 10y agoVideo is good for showing falling people (or naked). When I look for information - news, tutorials, knowledge - I avoid video like a plague. Three words: Low Information Density.
- Illniyar 10y agoWasn't there a paper from facebook where it says 80% of videos are watched without sound? Doesn't it mean that most of these videos are watched with subtitles? How is that taken into aaoumt with the "death" of text?
- kalleboo 10y ago> Doesn't it mean that most of these videos are watched with subtitles? No, it means they're not actually watched at all. Facebook autoplays videos (without sound) when you scroll through your timeline. If you get distracted and stop scrolling and 10 seconds play, they count that as a "play".
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago> Mendelsohn went further, suggesting that stats showed the written word becoming all but obsolete, replaced by moving images and speech. "The best way to tell stories in this world, where so much information is coming at us, actually is video," Mendelsohn said. This is going to go down in history alongside the mythical "640K ought to be enough for anybody" and the guy who thought the internet was just a fad.
- spazzpp2 10y agoFirst, FB assimilated Wikipedia (just text, few images). FB also assimilated IMDB. Then, they discovered that most links aren't Wikipedia anymore but it's youtube. So they assimilate a video service so that they will be quoted when another hyped video comes up and not youtube again. Aaand facebook will continue to assimilate. Google's AI features should be at their next aim. Facebook is Borg. Faceborg.
- welanes 10y ago"stats showed the written word becoming all but obsolete, replaced by moving images and speech." Obsolete would be a stretch however for many the web is all about consumption. Mobile devices cement this point. And videos are a very efficient way to consume information: - Read the book VS watch the TED talk. - Go to the recipe site VS watch this Tastemade video. - Read the Foreign Affairs article on the complexities of the Syrian war VS Watch this cool graphic filled Vox video. And even with the written word, text is becoming more terse: - Read this article vs Read this set of tweets But people will never stop writing so perhaps all Facebook is saying is that the written word will become less relevant to their business model as they slowly turn into something resembling Snapchat
- sametmax 10y agoText is an efficient medium to express something complex. But the average facebook user is not expressing something complex. He shares quick reactions, emotions, stuff that trigger anger or fun. Not things that requires deep analysis. For that, video is perfect. So in the context of Facebook, it makes sense. In the context of ads, it makes sense. Yes, we don't want to believe it because it sounds like hell to people reading HN religiously, where text is kind, where people debate, where people don't use smileys, and where ideas get evaluated. But that's not what Facebook is for. And that's not what the people on Facebook want.
- kalleboo 10y agoHow much Facebook browsing is done discreetly in school, at work, in meetings, on public transport, when waiting for someone? Will video work in these situations? I doubt they'll be able to replace their current text with video. It sounds more to me like they're looking at the bigger ad dollars YouTube is getting and want to absorb their market. The only way for Facebook to grow now is to get out of the "friends and family" market and take over Twitter and YouTube's "celebrity/popular people" market. It seems like this could be a difficult pivot.
- cheez 10y agoBut they already have Instagram don't they?
- hacksonx 10y agoAm I the only one who stops reading an informative English article when the word "because" is used to begin a sentence? Maybe text does deserve to die.
- nathan_long 10y agoBecause of your insightful commentary, the site has decided to close.
- sbmassey 10y agoTo devils advocate, though, what if automatic transcripting of text from video actually worked reliably? You might then get many of the advantages of text in video form: ability to search, copy-paste, fast forward and backward while still seeing what is going on. You would still see the presenters ugly mouth flapping up and down, however, which might be thought a negative.
- aout 10y ago"Plenty of people can deal with text better than they can spoken language" That's a joke right ?
- almost 10y agoDeaf people are an obvious example. As are people dealing with content not in their native language. Accents can also be an issue. And then there are many people who would simply prefer to read something over heating it. Is that really so hard to understand?
- dagw 10y agoI can read faster than most people talk. With text I can go back and re-read the bits I'm having trouble understanding and skim over the stuff I already know. With text the is never a problem with hard to understand accents or people who mumble or speak softly. In fact, thinking about it, text is almost always better to deal with than spoken language.
- maus42 10y agoWhy it would be? I sometimes have trouble conversing in crowded places if there's lot of other people having their conversations loudly. Not much trouble, though, but listening to the only one thread of discussion requires bit extra mental effort. Then there are people who don't speak clearly, and you have to ask them to repeat what they said... And all this in my native language. I find dealing with written forms of any foreign language I know much easier than the spoken language. (Both "understand" and "produce by myself".)
- heisenbit 10y agoHumans are wired to seek validation. Consumption of media that expresses resonant emotions is to a degree validating. However expressing and understanding myself and seeing myself emotionally and intellectually understood by peers is validation on another deeper level. The composition and writing of text has been shown to excite other areas of the brain than simple speech (there is a whole school on writing therapy). There is always going to be a need for an immediate way to consuming and reacting. That market is served by twitter and snap-chat. Then there is the need for longer, carefully considered deeper thought. Thought where emotions have been deliberately moderated to provide breathing space for facts. Video may provide more bits per second and via the eyes is more directly wired to our decision system. But the emotional space is already take by twitter and snapchat. The deliberation space is taken by text. It is not clear to me video will grow beyond a extended snapchat.
- known 10y agoIrrational exuberance by FB
- erikb 10y agoMaybe a reason for declining text on FB is that people who like to talk to other people don't use FB anymore.
- nelmaven 10y agoYou don't need sound for text.
- sverige 10y agoWhile video has the ability to communicate certain things more efficiently than text, it is far inferior in other ways. For example, video is great at showing the physical relationship between car parts - what they look like, where they go - so if I'm trying to figure out how to get to that sixth spark plug on a 1990 Bronco II, I'm going to look for a video. Video is also good at pacing the timing of emotional reactions. If it weren't, no one would watch movies. If, on the other hand, I'm trying to learn or experience something complicated, like how to code in a new language, or an overview of the history of the idea of revolution, or any kind of theology, I'm going to read about it. I'm not going to watch some talking head give me far fewer words in the same amount of time, even if the video has some nice music and pans across a few pictures of cathedrals while the narrator speaks. Words are the fundamental unit of thinking, and video is piss-poor at communicating words, especially when compared to writing.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> Words are the fundamental unit of thinking, Woa. Biig assumption. I totally agree that text is "fundamental" indeed to our ability to communicate our mind-state, but text is not our mind state and it's a huge leap from "I can communicate with text" to "I'm thinking in text". You might as well assume video frames are fundamental units of thinking.
- sverige 10y ago"Words," not "text." Illiterate people have words but can't read text. And some people "think in pictures" or "feelings" but that kind of thinking isn't the same as thinking in words.
- threepipeproblm 10y agoI would say the information density of text is much higher than that of video, at least for my purposes.
- gedrap 10y agoI don't think Facebook is wrong. It just so happens that video works better on Facebook (and probably other social networks), where the stream of information is huge. People, most of them anyway, suck at describing things. Most of them can snap a picture of something nice, exciting, cute, whatever. Not everyone is writer, nor should one be to share some everyday thing. Text has it's uses. It's just that other mediums usually tend to work better on Facebook. And that's fine.
- sklogic 10y ago> "It conveys so much more information in a much quicker period." What a pathetic load of hogwash. Video is the slowest possible way of conveying any meaningful information.
- nathan_long 10y agoCame here to comment on same. It depends. No amount of text can give you the feel of an event like a short video. On the other hand, imagine TV news as "read the entire NY Times" - it would take all night. Print has way more information, AND it's easy to skim.
- foobarbecue 10y agoInteresting that the author chose "deathless" over "immortal."
- hanniabu 10y agoIt'd be great if we could extract subtitles from video and put into a nice text format that's easy to read so it's skimmable. Then when you get to an area of interest, you should be able to click the place where you're interested and a video will pop up and start from there. Then when you've heard what you wanted to hear you can minimize the video and skim the text for the next area of interest and so on.
- enobrev 10y agoI imagine there could be an interesting means of moving the playhead along with your skimming, so when you highlight a block of text (as I do, habitually), the video would play through the selection and pause at the end. I'd love to use text as a video controller.
- trevyn 10y agoThis is a great idea -- text is much faster to read, but watching a speaker is much more information-dense due to body language and intonation. This would be a fun hack. Looks like the YouTube caption data is available via API: https://developers.google.com/youtube/v3/docs/captions/download https://developers.google.com/youtube/v3/docs/captions/downl...
- hanniabu 10y agoI can't try this out at the moment, but from looking at the documentation I don't see it say that it returns the timestamp of the caption anywhere.
- hanniabu 10y agoYes, this is pretty much what I was picturing except without having to select the end, this way it doesn't just cut off when you were still interested in what was being said even though you might not have planned on watching past that particular point.
- y14 10y agoThis is a problem we (accessible.ai) have been working on in the past few months. We're still tuning and improving but with a multi-modal approach of signal processing, speech recognition and text analysis we were able to come up with a pretty good MVP to solve this issue. You can take a look at our small demo here: http://accessible.ai/nav http://accessible.ai/nav
- x4m 10y agoI think that interesting topic is "will we create programs as text for a long time?". Projection IDE seems to stall. Some time ago I was thinking about visual query language for databases (domain-specific) and composed this list of text advantages: 1. Version control systems (VSC) out of the box. Software developers have been using safe source code tracking for many decades. Since queries are the main tools for data analysts, they should be treated the same way, but the development of all VCS features in a custom query editor is not economically viable. 2. Portability. Text queries can be written even on a whiteboard and a notepad. One of the great advantages of text queries is that they are unambiguous: there are no hidden parts in a text query. 3. Detachable. Text queries can be run in different warehouses. They should not depend on identifiers, conditions, and environmental variables. 4. Fragmentation. An analyst can extract some feature from a query and partly pass it to his colleagues. 5. Embedding. Software developers easily can embed queries into autotests, side subsystems can embed query parts into their code or resources. 6. Specification. DSQL can be a part of a system’s applied programming interface (API) for third party systems if DSQL specification is precise enough.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- adaptiveprism 10y agoFacebook having been created by a jew will most certainly always have text.
- adaptiveprism 10y agoFacebook was created by Mark Zuckerberg, who is jewish in his descent. It is commonly known that jews love to banter and argue for fun so it is only natural Facebook will always have text.
- matchagaucho 10y agoThe 90 / 9 / 1 rule is finally taking hold on Facebook. With only 1% of the users generating content, 9% simply liking/commenting, and 90% logging in to just watch.... FB is desperate to satiate the immediate gratification needs of 1B+ people. Video is the quick fix. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule_(Internet_culture) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1%25_rule_(Internet_culture)
- pixelmonkey 10y agoIt's interesting to consider how painful a "video-only Wikipedia" would be to use. If the point is to distract, then video is certainly at an advantage. If the point is to communicate or inform, then certainly text is the winner. I guess that explains FB's hope for a rise of video content.
- fuzzfactor 10y agoAs a consumer/dependent-based institution which benefits from increased control strives for growth and succeeds, eventually you reach a point where the most benefit to the institution can best be achieved using less literate followers/subjects.
- chiefalchemist 10y agoFB is missing three significant differences. 1 - Consuming video is time consuming. There is no quick scan for key words etc. If you're locked in on video X there's no scrolling on, etc. Your experience, in a way, stops. 2 - Video is passive. Reading takes engagement. Those will effect the brain very differently. 3 - Video is not conversational. It's traditional top down broadcasting. Sure FB might become more video but that doesn't mean it's going to result in the same attachment to the product, at least for adults.
- mark_l_watson 10y agoI don't agree with the article. As others have already said here, text is random access and easy to process and retain information. I am going to drift off topic: the future is AI that understands what we say, recognizes our facial expressions, and generally "gets us." While there are obvious potential downsides, the upsides involve getting notified of things in the order of most useful and entertaining first. AIs will use text, still photos, and videos to show us what we want to know and experience. This whole idea creeps me out a bit, but it is probably the future. At some point in time, effective computer to human neural I/O connectors will be invented, and the effect of civilization will be interesting. So, video -> direct neural implants.