7 ms·
I see a different problem here: Ethereum and the DAO were not in a mature state to handle this amount of money. For example, there is a limited support for upgr
by wslh 10y ago
I see a different problem here: Ethereum and the DAO were not in a mature state to handle this amount of money. For example, there is a limited support for upgrading contracts in Ethereum and the DAO was not reviewed enough to handle hundreds of million dollars.
Also, there are methods to make the software ultra secure using formal models.
- infodroid 10y agoI always wondered why there was such a rush to launch the DAO. As opposed to what Ethereum itself did: develop a proof of concept for over a year, then release a beta version and provide bounties for security bugs, all the while collaborating with testers and security researchers to stress the software.
- fudged71 10y agoTheDAO effectively turned into a massive bug bounty, a pot up for grabs.
- infodroid 10y agoIndeed an important question that will be decided soon is whether the "hacker" will get to keep the reward pot, or whether the rules of the game will change to deny it.
- drewm1980 10y agoI am curious if a huge DAO-like organization could avoid being a target solely by keeping very of its wealth liquid at any moment... i.e. what would have happened if 99.99% of the DAO's eth were loaned out... would the hacker have bothered? (assuming it wasn't an inside job)
- SkyMarshal 10y ago>I always wondered why there was such a rush to launch the DAO. So Slock.it could raise money, obviously. A common complaint right around when Slock.it launched the DAO was that Slock.it planned to offer the first funding proposal on it but only provided a brief 2-week period for review and debate before the voting started. It had the appearance of an attempt at railroading the crowdfunding process for a quick payoff. Fortunately cooler heads uncovered the problems and spoke out, putting the brakes on. Now it's a big learning experience for the ~23,000 people who blindly jumped on the hypetrain and put money into a flawed investment vehicle. You'd think the first 7 years of Bitcoin would have taught people a lesson that this technology is risky, but dollar signs in the eyes tend to obscure hindsight I guess.
- rphlx 10y ago> ~23,000 people who blindly jumped on the hypetrain I haven't touched ETH or the DAO personally, but it is unfair to label every investment in them irrational. Over the past 5 years cryptocurrencies have provided multiple opportunities to convert, say, $10k into $100k or even $1M within a year or two; once your networth exceeds a certain amount, risking 1-2% of it on an opportunity like that is arguably wise - i.e. would be worth repeating - even if it does fail spectacularly. It is certainly true that as long as that reasoning delivers 10-100x+ returns to some of the people some of the time, a giant fount of speculative money will continue to moisten a lot of scammers, con artists, and insufficiently-careful SW developers though.
- alvarosm 10y agoIt's pretty obvious and simple. Because they want to run away with your money NOW. Ethereum had money already so they could survive while waiting to scam you even more.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoCore problem: If contracts can be upgraded while in use, everything reduces to a game of Nomic.
- grandalf 10y agoThat depends on whether you think of a contract as an interface or as an implementation. A contract should present an interface that includes a declaration of its behavior. The declared behavior should be well defined, and if a bug in the implementation is discovered, the contract should be updatable to fix the bug. There could even be futures expressing the probability that a contract will be found to have a bug. The willingness of participants to use a contract would depend on the chances that something about the interface is bug-prone, untested, etc. As long as bugs do not result in reversal of money flow, the incentives seem to align properly toward a well-defined approach for declarative contracts.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoWhat you're trying to solve is something very similar to the recursive self improvement problem that MIRI[1] and friends are trying to solve in the sphere of "friendly" artificial intelligence. If something rewrites its own source code, how can you assert invariants that can be relied upon? So going and looking over there at what they've come up with may be fruitful. [1] https://intelligence.org/ https://intelligence.org/
- grandalf 10y agoVery interesting! Looking at the papers and going to read them. Any specific papers you'd recommend?
- JulianMorrison 10y agoSorry, not qualified to have an opinion. Opening this question to the floor?
- 10y ago
- grandalf 10y agoFormal verification is the right approach. Do you know of any specifics for this goal that exist for ETH now?
- SkyMarshal 10y agoVlad Zamfir, Greg Meredith, and Emin Gun Sirer are working on this for Ethereum's next consensus algo, Casper. Not aware that they've published anything on it yet though.
- wslh 10y agoThis: http://hackingdistributed.com/2016/06/17/thoughts-on-the-dao-hack/ http://hackingdistributed.com/2016/06/17/thoughts-on-the-dao...
- DennisP 10y agoContracts can be upgraded if they're designed that way. You can have a wrapper contract that just calls out to other contracts, where the addresses of the other contracts are updateable. You can even make the callee run in the context of the caller, so all the data is held at the caller, which calls an external function that manipulates it. Doing this is a tradeoff. On the one hand it lets you fix bugs and vulnerabilities, on the other your users have to trust you not to abuse your power.
- JulianMorrison 10y agoIt completely obviates the point, because a contract no longer means what it says, it means what Bob says. So just wire your money to Bob, it's simpler.
- carver 10y agoWhile I prefer non-upgradable contracts for the same reason, there are mechanisms to reach some middle ground, like: 1) a significant delay between the announcement of an upgrade and the actual upgrade (enforced by the blockchain) 2) a mechanism to opt-out or cash out before the upgrade happens
- wslh 10y agoAre you referring to this kind of upgrades https://gist.github.com/Arachnid/4ca9da48d51e23e5cfe0f0e14dd6318f https://gist.github.com/Arachnid/4ca9da48d51e23e5cfe0f0e14dd... ? Because you have an important limitation if you use that approach.
- cwillu 10y agoUntil such time as a College of Hortators gets invented and people start including standard provisions to defer some decisions to them. Yay, the courts have been reintroduced.