6 ms·
The thing is that I don't think what humans are good at is statically predicting the movement of objects from video. Rather, I think the strong human skill is
by joe_the_user 10y ago
The thing is that I don't think what humans are good at is statically predicting the movement of objects from video.
Rather, I think the strong human skill is reacting appropriately and quickly to movements.
- jamesrcole 10y agoI don't think you could react quickly to something without having predicted the behavior of that thing in advance.
- LionessLover 10y agoDepends on what you mean by "predict". Also, unfortunately I don't even remember where I saw or heard this in a lecture, but when studying neuroscience I remember to have seen exactly this question and an example showing that you actually don't have to make predictions. I also forgot the explanation that showed how the (real, biological) neural network solves just such a problem without having to make a prediction. I only have the fuzziest memory of it being a process and at no point was there any prediction of the path of the object being tracked. It was just matching several sensory signal inputs and creating outputs, something clever, using an indirect approach. "Predicting" would be observing the object for x amount of time, doing a calculation where it will be some time later, using a model to come up with a way to intercept, then creating outputs, all of that in a loop, something like that. In any case, the way the neural network actually solved it was completely different from how an engineer would do it. In a sense, the neural network was "cheating" and doing far less work than you would expect. The one thing I do remember for sure was there was no "prediction" involved - none at all. Unless you argue backwards and say because it succeeded you declare the process a "prediction". Once explained the whole process was actually quite primitive. Again, that was research on an actual biological neural network. Darn, now I wish I had paid more attention. Any actual neuroscientists here? Without the details even I myself can't see my own comment as a satisfactory reply, but only as a step to actually getting one from somewhere or someone else. But note that it depends on what you mean by "prediction" - as I said, if you define it backwards from success than sure, prediction happened. My point is that the process is very different from how a human-made algorithm would do it.
- jamesrcole 10y agoThink of trying to catch a fast moving object. Neutral process are relatively slow. Then they need to send nerve signals to muscles in the arm and hand. Then the muscles have to contact. All these things take time. That means the brain processing had to be done in anticipation of where the ball will be. That means it has to predict where the ball will be. I have a feeling that you're using an overly narrow meaning for "predict"
- joe_the_user 10y agoI have a feeling that you're using an overly narrow meaning for "predict" Well, I have writing in the context of the article, where people are asked to statically predict the position of an object from watching a video. I would concede it's quite possible that a very accurate object prediction engine lives somewhere in the brain but I think it's even more likely that such information can't be marshaled by a person based on a verbal cues any more than one could verbally describe with accuracy where one's foot should go next while walking.
- amatic 10y agoThere are different ways of predicting. There is a series of research on catching fly-balls that claims there is no prediction in the sense of "estimate/predict end position, move to estimated position"; instead there is an ongoing process of "maintaining the visually perceived velocity of the ball". You end up catching the ball just the same. http://www.mindreadings.com/OpticalTrajRM.pdf http://www.mindreadings.com/OpticalTrajRM.pdf http://www.mindreadings.com/ControlDemo/CatchXY.html http://www.mindreadings.com/ControlDemo/CatchXY.html
- jamesrcole 10y agoI mean 'predicting' in the general sense of needing to arrange the details in advance, which is a necessary requirement on any real-time system. . EDIT: to all the responses objecting to what I'm saying - I'm aware of the details you are talking about, and I believe you are reading much more into what I'm saying than I have actually said. - do you deny that the brain has to set in motion the muscular activities in advance? - you seem to all be working on a very narrow notion of what predicting means - that it must be some explicit calculation of coordinates.