8 ms·
The only thing I wish on NIMBYs is for them to spend a decade in a Soviet queue for apartments. This shortage is man-made.
by vkou 10y ago
The only thing I wish on NIMBYs is for them to spend a decade in a Soviet queue for apartments.
This shortage is man-made.
- bhickey 10y agoI have a handful of friends who left Russia in the early 90s and the pictures they paint of the USSR are highly unflattering in this regard. One, the daughter of Lenin Prize winner, grew up in a cramped two bedroom apartment. My guess is that things were much worse down the social totem pole.
- scarmig 10y agoWell, part of the Communist marketing brand is that everyone equally gets a cramped two bedroom apartment, so it'd be useful to get hard evidence one way or another. From what I've read about Soviet housing in the Krushchev era, though, you were very lucky if you got a cramped two bedroom. Not sure about the 70s and 80s.
- vkou 10y agoThe Communist marketing brand is that everyone would eventually get an apartment. Once communism is achieved, that is.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoThat sounds more like capitalism, which says that you might someday earn a one-bedroom condo, if you're innovative enough to start a company and get a good exit.
- eru 10y agoMarketing isn't very creative.. Christianity and some other religions also promise some utopia in the future.
- ctdonath 10y agoNo, capitalism is realizing that Zillow.com can find you a host of cheap properties in minutes, and HomeDepot.com or Tumbleweed.com can put a house on it cheap. ...while you start a company.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoYou're dodging my actual point, which the other replier definitely understood. Once Upon a Time, we Westerners looked at Communism and laughed. We justified our system (democracy for the state, capitalism for the economy) by pointing out all the obvious material benefits we reaped from it: * High economic growth * Cheap, varied, available, high-quality consumer goods * High and climbing wages * A class structure that looked more like a Gaussian curve than an exponential distribution, with greater actually-existing, de-facto equality than the Communist countries * Workers' rights and the free formation of unions * Public infrastructure, parks, and transit * Cheap, acceptable housing for families, leading to widespread owner-occupancy becoming the norm, something rarely seen in civilized human history * Ever-climbing life expectancies at birth, thanks to rigorous public health, sanitation, and disease control measures In contrast, the Eastern Bloc promised that Real Soon Now, actually-existing socialism would be transformed into Full Communism, and people could have nice things. All they had to do was make a few sacrifices today to defeat the fascist capitalists and experience great rewards tomorrow! They promised "jam tomorrow" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jam_tomorrow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jam_tomorrow), but we had jam today. Whereas nowadays, the spectrum of jam-promises has shifted. Nowadays, the capitalist West promises its people, "Jam tomorrow, for the deserving", while most of the Second and Third World have switched to promising, "Jam never, it was always a lie meant to lead you away from God and Putin." We can still kinda say we've got the cheap, widespread consumer goods, but not so much the rest of it.
- eru 10y agoRemember https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/We_will_bury_you https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/We_will_bury_you and Sputnik? Communism seemed to have higher growth rates for a while.
- csydas 10y agoThings have, for better or worse, changed pretty dramatically, at least from my experiences. I've been in Russia with my partner for about 3 years now, and we've lived in St. Petersburg, Moscow, and for a brief time, in Pereslavl. While the apartments aren't huge by comparison to most houses in the US, they are pretty comfortable, though the quality will vary depending on the particular building and region you live in. Most of the buildings appear to be the same that were built during the USSR, it's just the internals were remodeled with more modern amenities. It can take a little getting used to, living in somewhat cramped quarters, but for me anyways, I've always had fairly small places to live growing up, whether it was living in a 3 bedroom with 6 people in college, my cheapo first apartment, I guess it's more just something you get used to. Even now, my partner and I live with her mom/aunt in a 3 bedroom apartment in SPB and, aside from occasionally stumbling across each other in the kitchen and funny battles for the bathroom, we get by just fine.
- cema 10y agofunny battles for the bathroom Not so funny as soon as you have children.
- csydas 10y agoheh, meant it sarcastically. Both where I live now and growing up, I've been in situations where it's 1 bathroom for 5 and 4 people respectively, and a queue forming in your own home for the toilet just gets silly, even if it's frustrating.
- eru 10y agoHave a look at "Why are there NIMBYs?" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11919667 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11919667
- api 10y agoTL;DR: it's because home equity is used as a savings account, and it's the primary or sometimes only means whereby most members of the middle class can accumulate significant savings. Therefore any land use changes that might negatively impact home values threaten peoples' savings, and alternately any land use changes that positive impact home values can be profitable to existing homeowners. It's a very simple, deeply perverse incentive structure. It's in the best interests of those who own homes to lock people out of homeownership.
- eru 10y agoThe big insight I see is that it's not only expected values, but unhedged variance that make people NIMBYs.
- afarrell 10y agoHmmmmmm... As someone with family in Boston and who plans to return there, I really want a some way to invest 20% of my IRA contributions in the Boston housing market until I can actually afford to buy a house there and move back. I wonder if I can help someone else hedge against the market going down.
- eru 10y agoSlightly related, they have housing cooperative in Germany, especially the East. You can own a share, and get much reduced rent in return, in any of the cooperatives apartments and houses in the city. Depending on how well they do, they might also pay a dividend, but mostly the owners of the cooperative are also the renters, so generally they rather keep the rent down than make a profit. I know old people who `paid' for their shares by working on building sites for these very houses in the 50s and 60s. See http://www.wohnungsbaugenossenschaften.de/genossenschaften/how-cooperatives-work http://www.wohnungsbaugenossenschaften.de/genossenschaften/h... and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_cooperative#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_cooperative#Germany
- 13of40 10y agoIn the actual apartment isn't so hot either. I've stayed in my wife's childhood home a couple of times, and it's like two concrete shipping-container-sized boxes set side by side, with a tenth story balcony.
- sien 10y agoOne way to look at the problem is that something thought to handle externalities creates a bigger externality itself. If zoning laws could be priced somehow so that when they become a cost they had to change or reduce it might help. Zoning laws in places without expensive real estate like, say, much of the US midwest probably makes things better for people. In SF or in this example in MA and other really popular places they make things worse. Perhaps some economist has tried to calculate the price of NIMBY, zoning law externalities. Anyone know of someone who has tried?
- bhickey 10y agoI really doubt that zoning laws improve quality of life for people in your average randomly selected town. Zoning laws give us things like parking requirements which drive down density and force everyone to drive. Then there's frontage requirements, setbacks, bans on multifamily and commercial construction. One way we could price zoning laws is through their impact on buildable space. As long as we raise taxes on the beneficiaries, everything'll come out in the wash, right?
- gozur88 10y ago>I really doubt that zoning laws improve quality of life for people in your average randomly selected town. Zoning laws give us things like parking requirements which drive down density and force everyone to drive. If you do drive, though, you are not going to appreciate new development which makes it impossible to park when you get home from work. Not everyone hates living in places where people drive.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoIf people want a guaranteed place to park, they should build a parking space on their own property. There is no reason that public space should be given away to people for the purpose of parking.
- ghaff 10y ago
- ktRolster 10y agoEveryone is a NIMBY in their own way, it's just a difference of how much annoyance you are willing to tolerate. Most people wouldn't want a noisy factory or a smelly dairy next door, for example, but those things have to be somewhere. Now imagine you spent a lot of money to get a house with a nice view. Suddenly Larry Ellison decides to build a skyscraper next door, which blocks the sun on your property every day. You can't even grow flowers anymore because there's not enough sun. Some of your trees die. Are you happy? Now imagine you spent a lot of money for your house. A housing company proposes changes to the neighborhood that will reduce the value of your house by 20%. In other words, you will be working and paying for years on a portion of your house that no longer has value. Are you happy? Well, maybe you can handle it because you're rich. So these are the kinds of things that go through the minds of NIMBYs.
- manachar 10y agoFunny you mention Ellison. That's pretty much what he's doing on Lānaʻi, though less the giant skyscraper and more the idea of remaking the island for his own purposes.
- ktRolster 10y agoYeah, it (more or less) happened to him actually: http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702303654804576343763766328484 http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014240527023036548045763437...
- michael_h 10y agoHow strange is it to be Larry Ellison? Actually, all parties in that dispute are weird. Dude expects the world to freeze around him (who knew that redwoods would grow), so he offers to double the landowner's investment, giving them an $8 million dollar profit...and they don't accept. Know what I'd do with $8 million dollars in real estate profit? Retire immediately.
- ethbro 10y ago