5 ms·
While Buffer's transparency is incredible, the financial calculations in the article fail to account for the possibility of an employee exodus domino effect, es
by minimaxir 10y ago
While Buffer's transparency is incredible, the financial calculations in the article fail to account for the possibility of an employee exodus domino effect, especially after both knowing the financial state of the company, and relevant perks being cut.
- Animats 10y agoRight. In general, if you have a layoff and the job market isn't extremely tight, you will also lose some other employees you wanted to keep. Especially the ones who see that top management's plans aren't working and it's time to jump ship.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIs it possible to stem an employee exodus when fully transparent? I don't think so. It only works when there's a level of information asymmetry.
- st3v3r 10y agoI think it is, unless your situation is so terrible where you don't think you'll be around in 3-6 months.
- dasil003 10y agoI don't follow your thinking at all. You're assuming that the truth is always so horrible that management can never fully reveal it, and your not accounting for the whiff of secrecy and gossip that can be much worse than the actual withheld information.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoPerhaps its because I've been at more failed companies than most? Regardless of transparency vs secrecy, you reach a tipping point where the situation "feels" dire enough that employees leaving accelerates. I'm sure it depends on the demographics of the org, employees with families, mortgages, etc are willing to stick out volatility far less (in my experience) than employees with no obligations. Anecdotal of course! I'd love to have more data on this to find out what that tipping point is.
- dasil003 10y agoI agree with everything you said. But it doesn't address why you think secrecy is always necessary.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoIf you work because you need a job, and your company is transparent, and its in a financially precarious state, why would you stay?
- dasil003 10y agoIn this case though, the graph shows that the layoffs are bringing Buffer to profitability. If they kept that secret and just told the employees not to worry, they would be just as likely to assume that management was merely decreasing the burn, in which case their assumption would be worse than reality. Secrecy cuts both ways.
- st3v3r 10y agoI fail to see what the problem is here.
- hguant 10y agoI would actually think the opposite: if you're a buffer employee right now, you know a) the company will continue to exist b) that you're a valuable asset to the company and c) that your founders walk the walk when it comes to transparency and information sharing. I'd assume a few people will leave for better offers in the next few weeks, but this seems to prove that the founders are dedicated to the company and can learn from mistakes - hardly the prompt for a mass exodus.
- bovermyer 10y agoNot only that, but the founders themselves took a 40% pay cut each for the next year. That says to me that they value their employees enough that they chose that route rather than lay off an additional person. It's a strong gesture.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- abglassman 10y agoAnd the founders each loaned the company $100k out of their own pockets at "the lowest possible interest rate." There's a lot of laudable humility and self-accountability in this post and the actions they've taken.
- qmr 10y agoI read that as weasel word bullshit. The lowest possible rate would be 0.
- disordinary 10y agoExcept it seems as though they all signed up to be at a company that was transparent and practiced a certain way of doing business (and actually pushes it as one of the great reasons to work there) and then you find out it was all a lie and that management was hiding information from you as suited them. By their own admission the layoffs came out of the blue to staff despite the fact that they were deliberating on it for a while. If they practiced what they preached they would have laid it all out early. Some people may have had other opportunities and left, others might have said that they would take a paycut for the greater good, etc. What this may mean, is that some staff members think that the company isn't actually what it says it is, isn't genuine in its approach, and that they can't trust it to live up to it's values when the going does get tough.
- fideloper 10y agoFrom the outside looking in, I think I'd stay (if I was not laid off :D) because Buffer is transparent, because they refuse to be unprofitable, and because they aren't beholden to VC's. In my book, Buffer's doing it "more correctly" than many start ups.
- btilly 10y agoMachiavelli's _The Prince_ has excellent advice on this topic. If you must do bad things, do them all at once. Then create a steady stream of better than expected events. People will get over the shock of the bad, and will remember the good. By contrast if you try to hold back some of the bad, it will drip out bit by bit. Then people will get scared about where the real bottom is.
- abraae 10y agoSuch a great book. I've seen his tactics play our over and over again during my working lifetime.
- rhizome 10y agoFrom what I've experienced, I'd like to see both "The Prince" and "The Art of War" banished from the world of business.
- aioprisan 10y agoWhat do you mean by banished from the world of business? I've seen variations of the core principles applied at every company I've worked for so far.
- rhizome 10y agoMe too, and I think they cause more problems than they solve.
- btilly 10y agoI agree, but why? My take is that the advice in those books is great advice for those seeking to gain and hold power in organizations. All else being equal, you should want the person running your organization to have mastered those ideas and be able to apply them productively for your organization. That said, having an organization full of people who want to gain and hold power is a very, very bad thing. While you want the people at the top to do so, you don't want every Tom, Dick and Harry with a big ego doing so. So you are going to see an anti-pattern where a bunch of people who have no business trying to play Machiavellian games, attempt to do so. And part of the the reason why they should not do so is that they are not suited by temperament or competence.
- danielvf 10y agoGiven that the new statistics show that the company is now cashflow positive and continuing to grow, I don't think a mass exodus is likely.
- georgiecasey 10y agohttps://open.buffer.com/hiring-at-buffer-in-february-2024-applicants-3-offers-made/ https://open.buffer.com/hiring-at-buffer-in-february-2024-ap... i wouldn't be worried about an employee exodus as they get loads of applications as is. and everyone is replaceable IMO. the company fascinates me with their high salaries for customer service and relative low salaries for engineering. from that post, they've way more applications for customer service than engineering. why not save money by paying way less?
- ryanSrich 10y agoSo just hire more people? No one is irreplaceable. Buffer is a very well known, and well regarded startup. An employee exodus would be a minor hiccup (and something that is very unlikely to happen at all).