14 ms·
The illegal city of Somerville
- dang 10y agoUrl changed from http://www.vox.com/2016/6/16/11948630/somerville-zoning-illegal http://www.vox.com/2016/6/16/11948630/somerville-zoning-ille..., which points to this.
- bhickey 10y agoWe're talking about this a lot in Cambridge and I'm hoping to put together an analogous map for us. For example, here's a map of parcels where the floor-area-ratio exceeds 0.75: http://i.imgur.com/D9m9Gx2.jpg http://i.imgur.com/D9m9Gx2.jpg Most of our residential zones are currently zoned with a 0.5 or 0.6 cap. The local NIMBY group has been petitioning the zoning board for more restrictions: downzone an entire neighborhood, add setbacks and more area restrictions along the main thoroughfare. Meanwhile, everyone who isn't affluent or in subsidized housing is getting pushed out to the surrounding towns.
- thenipper 10y agoSeriously. I manage a building in Cambridge and get notifications about zoning changes all the time. And definitely can't afford to live there any more.
- bhickey 10y agoThe city council is currently considering an expansion of inclusionary zoning. The gist is that 20% of new apartments in buildings with six or more units will be reserved for people earning between 50-80% of median income. Put concretely, a school teacher with a stay at home spouse and two kids would be ineligible for one of these units. Since there's no concomitant increase in density, we should see two things: 1. Overall construction should decrease relative to where it would have been. Projects that were previously viable are now underwater. Even worse, if the cap rate fluctuates entire classes of projects become nonviable. 2. Market rate housing will become more expensive at a faster rate. The market is clearing at levels that people at 50% median income can't afford, so setting aside units strictly reduces the market rate supply without any demand reduction. The Terner Center at Berkeley has an interesting policy tool that simulates the impact of various policy choices: http://ternercenter2.berkeley.edu/examplecities/index.html http://ternercenter2.berkeley.edu/examplecities/index.html
- scythe 10y ago>The gist is that 20% of new apartments in buildings with six or more units will be reserved for people earning between 50-80% of median income. Put concretely, a school teacher with a stay at home spouse and two kids would be ineligible for one of these units. Are these developments really as "welfare cliff"-y as they seem? As in: if your income goes up, are you kicked out of the house? Although, most of what I've read suggests that laws which increase cost (such as affordable housing requirements) have a tiny impact relative to laws which increase development time (such as the Telegraph Hill Dwellers calling for a stay of ~everything at council meetings); the latter are far more damaging. On your tool: if you move the affordability requirement from 10% to 25% and reduce the time to approval from 6 months to 4 months, you still build more housing!
- rspeer 10y ago> As in: if your income goes up, are you kicked out of the house? I went to a City Council debate where this was a big issue. Theoretically, yes. But the city doesn't actually want to kick people out of their houses. But there was some concern that people had already pulled some shenanigans to make their finances temporarily suck so that they could get a house in Cambridge.
- vkou 10y agoThe only thing I wish on NIMBYs is for them to spend a decade in a Soviet queue for apartments. This shortage is man-made.
- bhickey 10y agoI have a handful of friends who left Russia in the early 90s and the pictures they paint of the USSR are highly unflattering in this regard. One, the daughter of Lenin Prize winner, grew up in a cramped two bedroom apartment. My guess is that things were much worse down the social totem pole.
- scarmig 10y agoWell, part of the Communist marketing brand is that everyone equally gets a cramped two bedroom apartment, so it'd be useful to get hard evidence one way or another. From what I've read about Soviet housing in the Krushchev era, though, you were very lucky if you got a cramped two bedroom. Not sure about the 70s and 80s.
- vkou 10y agoThe Communist marketing brand is that everyone would eventually get an apartment. Once communism is achieved, that is.
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoThat sounds more like capitalism, which says that you might someday earn a one-bedroom condo, if you're innovative enough to start a company and get a good exit.
- eru 10y agoMarketing isn't very creative.. Christianity and some other religions also promise some utopia in the future.
- 10y ago
- Spooky23 10y agoMy sister lived in Cambridge for awhile. What a shitshow. They wanted to add a second floor to their home, which would have basically made it look like the rest of the block. Some neighbor raised a stink, because they had built a potting shed on my sisters land, and the shadow of the higher roof would damage the plants in the shed!
- nsajko 10y agoWasn't it your sister's shed then?
- bhickey 10y agoDepends on how long it was there. Adverse possession takes 20 years in Massachusetts.
- _acme 10y agoThere are many requirements other than simple time to successfully adverse possess property, such as the possession being open and notorious. Also, adverse possession as such applies only to real property; analogous concepts may exist with respect to personal property depending on the jurisdiction.
- Spooky23 10y ago5 feet of it was :) The city made it clear that they didn't give a hoot about it. So she would have to litigate. Fortunately, the market is insane and they sold the place sight unseen to some Chinese dude for a significant profit.
- ascagnel_ 10y ago> Fortunately, the market is insane and they sold the place sight unseen to some Chinese dude for a significant profit. That's one of the larger issues with the housing market: it's seen as an investment tool by foreigners (especially in hot markets where prices are rising like crazy), so you end up with tons of real estate that's not on the market but also not being used to actually house anyone.
- vacri 10y agoIn an upper-middle class leafy neighbourhood in my hometown of Melbourne, there's a retirement home run by a charity, for people with special needs. They wanted to expand to double capacity, and the complaints came rolling in. The usual to be expected "The expansion is ugly, and will bring down the tone of the neighbourhood" (read: lower house prices with more homeless retirees around), with the best being "The expansion will need to cut down a beautiful 100-year-old tree" Getting services for underprivileged people in a wealthy neighbourhood was always going to be tough, but the kicker for me was this - the residents against the expansion were clear to state "We're not NIMBYs!". Really? What kind of things do you think NIMBYs complain about, if not exactly what you've just said?
- _-__--- 10y agoHey, my apartment is on there! Maybe this is just the fame going to my head, but I sure would like some semblance of a yard.
- jandrese 10y agoHow does this affect resale? I know when I sold my house the buyer's agent insisted that we bring it up to modern code first, and that involved some rather expensive retrofitting of the house.
- Lazare 10y agoThe article is discussing zoning codes; not building codes. Different issues entirely. It's not uncommon to find that you'll need to retrofit an old building to match current fire safety laws, etc. My family recently had to rip out a bunch of old electrical outlets and replace them with newer ones that were deemed safer. Nobody requires you to match current zoning laws.
- sokoloff 10y agoAs long as you can get a Certificate of Occupancy (which in my town requires smoke and CO alarms only), I'd never cure a building code violation in a building I was selling (certainly not in the current Cambridge/Somerville market). You want the code violation cured? No problem; I'll take one of the other 17 offers.
- hga 10y agoI wouldn't imagine new zoning that prevents new buildings in the Somerville model of triple deckers (with flat roofs) and Philadelphia 3 story houses (http://boston.curbed.com/2013/11/25/10170482/defining-philadelphia-style-in-greater-boston http://boston.curbed.com/2013/11/25/10170482/defining-philad...) with very little space between them would have much effect, those sorts of density details are grandfathered, and whatever the city council did is most grandstanding, seeing as how there's no space to build new buildings anyway (I was told houses were torn down to make a few parks in the city). As for code ... heh, I spend a lot of time in Somerville, witnessed a remodeling job in the house I was in back in the late '80s, and am now remodeling a house built in 1910 in my home town (which if memory serves is generally a bit older than most Boston area rental houses). The modern codes are a very different thing and mostly focused on the property itself, although to the extent they decrease the probability of fire they're better for your neighbors (although Somerville's fire department is top notch, which I've witnessed first hand, otherwise not much of it would still be standing, it's one of the few cities in the US that has the fuel density to support a firestorm).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- thenewwazoo 10y agoI genuinely don't get the point. Of course the buildings aren't legal under current zoning laws. They weren't built under current zoning laws! We don't tear down every skyscraper whenever the earthquake requirements change. Nobody moves their house when the setback requirement goes from 8' to 12'. These kinds of articles are tautological. edit: the article mentions "illegal neighborhoods and illegal houses" but doesn't say anything about the laws when they were built.
- chc 10y agoThe point seemed pretty clear to me from reading the article: The author is questioning whether zoning laws actually reflect what we want in a city, given that they would prevent well-liked places such as Somerville from having been built the way they are.
- zanny 10y agoThe laws reflect what those with the money to influence decision makers want in property allocation - maximum long term value through line item qualifications of a properties worth, rather than how useful that property actually is. But it comes full circle, because at the end of the day these properties must have a foundational estimate of value based on what everyone thinks of them. As long as most people agree an acre yard 3 car garage and wall around your land to hide the neighbors is optimal, at least a block away from any highly trafficked street, that is what you get.
- ianmiers 10y agoThe argument isn't about building code (e.g. safety standards) but more so zoning about neighborhood character. The author's point is that the type of higher density housing that actually makes up Somerville could not be built under current zoning laws even if safe and allowed under modern building code. Now, it's entirely possible the dataset the author is using to justify his position actually covers things that are safety issues.
- graeme 10y agoYou're focussing on a nit. The situation is not "the neighbourhood is generally fine, but would need some tweaks for the fire code" The situation is: it's impossible to build a neighbourhood resembling somerville under current zoning laws. I live in a prewar neighbourhood in Montreal. It's dense, beautiful, and loved by locals and tourists alike. If you could clone it and build it elsewhere, it would be worth trillions to cities across North America. But it's illegal to build, because the streets are too narrow, there isn't enough parking, there is a mix of residential buildings and businesses, the buildings aren't set back far enough, and so on.
- tn13 10y agoThe way people use land varies a lot of with time but the laws created by all wise bureaucrats don't. SF and bay area in general has been classic good example. The government attempts to solve problems creating by zoning law is to create more zoning laws eventually becoming an overfiting problem.
- Feneric 10y agoSomerville is not necessarily typical, though. Not sure if it is still true, but as of a few years ago it had the highest population density in all of Massachusetts. Higher than Boston, higher than Cambridge, higher than Worcester. Introducing it as an ordinary suburb of Boston is perhaps a little misleading.
- eru 10y agoJudging by the pictures in the article, Somerville looks very sparse. And that's already the most dense?
- tropo 10y agoYes. It's houses next to Boston. Boston itself has other stuff. People aren't supposed to live in the convention center, baseball stadium, or airport.
- ocschwar 10y agoEach of those houses is home to two or three families.
- bzbarsky 10y agoLooks very sparse compared to what? According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_cities_b... it's the 16th densest city or town in the US. The only place in the US that is both denser and has more people is New York City. Now you could argue that US cities are generally not that dense; NYC is half the density of Paris. But Amsterdam, say, is only 2/3 as dense as Somerville is. Berlin is even less dense than that (but I know its boundaries contain some serious chunks of park/woodland).
- cwmma 10y agoIt has the highest density because it doesn't have any large parks or open space unlike boston which has the islands the arboretum and the airport or Cambridge which has a large pond
- xyzzy4 10y agoSomerville needs more highrises and more subway trains.
- drdeadringer 10y agoI'd tentatively agree on the subway trains.
- Finnucane 10y agoThere's no solving the housing problem without more transit. You're just not going to ever have enough housing here for everyone to live in one place, zoning or no zoning. So: people need ways to get from one place to another. More cars? No. Then you need more roads, more parking. Where are they going to go? Guess what? Some people are going to end up in Malden, Medford, Everett, Revere, etc. So what? Is that so bad? Not if you have a way to get to work in the morning. I'm old enough to remember when we lived in Somerville because it was cheap. The Red Line and the end of rent control in Cambridge brought a lot of gentrification to Somerville. Transit is absolutely necessary in a dense urban area (and yeah, Somerville and Cambridge are already among the most densely populated cities in the country. Another thing is that people use more space now: Before WWII, these cities had more people living in fewer units of housing. We've gone from 4 per unit to 2. As you make more housing available, people want more of it. That's why there's never enough no matter how much you build.
- eru 10y agoI wouldn't want to live there. It's too sparse and suburban for me. (The kind of city I like is even more illegal in America.)
- ghaff 10y agoSomerville is hardly sparse. It's not high rises but it's a densely packed urban neighborhood without much in the way of industry (any longer) but local stores. As someone else said, it appears to be the most densely populated (i.e. people living in the space) area in Massachusetts. Sure, areas of NYC are denser and I appreciate that some might prefer that. This is in spite of the fact that Somerville rail transportation is limited. There's an effort to improve that but it's way over budget.
- eru 10y agoThey seem to have pretty wide streets, and lots of space between buildings. See https://duckduckgo.com/?q=!i+innenstadt https://duckduckgo.com/?q=!i+innenstadt for some random German examples.
- ghaff 10y agoDensity is always a difficult comparison as it depends upon the area chosen. But,according to Wikipedia, Somerville is about 50% denser than Munich for example.
- jonas21 10y agoThat's not really a direct comparison. Somerville is a residential area just outside of Boston, but central Boston is full of places similar to the German examples: https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3645779,-71.0554965,3a,75y,11.36h,79.12t/data=!3m7!1e1!3m5!1sAKp7BzFaQYsylz6QJrweKg!2e0!3e2!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3645779,-71.0554965,3a,75y,1... https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3578491,-71.057966,3a,75y,204.12h,80.91t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sigQE99LgXiCgqfWiRJPAmQ!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3578491,-71.057966,3a,75y,20... https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3503591,-71.0797167,3a,75y,95.51h,85.79t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sBTT0ZacOATxLsyOvFI_6Lw!2e0!7i13312!8i6656 https://www.google.com/maps/@42.3503591,-71.0797167,3a,75y,9...
- jhallenworld 10y agoThey should demolish it... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kowloon_Walled_City https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kowloon_Walled_City
- Aaron1011 10y agoDid you even read the original article?
- jhallenworld 10y agoOf course, and I was jokingly pointing out a slight similarity between Somerville and the famed Kowloon Walled City, which was demolished because of its extreme density (3.25 M inhabitants / square mile vs. 18K inhabitants / square mile for Somerville). Basically, is it possible for the mores to change so much (as reflected in the zoning codes) that not only would the city be illegal to build now, but that it should be demolished? What happened to Kowloon suggests that it is.
- cbr 10y agoSomerville is in the process of updating its zoning code: http://www.somervillema.gov/zoning/resources/2015-01-22-ordinance-boa-submittal.pdf http://www.somervillema.gov/zoning/resources/2015-01-22-ordi... My impression is that one of the goals of updating it is to make much more of the city be zoning conforming.
- abalone 10y agoFWIW the City of Somerville recognizes this and is working to reform the zoning code.[1] Here are some highlights from the proposal: "Makes Somerville a national leader in using zoning to produce affordable housing with the most ambitious inclusionary housing requirements in the state" "In areas of the city where major new development is planned, up to 20% of new units must be set aside for affordable housing." "Ensures that infill development fits into the form, scale, and pattern of existing neighborhoods and squares." "Only permits formula businesses and big-box stores by special permit." "Requires new buildings in certain districts... to set aside 5% of gross floor area as leasable arts and creative use spaces." [1] http://www.somervillema.gov/zoning/key-changes.html http://www.somervillema.gov/zoning/key-changes.html
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoI don't see anything there that, strictly speaking, requires them to actually build dense housing. Setting aside 20% of suburban development for people poor enough to qualify for "affordable housing" subsidies just creates a welfare cliff.
- rwhitman 10y agoPersonally I would love to see a suburb go completely rogue and draft up zoning laws that flipped the script and required their town be built to 1890's code.. or better yet, 15th century Europe code. Victorian era density is nice but we have so few places in the USA that have any of the human-scale character of the Old World to pull from, that most Americans have no idea what a small walkable village really should feel like. If we want to talk about the good old days before postwar zoning in order to get the character in our places back, why not look at the places that are real gems that we never had at all, like UNESCO villages and such?
- ocschwar 10y agoMassachusetts is doing that. Every outlying town is now required to select an area where they will now zone for denser housing with offices and shops. If they don't, Beacon Hill (the state government) will select it for them. It's still not going to be completely European (the early American settlers built streets wide for fear of fire, and because they really, really liked being able to do U-turns with horse carts,) but American 1890's style is well worth cherishing on its own merits.
- rwhitman 10y agoThat's amazing, I had no idea. I hope other states get on board with this
- agentgt 10y agoThey are even doing it in the rich suburbs of MA like Wellesley. Wellesley and Newton are trying to stop tear down McMansion mania and our passing laws that you can't knock and rebuild unless you have lived there for a while or have an "accident".... I predict more fires in the coming years...
- tehabe 10y agoIsn't there something like a "Bestandsschutz" for buildings? I couldn't find a fitting translation, it basically means, if you got a legal permit for building something and the rules are changing, your building is still legal. Which means that a town can only change the building code for the future, not for the past. On a side note, somewhere I heard or read that many US cities and town don't allow mixed use zoning, so that a building can used commercial and residential. Something which is very common in German town, especially in downtown areas, you have a lot of stores in the ground level and above that are flats.
- shados 10y agoGrandfathering? Yeah, it's how it works here too. And I don't know about the rest of the US, but the city from the article, has a fair bit of mixed used zoning.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoGenerally, yes. The phrase is "grandfathered in." If you have a building, and they change the zoning so that building your building would now be illegal, your building is grandfathered in, such that it is legal for it to continue to exist.
- ocschwar 10y agoThat is Somerville's biggest problem right now: very tight and inappropriate zoning and building regulations, but they only take effect in if you demolish your house and build something new. So Somerville is frozen in amber. A few years ago, I saw developers in Somerville get around that problem when they wanted to replace one 3-apartment house with one exactly the same shape, minus a whole lot of rotten wood, and plus a whole lot of good insulation and the like. So instead of tearing the building down and building it anew, they tore down half of it, all the way down to the foundation, then removed all the parts connecting to the foundation, leaving half of the building on stilts, and then started building the new building, with the shell still in place. They did good work. They replaced a well-designed but badly neglected building with one that is also well designed and more liveable. They should not have had to do this charade that they were just "renovating" it, but that was the only way to do it legally.
- gm-conspiracy 10y agoDon't get me started on classic automobiles.
- agentgt 10y agoI live in Waltham... I can tell you Waltham is not far off from Somerville. With Waltham we have the added complexity of having lots of mixed commercial and residential zones (Somerville on the other hand is mainly residential). Waltham is also more diverse than Somerville economically (Somerville has a large amount of college kids that skew the demographics). Waltham has a lot of first generation Americans that are afraid to report violations or just don't know that they can. I have seen single bed apartments with serious safety issues housing families of eight people and more. Almost every house in my neighborhood is in some sort of serious violation. In my small neighborhood (called the Island neighborhood) we have had 3 fires. That is three houses that have had fires substantial enough where they pretty much need to be demoed (luckily not the large family mentioned previously). Nobody has wired smoke alarms but every three family or above requires it. You are not supposed to have grills on any balcony or porch... everyone does... Somerville is massively guilty of this as well. Proper egresses... haha use a window. Such is the style of living in ancient New England houses in high density areas. There is very little incentive to update or even try to correct behavior legally. I'm not sure how towns like Somerville can get their landlords (I am landlord so I am guilty as well) to update their properties. I do know lots of people updated with the federal energy subsidizations. It would be nice if their was some safety subsidizations to maybe start turning this around (along with the rest of our crumbling infrastructure).