4 ms·
A century ago there were people [1] whose job was to manually light street lamps. How did they transition into the advent of electricity? There's been countles
by Razengan 10y ago
A century ago there were people [1] whose job was to manually light street lamps. How did they transition into the advent of electricity?
There's been countless other jobs where previously-essential human participation was rendered unnecessary by technology, sometimes with entire social classes finding themselves unemployed; why should this time be any different? How can it be different?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamplighter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lamplighter
Also interesting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link-boy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Link-boy
- Udik 10y agoBecause the current technological quest is, by definition, to build machines that cover any residual advantage human beings had on machines. In essence, the goal is to produce human beings - at least as far as working abilities are concerned - extremely cheap and infinitely available.
- riffraff 10y agoBut this has always been the quest, agriculture went from 80% of the workforce to 4% as productivity increased EDIT: sorry sent too early ...what changes is the "residual advantage". Until some time ago we assumed machines would only replace people in simple tasks (e.g. mill). Than only repetitive, "mechanic" tasks (i.e. assembly line). Now we realize they can replace in tasks which require some intelligence (i.e. self driving cars) but still assume they won't replace us in some "smarter" jobs. It looks to me like each step is just incremental, I don't see the "tipping" point.
- api 10y agoBut there was a ton of growth since then, and that growth created a ton of new jobs. Growth today is almost flat. Interest rates are zero bound. Jobs lost today might not be replaced because... nothing is happening. Or nothing that requires people that is.
- visarga 10y agoWhat about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turnspit_Dog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turnspit_Dog ? They've lost their jobs too! All in the name of progress. > Turnspit Dogs were bred to run on a wheel in order to turn meat so it would cook evenly. Due to the strenuous nature of the work, a pair of dogs would often be worked in shifts. The dogs were also taken to church to serve as foot warmers. One story says that during service at a church in Bath, the Bishop of Gloucester gave a sermon and uttered the line "It was then that Ezekiel saw the wheel...". At the mention of the word "wheel" several turnspit dogs, who had been brought to church as foot warmers, ran for the door
- ensiferum 10y agoBecause now through technology the compression rate will be enormous. How many new jobs do you think will be created when those 3.5m trucker jobs are automated? Probably some small fraction. And now the main thing to keep in mind that this will happening across work domains and technologies. A truck driver can't go on and switch career to a factory worker because those jobs are gone too! In the future more and more of these laboros grunt jobs will become automated. Just a while ago there was news how Foxconn cut 60k jobs at a single factory through automation. And this is the right way to go. Why should any human or sentient being be forced to work a boring mundane job in some factory when machines can do it? The only goal for the human race as a whole should be the liberation of people from back breaking labor. The only question is now, how will our societies react to this forthcoming change in the system. One way or another this change will come and if we're not prepared it will turn into dystopia everywhere with masses of the people sidelined out of jobs which means without means to support themselves or their families. Crime, poverty and massive slum cities are the only way this can turn out. Not to mention that since the consumer base is gone the whole world economy will simply collapse.
- tajen 10y ago> now through technology the compression rate will be enormous In 1800, with steam power, the compression rate was enormous. And sudden. The population of humanity was fewer than a billion. It implied massive misery in coal mines and factories, which hasn't disappeared much, and a greater low-to-high income ratio, yes, but it also implied an easier life for a greater part of humanity.
- shubhamjain 10y agoEven if driverless transport technology arrives, it would take quite sometime for it to be adopted on a massive scale. In that time, there would be a rapid rise in number of companies around this industry which would create a lot better work than those mundane jobs. I think people are underestimating how many new jobs could be created. Driverless trucks would give rise companies selling fleet tracking software, integrated inventory management software, and automated vehicle servicing applications. Imagine hundreds of such companies, employing engineers, sales people, marketers, customer success guys and you have a world where you think - "Did we really have humans to do that?"
- audunw 10y agoI would say it's different because it seems we're running out of manual jobs. I don't know what those lamp lighters went on to do, but I would guess some kind of manufacturing or transportation job, since they were growing industries. What do we have now? Are there any significant job growth for manual labor? I'm afraid that what new jobs there are, will be the kind that do not contribute to real economic growth, but are simply there to extract wealth. If most of the fundamental resource extraction, physical production and logistics is automated, I think it's better that people and groups can do more of what they find fulfilling and entertaining (which can be considered real economic growth even if money isn't exchanged) rather than selling each other more and more convoluted insurance policies and financial instruments.
- majewsky 10y ago> selling each other more and more convoluted insurance policies and financial instruments Exactly. When left with no other option, a plausible response of the system would be an unprecedented explosion in bureaucracy.
- drabiega 10y agoIt appears to me that this time isn't any different. Each major advance in automation has pushed the workforce increasingly into job categories with lower marginal productivity. When an automation breakthrough occurs a small portion of the population gets better jobs and the rest get absorbed into low productivity/wage jobs. So far the resulting economic growth has meant that these people were still able to afford the neccesities, but sometimes this requires Malthusian forces to kick in and cause massive misery until it is so. Right now, talk about it revolves around the transformation into service and knowledge economies and the increasing prevalence of bullshit jobs, but each successive wave of automation makes the problem worse. Combine this with the fact that our modern automation advances seem to only be increaing productivity marginally and the overall growth of the economy seems to be slowing down and you've got a recipe for disaster.
- SolarUpNote 10y agoIn the movie "Her" the main character's job is to help people write thoughtful letters to their loved ones. I'm sure the film meant that to be ironic, but that seems like a realistic 21st century job. When all the industrial jobs have been automated, couldn't they be replaced by jobs that help us fulfill our emotional needs? Or is there some set of core jobs that fundamentally produce value for the economy?