9 ms·
Facebook Offers Tools for Those Who Fear a Friend May Be Suicidal
- kome 10y agoPerhaps it is time to start a conversation on why suicide is seen as a problem, tout court. I always thought of suicide as a possibility among others. It’s a normal feeling to be tired of life. I would have suicided long time ago if suicide wasn’t so complicated and scary, with a huge risk of failure. I don’t want to feel pain, I just want to go. Like in euthanasia. I checked, and unfortunately not even Switzerland offers the possibility of euthanasia (good death) to healthy people. I really think that’s a society shortcoming, then need to be addressed in the future. What's the problem with suicide at all?
- gregw134 10y agoThe biggest problem is the cost to other people, especially if the person committing suicide has children. You have a point though.
- apsec112 10y agoGood question. Scott, a psychiatrist, explains his reasons here: http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/25/in-defense-of-psych-treatment-for-attempted-suicide/ http://slatestarcodex.com/2013/04/25/in-defense-of-psych-tre....
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- simonw 10y ago"What's the problem with suicide at all?" Aside from the horrible impact it has on friends and family (including the risk of it becoming contagious - http://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2016/04/21/474847921/the-arctic-suicides-its-not-the-dark-that-kills-you http://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2016/04/21/47484792... ), many people who attempt suicide and fail later decide that they are glad that they didn't go through with it.
- prodmerc 10y agoAnd many try it again.
- namenotrequired 10y agoAnd those might be the same people, that were unlucky enough to have one tiny bad enough moment.
- forgottenpass 10y agoWhat about all the unlucky moments of misery and/or wanting to not exist but hovering just below the threshold of suicidal? Days? Months? Years? Decades? I wish society had the balls to tell the depressed they're obligated to stay here and run out the clock, but beyond that we don't really care how miserable they are. That we'll talk about talking about depression, but not actually talk about depression [0]. That's what a shrink is for, go get one so we don't have to deal with you being mopey (I guess it'll be positive for you, too). [0] http://hotelconcierge.tumblr.com/post/116790700524/we-need-to-sing-about-mental-health http://hotelconcierge.tumblr.com/post/116790700524/we-need-t...
- Swizec 10y agoAs someone who used to be suicidal, I'm pretty glad I didn't do it. Sure life is still pointless and kind of meaningless, but I'm having a lot more fun than I would have if I was dead. Unexistence, while easier, doesn't sound nearly as fun. And besides, how will I ever achieve all those hopes and dreams I had as a 12 year old if I'm dead? I won't. But the longer I stay alive, the more likely it is. "Survive until tomorrow" is, in a sense, the only thing that matters. Or at least the thing that comes the closest to mattering.
- Mz 10y agoUnexistence, while easier, doesn't sound nearly as fun. We do not actually know that Unexistence would be easier, nor whether or not it would be fun. I don't intend any disrespect at all. I have attempted suicide and spent plenty of time suicidal. So this is a conclusion I drew in earnestness. We have no means that I know of to investigate what comes after death, whether or not something survives the physical body, etc. Many people believe in religion and an afterlife or in reincarnation. Others believe nothing survives after the body dies. But, scientifically speaking, we do not actually know. I am glad you are no longer suicidal. Peace.
- dreamdu5t 10y agoIt's seen as a problem because most people who attempt suicide regret it or change their mind later.
- styrophone 10y agoI don't think suicide is inherently a much worse cause of death than many others, but it is often associated with a mental illness, outside of which the sufferer would not choose to die. Althoigh the illness manifests as free will, it is an illness nonetheless that might be treated. I don't mean to say that it is impossible for a person of sound mind to choose not to live any longer. However, given how often treatment results in improved will to live and improved quality of life, I think it would be irresponsible to assume a healthy mind without challenge and go to euthanasia as a first resort standard of care. We certainly wouldn't do that for any other presentation of symptoms.
- somedudethere 10y agoI'm not saying that suicide isn't associated with mental health, but when I read this I got a vague feeling of a tautology. If we define the components of mental illness as being suicidal, obviously that would lead you to classify all suicidals as mentally ill. For a long time being homosexual was seen as a mental illness and those (probably most) administering treatments saw themselves as helping them and the patient would have a higher quality of life after they were cured. The doctors thought the patient was harming themselves and their family by participating in lewd activities. Not trying to say one thing or the other about suicide. I just think it is interesting what we consider a mental illness and why and why its dangerous to go to the "mental illness" (I hate this phrasing) reasoning right away.
- s3arch 10y agoSome people who are suicidal are not mentally ill. Sometimes they lose perspective of their life, and this may continue for many months/years. They feel that the pain they are in now, is much worse than death. They run out of answers for "why they must live".
- ionised 10y agoYeah, ritual suicide for example was not carried out by depressed people. It was a cultural phenomenon, not mental illness.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoMany, probably most, who consider suicide are not well. They may be in good physical health but poor mental health. When we have a physical ailment we (the patient) can generally understand the path to recovery, hence we don't kill ourselves when we break an arm. With mental health not only is it difficult to understand when you are in good mental condition but it is almost impossible to see the path to recovery when you are sick. In other words wanting to end your life may be a symptom of a short term illness (say someone with depression who will be better in a few months). Differentiating between people who are of completely sound mind and want to end their life and people who are suffering need treatment is not going to be full proof so it couldn't be offered in the same way as euthanasia (similar to how most countries don't practice the death penalty - it's nearly impossible to be 100% sure of something and you need to be when it comes to doing something as permanent as ending a life).
- niftich 10y agoFrom a secular, philosophical point-of-view, part of it is the notion of informed consent. We, as a society, have decided that certain serious decisions should only be made by people we judge as possessing all their mental faculties and be given a neutral, pressure-free environment to formulate their point-of-view. Of course, this is subjective, and vulnerable to the no-true-Scotsman fallacy: "if you have decided to commit suicide you must have not possessed all your mental faculties or felt otherwise pressured towards that outcome." Hence find it hard to accept that their choice was made in earnest. (edit: quotes)
- lazyant 10y agoBecause a lot of people attempting suicide and failing often don't try any more and lead "normal" lives, see the study on Golden Gate jumpers who survived for example ("the moment I jumped I regretted it").
- somedudethere 10y agoNot advocating for suicide but playing devils advocate... I would imagine that bank robbers the moment they get caught instantly regret it. But that doesn't prevent the ones that got away from completing their goal and not regretting it. People who fail suicide often have HUGE amounts of personal anguish because of the police, hospital, family, etc. all judging them from the suicide attempt. I think its easy to confuse regret of the action over all and regret that you tried the action and failed. But I imagine there are some who genuinely regret their attempts.
- pimlottc 10y agoAt the very least, suicide causes a lot of grief and pain to others, generates work in dealing with the deceased, their possessions, disruptions caused, etc., and wastes a valuable resource that took years of time and effort to develop.
- ben174 10y agoCouldn't you say the same about any death? Regardless of reason?
- wodenokoto 10y agoYes, and the general consensus towards death is against. Parents point is that just like any other kind of death, suicidal death is a problem.
- malandrew 10y agoWe often hear that social media can make people more depressed. It's worth seeing if that effect can not only be cancelled out but reversed. With this in mind, it would be nice if they detected those who might be depressed and tailored the news feed to try to make people happier.
- Olscore 10y agoAh yes. Keep them in a perfectly balanced, harmonious state. /s
- johnpowell 10y agoAds for Zoloft?
- Archio 10y agoMildly interesting observation: the suicide prevention team is 100% female.
- aganders3 10y agoThe photo shows four women, but the article states that "Facebook has a team of more than a dozen engineers and researchers dedicated to the project."
- Amorymeltzer 10y agoThe Facebook tack is interesting, because it's technically not a service for the suicidal individual; rather, it's a service for their friends who "really want to help, but... just don’t know what to say, what to do or how to help their friends." That's a unique angle, which sets it apart from, say Apple, which has taken significant steps since the first roleout of Siri to enable her to respond appropriately to certain queries (e.g., "I was raped" or "I want to commit suicide).[1,2] The conversation on how we want our electronics and services to behave is really interesting and one that is only going to get more complex as we get better at language and mood processing/modeling/profiling. 1: http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/apples-siri-now-prevent-suicides/story?id=19438495 http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/apples-siri-now-prevent-sui... 2: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/04/04/siri-update-offers-support-for-rape-victims-and-suicide-question/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2016/04/04/siri-update...
- lalos 10y agoThis has a ton of implications. First people 'tagging' profiles as depressive and probably training an algorithm behind the scenes, so now if you behave a certain way you the chances you are depressed are 94%. Second, who owns this valuable health information? Can they sell it to third party's? Insurance or recruiting companies? Not against the idea but thought provoking the several implications of what this data means.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tajen 10y agoJust watched a documentary about Foxconn which tries to filter out suicidal employees. Sure Facebook's profiling would be useful for many companies who put a high pressure, and their HR depts. Not sure humanity is progressing, though.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TruthAndDare 10y ago> Not sure humanity is progressing, though. What would constitute humanity progressing? Would evolution count? Would it count if it appeared in the shape of weeding out suicidal people?
- walrus01 10y ago> which tries to filter out suicidal employees The cynic in me says they don't particularly care about the high suicide rate of assembly line factory workers in China, as long as said factory workers don't off themselves while on company property or at the company dormitory. Because that's bad PR, guys.
- x5n1 10y agoFacebook wants to tell insurers and corporations employees and customers who might be a suicide risk.
- prodmerc 10y agoOh gee, he's alive today. Mission accomplished! Or not? Living another miserable 30+ years is a worse way to go than a gunshot. Sad for those who care, but when you've been considering it over and over again and nothing helps, maybe it should be an option.
- vox_mollis 10y agoWhy is this viewpoint SO unpopular on HN? What, precisely, is wrong with a miserable person wanting to end his or her misery? Why do we lionize personal choice in virtually every domain, but collectively choose not to respect the wishes of those who hate their lives?
- Jtsummers 10y agoI suppose nothing. But what's wrong with people that care about a person helping them overcome a (usually) temporary situation and moving on to have a better and full life? We certainly shouldn't, as prodmerc seems to be doing, say, "Oh, they want to die. Good for them." and walk away. Personally, I'm glad you and prodmerc weren't my friends 10 years ago.
- drumdance 10y agoThe apparatus that thinks suicide is an option (the sufferer's brain) is any many cases not the best apparatus to make that decision. There are some rational reasons for suicide, such as severe chronic pain, but most of the time they are not.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoSuicide is often not a very rational or well considered option, except in regards to medical assisted suicide. Suicide is, as they say, a permanent solution to a temporary problem. But it's a lot more complicated than that. I think the best argument for suicide intervention are the many stories from folks who came the closest to succeeding in their suicide attempts, failed, and then changed their minds and decided against suicide. That speaks to the fact that the reasoning going into a suicide attempt is often not on solid ground, and that there are often a lot of ways to remediate "future decades of misery" that are not ending a life. Speaking personally, I know a lot of people who have had thoughts of committing suicide or have made an unsuccessful attempt at doing so and in every case it was an erroneous decision, in every case their future was full of a lot more than years of misery.
- DanBC 10y agoTwitter is also looking at suicide prevention. Machine classification and analysis of suicide-related communication on Twitter http://orca.cf.ac.uk/76188/ http://orca.cf.ac.uk/76188/ Analysing the connectivity and communication of suicidal users on twitter http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S014036641500256X http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140366415... I think they had a talk with Prof Louis Appleby (who pretty much leads suicide prevention in UK): https://twitter.com/ProfLAppleby/status/740957809924308992 https://twitter.com/ProfLAppleby/status/740957809924308992
- Aelinsaar 10y agoI can't think of many worse outlets for this type of concern, or forums to deal with it. Social media is very good at connecting people initially, but it's piss poor at forging much deeper.
- danso 10y agoSomewhat trusting person than I am, I can see this being an initiative borne out of genuine sympathy without sinister motive...but I can see a few potential pitfalls that, depending on how they're handled, could lead to unintended consequences. One of the more obvious obstacles will just be noise. The ideal situation is someone who posts a clearly suicidal note late at night and a single friend sees it in time to act...this is the kind of signal that a huge network like FB can uniquely catch because of its size. But what about all the more ambiguous situations? A friend with hundreds of FB friends has gone through a horrible breakup and other real life failures, and he starts posting notes that are potentially signs of suicidal thought...or, at least a dozen of his hundreds of friends think so, and they all flag it as suicidal. What should FB do then? At least a good number of these incidents will be false positives and people will start complaining about FB's human-backed algorithm for discerning potentially suicidal users. The imminent danger is that someone will post notes that are suicidal in retrospect, people will flag it, and the user will commit suicide anyway. It won't be FB's fault...after all, AFAIK, they're just offering to send a friendly help screen to the user, not call the cops. But that won't be how the media or the deceased user's friends will see it, and the revelation that FB's powerful network has a human/algorithm hybrid element will be controversial in the same way that the trending news kerfluffle was. Perhaps there will be demands that FB should have done more, and that cops should be involved in the decision making... But the seemingly inevitable decision would seem to be: why even bother waiting for humans to flag suicidal behavior? For a user who has a history of regular activity on the service, I'm sure there's a general profile they fit in terms of sentiment of messages and reduced engagement on the service, just like FB is reportedly able to tell how soon given couple might break up. Here's no reason why FB couldn't augment a profile with a hidden "depression" index to help the suicide response team triage reports...but the existence of such a calculation will undoubtedly be controversial. And then there's the question of: if FB can calculate such a depression index, why wait for it to reach a high level before taking action? And, why should action be limited to sending an explicit anti-suicide message? Shouldn't FB be obligated to populate the user's news feed with happier messages, more reminders that they have a family, fewer reminders that their former lovers have found new lovers, etc? And of course, for more controversy, we could always replace "suicide" with other kinds of unwanted behavior.
- 10y ago
- Animats 10y agoWhat if Facebook developed detection of drug users? Good? Bad?
- artursapek 10y agoThey probably have it
- orik 10y agoI think this sort of thing is dangerous because it's (probably) not data backed and you're really playing with dynamite. Do we know if this sort of message causes a person to be more or less likely to take their lives? How can you A-B test that? Does anyone else think your phone telling you it thinks 'you aren't being yourself anymore' could set someone over the edge?
- manufacturious 10y agoTo reply to your middle paragraph, you'd probably want a longitudinal cohort study rather than an A/B test. A well-designed one can provide pretty conclusive indications in situations where A/B testing (or, testing with a double blind control as the epi community might call it) isn't possible.
- chillacy 10y ago> Do we know if this sort of message causes a person to be more or less likely to take their lives? How can you A-B test that? Actually... you probably could train a model to detect suicidal posts. I had a friend who committed suicide a few months ago, and I didn't see it coming. But looking back, there were signs in his facebook posts (in line with this article's example of thanking everyone), but our conversations were normal. It is at the very least a wishful line of thinking for me that ML can recognize this type of pattern.
- droithomme 10y agoMany questions are never asked in these articles. Is suicide bad? Is it immoral? Is it a crime? Should it not be permitted? If it is wrong, immoral, and a crime, should people who attempt it be punished?
- Declanomous 10y agoWell, from what I recall from biomedical ethics, the majority of people who attempt suicide and fail do not attempt suicide again. This would suggest that for most people suicide is merely a phase they can pass through. Regardless, these questions are asked all of the time. A news article about a new feature on a social media site isn't an appropriate forum for discussing such a ridiculously complex topic as the ethics of suicide. The only way your comment could be less appropriate is if you were advocating for a discussion on the ethics of murder on an article about a murder suicide. Edit: I suggest checking out the article on suicide on the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. The Encyclopedia as a whole is a great resource, and this article is no different: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/suicide/ http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/suicide/
- TruthAndDare 10y ago> This would suggest that for most people suicide is merely a phase they can pass through. Strictly speaking, I don't think that necessarily means that these people are better off surviving. One could imagine that they are in pain that is temporary, but severe enough that they are better off dieing immediately, even taking into account that they are missing out on the life that would otherwise have come after the pain. By making them stay alive, we are perhaps forcing them into the worse option.
- Declanomous 10y agoOh, I don't disagree. I personally believe that suicide can be a rational decision. However, I believe that it is not a rational decision with much greater frequency.
- x3n0ph3n3 10y ago
- cs2818 10y agoI have mixed feelings about this, but I think it could be positive depending on how data related to a user's suicidal state is protected. I recently started conducting studies dealing with technology and psychological interventions and had to find ethical (privacy protecting) mechanisms for responding to participants who express suicidal intentions or show several indicators suggesting depression. We ultimately settled on an automated mechanism that suggests resources to the participant directly in cases indicating depression and human intervention on cases expressing suicidal intentions. It isn't perfect but seemed to be the best balance between privacy and helpfulness.
- dlitz 10y agoIs there any way to see exactly what this system does, aside from faking a suicidal episode on my timeline and getting friends to report it? I've heard that early versions of this system basically inserted barriers between suicidal people---who are already overwhelmed---and their support networks. Considering Facebook's poor track record when it comes to handling vulnerable populations (nym policy, location support in Messenger, etc.), I'd strongly discourage anyone from using this reporting system without a complete understanding of what it actually does. Heed should also be paid to the effect of having more than one of these systems being triggered at the same time. The last thing I need when I'm feeling overwhelmed is a dozen apps on my phone suddenly changing their behavior.
- schnevets 10y agoI understand other people's skepticism, but I have a Facebook friend from high school whose behavior has been extremely volatile. He was always an outcast, but lately he has been reaching out to random people from our grade and leaving incoherent comments. He would make up stories that clearly never happened, and sometimes would become extremely sympathetic, thanking them for "all they tried to do". I have been watching this strange story from the sidelines, but I know other people have shown concern as well. If this research can help people like him, I think it would be well worthwhile.
- artur_makly 10y agowhat's next? Flag as Muslim Extremist?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ionised 10y agoI think that already exists, just not publicly.
- andrewfromx 10y agowhen I try and report a post I don't see that option. Where is it? I just see "report spam, report not appropriate, etc."
- krapp 10y agoI find this incredibly disturbing. Facebook's entire business model is built around manipulation and control. They do psychological experiments on their users and skew their news feeds to influence their political opinions. And now Facebook wants me to tag my emotionally vulnerable friends, possibly for further abuse, surveillance and manipulation? For profit? For the good of the state? How much will insurance companies and my future employers need to pay Facebook for the improved psychological profile they're building? No. If I see anything on Facebook that makes it seem as if someone I know is depressed or needs help, the last thing I'm going to do is make Facebook aware of it.