8 ms·
Clinton approved CIA drone assassinations with her cellphone, report says
- cyberferret 10y agoShe could have approved drone strikes using smoke signals or carrier pigeons... - it all boils down to the same thing - execution of human beings without a trial...
- golergka 10y agoThis description fits almost any action that you can perform when you're at war. So, either you advocate that war courts review cases of all the enemy soldiers before aithorizing an attack, or you have to come up with a more precise definition of what is exactly wrong here. Clarification: I'm not a fan of CIA assasinations, far from it; but "execution without a trial" isn't logically justifiable complaint: we do it in a lot of situations no reasonable person would argue with. Edit: my original comment was pointing out errors in someone's logic. Sadly, everybody seems to think that this means that I've taken a certain side in drone debate. This is not the case; please, read my comment and understand what exactly am I saying — and what I'm not — before reacting.
- voidz 10y ago> no reasonable person would argue with. By framing it like this, that's where you take a wrong turn.
- x0x0 10y agoIt's one thing to shoot soldiers without a trial. It's a far different thing to bomb random folks living their lives in Afghanistan, then retcon all male casualties to terrorists.
- m_eiman 10y agoSaying that the US is at war with various groups of people in the country side of Pakistan is a rather generous definition of the concept of war, isn't it? It's more like "the US is blowing up people who may or may not be those intended, but it's kinda hard to tell since they're doing it all by remote control".
- jflatow 10y agoAlso, congress hasn't declared war since WWII, which is required by law.
- rurban 10y agoNo it's not. They came up with the interpretation that the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Powers_Resolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_Powers_Resolution allows them to engage into limited armed conflicts without Congress authorization. Which is dearly needed, because that's what they are doing since decades, with the CIA and friends. And several such CIA wars happened even without the President's authorization, but usually the just lie to the president to able to engage in such armed conflicts. What this War Powers Resolution does not authorize is a formal declaration of war (Clinton did not care) and any engagement voiding the Geneva conventions. All those drone killings are of course war crimes. This is one of the reasons the US does not recognize international law.
- Retric 10y agoThey are happy to use weasel words, this is a declaration of war: https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/107-2002/h455 https://www.govtrack.us/congress/votes/107-2002/h455
- nikdaheratik 10y agoThere are a number of reasons why this has happened. Some more nebulous than others. There are a number of extra powers granted to the Executive during a time of war that Congress didn't want activated. There are a number of requirements that kick in when war is "legally" declared that Congress didn't want activated as well. I'm not saying drone strikes aren't shady, but they aren't strictly illegal. This is a case where Congress needs to get it together and start overseeing if they want it to stop happening. Otherwise, we're just left depending on diplomacy or the UN trying to put a stop to it, which likely won't happen either.
- golergka 10y ago> Saying that the US is at war with various groups of people in the country side of Pakistan is a rather generous definition of the concept of war, isn't it? Nobody's saying that though.
- pjc50 10y agoenemy soldiers There is a legal obligation in the Geneva protocols 1949 to identify who you're targeting and refrain from targeting civilians. https://www.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/9ac284404d38ed2bc1256311002afd89/50fb5579fb098faac12563cd0051dd7c https://www.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/9ac284404d38ed2bc125... "refrain from deciding to launch any attack which may be expected to cause incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects, or a combination thereof, which would be excessive in relation to the concrete and direct military advantage anticipated;" Article 52 para 3: "3. In case of doubt whether an object which is normally dedicated to civilian purposes, such as a place of worship, a house or other dwelling or a school, is being used to make an effective contribution to military action, it shall be presumed not to be so used." The US has taken an extremely lax approach to this with the intelligence-based targeting. Air strikes in the course of combat are probably defensible - if you see someone running into a house carrying a weapon it becomes a military objective - but the intelligence-based targeting lacks that confirmation.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoThe very words you quote authorise "incidental loss of civilian life, injury to civilians, damage to civilian objects" as long as it's not "excessive", and the treating of a "place of worship, a house or other dwelling or school" as a military target as long as you're fairly sure it's being used for military purposes. Obviously you can argue about what is "excessive" and what is a "case of doubt" but whoever wrote these lines was clearly anticipating blowing churches and civilians up and it being within the rules. I don't say this to make drone killing seem more humane, but to make war in general seem like the everyday insanity that it is.
- ionised 10y agoMost of the deaths in drone strikes have been civilian. We're talking like 70%+ of the casualties being 'incidental'. That should warrant a description of 'excessive' I think.
- golergka 10y agoA lot of comments with similar sentiments, so I'll reply just to yours, because it's on top. Basically, you're making my point for me: there's nothing inherently wrong with remote strikes or drones in particular. It's just a tool; and as a tool, it can be used rightly and wrongly. So, the fact that Clinton used that tool doesn't make her bad. But if you would have information about her using that tool to authorize a strike which she would've known would cause significant collateral damage, and which wouldn't save as many innocent lives as it would take — this would. But the article presents no such information, so all emptional reaction you can have to such a headline is not really justified.
- belorn 10y agoAny action? Lets look at some specifics and ask which ones should count as murder. A reasonable person might see a different degree of justification in each case. A person wielding a gun is running and firring their weapon towards a solider. The solider shoots back and kills them. A boat full with military weapons enters an areas which marines are defending and refuse to turn back. The marines sinks the boat. A tank drives into a town. The Solider defending the civilians attacks the tank and the tank driver dies in an explosion. A bomb plane that drops bombs on military facility with tanks, airfield with bombers on them, and docks with military ships. A bomb plane that dropping bombs on a factory that produce tanks and guns, killing workers. A bomb plane that fire bombs on housing districts to demoralize the population. A person is driving down the road in uninhabited area, and a solider sends a remote missile. A person is celebrating a wedding in their own house, and a soldier sends a remote missile to kill everyone in the wedding.
- tajen 10y agoI don't see what degree of difference there is in your first 4 examples: They're all armed people in a situation of war. Of course the last 3 are murders (although we know that the Allied erased most of German and Japanese cities, including the civilian neighbourhoods, for morale and retaliation) and the 4th before the end (killing military workers) is debatable. Last point, concerning French nationals who went to Syria twice to train in military camps and came back to lead the terrorist attacks with actual killings: Can we please extend the Geneva convention to consider them ennemy military corps (and thus, prisonners of war)? I have zero tolerance for police investigating innocents or listening to everyone, but once we know what they've done, I wonder why they just face some penal law (a few years in jail, max, like a driver in a car accident).
- tajen 10y agoI don't mind the downvotes, please explain first how parent's 8 examples are different, and how people being trained in enemy military camps and coming back doesn't raise the POW legislation.
- golergka 10y ago
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> This description fits almost any action that you can perform when you're at war. So, either you advocate that war courts review cases of all the enemy soldiers before aithorizing an attack, or you have to come up with a more precise definition of what is exactly wrong here. What everyone else said. What you can do to people you're at war with isn't relevant; there is not even a pretense of being at war here. The description doesn't even match what happens in war; execution implies sentencing, which does happen here but doesn't in war, where there would be no point.
- Natsu 10y agoIt's one thing to shoot back at people who are shooting at you, but we're talking about blowing up people in remote places who aren't currently attacking anyone or doing anything obviously bad, along with anyone near them at the time.
- golergka 10y agoOK, so come up with a more precise definition than "execution without a trial".
- notahacker 10y agoInternational law has always been very careful not to proscribe the bombing of enemy leaders just because they're not in a conflict zone, never mind going so far as to require soldiers to wait until they're under fire before shooting enemy soldiers. There are serious questions about the adequacy of the intelligence reports and whether - as with many conventional military operations - the tendency to cause civilian casualties means the strikes do more far harm than good, but on the other hand more research has been put into identifying that the intended targets were responsible for "obviously bad" things than virtually anyone else killed in warfare.
- bootload 10y ago"This description fits almost any action that you can perform when you're at war." Except there is no man in the loop in the kill chain. "where the maimed survivors of a mistaken drone strike on unarmed civilians in February 2010, which killed 23 people, describe what happened when they were attacked. The juxtaposition of the appallingly gung-ho attitude of the drone operatives, re-enacted from a transcript of the event, and raw footage of the dead bodies" [0] How do you confirm ground-truth? That truck you targeted with a high statistical chance of having X leader also is surrounded with non-combatants. Eyes on the ground will be responsible and wrestle with this and take responsibility. [1] Even if it's personal. Death by algorythm, remote control, sanctioned higher up the command chain, does not. [0] "National Bird review – chilling film reveals truths about drones" ~ https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/apr/17/national-bird-review-us-drones-program-tribeca-film-festival https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/apr/17/national-bird-r... [1] "Into the Fog of War" ~ http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2016-05-23/soldier's-story-exposes-serious-flaws-in-deadly-adf-raid/7435548 http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2016-05-23/soldier's-story-exp...
- superuser2 10y agoExactly 0 people have ever been in the category "enemy soldiers" since WWII because we haven't declared war.
- huffmsa 10y agoCellphones are functionally equivalent to laptops and desktops-- they're computers. Now, independent of that, if the regulations and law do not treat them equally, they are not legally equal.
- dogma1138 10y agoI think the issue here is she used her unsecure cellphone and presumably "private" email server to approve these strikes in which case it might have caused operational information to leak. This isn't about someone using a cellphone or a laptop, this is about someone using any communication device that wasn't clear for the transmission of classified information to approve strikes which i would only presume to be classified if only due to operational reasons.
- hacker42 10y agoIt leaves the impression of a quick and weakly informed decision (especially so in the context of executing people). I personally would never respond to an important inquiry on mobile because the relatively limited screen and input interface (e.g. auto-correct) would make me anxious that I am missing some crucial piece of information.
- dogma1138 10y agoNot really a lot of times this can be a "last moment" highly time sensitive decision based on who exactly is identified at the strike target. Allot of people are involved in the decision making, various heads of agencies, the joint chiefs, cabinet members, the president, the vice president, members of congress, the speaker of the house etc. all can be involved depending on the strike. You also have variables that can change for example a large than expected number of non-combatants or an unexpected high value target and when those parameters change the mission planners and operators usually have to refer up to notify people like the Secretary of State and have them make a decision to proceed, abort, change mission parameters (e.g. from survey to kill, or from kill to capture) etc. Like it or not from all aspects these aren't decisions that can be open to lengthy debate this isn't how combat works, and having to make a time sensitive decision is something that people at those levels of government and the military have to do all the time. So sorry I don't see how the fact that a cellphone has been used is some how makes it look worse than what it already is, it's just a tool like anything else.
- factorialboy 10y agoQuestion is are you in a state of war? Are these considered casualties of war? If yes, then execution without trial is a given.
- chopin 10y agoLast I looked the US weren't at war with Pakistan.
- democracy 10y agoYou are so last century mate!
- bduerst 10y agoBut the U.S. is at war with ISIL, as part of a joint task force involving the Pakistan armed forces. It's not total war, so the real issue is whether or not the CIA drone assassinations killed innocent civilians. The article mentions how drone attacks have killed civilians, but it doesn't specify if those are the CIA requested attacks or if they were approved by Clinton.
- chopin 10y agoBy the same logic, China could declare war at certain dissident groups, say Tibet activists (which I think China assumes to be terrorists) and then drone strike their members in the US, if the US refuses to act against those. I don't think this is the standard a civilized nation should hold. EDIT: spelling
- bduerst 10y agoAssuming that the U.S. Military is allied with China against (and at war with) the Tibeten activists, and the drone assassination was of a leader in that group - then yes, your hypothetical slippery slope is analogous.
- awesomerobot 10y agoI too, believe that war should not exist.
- tomjen3 10y agoUsing this results in a lot fewer civilian casualties compared to carpet bombing the area. War will always have civilian casualties and it will always be with us.
- coldtea 10y agoEasy to say when your side is the one causing them...
- chriswarbo 10y agoCarpet bombing results in a lot fewer civilian casualties compared to nuking the population centres. So does not performing drone strikes.
- littletimmy 10y agoIs this against the law, or just the way things are done now? My gut instinct would be there's more examination that goes into a drone strike but after the Snowden revelations I don't know what to believe.
- bertil 10y agoOutside of handling confidential information on non-secure channels, the issue could the authentication. You want to be sure it is actually her approving it. Another issue could be about the quality of the briefing: if the phone call was all she got, it might mean that she wasn’t briefed enough to review the evidence and make an informed decision. However, I think that this just goes to the line: she was reckless with confidential information — which, at this level, is against the law.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoRead about "signature strikes". It's like Duck Typing, except with murdering.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- elcapitan 10y ago"There's an app for that!"™
- rvense 10y agoDroneder! Swipe left and you'll never hear from them again.
- nmc 10y agoOriginal source is the WSJ: http://www.wsj.com/articles/clinton-emails-in-probe-dealt-with-planned-drone-strikes-1465509863 http://www.wsj.com/articles/clinton-emails-in-probe-dealt-wi... (may be paywalled, just google the headline to bypass)
- Fuxy 10y agoWhenever I hear something about US drone Strikes I always think how long until the other side starts getting drones developed and and easy way to mass produce them and smuggle them into the US assemble them and start launching drone strikes from within the US on US persons of interest like politicians and CIA officials. Drone parts are getting cheaper and cheaper and easier to get it's only a matter a time someone start using them as assassination tools. Plus they don't really need to be as big or as powerful as what the CIA uses they can be small and weak and make it up in numbers. I certainly would hate to be on the receiving end of a swarm of assassination drones. It's a slippery slope and the more they get used the more pissed off people with the know-how and the reason to do it are created like people who have lost family members in these strikes.
- gonvaled 10y agoWhich of course is the only bad thing about drone strikes, right? That they could ever hit the "right guys"? Who cares that hundreds of innocent civilians are killed, if they are not american citizens? Disgusting, really. EDIT, for the downvoters you'll have to justify what in my comment you do not like. The parent is making the case that what worries him/her is that drone strikes will eventually be used to attack american targets, and by implication suggesting that the current targets are not really something to worry about. Or he/she is at least suggesting that is not as serious, since what he really is worried about are american targets. Which, if you ask me, is a very widespread opinion, thus my comment.
- spacecowboy_lon 10y agoCompered to the previous method of carpet bombing?
- gonvaled 10y agoWho is comparing what to carpet bombing? My comment is directly referring to the fact that american targets are something that worries the parent, but foreign targets (civilians) seem to not worry him/her that much. What do carpet bombs have to do with all this?
- curiousgal 10y agoI finished watching "13 Hours" last night, a movie about the Benghazi events. The use of drones to kill indirect threats is ubiquitous and yet when it came to saving Americans citizens, drones suddenly weren't in use? dafuq.
- dogma1138 10y agoDrone strikes are arranged and approved weeks and even months in advance it's not like the US has an army of drones waiting to strike at targets of opportunity. Also allot of the "drone strikes" that happen over pakistan aren't actually drone strikes it's just more convenient to both Pakistan and the US to claim that no manned aircraft are used but quite a few released/leaked BDA images show craters that are way too big for AGM-114's and even the GBU-12's which is the biggest thing that US drones can currently carry. While some of the craters might be caused due to secondaries many of them don't show the tell signs of being secondary explosions. But onto Benghazi drones wouldn't really help, drones won't stop mobs of 100's of people with AK47's storming a compound, even full on CAS with gunships could had very little effect on the end result as far as US casualties go, the people storming the both the embassy and the secondary "support compound" were doing it knowing that they will most likely die in the process. These aren't regular armies that when they suffer even high single digit %'s force depletion sound the retreat because it would be foolish to stay otherwise.
- mtgx 10y agoWhat's scary is that most still don't seem to realize how much worse this will be made by autonomous killer robots. They're already killing people essentially based on an algorithm, that may have only a 51% chance of identifying the "right target" (that's the logic they use to spy on Americans, too). They've already admitted to targeting people with drone strikes based on the phone SIM alone, which is not much better than targeting someone based on their IP address. But now they would be able to just build that into an autonomous drone, and allow it to kill anyone it meets that has a 51%+ chance of being a "bad guy". Truly scary stuff, which many still seem to excuse with nonsense such as "yeah, but they would've killed those guys just the same with Apache helicopters!". No, they wouldn't. They would only target the most important targets and the ones they are most sure it's who they think they are. With autonomous killer drones they can just launch 1,000 of them upon a country and allow them to kill anyone on sight that has whatever chance of being a target is implemented into their code. It's also the same BS excuse people used post-Snowden revelations: "But NSA has always spied on a few dictators and rival countries - surely that's just the same as them now spying on everything billions of people are doing every day, storing everything for decades, and from all ally countries as well? Right?!" And that's without even discussing the possibility of these machines being hacked, or having software bugs (which they'll probably use as an excuse everytime they get caught killing innocent people by the media - "Whoopsie, a software bug just killed 20 innocent people - What ya gonna do? - What's important is that nobody takes responsibility and gets punished for it now..."
- whbk 10y agoThe US had some "bad luck" with drone strikes during her tenure. There's been no evidence released to prove it (and it may well not exist), but for people still questioning why this email setup matters: Given that it's abundantly clear any state-sponsored hacker would have no difficulty hacking her server, it isn't exactly a stretch for our enemies to move the targets of drone strikes and put innocent civilians in their place to win the propaganda war. A former State Department aide attached his name to claims that her sloppy comms may have foiled multiple counterterrorism operations. [1] That said, this isn't "just what it is that the FBI is looking to" as this article says. The FBI director originally said they expected to wrap this up by October 2015. If we were talking about a few emails sent over the holidays, this would've been wrapped up a long time ago. In a separate civil suit, the FBI filed a motion to prevent the release of documents, or even the number of documents, for which a FOIA request had been issued. [2] Even the number of documents would tip their hand? The only explanation that really makes sense there is that they're building a RICO case against the Clinton Foundation - and thus a ton more documents than would otherwise be relevant are in play. The fact that they started investigating VA governor McAuliffe's time at the Clinton Foundation shortly after receiving the backups of Clinton's server from their third-party data backup service makes this kind of obvious. Yes, the backups that Clinton's associates attempted to have destroyed even after the State Department asked them to turn over her emails. [3] [1] http://www.newsweek.com/hillary-clinton-email-terrorism-sloppy-communications-463605 http://www.newsweek.com/hillary-clinton-email-terrorism-slop... [2] "disclosure of these records [his immunity agreement] could reasonably be expected to reveal the nature, scope, and focus of the FBI’s activities in the investigation.” http://lawnewz.com/high-profile/new-fbi-filings-reveal-pending-investigation-into-clintons-e-mails-is-far-from-over/ http://lawnewz.com/high-profile/new-fbi-filings-reveal-pendi... [3]Despite Boian’s statement that Platte River set up a 30-day revolving retention policy for Clinton’s emails, Johnson’s letter noted that Platte River employees were directed to reduce the amount of email data being stored with each backup. Late this summer, Johnson wrote, a Platte River employee took note of this change and inquired whether the company could search its archives for an email from Clinton Executive Service Corp. directing such a reduction in October or November 2014 and then again around February, advising Platte River to save only emails sent during the most recent 30 days. Those reductions would have occurred after the State Department requested that Clinton turn over her emails. It was here that a Platte River employee voiced suspicions about a cover-up and sought to protect the company. “If we have it in writing that they told us to cut the backups,” the employee wrote, “and that we can go public with our statement saying we have had backups since day one, then we were told to trim to 30 days, it would make us look a WHOLE LOT better,” according to the email cited by Johnson. http://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/national/article37968711.html http://www.mcclatchydc.com/news/nation-world/national/articl...
- Patient0 10y agoThis is exactly the sort of political crap I'd rather not see on the Hacker News front page.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rando444 10y agoIt's political, but if you think about it, it's really technology/security. I mean not only about this information falling into the wrong hands, but also the fact that using unsecured channels for these things could lead to hackers approving or even ordering drone strikes themselves.
- JoBrad 10y agoEverything could be about technology/security. That doesn't mean it should be on Hacker News.
- gloves 10y agoI stopped reading at "An explosive new report reveals..." Just give me the actual news, not your opinion of it.
- bvtd22 10y agoClinton approved a number of controversial things during her tenure, but who approved this article at Salon, knowing full well that the major search engines would not curate it? We can be fairly certain a satirical piece from the Onion or NYT's Borowitz on Trump ordering drone strikes via Twitter would be far more likely to make search engine news.
- kogus 10y agoMaybe I'm being nitpicky, but this line really bothers me: Under Sec. Clinton, State Department officials approved almost every single proposed CIA drone assassination. They only objected to one or two attacks. One or two? Which one is it? If they have actually gone through a list of requests and vetted which ones were approved by the State Department, then they know the actual number. A hand-wavy figure indicates that someone sat down, skimmed through the list, found "a couple, I think" and wrote the article. Something of this importance deserves rigor.
- okoksowhatis 10y agoThe problem is that we kill at all. This is self-evident.
- dragonwriter 10y agoMy bigger problem is with the Secretary of State approving drone strikes than with the "with her cell phone" part. The Secretary of State isn't the Director of the CIA, nor in any chain of command above the Director of the CIA, nor anywhere in the military chain of command.