7 ms·
‘Warcraft’ sets records in Chinese market while stumbling in the U.S
- NuSkooler 10y agoInteresting. Just got back from watching this tonight and thought it was great. I think people watching this will certainly need to have a understanding of the lore, names, and landscapes presented to really enjoy the movie, however.
- andyjdavis 10y ago> I think people watching this will certainly need to have a understanding of the lore, names, and landscapes presented to really enjoy the movie, however. That is an interesting remark. Usually film adaptions go the other way and frustrate those familiar with the books/games/whatever by spending a bunch of time explaining the setting, presumably on the assumption that most of the audience is coming in knowing nothing.
- mjevans 10y agoScripts enabled required article, not bothering to read. Similarly, Hollywood in general has shown me every other time that I've given 'film adaptation of X' in my life that the original form was better. Were I interested in the story of WoW I suppose the best form to experience it in would be in the actual game (I've heard players of that game admit that parts of it are better left un-played and that they are this fine with the now more rapid ascent to newer content in the game).
- mikeash 10y agoIt's a common refrain that films based on other stuff are always worse, but I think it's sampling bias. When a movie is based on a mediocre source, people often just don't realize that the movie isn't original. The fact that a movie is "based on" is more likely to be known if the source is good, and reversion to the mean means that these are likely to have movies that aren't as good. For one example, Forrest Gump is based on a pretty crappy book. It's mildly entertaining but it's pretty wacky and definitely not the amazing classic that the movie was. For another one that turns up a lot, The Godfather is said to be a lot better than the book, although I haven't read it myself. One more, Pirates of the Caribbean, while not exactly deep and meaningful, is a pretty fun movie based on a pretty mediocre amusement park ride. I will admit that I can't come up with any good movies based on a video game. Another source of trouble, I think, is that a movie based on something well known can survive on name recognition, so it doesn't have to be good. A Warcraft movie could be good in theory, but they probably haven't bothered.
- HannibalLecter 10y agoThe two that stand out as best video game adaptations were Silent Hill and Resident Evil. Sure some of the aspects of each were utterly annoying fanboy service, but for what they were -- video game adaptations -- they were done right. Warcraft isn't a video game adaptation though. The lore within the mmo is its own story, and so the film could have easily adapted the story over the idea of a video game, which is probably why the film fails on so many levels. WoW lore is rich. Powerful. And it has lost its way since about The Burning Crusade expansion. I don't see Blizzard ever getting it right again. Have you seen the latest expansion footage? Everyone is Illidan. Everyone can have warglavies. Basically all the greatest things the game ever introduced that were hard to get are handed out to everyone so nothing matters in the game anymore. It's garbage. The movie is garbage, unsurprisingly.
- xahrepap 10y agoPrince of Persia Sands of Time. I liked that movie quite a bit. :) Only video game based movie I've seen and liked. Granted, it's only related by name from what I understand.
- douche 10y agoGo read the Godfather - it's an excellent book. Mario Puzo does some good work. Another really interesting one is his book on the Borgias[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Family_(Puzo_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Family_(Puzo_novel)
- csense 10y agoWoW takes place way later than the movie. The story shown in the movie is during the events of the original Warcraft: Orcs and Humans real time strategy game (from 1994).
- epynonymous 10y agoterrible movie, same old plot, bad guy, good guy, bad guy loses to good guy. i played warcraft and warcraft2, but not a lot of wow so perhaps i'm missing something. i would say in china, the fascination was more about the hype, most people probably never played any of the blizzard games that went to see the movie
- maruhan2 10y agoThat was the worry before even the movie came out. The movie is based off warcraft1, which was literally "orcs came to attack humans" and nothing more. It wasn't until warcraft 3 that they actually tried to describe the motives, but still you can't really change much of what was already made. However, if they manage to make a trilogy, they could utilize the arthras turns to lich king story in warcraft 3, which is much deeper.
- Longhanks 10y agoNot to spoil to much, but they changed some things in the movie, and the motives are very well explained. There are Orc protagonists as well.
- maruhan2 10y agoI haven't seen the movie but I have read the synopsis. And those "that changed for the movie" you mention is probably the background information of Warcraft1 that was added as flashback in Warcraft3. However, that was still a patch job for what was already written one dimensionally, hence still rather one dimensional despite the improvement. In short, what I meant as "based off warcraft1" is including the extra information from warcraft3, which understandably is still weak in story.
- princeb 10y agoguessing china didn't grow up with star wars 4-6 or the disney renaissance but they did with WC so this particular IP naturally did better at the theatres
- taneq 10y ago
- lsiebert 10y agoThe number of Western Films allowed in China is limited, and they all tend to do well. It's a soft power Beijing has learned to wield deftly that has led to some marked changes in the film industry.
- r0b1n_yzl 10y agoI’m from China. What you said is partly true. But the reason why the success of Warcraft in China is that this film is produced by Legendary Pictures owned by Wanda, the one that owns the largest number of cinemas in China. And Wanda is very good at marketing.
- Eliezer 10y agoMaybe the plot was sort of wuxia-ish? I haven't seen the movie so could be compleeeetely off base here, I was just trying to imagine what about the trailer I saw could map onto something that worked surprisingly well in China.
- chillacy 10y agoWarcraft made more money in China than the most recent Star Wars movie. The reason I've read is that Star Wars came out back before China had big cinema attendance, while Warcraft (1994) came out when China was modernizing. It's a big cultural hit. Edit: check out this video of chinese audiences cheering for the Blizzard logo: https://youtu.be/l67mA7ah9qE?t=51s https://youtu.be/l67mA7ah9qE?t=51s
- lsiebert 10y agoWanda acquiring legendary is one of the changes. Being owned locally means the pictures are more likely to be approved.
- seanmcdirmid 10y agoThis movie probably wouldn't have even been made if not for China. It is just one of those things that would make studios fearful, and someone then says "but china..." I saw it with my wife who was an avid Chinese WoW player back in her college years. It was pretty much as expected: visuals are good, story was edited to heck, and the acting was...just bad. The reaction from other movie goers weren't that positive either...we heard people complaining about the story on the way out (this is Beijing BTW), though I don't think anyone thought it was "bad."
- HannibalLecter 10y agoThis is funny to me because of Chinese gold farmers WOULD love that movie -- it's about their jobs!
- studentrob 10y agoI watched it and liked it. I'm an American living in Asia, and haven't played video games in 15 years. I thought I would hate this movie but I actually liked the mind games of a few parts, particularly near the end where one character tells another to "bring peace" to the two races. No spoiler there, but if you saw it you know what part I mean =). Anyway, to each his own. I'd recommend seeing it even if you're not into gaming. I also liked the new Alice movie..
- chillacy 10y agoI went in with very low expectations (at the time it had a 22% RT score), so I kind of liked the movie too, since it wasn't that bad. Might even see the sequel, since warcraft starts slow but sets up some nice drama for the future.
- studentrob 10y ago> Might even see the sequel, since warcraft starts slow but sets up some nice drama for the future. For sure. They're set up to be a great fantasy series The movie is based on the books. There are a ton of Warcraft books - I haven't read them but after seeing the movie I might. 22% on RT is ridiculous. I bet that goes up a lot over time. This story of good/evil people, where each group has good and evil people within it, along with good and evil magic is as good as star wars in my opinion, just in 2016-level graphics instead. It's another lesson that races, religion, etc. don't define whether people are good or not.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoreading a lot of the reviews, they seemed to be from a lot of older people who had a clear disdain for the type of movie. they seemed not to understand what fell was or orcs or anything and saw it as for dungeons and dragons nerds
- studentrob 10y agoYeah, oh well, their loss! I think this will become a great series.
- spdionis 10y agoA factor is probably that Dota was originally a warcraft map, and it was/still is most popular in China, almost at the level of starcraft in Korea.
- skoczymroczny 10y agoNot even Dota, but Warcraft 3 is still alive pretty much only in China.
- schuke 10y agoYoung people in China has a special bond with the Warcraft franchise, which is absent almost everywhere else in the world. Consoles were banned in China for two decades--basically a whole generation had limited access to games except on PC. In addition to this, there was the censorship that excluded many other foreign games, further condensing audience population on games like Warcraft. For Chinese young people born in the 80s and 90s, Warcraft is something like Star Wars, it's one of the things that gets to represent their childhood memory and teenage years. The Red Alert series, also hugely popular for the same generation of people, despite being banned, would probably have enjoyed similar success in China.
- rdsnsca 10y agoWarcraft the game IS censored in China, Blizzard had to change all the skeletons into ghouls before being allowed to sell the game there.
- kahnpro 10y agoIt was a cool movie. But the direction and acting were both pretty terrible. You could tell that the humans were standing in front of green screens. It really failed at immersion.
- namaemuta 10y agoJust from watching the trailer I got the impression of this being another 'Dungeons and Dragons' disappointment (if you haven't watched that movie, you totally should. It's beyond of being horrible). It's a pity if you have watched the CGI animations in Blizzard games. I think that was what most of the people were waiting but they decided to use real humans (which small bodies don't match at all with the overbuild bodies in CGI) with a terrible acting instead.
- HannibalLecter 10y agoFor years Blizzard has let their success go to their head. They no longer report their subscription count due to the massive hemorrhaging of players to better games. One only needs to look at Game of Thrones to enjoy a good story. Warcraft entirely missed the mark in that regard, and the CGI scaling issues could easily be forgiven if the company would listen to anyone at all. But they still have their heads locked firmly in their asses, so we can expect a couple more films and some tweaks to their process but nothing more. Short of bombing at the boxoffice, wow will plod along ruining a genre.
- ralusek 10y agoThe movie was surprisingly good.
- conradfr 10y agoAt least there was a good trailer ;) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m59oTieJFF4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m59oTieJFF4