7 ms·
Downvotes
I've noticed quite a trend of downvotes on well-composed comments over the last two months or so. It's disappointing.
I'm concerned that as it gains users, HN is acquiring an attribute common to other social news sites where users simply downvote a comment because they don't agree with it, or because it criticizes something that they favor or like. I believe that downvotes should only be used on content that does not generate interesting discussion, is spammy, or patently and generally offensive.
I've noticed that there is not much language addressing general appropriate voting behavior in the Guidelines (at http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html ). Is this something we want to address, or not?
I think a good way to help curb inappropriate downmodding is to invoke a small cost for each downvote. StackOverflow does this and it seems to work pretty well.
Has anyone else noticed this trend recently? If so, what are your feelings regarding it?
- pvg 17y agoI think the simplest thing to do about it is to not give a hoot. The karma point system is so obviously broken that hand-wringing about its deficiencies is largely a waste of time. Case in point - the person who was lucky enough to post the google announcement regarding China got 1000+ points. Let's say a particularly insightful comment is worth 40 points. That means being first on something everyone is likely to know about within half an hour is worth 25 (count em) very insightful comments. If you take the hit of posting an unpopular opinion, you can make it up in spades by posting an old pg essay.
- stingraycharles 17y agoWhile I agree that the per-user karma is worthless, comparing the rating of comments with the rating of stories is a bit like apples and oranges: multiple users can submit the same story, and when one submission "wins" over the other, little harm is done to the whole of HN. But when a comment is downvoted solely because people disagree with it, it hurts the discussion because the well constructed comment is less likely to be seen. Furthermore, this works both ways: snarky comments with little added value suddenly get a lot of appearance. It's a very difficult problem to solve, but to just "not give a hoot" is hard, given the fact that the order of appearance for comments on HN depends so much on karma.
- pvg 17y agoActually it's a surprisingly simple problem to solve. Split comment and submission karma. Reddit, which HN was inspired by does that already. but to just "not give a hoot" is hard try it! at 1k or so karma you have more or less nothing to lose.
- stingraycharles 17y agoI don't think you understand my point: I agree that per-user karma records are worthless. However, I am not convinced that there is little to lose with bad comment ratings, since HN bases the appearance of comments on these ratings.
- gridspy 17y agoI am also interested only in the ordering of comments within a given discussion thread. The number of points that my user account gets does not matter to me. Same with my submissions - I only care about up-votes there because I want more people to see what I have posted and benefit from it.
- silvajoao 17y agoHow about the following: whenever a user down votes a comment, a popup comes up describing the community rules for downvotes (e.g. "don't down vote just because you disagree", etc). After having been shown this box a couple of times it could be disabled for that user so that is isn't too annoying. New users would thus "learn" the rules as they use the site.
- pvg 17y agoA pop-up is not going to fix the tremendous discrepancy between submission votes and comment votes. It's mostly a matter of 'how about acknowledging this was a poor idea'
- TomOfTTB 17y agoDo you really think the problem is lack of understanding? I mean, a reputation system is a pretty easy concept and I can't imagine there are people out there who just don't know what a Karma system is. Which is the problem. If you understand what a karma system is than you understand you're doing damage to a person's actual reputation by down voting them. So the obvious conclusion for anyone who understands the concept of karma points is that down voting is an act designed to cause harm to the person not to express disagreement with the idea. I can't imagine a person who doesn't have at least a subconscious understanding of such an obvious result so I don't think a notice when someone down votes would change anything
- marshallp 17y agoThere should be two sets of karma, one for comments and one for submissions
- chaosmachine 17y agoIt's easy to get comment karma, as well. You just have to be the first person to post the generally prevailing opinion on whatever the current topic is. Then everyone who was coming to post the same thing will just upvote you instead.
- marshallp 17y agoThere should be third karma for indicating obviousness which also deletes some of your comment karma
- jackowayed 17y agoYeah, let's just have an infinite number of separate karmas to measure every attribute of each comment. It's not that quantifying all of these things wouldn't be great, just that you very quickly will end up with a system way too complex to be reasonable.
- marshallp 17y agoI think users of this forums, the majority of them programmers, can handle a few different karma arrows
- jackowayed 17y agoBut there's all kinds of issues. How do you display them all (especially if you exceed 2 sets of arrows)? How do you remember which one is which (again, not a huge issue if you just add one more karma type)? How much will having to sort by several karmas slow down the site?
- 17y ago
- TomOfTTB 17y agoI don't really disagree with the point system being unfair but I'm not sure I'd go so far as to say "broken" either. I think the karma system could work a lot better but it does do what it's intended which is to separate those who are dedicated to the community from those who are just fly-by trolls. I think that was all it was ever intended to do and in that sense it works well enough. I think it's an important distinction because it reflects on what would happen when it gets "fixed". For example comments by those who just submit stories would be treated no differently than someone who just came on the site today. But I'd argue that someone who has a couple thousand submit points behind them cares quite a bit about the community and if they felt inspired to comment on something after never having commented before I'd consider that comment of the utmost importance. So while the karma system is flawed it's not broken. It's just the most basic implementation of it's intent which is to reward people who have contributed to the community with status for having done so.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- smakz 17y agoFor me, it doesn't have anything to do with karma. Maximum when people disagree with me I get a little peeved that I spent time on what I thought was a thoughtful comment only to be down voted but it happens. I think the problem arises when thoughtful comments, maybe from people playing devil's advocate, are buried at the bottom on the thread or even worse highlighted in light gray. To be honest it probably is the exceptional case, but it's disappointing the times it does happen that those comments miss their opportunity to generate interesting discussion especially when the rest of the thread is, no offense intended, the usual hacker news echo chamber.
- kiba 17y agoEconomic contrarians like me quite often experience a resurgence in karma points after a user point out how unfair the downvotes is. My opinions may be unpopular but it is respected.
- jacabado 17y agoObviously broken? Aren't you demanding too much of it? Also your math doesn't demonstrate that much: the incentive for trying to be the first is big (25x an insightfull comment) but there aren't that many opportunities, and it establishes competition for a good thing, having fresh news on HN. You also tell that the referred mechanism would be gamed by people who would post old pg essays. Then again your scenario is wrong. The mechanism can be implemented to work so that the PG essays as not enough for the demand of points. And if you tell me that people would post other things just for points, isn't that the whole point of the voting/karma system? There are problems, but I think the karma system is not obviously broken. It's true it's hard to create the right incentives to fight those problems. But HN has done it so better than everyone that I'm confident it will get better soon. On a side note, has anyone ever tought of dynamic partitions of the community to address the problems of exponential grow and dissolution of identity?
- slater 17y agopg should just start charging a nominal fee for new user accounts. Cuts down on trolls AND spammers.
- wynand 17y agoThis is a cool idea. I'm just wondering how people without credit cards would be able to join (I know quite a few people who don't have credit cards). Perhaps via a premium SMS (very few people have neither a mobile nor a credit card).
- jff 17y agoThere's certainly no trolling on Somethingawful, home of the :10bux: entry fee!</sarcasm>
- char 17y agoI haven't really noticed this trend. But keep in mind, I'm just one data point. To give a rough estimate, I'd say that for every 20 or so down-voted comments I come across, there is one whose lack of points is actually confusing to me. I find that most of the down-voted comments tend to contain at least one (or a combination of) a number of things, including being off topic, using immature language, presenting opinions as facts without anything to back them up, being hostile, etc. It is because of these observations that I haven't gotten the impression that there is a trend towards down-voting solely due to disagreement. I believe it does happen, but not as much as some say.
- tokenadult 17y agoI'm concerned that as it gains users, HN is acquiring an attribute common to other social news sites where users simply downvote a comment because they don't agree with it, or because it criticizes something that they favor or like. This is an often-discussed issue. I see your join date is not quite from long enough ago that you may have seen this comment from pg http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 in which he said, "I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness. "It only becomes abuse when people resort to karma bombing: downvoting a lot of comments by one user without reading them in order to subtract maximum karma. Fortunately we now have several levels of software to protect against that." But I have a still more recent join date, and I have seen links back to that comment on the MANY previous occasions when downvotes have been discussed, so I have become aware of this point of view. Of course, more recent discussions of the issue of voting behavior on HN http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507948 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=507948 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1057133 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1057133 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1103339 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1103339 (this set of links is far from exhaustive) show that there is thought on the part of site management about how to improve current incentives. I try to learn from the downvotes I receive. I don't expect everyone to agree with me, but I expect myself to analyze my own behavior to figure out what really contributes to the community. The site management, of course, has to figure out how to set up incentives for altruistic rather than mob behavior. I always wonder, when I see a post about the evils of downvotes, why I don't see more replies about what is good to upvote. I tried opening a separate thread about that issue recently http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1065084 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1065084 but you can see for yourself it didn't get upvoted much at the time. I will ask again here: what ought to be upvoted? I would like advice from the community about how to use my upvotes to build up the community.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago>I try to learn from the downvotes I receive. I don't expect everyone to agree with me, but I expect myself to analyze my own behavior to figure out what really contributes to the community. As downvotes don't differentiate between agreement and poor construction of argument how can you tell what contributes. I find that those who disagree with me in a well thought out way are instructive. I don't wish to homogenise with the community but want to know if I'm not expressing myself well. For example, this comment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1135803 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1135803, I can't work out why it's downvoted. Thus I can't see what I could have done to improve the comment or why I should perhaps of not made it. IMO we should have an agreement vote as well as a quality vote.
- ErrantX 17y agoI have noticed some more downvoting than is usual - and, yes, sometimes on well worded and apparently good comments. I've never seen much problem with downvoting for disagreement myself - but I do dislike this idea of downvoting instead of commenting your disagreement/counter view etc. (I personally don't think a downvote is worth much if you can't support it) I think it would be nice to see a social pressure to add a reply if one doesn't already exist explaining disagreement etc. Both for the benefit of the commenter and other readers.
- alttab 17y agoI've seen perfectly intelligent responses downmodded for an opposing view. This wouldn't sadden me as much if some of the threads were not echo-chambered group think. I know I just thew out two very over used buzz words, but in this case there are some pockets of conversation that lend itself to this on HN (and anywhere else on the internet). There have been times I've decided against posting my two cents because its obvious other views (that aren't necessarily opposing) aren't welcomed.
- samd 17y agoThe voting system encourages groupthink. The Mahalo/Calacanis issue is a perfect example. No matter what Calacanis says in the comments he gets massively downvoted, that certainly sends a message to anyone who might dare to agree with him.
- KC8ZKF 17y agoJason Calacanis does not get "massively downvoted" no matter what he says. He has a reputation of 247, 32 points coming from four submissions.
- jasonmcalacanis 17y agoWell, when I comment on anything to do with Mahalo the group of SEOs who are leading this campaign against me just attack en masse and overpower the native HN group. I'm a polarizing guy who shoots from the hip, so I expect detractors or people who disagree with me to vote me down. In fact, I think it's kind of funny that sometimes within 30 seconds of posting I'll have a ton of down votes. It would be great if HN SHOWED the down votes and who votes each person down the most. If there was a leaderboard of who is voting me down it would be VERY telling. You would see ten folks voting me down all at the same time. That's the thing about social news systems... they are easy to game. If control as not put in place the dialogue simply goes to shit.... which is starting to happen. What normally happens is that intelligent folks leave the discussion and go somewhere else. I'm sure many folks here are refugees from digg or reddit or /. in fact. At this point I don't bother commenting on threads about me or Mahalo... and I'm skipping the comment section on HN and going to the links themselves for dialogue. The only way to correct the issue is really to expose the down votes.... folks need to take ownership of their voting. we did this on Mahalo Answers and we don't have the problem of folks using voting down as a way to attack someone. we did have this problem in the early days and when we exposed it it was VERY telling. you had really good users who would have it in for just one person and they would follow them around the site voting everything they did down. so, we did amnesty for past votes and turned on down votes from X day forward. That is what i would do here.... you should turn on link for every post from April 1st on that shows a list of who voted and how--as well as a leaderboard. anyway.... hack on.
- RevRal 17y agoI don't like drive-by downvotes, is basically how I feel about it.
- tokenadult 17y agoWhat do you mean by "drive-by downvotes"? Some comments are more apt to elicit written responses than others. Sometimes a downvote is a user's efficient use of time to improve the quality of the forum, saving time for posting written responses in other subthreads.
- RevRal 17y ago:) I mostly mean downvotes without an explanation, which you discerned. Technically, a drive-by downvote would be a subset of "downvoting without an explanation," since you're not always drive-by downvoting if you're not giving an explanation. Some comments just don't belong, and those comments are normally obvious. I often get the impression that the downvoters did not read a comment too carefully, quickly passed judgment without thinking about it too much, downvoted, then moved on. Hence, the other reason I call them drive-by downvotes. It is annoying to see a reasonable comment downvoted to 0, or less. I feel like I'm missing something and what I'm missing is an explanation. Why was the comment voted down? Then the comment gets voted up. I'll never know why the comment was downvoted, and it feels like a small loss. What's happening here can play out in different scenarios. So, that's it. I wish there was more explaining going on, and perhaps people would be less disposed to pass thoughtless judgment. It is what it is. The submitter asked for our thoughts about the downvote system, so if there's one thing that I'm going to complain about -- and I don't mean to say that this is a horrible, horrible phenomenon -- it's drive-by downvotes.
- RevRal 17y ago. . . ironic. (Downvoted. And others too. Did somebody just spam downvote as a joke?)
- arnorhs 17y agoI'm a bit confused. Who can vote something down? I don't have a down vote button and thought only moderators had one or something like that. How does that work?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- chacha102 17y agoI believe if you have over a certain number of points you can downvote items From the FAQ: Why don't I see down arrows? There are no down arrows on submissions. They only appear on comments after users reach a certain karma threshold.
- dirtbox 17y agoThe threshold being 200.
- allenbrunson 17y agothat may be the threshold now, but it almost certainly won't stay there. pg regularly increases the thresholds, to account for 'karma inflation.' so it's a good idea to quantify numbers, if you give them, so that people don't google them up in the future and come to mistaken conclusions.
- sammyo 17y agoYep, I had downvote access for a while and then it passed me by... story of my life.
- algorias 17y agoThere's a karma threshold.
- coryl 17y agoThis is one of the flaws of the upvote/downvote system, it can give people a bit of a mob mentality where making a comment or opinion disappear is as easy as a click (and anonymously too). Maybe downvotes could cost the voter karma, or have a higher bar for who can downvote.
- almost 17y agoThis has been discussed to death many times. The system isn't perfect and various meanings get assigned to downvotes. I believe pg was considering a separate voting axis for uncivil messages, maybe he'll do that but I don't think there's any use us discussing this yet again.
- algorias 17y agoDownvoting needs to cost a karma point, or perhaps a fraction of one.
- olefoo 17y agoThat's an interesting idea and should be explored further. The idea that as you gain standing (karma) you can expend it on socially damaging acts that may be useful. It would certainly alter the dynamic and make the downvote less casual.
- tokenadult 17y agoI challenge the assumption in this subthread that downvoting is a "socially damaging act." In many cases, downvoting is simply cleaning out the trash and improving the community. There are quite a few downvotes that should, if anything, GAIN karma for the users who make them.
- olefoo 17y agoLike it or not, downvoting is often perceived as an act of social violence by the downvotee. And it is intended and widely understood to be a punishment, the opposite of approval. Social sanctions like that may be necessary, but they also degrade the quality of life overall. Downvoting should have a cost, especially when it's an anonymous act.
- cmelbye 17y agoThat's actually a great idea. Maybe the karma point could be given back if the post is voted down to -4 (showing that it actually should be voted down).
- algorias 17y agoI like this idea. Could be gamed by a group of 'bullies', but it would be very obvious and easy to pick up by an automated filter similar to those already in place.
- 17y ago
- jacquesm 17y agoThis used to upset me, I have simply stopped caring and feel much better for it. That said, I've had some fairly drastic changes in my private situation so I'm not nearly as active on HN as I have been in the past. The best way to deal with an unjustly downvoted comment is to simply vote it up if you come across it (this you can do pretty much forever), and to ignore the issue if it happens to you on the assumption that on balance HN contains more nice people that griefers.
- Mz 17y agoMy opinion/experience: Karma and other systems may have their social uses, but the single most effective means to improve a social setting is to set a better example. Resist the temptation to snipe at people. Give the benefit of the doubt and first assume misunderstanding rather than malice and, if possible, attempt to clarify rather than attack or defend. Don't take things too personally. If I am in a personal space (not feeling well, recently had something negative happen to me, etc) where I am feeling particularly prickly and thin-skinned, just walk away and come back another time when I am less likely to make a mole-hill into a mountain. And so on. My experience over the years is that if I engage in more socially effective behavior and do so consistently, eventually, other people will begin to mimic some of those behaviors. Not because they think highly of me, but just because it works. If people don't know a better way, they fiddle around and do whatever it is they do know and then vent about their frustrations. Show them a better way and many people will eventually happily and voluntarily adopt those methodologies because it makes their own lives better. If you want to live in a better social "ecosystem", look to "the man in the mirror" (though, technically, in my case it is "the woman in the mirror") and work on their behavior. Then have a little patience. Sow the seeds. It will bear fruit (as long as you don't then pull it up by the roots to check if it's growing :-D ).
- wynand 17y agoI think that really hits the nail on the head. I don't know if people will ever stumble upon a set of interaction constraints that will make people civil if they're not already committed to civility. In that regard HN has always been good (but not perfect, as evidenced by some of the episodes mentioned in this comment section). If someone lashes out and gets a calm response instead of being downvoted to oblivion or without being baited, the whole atmosphere becomes much less toxic (even if the original commenter insists on trolling).
- Mz 17y agoIf someone lashes out and gets a calm response instead of being downvoted to oblivion or without being baited, the whole atmosphere becomes much less toxic (even if the original commenter insists on trolling). The other thing a calm (compassionate, tolerant) response does is it tends to prevent "train wrecks". One of the biggest problems with many online forums is the tendency for everyone to try to jump into the fray to "defend" righteousness and goodness and what not, thus keeping the fighting alive. Many of them are attempting to put a stop to the fighting but they miss the fact that fighting against the fighting is still fighting. Many people seem to just not know how to effectively defuse a negative situation and put a stop to it, which is a very different skill set than "arguing"/fighting. Fighting against it is the typical knee-jerk response of the vast majority of people, even for most very well educated and intelligent people. "Train wrecks" are best diverted by redirecting the flow of conversation in a constructive fashion rather than attacking the person who has said something that sounds asinine (but maybe wasn't really intended to be, they could be having a bad day or it's a pet peeve they aren't wholly rational about, etc).
- alecco 17y agoIMHE, there's a paradox similar to the Dunning-Kruger effect on up-down voting. The loud strongly opinionated newbies (or even plain idiots) downvote anything that challenges their point of view or their latest fad, while many of the more educated, experienced, or rational users become apathetic.
- hexis 17y agoMy HN account is 521 days old and I can't downvote. Granted, I don't comment or submit very much, but I would assume that getting to 200? karma is something of a brake on opinionated newbies downvoting anything. Of course, this is less of a brake on idiots.
- cmelbye 17y agoGetting to 201 karma is the threshold for downvoting I believe. It may have been moved to 251.
- epochwolf 17y agoAs of this post I have 228 karma. I got the privilege to downvote at 201 (which I got to about a week ago).
- alecco 17y agoHigher karma doesn't certify knowledgeable or interesting people at all. Others answered plenty of times how easy is increasing karma.
- cema 17y agoAt the moment I am reading this, several most recent (and, it seems, perfectly legitimate) comments have been downvoted to zero: one by Mz (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1189009 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1189009), jacquesm (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1189007 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1189007), algorias (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1189004 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1189004), coryl (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188999 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188999), as well as arnorhs (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188988 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188988) and pbhjpbhj (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188906 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1188906). And a few minutes later, they are now back in the positive. Could it have been a case of vandalism?
- jules 17y agoI sometimes click on the wrong arrow accidentally, and on HN there is no way to repair the damage.
- lucifer 17y agoThe problem is that we are given a single qualifier that is then conflated to represent a variety of reactions. Even just one additional qualifier would go a long way to disambiguate the community opinion.
- dpcan 17y agoI agree with it "costing" something to down-vote, I actually thought it already did.... hmm. However, when you click the down-arrow, what if it prompted you with options like Digg does (minus an "other" option) as to why you are down voting, and you have to choose one. If the reason why you are down voting is not listed, you learn pretty quickly what reasons are valid for down voting.
- tokenadult 17y agowhat if it prompted you with options like Digg does (minus an "other" option) as to why you are down voting pg opened a thread a while ago asking options for flagging posts. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1006589 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1006589
- dpcan 17y agoDidn't see that one.
- eplanit 17y agoAn up-vote is a bit different from a down-vote. It's a way of saying "I agree. Were I to post a comment, it would be similar to yours. In fact, you said it better". See, there isn't much to add to an up-vote, because it is agreement. However, a down-vote is rebuttal. However, when no actual rebuttal is given, there is no meaningful conversation happening. It's just an anonymous rejection. I think that to be meaningful, a down-vote should _require_ some explanation as to why. And, the 'rule' should be that simply disagreeing is insufficient rationale to down-vote. You must state why. Absent this kind of 'rule', I worry that HN encourages group-think. It's already a kind of psychological school yard, I fear. One gains "cred" by earning points. Ideally, these are earned by meaningful contributions and commentary. To avoid these anonymous down-votes, however, posters might very well be adding comments that seem consistent with the rest of the group, instead of what might be regarding as opposed to that of the majority. The idea of charging would not be a good solution, at all. That would have a worse kind of school yard effect -- a nursery school effect, in fact. That would say "it's free to agree, but to if you disagree with somebody, you have to pay to express your disagreement." If this is to be a forum of ideas, then make it so. Anonymous/un-qualified nay-saying does not contribute that.
- Mz 17y agoAn up-vote is a bit different from a down-vote. It's a way of saying "I agree. Were I to post a comment, it would be similar to yours. In fact, you said it better". See, there isn't much to add to an up-vote, because it is agreement. However, a down-vote is rebuttal. However, when no actual rebuttal is given, there is no meaningful conversation happening. It's just an anonymous rejection. I think that to be meaningful, a down-vote should _require_ some explanation as to why. And, the 'rule' should be that simply disagreeing is insufficient rationale to down-vote. You must state why. The problem with your suggestion is that it would actively encourage fighting and discourage more agreeable discourse: Upvote all you like without comment but you must comment when downvoting. Yes, a forum of ideas needs to have a certain tolerance for different points of view and opinions and for the friction involved in expressing those differences. But it's really quite a tricky thing to foster an environment where sharing different points of view is constructive and additive rather than merely socially destructive and a promotion of in-fighting, promotion of polarized "camps" within the community, etc. I am someone who has, at times, asked why I got downvoted because I wanted to understand what the problem was with my remark. Sometimes, that turned out to be a constructive exercise. But requiring people to state their criticism/reasons for nay-saying is highly unlikely to be constructive or improve the atmosphere here. It will most likely just promote hurt feelings, feuds and so on.
- brandon272 17y agoMy feelings regarding downvoting are that downvotes are virtually inconsequential, aside from the rise they get from some as a result of bruised egos. I also think that it's kind of silly to try and establish upvote or downvote "guidelines" because there's no way to ultimately control or accurately measure what upvotes or downvotes are being used for. You could put big, red text in the HN Guidelines that instructed people to upvote or downvote in a certain way, and users would continue to upvote or downvote however they wished.
- marshallp 17y agoOnce downvoted to below 1, insightful comments tend to get ignored and this a real loss beyond bruised egos
- brandon272 17y agoI tend to read all of the comments, regardless of their comment score. The score just ends up affecting what order the comments get read in, which is fine with me. I often see downvoted comments still receiving replies, so I'm not sure it's fully accurate to say that they are being ignored. Also, quality and insightfulness are still subjective. You may feel that a post is of high-quality and very insightful, but someone else may feel that the post is junk for their own reasons.
- tokenadult 17y agoOnce downvoted to below 1, insightful comments tend to get ignored and this a real loss beyond bruised egos Do you have some current examples with links at hand? I have noticed that one can upvote comments, however old, so any of us who like to emphasize the positive can upvote good comments whenever we find them. By the way, I asked in my reply to the thread-opening post what kinds of upvotes are most helpful to the community. I'd love to hear replies to that question in that subthread, if you please.
- xtho 17y agoWhat's so bad about downvoting comments you disagree with? IMHO the problem rather is "kharma whoring", which is incited by the possibility of accumulating kharma. IMHO2 those points should be only relevant for sorting articles and comments but there should be now way to hoard "points" on a user level.
- DanBlake 17y agoThis might sound silly, but what about just listing those who have upvoted and listing those who have downvoted somewhere. I think there would be alot less downvotes if it wasnt anonymous.
- andrewcooke 17y agowhat bothers me most about downvotes is their passive aggressive nature - when you get a downvote but no explanation. that, more than anything, has made me consciously try to ignore karma.
- gojomo 17y agoI would like to see two-axis voting. Up/down would mean, "valuable/non-valuable". Right/left would mean "agree/disagree" -- the easiest possible way to register opinion without the effort of composing a reply. Up/down would show a net score, like now. Right/left would show both totals -- perhaps even a little inline sparkline bargraph (perhaps initially hidden). It's reasonable that people want a lazy, one-click way to show disagreement. It's problematic that impulse gets channeled into the same downvote-gesture-tally that also means "this is spam; this is rude; this should be sunk and faded out of existence". Those meanings are scolding; the effect of a downvote is censorius (by the ranking/fading). It's coarsening for conversation to cross the signals for "I respectfully disagree" and "your comment should be penalized".
- vog 17y agoI don't think that an "agree/disagree"-axis would be very useful. If you disagree, just reply and explain your disagreement. That adds more value to the discussion. I'm not interested at all in the number of agreements or disagreements to my statements. I'm only interested in those who agree/disagree and care to elaborate on their point.
- gojomo 17y agoIf it were as simple as asking people to only disagree with a thoughtful response comment, it would have already been solved. The participants we actually have often can't be bothered to do more than a grunt's worth of disagreement. This gets channeled into downvotes, which carry a slight 'sting' of moral judgment, and spawn big threads like this one every so often. An outlet for one-click-disagreement separate from one-click-censure could help remedy the actual problem without requiring an unlikely change in the behavior of the mostly-anonymous, distracted downvoting hordes.