20 ms·
Open access: All human knowledge is there, so why can’t everybody access it?
- Houshalter 10y agoI think it's an issue of copyright law being ridiculous. Nonfiction and scientific work should be treated differently than fictional works. I don't really care if Mickey Mouse goes into the public domain. But it's crazy that 100 year old scientific works can still be under copyright and illegal to distribute. These objectively have value to society, and the argument for the existence of the public domain is much stronger. It shouldn't last indefinitely. Maybe only 10 or 15 years. I believe 99% of all works make most of their money in the first few years. Having copyright last a lifetime, let alone much longer, is just crazy. Put a cost on renewing copyright. This is actually how it used to be. Half way through, you could pay a fee to have copyright extended. Very few people paid this fee (because most works aren't economically valuable), so most works went into public domain much sooner. Journals charge $30 to access obscure ancient papers. But I bet they wouldn't pay even $30 to keep the rights to those same papers. Don't put everything into copyright by default. And again especially works of nonfiction or scientific papers. If the authors want that, then sure. This wouldn't fix the issues with big journals that demand it. But it still seems like a sensible idea to have copyright opt-in, not opt-out.
- contravariant 10y ago> I think it's an issue of copyright law being ridiculous. I disagree, scientists generally aren't seeking to get money by people buying a copy of their paper (if anything they're currently paying so people can read it) there's no need for them to invoke copyright law at all, in fact that would be against their own interest. The problem is that the current system forces scientists to publish in journals, which will happily charge an arm and a leg for the privilege, and invoke whatever law they can to make more money, even if this goes directly against the interests of the scientists who wrote the papers.
- Houshalter 10y agoThe Journals wouldn't be an issue in the first place without copyright law. And fixing copyright solves problems beyond scientific Journals. You could have nonfiction books in general, textbooks, etc, all available to the public domain.
- dredmorbius 10y agoYou're pretty much entirely missing the point. 1. Scientists aren't at the heart of the scientific Open Access problem. Journals are. 2. The fact that copyright exists means that journals can then request it be transferred (or licensed) to the journal. For what's effectively forever. 3. Journals exercise gatekeeper access over scientists' careers, in that publishing in prestige journals is how scientists advance academically. This is de facto* coercive control over scientists. 4. With that control, journals compell publication of articles in controlled journals, for scientists to advance, require subscriptions of libraries (who otherwise forgo access to the material), and maintain a bank of virtually all scientific papers published since 1924 as an absolute monopoly. Hence: no copyright, or a far-less-rediculous copyright, say, 14, 28, or 54 years (as was historically the case, via registration(s) and/or renewals), and much the problem would disappear. The additional factor of deadweight costs of denied access to virtually all of humanity for this material is the other cost.
- rflrob 10y ago> And again especially works of nonfiction or scientific papers. As much as I feel that science---especially publicly funded science (which almost all of it is)---ought to be freely available fairly quickly, I think making a distinction for the purposes of copyright law between fiction and non-fiction is fairly hairy. Clearly "A Streetcar Named Desire" is fiction, but what about memoirs? Poetry? The Onion? Dianetics? The output of human writing spans a continuum of factual-ness, and it's not obvious to me that there's a good way to draw a line. Even in the hardest of sciences, it's often underappreciated how much interpretation and creative energy goes into a paper.
- 100ideas 10y agoI wish copyright was more limited with regard to scientific works. But how to define them? In a conservative sense, perhaps works that are 1) a technical or research article 2) produced with public funding Could receive more limited (shorter-term) copyrights etc.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Houshalter 10y agoFiction and nonfiction seems like a very natural way to categorize works. Is anyone really going to argue that scientific papers are works of fiction? Would any reasonable court hold that up? All laws have to deal with the natural fuzziness of concept space. But if libraries can manage it successfully, surely the copyright office can.
- jobigoud 10y agoWhat about allegories and thought experiments? Two examples on the top of my head: 1. The strange cave of Ali Baba (or how to explain Zero-Knowledge protocols to your children) - Jean-Jacques Quisquater - Advances in Cryptology - 1990. 2. The fable of the Tyrant Dragon - Nick Bostrom - Journal of Medical Ethics, 2005¹. This is a work of fiction designed to make a statement about the stance of society towards fighting aging. ¹ http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~mkowalcz/628.pdf http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~mkowalcz/628.pdf ² http://www.nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon.html http://www.nickbostrom.com/fable/dragon.html
- zanny 10y agoFictional works are not a special case. I'd personally argue copyright never made sense, but people like to say back when the marginal cost of producing duplicates of information was greater than nothing, copyright at least functioned. Remember, today, there are millions of people using their computer to voluntarily and entirely charitably give away information for free, that other people want to stop them from doing. That is so absurd and insane. I've said it before, and many of us will inevitably say it again, but this is not 1800. Charge for what is valuable and scarce, your creativity (or in the case of a scientist, their knowledge), not what is not valuable or scarce, which is bits on a hard drive.
- dnautics 10y agoTo help categorize and understand: I'd characterize your argument as the "Stallman" argument, where the simplicity of copying justifies the moral argument against copyright. There is a alternate vein which doesn't have to do with value or scarcity, but which has to do with rivalrousness (that is a very subtle distinction): http://blog.ninapaley.com/2011/07/09/culture-is-anti-rivalrous/ http://blog.ninapaley.com/2011/07/09/culture-is-anti-rivalro... You may find it interesting.
- zanny 10y agoThat is an excellent argument from what I would also call the big picture perspective. I just usually use the utilitarian one because it just seems any time you want to argue about social fundamentals - be it anything from segregated bathrooms (of all varieties) to street naming to intellectual property, people get incredibly defensive about the status quo as if their livelihood depended on it - as if culture / information cannot be made without IP, rather than the reverse. I do think at some point in the future historians will look back and see the catastrophic death of culture permanent copyright wrought throughout the 20th / 21st centuries as a huge crime against humanity. We are sad we have few historical recounts of ancient Egyptian / Greek / Roman living, or even moreso ancient Mesoamerican peoples, or the Babylonians, but we seem perfectly complacent in how some ~95% of all music, film, photography, writing, and even probably code is lost forever because of copyright meaning if the owners take it to their grave it stays dead with them. It is just a tremendous disservice to humanity to just let so much creative work die like that, and how generations have now grown and died without any of the commercial works of their childhood ever being accessible to their own creativeness in their lifetimes.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoI think in general scientific discoveries (pharmaceuticals, algorithms etc) should not be granted monopolistic production rights, but rather monopolistic royalty rights. So, for example, if you invented Viagara, and every pharma company in the world figured out how to make it cheaper in their own way, they're free to make it but they have to pay the creator (individual or corporation) a royalty fee to do so. I think royalties are a better way to incentivize innovation while not allowing patent protections to stifle the market as a whole.
- Houshalter 10y agoThe problem is there is no objective way to set the price of the royalty. Pharma companies won't invest in a drug that is only worth $1 per pill. And some pills will need to be taken for a lifetime, while others only need to be taken once - but the value of curing a disease is the same.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoYeah that's a good point. Maybe instead it could be a fee you could have to pay the creator to sell the same thing up to some limit, maybe determined by the creator's market price?
- dreamdu5t 10y agoSo we should pay royalties for using Calculus? Do we need to pay royalties everytime we use certain equations? Ridiculous.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y agoPatents expire.
- m1sta_ 10y agoCopyright only covers expression. It doesn't cover the content of a scientific paper. One effort of paraphrasing a paper and we're good to go.
- qmr 10y ago> Maybe only 10 or 15 years. That's 10 or 15 years potentially holding back humanity and preventing Shit Getting Done.
- Houshalter 10y agoOf course. I'd prefer that journals switch to open access, and that governments demand publicly funded research to be released in the public domain. My proposals are independent of that policy.
- bra-ket 10y agoAn article on open access without mentioning sci-hub?
- catnaroek 10y agoIt does mention Sci-Hub.
- wolfgke 10y ago> An article on open access without mentioning sci-hub and libgen (the latter one really isn't mentioned).
- geonnave 10y agoActually, both Sci-Hub and LibGen are mentioned in the article. Perhaps your ctrl+f failed because the page only loads the next section when you scroll down near the bottom of the page.
- wolfgke 10y ago> Perhaps your ctrl+f failed because the page only loads the next section when you scroll down near the bottom of the page. Exactly that happened.
- duncan_bayne 10y ago...? I'm confused as to why anyone would do that, when just loading a page of HTML and letting the user scroll is a demonstrably superior solution.
- gavinpc 10y agoThe charitable view is that this saves bandwidth (and load time) for page views that never get scrolled. Also, it may allow them to count the ads in those sections as impressions without having to paginate the article, which presumably they know that people hate. But I think it's ironic for an article about open access to make itself essentially unprintable in this way. It's too long for me to read on the screen. A "page of HTML" would be demonstrably superior for that purpose.
- dougmccune 10y agoIf you're doing a startup trying to innovate in the research and academic journal space I'd love to talk to you. I've put out requests for contact in HN comment threads like this before and gotten great responses and great conversations, and one even resulted in a funding round. I'm a shareholder and board member of SAGE Publications, which was founded by my grandparents. SAGE is about the 5th largest journal publisher and is and will remain a private family-owned company. I know it's hard to believe, but publishers aren't one homogenous evil entity plotting how to rip off the public. There are lots of fucked up things about the journal system, many of which publishers have caused or been complicit in. But there are also a lot of complicated factors that are entirely outside publishers' ability to change. Academia is a mess in a lot of ways, and much of the overall dysfunction of the whole system has manifested in what has become the hard to comprehend journal publishing system of today. I live in Oakland and would love to meet up with anyone who happens to be in the Bay Area, or just have Skype calls no matter where you are. My contact info is in my HN profile. Drop me an email and I'd love to pick your brain to hear about how you're approaching academic publishing. We've funded two startups in the last few years. PeerJ is an open access journal undercutting the traditional publishers AND most OA publishers (like PLOS) on price. Publons is trying to provide incentives for peer review and encourage openness in the peer review process. We'd love to find a few more good companies doing truly innovative stuff that will have an impact on academic publishing.
- wolfgke 10y ago> If you're doing a startup trying to innovate in the research and academic journal space I'd love to talk to you. Make contact with Alexandra Elbakyan. She clearly tries to bring innovation to the academic journal space (though not legal one).
- dougmccune 10y agoI emailed her to try to get her to speak (remotely) at a SAGE board meeting. Never heard back. I'd love to have her engage in a conversation with us.
- 10y ago
- graycat 10y agoFirst, some of the "knowledge" is deep, that is, has prerequisites, and getting through the prerequisites can use some guidance, help, etc., say, in high school, college, and graduate schools. Next, finding the material on the Internet, say, 1 trillion or so Web pages, is too often from difficult to much worse. My startup is intended to help with that.
- GroSacASacs 10y agoHow do you helm with that
- graycat 10y agoBy "helm" you mean "help"? I've developed a new Internet search engine except it's very different from any other search engine (Google, Bing, Yahoo, etc.) and is more for discovery, recommendation, curation, notification, and subscription. Mostly it's for discovery and recommendation. What Google, etc. do is part of what long ago the field of information retrieval characterized as just part of the problem, the part where the user knows that the content exists, knows they will like the content, and has keywords/phrases that characterize that content. For that part, Google, Bing, etc. work great. But, again, as has been known for decades, that's only part of the problem. I'm attacking the rest of the problem, that is, where a user knows less about what they want. For that I derived some new mathematics, with some advanced prerequisites, with theorems and proofs, designed the business model, the user interface, the Web pages, the SQL database, the software and server farm architecture and the code, wrote the code, for the production code, 20,000 programming language statements in 80,000 lines of typing. The code is darned fast and appears to run as intended. Currently the code is in alpha test. Then beta test and going live.
- Roritharr 10y agoI consider my belief how this particular battle will turn out a good litmus test for my pessimism/optimism. Some days I can't imagine a future where universal open access is implemented, at other times it seems inevitable. Seeing that I must normally believe it to be a 50/50 thing makes it a great way to calibrate my mood out of my decision making process. More on topic: I wonder if we'll see countries take a stance in these battles. Why isn't Ecuador Hosting a Sci-Hub Mirror for their citizens? The naive observer might think there is only upsides for countries like these to such an action.
- wolfgke 10y ago> Some days I can't imagine a future where universal open access is implemented, at other times it seems inevitable. Even if in the future universal open access is implemented, this will not solve the problem. To quote Aaron Swartz (https://archive.org/stream/GuerillaOpenAccessManifesto/Goamjuly2008_djvu.txt https://archive.org/stream/GuerillaOpenAccessManifesto/Goamj...): "The Open Access Movement has fought valiantly to ensure that scientists do not sign their copyrights away but instead ensure their work is published on the Internet, under terms that allow anyone to access it. But even under the best scenarios, their work will only apply to things published in the future. Everything up until now will have been lost. That is too high a price to pay."
- dougmccune 10y agoI hope you're OK with a compromise between your pessimism and optimism. I think what you'll see over the next few years is continued movement (with increased velocity) toward open access for well-funded research areas (ie bio and other hard sciences, etc). If you're getting decent grant money from the government or a funding body (like Wellcome Trust or Gates) then your research will be highly likely to be open access, and not just after an embargo period. But in disciplines that aren't well funded it's going to be a different story. Humanities and much of Social Science doesn't have the same funding situation, and so therefore the existing system is going to stick around for quite a while. The zealots will argue that every service a traditional publisher provides should only cost $20 a paper (or whatever other number you pull form thin air). Except if that was true you'd have a bunch of startups offering compelling publishing services for that price point, which you don't. Vetting and curating scientific literature has real costs, and those who say it doesn't don't have defensible models they can point to to show that it can work without real money flowing. It's always just hand-wavey arguments about theoretical cheap costs. So I think your optimism will be proven right (or at least more right than wrong) when it comes to well-funded research areas. And your pessimism will be proven right when it comes to fields without the same funding structure.
- Ruud-v-A 10y agoI try to avoid citing articles that are only available behind a paywall. Even though there isn’t always an alternative source available, if enough people favour citing open-access articles over paywalled ones, that should create an incentive to publish in open-access journals, because in academia, citations are everything. (That is a problem in itself, but it is the status quo.)
- jobigoud 10y agoI wish everyone would do this. Like a code of honor akin to a copyleft license: if you use open access references, your article should be open access too. When reproducing findings of an openly accessible paper it's extremely frustrating when some of the references are unreachable. I'm not in academia so for one I don't have university access to papers and for two I often need to trickle down the references to fill knowledge gaps.
- jean_claude 10y agoIt's just not always possible to do that. I know it can be frustrating to not have ready access to academic journals, but you can usually find the article one way or another. Many journals are allowing pre-print publications to reside on open-access archives ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_academic_journals_by_preprint_policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_academic_journals_by_p... ), some will allow 'limited' distribution of either pre-print or published papers (generally means you have to ask the author for a PDF directly), and, with apologies to John Gilmore, the internet interprets copyright as damage and routes around it.
- zw123456 10y agoThis reminded me of back 30 years ago or more when I first was messing around with Arpanet and it was just turning into the Internet, I remember how all of my friends and I were so stoked about how it was going to change the world because everyone would have access to all the knowledge in the world and how exciting that was, the democratization of knowledge. We speculated on how everyone in the future would be so much smarter because they would have access to so much information and knowledge. Some of that is true, but sadly, not entirely. Much of the greatest knowledge is locked away. And even sadder still, so many people do not really cherish what we have and instead use it for a lot of ridiculous nonsense, which, I guess is me being Judgmental about what the internet should be used for. I guess what it really shows, is that the future often does not turn out the way you thought it would . I think this is a case like that, we thought knowledge would flow freely like from a fountain or oracle of wisdom, but instead it is filled with 140 character snotty comments and pictures of cats with fruit on their heads. Sorry for the rant.
- SerLava 10y agoI'm speculating here but there might actually be a lot of knowledge out there created by the internet that you don't really see - like little details about mundane aspects of life that people previously had no concept of, but aren't controversial.
- zw123456 10y agoYou know what, thank you, you are right, every time I am depressed about the crap I see online, then I see something really great. you take the good with the bad, just like life :)
- SerLava 10y agoI'm speculating here but there might actually be a lot of knowledge out there created by the internet that you don't really see - like little details about mundane aspects of life that people previously had no concept of, but aren't controversial.
- rm_-rf_slash 10y ago
- keyle 10y agoTo be fair though, if I had access to all these papers I wouldn't understand a third of it. It's the dumbed down version of them that should be more proactively shared. And if interested, one can dig deep into the subject at hand.
- SkyMarshal 10y agoThat's the problem, digging deep requires access to the un-dumbed-down ones.
- moribondus 10y agoThe problem is generated by a combination of false, pagan beliefs. First, that these journals would be needed for anything at all. Second, that it would be legitimate to enforce human-invented rules. I have long time ago given up on trying to counter credentialist rhetoric. People's opinions are in fact never important. Only what they are willing to risk their lives for and die, could ever be important.
- sgt101 10y agoThere is a more fundamental issue - try answering questions about science with a six year old and google. Yes, they can frame their question, yes they can type it into google, yes google provides links. But, click on the links and ads, speedbumps and plain clickbait stop them dead. Very disappointing. Ok you say, put an adblocker on.. well yes but there goes the revenue that keeps many sites online.
- geekstrada 10y agohttps://openaccessbutton.org/ https://openaccessbutton.org/
- doener 10y agoAt least in the EU there is some progress on this matter: All European scientific articles to be freely accessible by 2020 http://english.eu2016.nl/latest/news/2016/05/27/all-european-scientific-articles-to-be-freely-accessible-by-2020 http://english.eu2016.nl/latest/news/2016/05/27/all-european...
- pasbesoin 10y agoFor me, it's coming down to a fundamental difference or distinction: Those who believe in a zero-sum-gain world, and those who believe in a net-sum-gain world. I fall into the latter camp. In other words, I believe that by sharing and cooperating, we all can advance. And, I find myself increasingly thinking and experiencing that the zero-sum-gainers are my opposition. They take as much as they can get away with, and they give as little as they can get away with. Personal advancement, versus communal. I can't cooperate with them. And, I no longer want to engage with them. I cannot afford to do things that lend or provide them power. For it is only ever turned against me, to leverage further advantage. Now... for "the community" to come to realize this, and act upon it.
- ikeyany 10y ago> For me, it's coming down to a fundamental difference or distinction: Those who believe in a zero-sum-gain world, and those who believe in a net-sum-gain world. I fall into the latter camp. In other words, I believe that by sharing and cooperating, we all can advance. People like to say this, but they are only okay with sharing things they approve of. By your logic, aren't you morally obligated to let me have something of yours if I ask for it? I'm not criticizing cooperation, just the idealism that falls apart in practice. The best course of action is a complex blend of the two camps you mentioned.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt depends on how you ask, what you're using it for, and of course, the reciprocal obligation on you to assist others, on request.
- yagyu 10y agoA light academic disobedience is to refuse to peer-review non-open papers. I'm trying it for now, you could, too. http://www.jonaseinarsson.se/2016/only-open-access-peer-review.html http://www.jonaseinarsson.se/2016/only-open-access-peer-revi...
- dredmorbius 10y agoOrganised collective behavior is better than individual, and much more powerful.
- IncRnd 10y agoThe premise of the click-bait title is clearly false.