10 ms·
Apple's OS X, which wouldn't be what it is if Linux hadn't already been the leading nix OS.* Well that isn't true. NeXTStep was built on the 68k from 4.3BSD wh
by gaius 10y ago
Apple's OS X, which wouldn't be what it is if Linux hadn't already been the leading nix OS.*
Well that isn't true. NeXTStep was built on the 68k from 4.3BSD which originated on the VAX. It has no lineage in common with Linux, and in fact pre-dates it. And OSX now is by far the most popular workstation Unix.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Unix_history-simple.svg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Unix_history-simple.svg
- deng 10y ago> It has no lineage in common with Linux. That's not what he wrote. In its initial release, OS X did depend heavily on free software (Samba, Apache, GNU, etc.), which again thrived because of Linux.
- gaius 10y agoIt would be more accurate to say Linux thrived because of them! Samba IIRC predates Linux too, as does the GNU project, Apache is based on the original httpd which was built on... Drum roll... NeXTStep. In 1990, before Linux existed.
- pvg 10y agoApache was a fork of NCSA httpd, not CERN httpd.
- Retric 10y agoNCSA httpd also predates Linux. NCSA httpd released version 0.1 was June 1991. http://www.w3.org/Daemon/Features.html http://www.w3.org/Daemon/Features.html Amusingly: http://www.diam.unige.it/informatica/documentazione/httpd_docs/docs/FAQ.html http://www.diam.unige.it/informatica/documentazione/httpd_do... "3.5) Why doesn't NCSA HTTPd work on my Linux system? NCSA HTTPd is not crippled. Linux may be crippled. NCSA HTTPd uses a standard BSD4 and SYSV feature known as file descriptor passing. NCSA HTTPd supports both the BSD and SYSV style of file descriptor passing. Linux chose not to implement either."
- batbomb 10y agoThat's CERN httpd release notes for 0.1 @ 1991, not NCSA. NCSA didn't join the web until much later. In fact, SLAC was first to the web in the USA, and Marc had originally approached my boss, who wrote MidasWWW, to see if he'd want to collaborate on the web browser which would become Mosaic.
- Retric 10y agoDoh, missed the edit window. However, it's clear that NCSA was not initially developed on or for Linux. PS: An interesting side note, the SGML standard committee decided not to include hyperlinks which more or less directly resulted in HMTL. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Generalized_Markup_Language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Generalized_Markup_La... I wonder if that would have pushed the web forward even faster or not as HTML is far less strict, but you could make a less strict render for SGML as well.
- iheartmemcache 10y agoCame in here to be that guy and make this comment, but you beat me to it. Have an up-vote. I can't anyone is even disputing the fact that OS X didn't largely benefit from the fact that there was tons of GNU/GPL tooling out of the box that power users could use. Bash? GCC/G++ (before the clang/llvm migration out)? GNU. X-windows (granted I don't think many people used it post-Carbon, but I remember using it on my iBook 266mhz...). \/ Edit: Mea culpa. IIRC you're right re: tcsh. I haven't used OS X as a daily operating system since first year undergrad (placing that at just under a decade) so afford me some liberties with details, kindly :)
- gaius 10y agoGNU yes, but GNU pre-dates Linux. I first used GCC on SunOS.
- pvg 10y agoWell, OS X's ancestors had a largely BSD-derived userspace so that's neither here nor there. The strongest claim and perhaps biggest contribution, I think, was GCC on which NeXTs Objective C compiler was based from the beginning.
- QuercusMax 10y agoIf my memory serves me right, early OSX used tcsh as the default shell; it wasn't till around 10.4 or so that they switched to bash.
- cm3 10y ago> Samba IIRC predates Linux too Not quite, actually. Samba => sometime in 1992 Linux => October 1991
- qbrass 10y agohttp://www.rxn.com/services/faq/smb/samba.history.txt http://www.rxn.com/services/faq/smb/samba.history.txt It wasn't invented for Linux, but Samba exists today because of it.
- kazinator 10y ago> Samba IIRC predates Linux too I don't think so. But IRC predates Linux. :)
- ajsalminen 10y agoWhat many of these comments seem to be missing is that I don't think Doc Searls meant Linux the kernel when he said this. He meant Linux the OS (which some want to call GNU/Linux as he mentioned) with all these parts included. All of these components played their part in the rise of the OS and benefited from each other. The Linux kernel as well as things like the GNU project were absolutely necessary for this ecosystem to becoming a reality and that is what OS X benefited from as well.
- simonh 10y agoSolaris was a much bigger deal than Linux well into the OSX era. In fact if Linux had never happened Solaris would probably still be around and we'd be arguing about how much OS X owes to Solaris and whether it matters that SunOS predated NEXT but Solaris didn't.
- deng 10y ago> In fact if Linux had never happened Solaris would probably still be around and we'd be arguing about how much OS X owes to Solaris Hardly. How would have Apple developed a full userland and development toolchain with the resources it had at that time? That's exactly the point of the article: OS X wouldn't be where it is without Linux (read: GNU/Linux), not because it was technically the best Unix (it wasn't), but because it was free software.
- simonh 10y agoYou do know that OS X was just a rebranding of NeXTSTEP which dates back to 1985 and so had all those things (dev tool chain, userland, etc) 6 years before Linux started, right? How much did NeXTSTEP owe to Linux, say in 1990?
- vetinari 10y agoNexTSTEP didn't have a lot of stuff that OSX had. Samba comes to mind. Another are autofs, bash, curl, less, libxml2, libxslt, screen and countless others.
- JdeBP 10y agoscreen was posted to net.sources in March 1987, under the name BSD screen manager. It made it to comp.sources.unix in August 1987 (v10i095), and was BSD multi-screen manager. Linux did not exist at the time.
- simonh 10y agoSamba, bash, screen and autofs all predate Linux and most of the rest were either initially developed on others unixes or at least at a time when Linux was far away from its current dominance. The idea that modern OSX relies in any material way on Linux is simply obviously false to anyone with a basic understanding of the history of UNIX. Linux succeeded due to its compatibility with this rich ecosystem of software, not the other way around.
- stormbrew 10y agoAlso most of the early adopters of osx that I knew at the time were actively seeking out a unixy desktop because they worked on software eventually destined for Linux servers and didn't like the available desktop options for Linux. Not to say that was the entire market, but it was a good chunk of it.
- ethbro 10y agoThis is a critical point. There are probably people on this board who were born after Ubuntu/Linux desktop UX received attention. For reference, older Linux desktop options were... well, I'll just say they played a lot like Dwarf Fortress.
- vetinari 10y agoIn the beginning (10.0 - 10.2 timeframe), OSX was pretty much broken if you wanted to work on software that was destined for Linux. Even the existing software was PITA to get running on OSX, you were fighting both autotools and OSX linker and libraries at once.
- fit2rule 10y agoNot strictly true, it was quite possible to write code on OSX that could be run on Solaris and Linux easily enough. You just had to not depend on autotools too much, and understand how to use the OSX linker/libraries properly in your project. (Disclaimer: I am one of those programmers who only switched to Apple because of the tiBook, which was a damned sexy Unix workstation in spite of the fact it was also a damned sexy laptop.. and I used it for developing apps for Linux and SGI Irix without much hassle.)
- MustardTiger 10y agoNone of that thrived because of linux. And OSX didn't depend on them at all, it simply provided some of them. OSX would still exist without bash.
- dTal 10y agoIf we assume that the author is following the usual convention of referring to GNU/Linux as simply "Linux", I don't think it's unfair to say that OSX draws heavily from the free software ecosystem. Take a look in /usr/bin on an OSX machine and it's pretty much the free software kitchen sink. Emacs AND Vim even. The only reason Unix is popular for a workstation at all nowadays is because Linux runs everything.
- gaius 10y ago...apart from workstations...
- simonh 10y agoIf he meant GNU why didn't he say so? Linux has nothing to do with OSX, whether you call it Linus or GNU/Linux. > The only reason Unix is popular for a workstation at all nowadays is because Linux runs everything. And at a stroke the entire history of Sun, Solaris and Sun OS is brushed under the carpet as though it never existed. Yes. I give up. You win. Workstations only exist because of Linux. I think I need a little lie down.
- rpdillon 10y ago> If he meant GNU why didn't he say so? Because people think it's cool to just call it Linux and endlessly deride Stallman for insisting it be called GNU/Linux, even though the nuance is very important in discussions like this one.
- kahnpro 10y agoFor starters, it doesn't sound idiotic to say "Linux" in conversation
- wtbob 10y ago> And at a stroke the entire history of Sun, Solaris and Sun OS is brushed under the carpet as though it never existed. I don't think Sun is responsible for Apple's choice of a Unix. I was around in the late 90s, and Linux really was an amazing workstation — far more so than a Sun, because the value for money ratio was incredibly good. I also remember when OS X first came out (and before that, mklinux), and the selling point was that it was a Unix, like Linux. I'd still rather have a Linux workstation than a Mac. Linux gets out of my way and lets me work. Solaris never did that (oh, the days of Solaris 'packages' …), and OS X still doesn't.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> And OSX now is by far the most popular workstation Unix. That's kind of cheating though. OS X is a "workstation OS" but it's also a "desktop OS" used by millions of elementary school teachers and news reporters. So then the "workstation OS" gets to claim those people as users, but their main competition in that market is Microsoft Windows, which OS X loses the popularity contest to in the same way that OS X (including iOS) loses to Linux (including Android).
- unethical_ban 10y agoWorkstation = desktop when comparing to server.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThat's what I'm saying. Apple don't have 90% of the workstation market if you include Windows PCs in the same market, but they also don't have 90% of the workstation market if you don't include Mac users who don't care anything about Unix because they only run Firefox and MS Office.
- MrTonyD 10y agoWell, since I worked on the team moving NeXTstep to the i386 family at NeXT, I can say with certainty that Linux played no role at all. We had copies of ATT UNIX and BSD UNIX which had portions already running on Intel (so we didn't have to completely reinvent the wheel.) There was some discussion about which UNIX we should be using on Intel in order to move it all to Mach - but the easy path was to build on some earlier work with the existing BSD port to i386 (in particular, memory management had been done in one of the ports, and using that as a starting point was very helpful.) As for GNU - we spent an incredible amount of time fixing bugs in both the C and C++ compilers. Really, GNU wasn't really considered "production worthy" before the NeXT project - and it was more of a toy until we fixed it. Steve was committed to using GNU to try to to compete with Apple based on low cost open source. As a programmer, it wasn't open source that helped us, - we were fixing and helping open source. I've always found it ironic that the open source community ignores the role of the rich and powerful in allowing them to succeed. (Ironically, I was later involved with the team at Oracle that converted Linux from a toy into a functioning kernel. It was missing many system calls and a lot of functionality. Speaking as a kernel engineer, Linux was almost useless. Larry decided to use Linux as a way to price compete against Microsoft - shouldn't be too surprising since Larry and Steve were good friends and shared ideas. I wrote the original white paper for Larry analyzing the state of the Linux kernel.)
- ktRolster 10y agoIronically, I was later involved with the team at Oracle that converted Linux from a toy into a functioning kernel. Seriously?
- k__ 10y agoso full of himself...
- kazinator 10y agoIn 1994 I did contract work for a serious businesses that ran commercial pay-for-click information website that ran fabulously on Linux, 1.2.x kernels. Since I first started using Linux in 1993 (0.99 patch level 12), it has always been a functioning kernel.