4 ms·
There is little doubt these bags are dangerous and pose a known threat to passenger safety. But to call these car bombs is irresponsible. They are not purpose
by mc32 10y ago
There is little doubt these bags are dangerous and pose a known threat to passenger safety. But to call these car bombs is irresponsible. They are not purposely armed with the intent to inflict damage to people. Yes, they have design flaws which have resulted in deadly injuries. But while technically these are explosives to aid in deploying the safety mechanism, they are not bombs as most people understand things.
This is as unjust as calling people who get arrested "disappeared" with all the connotations that word has (i.e. secret summary executions). This has the same approach, a bombastic approach to headline writing. For shame!
- mistermann 10y agoI didn't RTFA, did it happen to quote total recorded deployments of these bags vs noteworthy injury vs death?
- mc32 10y ago13/100+/60,000,000-100,000,000 is the known tally. Not sure about injuries or if such numbers could be reliable as it could be hard to trace source of injury conclusively (as there may be many parts in motion or contact during a collision induced deployment.
- paganel 10y agoWhen I read that they used ammonium nitrate first thing I thought about was: "That's bomb-material, how can you put that into a running vehicle?". One of the worst road-side accidents that happened in my country was this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mih%C4%83ile%C8%99ti_explosion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mih%C4%83ile%C8%99ti_explosion > The Mihăileşti explosion occurred on 24 May 2004 in the village of Mihăileşti, Buzău County, Romania. A truck loaded with ammonium nitrate rolled over and caught fire, and one hour later exploded killing at least 18 people and another 13 were wounded Notice the "one hour later" part. They are indeed ticking time bombs.
- digler999 10y ago> That's bomb-material how else do you suggest they produce enough gas within milliseconds to inflate two or more airbags ?
- amelius 10y agoReminds me of http://www.dhmo.org/facts.html http://www.dhmo.org/facts.html
- paganel 10y agoAs mentioned in the article, which I hope you have read: > But ammonium nitrate had a critical flaw that he says led other air bag makers to give up on it: Ammonium nitrate has five phases of varying density that make it hard to keep stable over time. A propellant made with ammonium nitrate would swell and shrink with temperature changes, and eventually the tablet would break down into powder. It seems like ammonium nitrate is more unstable compared to the other solutions (this is why it makes for good bomb material, see the Oklahoma terror attack or the Breivik terror attack in Norway), so it was a very bad decision to use it. But if you want to hit your straw-men then go ahead.
- zeveb 10y ago> It seems like ammonium nitrate is more unstable Bloomberg, I think, used the word 'stable' incorrectly in the excerpt. It's not unstable — i.e., it doesn't just go off without being ignited — it's unpredictable. I.e., what should be a relatively slow explosion instead is a very fast one, increasing pressure & thus brisance, leading to shrapnel.
- paganel 10y agoAs I understood from the article ammonium nitrate is way more unstable compared to the other solutions. Apart from the Oklahoma terror attack and the case I mentioned there is also this (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Norway_attacks#Breivik_Geofarm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2011_Norway_attacks#Breivik_Ge...): > The place of business was given as Åmot in Hedmark. On 4 May 2011 Breivik purchased six tonnes (13,000 lb) of fertilizer through Geofarm at Felleskjøpet, three tonnes (6,600 lb) of ammonium nitrate and three tonnes of calcium ammonium nitrate. According to neighbours, all the fertilizer was stored in his barn.[47] After conducting a reconstruction of the bomb with equivalent amount of fertilizer on the farm in Åmot, police and bomb experts concluded that the bomb had been 950 kilograms,[48] about the same size as the one used in the 2002 Bali bombings. All I'm saying is that they could have chosen another explosive-like material, not one which is known to be unstable and which has been used by terrorists to make bombs exactly for this reason.
- imglorp 10y agoThe implication here is corporate malfeasance which is exactly what was displayed. How many design reviews have you been present where an engineer said, “If we go forward with this, somebody will be killed” At that point, I'd lay my badge on the table and resign then and there.
- slededit 10y agoI think once they've degraded a bomb is apt. Not in the hollywood exploding car sense, but like a more realistic anti-personnel explosive complete with shrapnel. In most real bombs its the shrapnel that kills not the blast itself.