4 ms·
I feel fine about them, thanks for asking. I think it's reasonable to make a distinction between those and images of sexual crimes on the basis of protecting th
by simonh 10y ago
I feel fine about them, thanks for asking. I think it's reasonable to make a distinction between those and images of sexual crimes on the basis of protecting the victims depicted in illegal pornography. Reportage also serves a valuable informative social purpose which images of sex crimes do not serve.
- Dylan16807 10y agoWhat if the victims of the sex crime are dead (of natural causes)? How about non-reporters using murder footage for some dumb purpose like background footage to their halloween album? You can draw reasonable lines, but it's in a very different place from "depicts a crime yes/no".
- simonh 10y ago> What if the victims of the sex crime are dead (of natural causes)? Still ok to ban it. Clearly I am putting pornography in a different category from other forms of images and 'speech' but I'm comfortable doing so. > How about non-reporters using murder footage for some dumb purpose like background footage to their halloween album? Fine. > You can draw reasonable lines, but it's in a very different place from "depicts a crime yes/no". I agree. Depicting crimes isn't the problem, there's the issue of preventing incitement and blocking avenues for funding criminal activities. Pornography is so particularly and differently vulnerable to these abuses that I think special treatment under the law is reasonable.