3 ms·
It is a very good documentary on the subject. For me it really drove home the idea that current nuclear power comes with too expensive externalities in the form
by e12e 10y ago
It is a very good documentary on the subject. For me it really drove home the idea that current nuclear power comes with too expensive externalities in the form of "keep this stuff safe for 100 000 years". We've never come close to doing something like that as a species. I don't think we ever will.
- bcg1 10y agoKind of makes you wonder if its really such a good idea to smash atoms just to boil some water.
- santoshalper 10y agoWe already live in the orbit of a giant nuclear reactor that puts out so much energy that its waste energy can power our entire world for any foreseeable future. Why build our own?
- Turing_Machine 10y agoActually, after a couple of hundred years it's no more dangerous than the ore from which it came. No one worries about putting up signs around natural uranium ore bodies. Saying that "x has a long half-life" is exactly the same thing as saying "x is not very radioactive". By definition.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoExample: Uranium-238 is the most common isotope of natural uranium. It has a half-life of 4.468 billion years. By the "long half-life = ZOMG! DANGERRRRR!" standard it must be really, really bad, no? Nope. It's just not very radioactive. You can buy uranium ore on Amazon and even get free shipping (no hazmat or anything). Uranium was also used to color glass in the early 20th century. While it's not used for that purpose any more (and I probably would not routinely drink out of a uranium glass vessel), it's not considered hazardous. There's a lot of it for sale on eBay. The really dangerous stuff tends to have a short half-life (= intensely radioactive, again by definition) and an affinity for body tissues. For example, iodine-131 -- half-live 8 days, and gets absorbed by your thyroid gland, or strontium-90 -- half-life about 29 years, and gets absorbed into your bones (it mimics calcium). The people who convinced you that isotopes with long half-lives are somehow more dangerous? They either didn't know what they were talking about, or they were lying to you.
- e12e 10y agoPlutonium has a half-life of 24 000 years or so, I would still rather not drink it and certainly not breathe it in.
- rmccue 10y agoThe full report with the longer message (linked elsewhere in this thread; page 214 or F-125) explicitly notes that the 10,000 year point is when it matches the ore: > Radioactivity declines exponentially with time. By 10,000 years after the waste was buried here, the waste will be no more hazardous than the ore from which the radioactive material was taken [see 50 FR 38071a].