5 ms·
Tesla and Tucker – Similarities Between Automakers
- vvanders 10y agoGiven Musk's legal jujutsu w/ SpaceX and ULA I think Tesla is much less susceptible to similar issues. It's just anecdotal evidence but it seems like Telsa has plenty of momentum and real tangible products.
- technobabble 10y agoTesla has also delivered the Roadster,Model S, and Model X already. Worst case they will probably be scooped up by a competitor, though based on Musk's record that likely won't happen. From the armchair.
- rgbrenner 10y agoWorst case they will probably be scooped up by a competitor, though based on Musk's record that likely won't happen. What record is that? Musk has shown he's willing to sell his companies in the past. Between starting PayPal and selling to Ebay was only 3 years. He owns less than 30% of tesla. So if another company wants to take it over, he may not have a choice.
- boznz 10y agoMusk is a tangable asset to Tesla. A Hostile takeover would be a real bad idea IMHO
- djloche 10y agoI think he'd be open to a reverse talent takeover (in the same way that Pixar talent took control of Disney Animation when Disney bought Pixar). I could see Ford merging with Tesla in a few years after Elon isn't running the day to day and is just on the board of Tesla (and running space x) vs ceo of both
- tcoppi 10y agoI've seen a couple of people now suggest Ford as possibly taking over Tesla in a similar manner, and the more I think about it the more it makes sense. As soon as Tesla makes electric cars available in quantity with the Model 3, their best option for continuing to drive down prices and scale out to even lower cost segments is to pair up with an established automaker with the knowledge and history of building <$20k market cars. Tesla management could mostly take over, and Tesla could stay an upmarket badge while trickling down the technology to Ford-badged electric cars. It would really be pretty brilliant I think, and could dramatically shorten the time it takes for mass adoption of electric vehicles.
- j2bax 10y agoAny speculation on what Ford would pay for Tesla?
- djloche 10y agoIn terms of legacy strictly from an USA auto industry standpoint, I think Elon would find a Telsa led Ford appropriate. In terms of Elon's long term goals, I think a merger and revitalization of Ford would win him huge political points which he can then use for cutting through red tape for SpaceX.
- Grishnakh 10y agoIf they do that, they need to retire the old Ford logo finally and come up with something more upscale-looking. The logo is the worst thing about Ford cars; it looks goofy, compared to the badges seen on all the Japanese brands and on Teslas.
- adventured 10y agoGM and Ford are drastically less powerful today than they were in Tucker's time. By 1945-1950, GM was already the global leader in auto sales, and of course Ford had been a juggernaut for some time as well. That's the biggest difference. Toyota, Honda, BMW, Daimler, Volkswagen, Hyundai, Nissan, Mazda - the combination of those companies effectively neutered the old GM / Ford political monster. It sucked the money out of the old Detroit political machine, making it far less fearsome and influential in DC. The GM / Ford that Musk is facing off against, is a joke compared to what it used to be able to bring to the table in terms of abusing the system to stop competition.
- Shivetya 10y agoHowever as GM has proved that they can pivot quickly and bring a product to market faster than Tesla. They have the supplier relationships needed as well as the manufacturing and testing expertise to do so. They key is having management that wants to do it. I suspect Ford could as well but their leadership isn't as willing to change direction as GMs does.
- Grishnakh 10y agoPerhaps, but GM also has a worse reputation than Ford among buyers. Ford's reputation among the American brands is the best, while GM's is not that great, though Chrysler's is even worse. If I want to buy a reliable, high-quality car that I know is going to last 10 years and not have the interior plastics all looking nasty and faded and falling apart after a mere half-decade, GM is one of the last brands I'd think of. No one thinks that Cadillacs are serious competition to real luxury cars like Mercedes. I think Tesla would do much better partnering with a Japanese automaker. They know how to build high-quality cars in high volume, and they have great reputations too, which is important if you're trying to sell $100k cars.
- Grishnakh 10y agoI'll also add that if they have to partner with an American automaker, Ford is surely the best choice as long as they don't stick that ugly blue oval logo on their cars. Ford has a lot of experience partnering with other brands in mutually-beneficial relationships: they did it before with both Volvo and Mazda. In both cases, it seems like all 3 companies benefited from the arrangement.
- S_A_P 10y agoThe article is ok I guess. Although I think this is more a book plug than true analysis. I've often thought of the tesla/tucker parallel and how hard it is to get a foothold in a capital intensive business as a start up. However I don't think the parallels stick. Tesla has built and delivered a sizable number of cars. I think the political influence of the big 3 is much lower now as well. For tesla, I think that it's survival hinges upon delivering the model 3 on time and at high quality. Along with a lot of other things going right as well. I probably make about 50k too little to comfortably afford a model x but I would love to own one some day. Quirks and all.
- gutnor 10y ago> I think that it's survival hinges upon delivering the model 3 on time and at high quality ... and in sufficient quantities. They have proven the technology, the approach and the readiness of the market. The last thing they need to prove is their capacity to scale. If they achieve their target (i.e. Model 3 generally available in 2018), they will have built a serious lead over the competition - meaning several years (at least 2) on that sweet sweet market unchallenged. Of course, Tesla has failed to deliver in time, at expected price or in expected quantities before. Time will tell.
- S_A_P 10y agoAgree. This is the biggest risk. Right now I think they have enough cache that I would jump to electric for them where I may be too skeptical to buy an electric ford. Delivering high quantity with high quality on time will almost guarantee success.
- vatotemking 10y agoPublic perception is big factor too. In Tucker's time info is disseminated via radio. If the radio host is bias and hostile towards your business, then good luck. Now we have internet.
- Animats 10y agoThe law here is the FTC's "Mail Order Rule".[1] Properly, Tesla allows consumers to cancel your order at any time and receive a full refund. The other requirement is that if Tesla misses their ship date, they have to send the consumer a letter with a new ship date and an option to cancel. That part is "opt-out". If, 30 days after the original ship date, the product hasn't shipped, a refund has to be sent unless the customer explicitly requests otherwise. That part is "opt-in". The seller can't just keep the money at that point. This is why, if you're selling online, you have to make sure not to take orders you can't fill in time. In the early days of the Internet, this was a big problem, because many sites had online ordering systems that had no connection to inventory control. By now, everybody with a clue knows to check inventory in the shopping cart program. [1] https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/business-guide-ftcs-mail-internet-or-telephone-order https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/bus...
- rasz_pl 10y agoI seem to remember hearing in one of Computer History Museum interviews that in the early days of home computers it was actually illegal to sell Computer by mail :o !?
- pmarreck 10y ago"Tucker: A Man And His Dream" was a good movie. I too thought of the Musk parallel many times.