11 ms·
[Warning metric not used] I was reading this and trying to parse the economics. I mean 70k square feet is about two acres [@ 43560/acre] and at 75x efficiency
by brudgers 10y ago
[Warning metric not used]
I was reading this and trying to parse the economics. I mean 70k square feet is about two acres [@ 43560/acre] and at 75x efficiency per square foot it works out to about 150 acres of farmland. Lets call it a quarter section [160 acres]. Now a quarter section is the size farm my boy's Great Grandpa Fred farmed with his German speaking father and a mule in Kussuth County, Iowa the better part of 100 years ago. Enough land in a year with no major misfortune to support a family farm as a business but that today would perhaps need subscribed city folk and organic certification and a used tractor to be a gentleman's break even hobby.
At this point in the rant I was going to write, I was going to write about how little food two million pounds is and how it would never make a dent in the logistics of feeding people. And as I composed that part in my head, "two million pounds" seemed a queer [with no sexual connotation] way of marketing the output. And the whole thing made little sense economically...I mean even at Whole Foods, two million pounds of tomatoes might barely keep the lights on and the employee parking lot full.
I thought "What are they smoking?" And it looks to me like this is an effort to get out in front of marijuana legalization. Two million pounds at even a piddly $1000/per does make sense with the big bucks of the Big Apple's stoners spitting distance away. And since that is consistent with my heuristic that when someone looks like an idiot and they're not a teenager, then I'm probably the idiot if I assume that they are, so I figure that getting ready for growing weed is about the best sense of the venture I'm going to make.
- wcchandler 10y agoAgreed. Right now the only thing that's economically viable to grow with these setups is cannabis. But it does lay a good foundation for innovation and research.
- gozur88 10y agoI wonder. If cannabis is legalized presumably the price will fall and take out of the realm of economic viability.
- wcchandler 10y agoGood question. My estimates from ~6 months ago suggested I could sustain 90% drop in price and still be sustainable and profitable, albeit, less lucrative. ($2k/lb -> $200/lb)
- golergka 10y agoAll that matters is unit economics — if a single tomato takes significantly less money to grow in that farm than in an ordinary one, these "two million pounds" will turn into billions pretty soon.
- brudgers 10y agoMy gut is that tomatoes will never offer an acceptable IRR for a real-estate investor. Compared to dirt, it's capital intensive. The risk profile doesn't match that pool of capital either: real-estate investors tend to heavily weight track records and historical outcomes.
- adventured 10y agoThe best ROI for indoor farming, other than perhaps marijuana, is going to be almonds trees. That'll take some serious engineering effort, and it'll be worth billions of dollars to whomever figures it out. So much of the water directed at almond trees today is entirely wasted. Just being able to strictly control how much water each almond tree gets, and therefore dramatically reducing water waste, will justify indoor almond farming all by itself. We should be aggressively genetically altering almond trees to be smaller, while yielding near the same output, and requiring a lot less water.
- brudgers 10y agoI just want to point out that two million pounds of pot at $1000/per is already worth billions from a facility about the combined size of a CVS and Walgreens sharing a street corner.
- jongpieter 10y agoThe volume weight ratio of leafy greens, is much higher compared to tomatoes. Second the shelf life of leafy greens is lower compared to fruit crops. In respect to transportation costs, shelf life and transportation distance, it makes sense growing these crops near their distribution points. Second not to forget the benefit of CO2 reduction in urban area's, as there is less and less space for nature in urban areas. The only downside is the energy usage, this has been reduced using LED lighting, but is still compared to traditional greenhouse or open-field growing.
- brudgers 10y agoI don't disagree. Weed is the leafy green with the best potential returns.
- jwr 10y agoWell, but you could use solar power to supply power to those LEDs… oh, wait…
- reportingsjr 10y agoThis can theoretically be more efficient than growing plants under sunlight. Chlorophyll mostly absorbs light in the 400nm to 700nm band which is about half of all the photons that hit lights. Even in that band ~24%[1] of the energy in them in lost due to the higher energy photons (closer to the 400nm side) being converted to lower energy photons. So right there plants are only 25% efficient at collecting energy from photons. This is why you see indoor plants grown under red LEDs. Modern commercially available solar panels are about 21% efficient so that is actually getting close to plant can do (I'm not going to include inefficiencies in power conversion right now). Solar panels in the high 40% efficiency range exist, but they are crazy expensive and only used on things like satellites. So using current (very advanced) technology we could actually get about double the plant output per area land by using the most advanced solar panels we have to collect light energy to power LEDs. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Photosynthetic_efficiency
- 10y ago
- london888 10y agoThe much smaller one in London grows herbs for restaurants so weed isn't too far off. I would be concerned about security though having it in a big city - why not in the middle of nowhere, like a data centre?
- pavel_lishin 10y agoI would imagine that it's harder to pull of a bank-heist-equivalent in a city like Newark - with police, FBI, etc. nearby and usually on call - than out in the country where the nearest law enforcement might consist of a sleepy sheriff and a deputy.
- ortusdux 10y agoThe market will sort out if some configuration of this tech is profitable. For me, the real value in researching and developing systems like this is the non-terrestrial applications. Mars is the exact environment where maximising lbs of edible plant per cubic foot or gallon of water is most important.
- pdeuchler 10y agoThere are a bunch of (sometimes hydroponic) indoor greenhouses popping up all around Florida since the near miss in decriminalizing medical marijuana on the last ballot. They mostly just grow crap loads of lettuce and tomatoes (tomatoes and marijuana have extremely similar growing requirements and cycles) which they sell to "organic" places and literally throw away (or in some cases give away) the rest because at this point they're just working out the kinks in their production systems until the real money maker becomes legal. It really hit me when a friend of mine told me about a greenhouse that was experimenting with RFID to track its lettuce production and I thought that seemed like an awfully expensive way to track a product nobody cared about... If anyone is curious the way FL has gone about awarding licenses for potential marijuana growers has been a pretty drama filled saga and is a great example of corruption in today's society
- Agustus 10y agoThis. I was going to sign the petition and was perfectly happy until I read the fine print for who was going to get a license. The general public was not going to be able to commercially grow, only 22 (if I remember) growers were going to be able to sell it. No.
- Justsignedup 10y agoBut the missing point here is: The land used is actually TINY and vertical. The complete climate control means we can grow any food in any weather. No more growing in south america and shipping to new york. All of a sudden massive farming is possible in a few acres of greenhouses to support a major city. No need for machinery to plow the land or anything. Just fresh food grown literally locally to a city. No pesticides because there's no bugs. Great harvests year-round. So this has the potential to make completely sustainable farming anywhere in any climate with minimal need for water and soil.
- brudgers 10y agoI agree the footprint is tiny. But the amount of farmland is vast. At the equivalent of 150 acres it pencils out to about 5000 vertical farms to equal the farmland of New Jersey. 50,000 to equal the farmland of New York State and 850,000 to equal that of Texas. [1] For comparison, New York City has approximately 1,000,000 buildings and structures [2]. Just running back of envelope calculations using cropland instead of farmland: 20 million people in NYC Metropolitan Statistical Area [wikipedia] 324 million people in the US [wikipedia] 406 million acres of crop land in US [3] --------- 25 million acres of cropland for NYC MSA [per capita basis] That's about 165,000 high tech farms at 1:150 acres. At 70,000 square feet per farm it's 11.5 billion square feet. For comparison, there are 2 billion combined total square feet of office space in the major US markets[4]. Converting all of it to vertical farming would be equivalent to the per capita cropland for the NYC MSA if my calculation is high by more than 500% and if pastureland (another 30 million acre equivalents [3]) aren't part of the picture.[5] More locally converting all Manhattan's 500 million square feet of office space [4] to vertical farming could provide about 5% of the cropland equivalent for the New York City MSA. Or roughly half the 945,000,000 square feet of vertical farms to provide Manhattan's population of 1.6 million people with a per capita cropland equivalent. [1]: http://www.stuffaboutstates.com/agriculture/farm_by_total_acres.htm http://www.stuffaboutstates.com/agriculture/farm_by_total_ac... [2]: http://www.nyc.gov/html/sirr/downloads/pdf/final_report/Ch4_Buildings_FINAL_singles.pdf http://www.nyc.gov/html/sirr/downloads/pdf/final_report/Ch4_... [3]: http://www.ers.usda.gov/about-ers/strengthening-statistics-through-the-interagency-council-on-agricultural-rural-statistics/land-use-and-land-cover-estimates-for-the-united-states.aspx http://www.ers.usda.gov/about-ers/strengthening-statistics-t... [4]: http://www.colliers.com/-/media/files/marketresearch/unitedstates/2015-market-reports/2015-2q-na-office.pdf?la=en-us http://www.colliers.com/-/media/files/marketresearch/uniteds... [5]: For equity, cropland does include a lot of cotton even if it's not that much relative to pastureland. On the other hand, major food crops like corn and soy and citrus don't provide the same vertical density as leafy greens.
- rwhitman 10y agoThis article was an oversimplification of the story in terms of why there is a vertical farm in Newark, at least. If you google around a bit, the reason for building in Newark is simply that they needed a HQ with attached research facility within commutable proximity of the NYC talent market, and Newark made economic sense. The city of Newark is looking for green tech to move to the city, in the hopes of economic growth and luring other startups to Newark. So they were given a favorable deal to move onto a recently cleared brownfield site. It looks like their proximity to NYC consumers is just an added bonus. However, the company initially was focused on the manufacture of patented technology and was originally focused on developing these urban farms in order to sell the equipment. The only veggies that the work in this setup so far are leafy greens. So you're likely very right about what this tech is intended to grow... Some articles I found: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/08/realestate/commercial/in-newark-a-vertical-indoor-farm-helps-anchor-an-areas-revival.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/08/realestate/commercial/in-n... http://www.nj.com/essex/index.ssf/2015/03/30m_vertical_farm_to_bring_jobs_fresh_greens_to_ne.html http://www.nj.com/essex/index.ssf/2015/03/30m_vertical_farm_... http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-30/aerofarms-plans-aeroponic-farm-in-newark-to-grow-leafy-greens http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-10-30/aerofarms-... http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/08/05/429345848/green-pie-in-the-sky-vertical-farming-is-on-the-rise-in-newark http://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2015/08/05/429345848/gre... http://blogs.wsj.com/venturecapital/2015/12/10/aerofarms-raises-20-million-for-high-tech-urban-agriculture/ http://blogs.wsj.com/venturecapital/2015/12/10/aerofarms-rai...