9 ms·
Do Scientists Really Need Ph.D.s?
- marshallp 17y agoThe entire system of academia is horribly twisted mess of politics and inefficiency that creates competition at wrong the level (individual in their 20/30s rather than teams of people at whatever age). Who got human genome mapped in three months - a team from private industry (it took academia 15 years and boatloads of cash) Who got a car to autonomously drive through the desert - s team people motivated by a competition (academia hadn't managed to get it done before then) The current academic system of well connected 'star' PI's who are 'geniuses' directing around masses of lesser 'grads/postdocs' is a scale of snobbery not seen anywhere but show business and politics. It should be feel disgusting to anyone who sincerely values science and human progress.
- foldr 17y agoI don't really get the point of your examples. No doubt one could also point to cases where academic researchers discovered something that industry didn't. And businesses also tend to have a hierarchical organization.
- marshallp 17y agoBusinessman live or die by their skill at picking talent. Bureacrats who fund science live and die by their skill at picked themselves. I'd trust the businessmen to get the job done. Monetary competitions like the X prize would get you scientific discoveries faster and cheaper than the current system, simply because you would have a businessman driving progress rather than studious scientist-cum-team leader (PI).
- foldr 17y agoAcademics aren't particularly beuracratic in my experience -- most of them hate doing paperwork. In any case, your views on this are obviously based on considering what "ought" to happen given your stereotypes, rather than looking at the facts. A vast amount of research gets done in academia.
- akadien 17y agoNo, they need knowledge, creativity, and courage to ask "why?" and "why not?" A PhD is a firm credential for a job in academia that may or may not indicate that you have these qualities. It is neither necessary nor sufficient to becoming a scientist.
- scott_s 17y agoThe question isn't "Do people need the degree?" They're using PhD as a metonymy for the Western process of training researchers. What they're asking is "Is our current process of training researchers necessary?" The current process involves some breadth requirement (exposure to most of your field), and doing a starter-project (the dissertation).
- cool-RR 17y agoAnd willingness to spend years of their young adult life jumping through academia's hoops.
- cool-RR 17y agoAnd willingness to spend years of their young adult life jumping through academia's hoops.
- foldr 17y agoYou can make that sort of snarky comment about pretty much any career. There are always hoops to jump through (though you might not see them till you get there).
- akadien 17y agoThose two questions have the same answer. I have a PhD and my experience is that the process is broken because it's geared towards the wrong goals of (1) writing papers, (2) getting grants, and (3) the game of getting a tenure-track position and then tenure. If you happen to make a great discovery, that's nice, too. Most people I know get a PhD for career advancement, not to engage in the scientific and discovery process. My experience was that the process was more "cargo cult science" and less science.
- carbocation 17y agoMy favorite example is Mark Daly (of GWAS fame). He basically got a PhD for signaling purposes. He was already doing his excellent work beforehand, and got the PhD for the benefit of the institution (MIT/Broad). Or, at least, so goes the lore.
- yarapavan 17y agoNot exactly. Look at computer scientists like Chuck Thacker, Robin Milner, Simon Peyton Jones never had a PhD and they did first class work.
- wheels 17y agoThe prerequisite seems to only be about a century old in western academia. Michael Faraday, James Maxwell, Betrand Russel, et al didn't have PhDs. Faraday actually had no university at all. Edit: Ah, apparently doctorates weren't even broadly granted in the sciences until about a century ago: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_of_Philosophy#History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_of_Philosophy#History
- wynand 17y agoThe mathematician Stieltjes never completed a PhD, but was first rate. He was given an honorary doctorate so that he could apply for a chair at Groningen university.
- anamax 17y agoBob Floyd never even tried to get a PhD. (He did collect letters addressed to "Dr. Floyd".) Stanford made him a full professor even though he didn't spend "enough" time on the tenure track.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agocredentials are for grant oriented signaling.
- brg 17y agoThis comment has a bit of truth in it. Institutions look at grant money obtained before anything else when evaluating faculty. And without credentials, the NSF et al have little else to go on for a new researcher.
- mo34 17y agoThe correlation between individuals that have an extreme interest in a subject and those that obtain the highest degree in that subject is high. Yes there may be some outliers but when you are looking for these types of people it is best to see if they have the letters 'Ph.D' after their name.
- T_S_ 17y agoTo make this clear, you may as well ask if surgeons need to go to med school. It's required by regulation and tradition. Same with lawyers. It's more an indication of the maturity of the field than the ability of the person, although it hopefully represents a relevant hurdle. So if you can devise a quantum computer without a PhD then the lack of one won't hold you back.
- geebee 17y agoI don't think it's the same question - the function of a PhD for science researchers is very different from the MD/residency for surgeons, which is actually very different from the function of a JD and the Bar for lawyers (lawyers don't go through anything like the apprenticeship a surgeon goes through to become licensed, and a PhD generally doesn't provide a license to do anything). Also, keep in mind that many people believe that the Bar and AMA are actually large scale cartels that do more to harm the public than good. This isn't necessarily an argument that credentials and licensing are bad per se, it's an argument that the scarcity of services causes more damage than the dilution of talent (for instance, nurse practitioners might be able to provide a very high level of service in areas where MD's currently enjoy a monopoly). I'm one of the folks who are frustrated with the cartel-like behavior of professional associations in the US (and elsewhere), but there's obviously a wide range of opinions on the subject - some think they should be essentially abolished, others think they are fine in principle but need to be reigned in to ensure that "protecting the public" doesn't morph into "protecting the cartel." It's controversial, of course. But you might be interested in reading Milton Friedman's essay on the licensing of Medical professionals (just google for it, you'll find it quickly). Regardless of whether you agree with it, you'll probably find it interesting.
- arethuza 17y agoMedics, lawyers, accountants etc. are professionally qualified, a PhD is an academic qualification. They need to be licensed to do their job and if they aren't they can't do it. Not the same thing at all.
- foldr 17y agoIt's pretty similar in practice, though. A PhD is effectively a "license" to hold an academic position.
- papaf 17y agoI'm handing in my PhD thesis tomorrow so this is a well timed question :-) I have learnt a lot from my studies and feel that I have gained important skills in attacking problems and evaluating my solutions to them that will be useful inside and outside of academia. I couldn't have picked up these skills in the 15 years I spent in industry. There may be many examples of people who can do great science without a PhD but for me the experiences of the last 4 years would be essential if I were to get a job in academia. As it is, I will be going back to programming -- I feel the academic job market is overly competitive for somebody my age.
- johnohara 17y agoI'm listening to David Gilmour's "On An Island" right now. He didn't concern himself with pursuing a Ph.D in music before starting his career. But his body of work is extraordinary nevertheless and society has benefited tremendously. Asking questions and following the scientific method doesn't need anyone's permission either.
- jderick 17y agoIt really isn't a question of which system is better. It is about supply and demand. If there is a huge demand for scientists (as there appears to be at BGI today) then the requrements for getting a good job will be reduced. With the scarcity of decent jobs in US Academia today the prolonged PhD/Postdoc cycle is just a symptom of the underlying lack of demand.
- jessriedel 17y agoIt's not just a lack of demand for PI's, it's a strong demand for lab monkeys aka grad students, like yours truly. So long as (1) most research labs require many grad-student-level-trained hands for every professor-level-trained supervisor and (2) grad students continue to be deluded about their chance of securing a tenured position in the future, the situation will continue.
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoIt depends on the field. As far as I can tell, some undergraduate degrees are traditionally so watered down that most graduates simply haven't had the opportunity to become fit for research. (Chemistry, I'm looking at you.) Other programs do better. (Physics. EE. CS at the more hardcore schools.)
- jessriedel 17y agoI was a physics undergrad at a very hardcore school, and I can tell you that I wasn't even remotely close to being able to do physics research upon graduation. Even after taking two years of full-time grad classes, I considered myself (and my fellow student) somewhat unprepared to choose a research field, much less do independent research. Part of this stems from the fact that US undergrad degrees are much broader than in Europe. My understanding is that European undergrads specialize in a topic day one, whereas US undergrads take at most half of their college classes in their major.
- marshallp 17y agoIt's more that there is too much hand holding and babying of american students. European students (at the good universities) are expected to thoroughly and independently study for exams that will come two or more years later. American students are driven by weekly assignments and all sorts of midterms and quizzes. When it comes time to do independent research, the american student is thoroughly unprepared compared to the european.
- jessriedel 17y agoIn my experience (physics graduate student), American students and European students do not differ significantly based on work ethic, planning, or organization. Certainly, the variance within each group in those categories is much larger than the difference between those groups. The significant difference was that Europeans had completed more math and physics course before they had to choose an advisor and commit to a research topic.
- marshallp 17y ago
- DaniFong 17y agoFreeman Dyson on the topic: http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/freeman-dyson-on-invention-and-phds/ http://michaelnielsen.org/blog/freeman-dyson-on-invention-an... Brand: One of the things I got from Infinite in All Directions – it was a delight to me, and I’ve been quoting it ever since – is that you honor inventors as much as scientists. Dyson: It’s as great a part of the human adventure to invent things as to understand them. John Randall wasn’t a great scientist, but he was a great inventor. There’s been lots more like him, and it’s a shame they don’t get Nobel Prizes. Brand: Is it the scientists who are putting them down? Dyson: Yes. There is this snobbism among scientists, especially the academic types. Brand: Are there other kinds? Dyson: There are scientists in industry who are a bit more broad minded. The academics look down on them, too. Brand: Is that a weird British hangover? Dyson: It’s even worse in Germany. Intellectual snobbery is a worldwide disease. It certainly was very bad in China and probably held back development there by 2,000 years. Brand: How would you stop this intellectual snobbery? Dyson: I would abolish the PhD system. The PhD system is the real root of the evil of academic snobbery. People who have PhDs consider themselves a priesthood, and inventors generally don’t have PhDs.
- RK 17y agoI worked as an applied physicist / engineer at a smallish engineering company directly out of college, where about 50% of the employees had PhD's. When I decided to quit to get my PhD, the VP in charge of my boss gave me a 30 minute lecture about how a PhD would stifle my creativity and that some of the best people they had didn't have grad degrees. I was a little skeptical of that claim, as the only technical person I could think of without a graduate degree was that VP. He was very impressive, being both extremely intelligent and clearly someone who just absorbed technical material (he had two bookshelves full of grad-level math texts and seemed to know something useful on almost every topic). Looking back, I feel that I would be much more useful to that company after a few years of grad school, receiving a more thorough mathematical and physics background and experience leading my own research projects. Of course you could attribute some of that to just "experience", which I might have gotten just the same at that job.