8 ms·
Why you can’t get a ticket to the NBA finals or other major events
- pitt1980 10y agohttp://www.stubhub.com/nba-finals-tickets/grouping/145491/ http://www.stubhub.com/nba-finals-tickets/grouping/145491/ Seems like there are tickets to be had if you want them Not sure why I should be upset people can't get below market prices
- goshx 10y agoPoint is you should be able to purchase good tickets primarily and not from resale. Add to the conversation the outrageous fees charged for the tickets by Ticketmaster and the likes... it is pretty bad right now and it has to change.
- pbreit 10y agoFor the hottest event on the planet? And the fees actually aren't that outrageous when you're seeing the tickets being resold for 2-10x face.
- Dylan16807 10y agoThe hotness of the event does not change that when resellers make a profit, they do it without providing value to anyone.
- xivzgrev 10y agoThey do provide value to those people who buy their tickets. Like uber 10x surge they guarantee inventory during tight supply but you goina pay!!
- Dylan16807 10y agoThere is no value in having a middleman in that process. They actually make it harder for ticket buyer and ticket seller to meet, unlike your typical middleman. Uber is a perfect example of why no middleman is needed.
- pitt1980 10y agoI'm not actually sure that there's that big a markup over all the tickets sold Most of the big mark up tickets are bought from season ticket packages, which include plenty of dud games that can only be resold at a loss Averaged over all the games, whatever markup realize can probably be accounted for as taking risk of not selling tickets off the primary sellers (the teams) (especially the hard to sell games on Wednesdays in January when the team isn't the best team in the league)
- icebraining 10y agoThe idea of surge pricing is actually to convince more drivers to take rides, increasing the supply, unlike these resellers.
- tamana 10y agoThat's only half the idea. High prices induce ticket holders to sell, which does free up supply.
- goshx 10y agoYou do realize that when you see the ticket being resold for 2-10x face value it is already too late to even consider the fees, right?
- xivzgrev 10y agoone of his points was so many tickets go to people who dont care about seeing the event. If you threw fewer of those around and instead put them up for public sale there would be more inventory for fans (or at least for fan club). Also its one thing to stand in line and not get a ticket. Another thing entirely for scalpers to cut to the front of the line and buy everything up. You dont even have a chance (or much much less). People are angry about that too.
- zippergz 10y agoI'm upset that I have to go through StubHub, which exposes me to shady sellers (who I have zero means to vet - I can't even see who is selling which tickets). E.g. https://twitter.com/Jason/status/738489612075569152 https://twitter.com/Jason/status/738489612075569152 I'd much more happily pay market price directly on Ticketmaster than to some random seller on a secondary site. Edited to add: I know that StubHub "guarantees" the tickets. But the compensation is less than the hassle and disappointment of potentially missing out on an event I want to see. Especially if it comes in the form of getting to the door only to find out that the tickets are fake or duplicates (which does happen).
- jessaustin 10y agoISTM StubHub could end this practice by keeping ticket payments in escrow until a week after the event. Yeah that would be inconvenient for whoever has a ticket to sell (as TFA suggests this is kept deliberately vague), but it would be death for the fraud you describe.
- DrScump 10y agoFew sellers would list tickets for far-in-advance sale, then. The strategy seems to be to do huge volume and let fraud get lost in the noise. They fail to see the risk of high-volume, planned fraud of well-in-advance sales for pricey events that are guaranteed to happen (say, the Final Four or Indy 500): sell bogus tickets a month out, collect payment, close accounts behind you, profit.
- jessaustin 10y agoTFA indicates that these sellers aren't selling on a whim, but rather because that's part of the income they derive from services they provide to the music industry. Added inconvenience will annoy them, but it won't inspire them to leave this money on the table.
- FireBeyond 10y agoI wonder how many people who aren't in Twitter's "first name club", aren't SV elite, actually get more than a: "Sorry, your tickets were verified to be false. Here's a refund and $50 in credit for your next StubHub purchase." rather than "we reached out to the Warriers (because oh shit, you have more than a quarter million followers) and got you better tickets". Sorry, maybe that's the cynic in me...
- DrScump 10y agoOne irony is that you can't be sure their tickets are legit -- they do nothing to vet tickets for events they don't have official-marketplace status and control the ticket codes. They even accept edited PDFs. All the guarantee says is that if the tickets are no good, they can (their choice) either (a) give you different tickets that they call "as good or better" or (b) just refund your money, and you're SOL (too bad if you've already spent hundreds to thousands on travel and such). They will do (a) only if they have cheaper inventory (again, unvetted, so you face the entry-denial risk all over again) still available on the site. This strategy usually works, as 90+% of events experience price drops as the event nears.
- FireBeyond 10y agoIn some cases, those market prices, as alluded to in the article, might not be so high if anything more than _fifteen per cent_ were actually available to the general public.
- pbreit 10y agoFormer CEO of Ticketmaster (and the now defunct Twitter commerce group) so you gotta take him seriously. But the article is a little ridiculous. First, the converse is that very few events actually sell-out. Just the hit ones. Second, you've got a million Warriors fans from the bay area alone. Yes, it's going to be hard (but hardly impossible) to get 1 of the 20,000 tickets.
- uremog 10y agoI recall NPR did a story about how Kid Rock tries to fight scalpers. http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/06/27/196277836/kid-rock-takes-on-the-scalpers http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2013/06/27/196277836/kid-r... TLDR; The best seats are raffle-only. The next best seats are market priced, all other seats are dirt cheap. Reselling dirt cheap seats is discouraged by offering slightly more events than there is demand for. In other words, that strategy will have less (maybe even no) success for high-profile events which cannot offer more showings. Bots COULD still kill you, but if everyone who wants a seat can get one, bots will disappear because no one will buy them.
- danieltillett 10y agoI just suggested this from first principles :) Rather than raffle the best seats, sell a ticked that has an 50% chance of being a good seat and a 50% chance of being a dirt cheap seat and then decide on entry which seat you have. A true fan will be ok either way (they will of course be happier with a good seat), but the scalper won't be able to charge a premium for a good seat ticket.
- eridius 10y agoA true fan would probably be pissed off that some random person who's going on a lark gets awesome seats whereas the true fan is sitting in the worst area, despite paying the same price and despite the true fan probably buying their ticket first. Also, this system completely breaks down when you consider that people often go to venues in groups, which means they want to sit together, which means they need to buy their seats in a batch. If you don't know where you're actually sitting until you arrive, you won't end up sitting together.
- danieltillett 10y agoA true fan is probably pissed off already that some rich bastard is in the good seats that they couldn’t get. The idea is to give the true fan a chance of getting a good seat while breaking the economics of scalping. There is no reason the allocation has to be 50-50. It could be 90-10 where the tickets are basically sold a little over the cheap price, but you have a chance on the night of being in the front row. The true fan is going to dream that they will be the lucky ones. The group issue could be solved in a number of ways, but the simplest would be to just sell the tickets in blocks and allocate the blocks to the good or to the cheap seats. Somewhat related to this topic the best concert I ever went to was the OK Computer tour by Radiohead (in 1998 from memory). A couple of friends and I decided at the last moment to go to the venue and hope that we could get some tickets off a scalper. Just as we arrived Radiohead released about 50 extra seats at rock bottom prices (less than $30) via the main ticket office. We end up in the second row of what was one of the concerts of the decade :)
- danieltillett 10y agoI would have thought the solution would be to put the general public (true fans) allocation into a lottery that was drawn a limited time from the day of the show. If you wanted to be clever about it you could charge a small fee to enter the lottery that would in aggregate amount to the true market value of the tickets on offer.
- realdlee 10y agoYou could get Finals Game 1 tickets for less than face value in the days leading up to Game 1. Same for Game 2 to a lesser extent. This doesn't apply for every seat level, but it's definitely possible. The Warriors' solution seems to have been to set face value to be as high as possible since this year's finals tickets are notably higher than last year.
- DrScump 10y agoHeck, for Game 5 in last year's Finals, there were tickets in the Lower Bowl for < $200 and in Club for < $350 by game time. That turned out to be the last home game. Prices collapsed after the Game 3 loss.
- jessaustin 10y agoPrices collapsed after the Game 3 loss. That's surprising. They only lost by 5 on the road!
- DrScump 10y agoThe psychology seems to be: "since we can't see them win out this game, we'll save our money for a possible game 7". Same results for the World Series and NHL Finals. Resale prices for Game 3 in San Jose have dropped significantly. Resale prices for the 2012 NLCS Game 6 dropped a lot after the Giants fell behind 3 games to 1. etc. etc.
- FireBeyond 10y agoHehe... as soon as Blake went out on injury, you could get Clippers - Blazers tickets in LA in the playoffs for $17. LA fans are notoriously fickle, but still, I know several Blazers fans who took the opportunity to fly down and go to a game (albeit where they were in the vast minority).
- ams6110 10y agoIf you in any way sell tickets for less than the true market value, people will find a way to take advantage of that. The only solution is to sell the tickets at market value from the start. Then there is no profit to be made by resellers. Edit: Well there might be still some "market making" business in buying and selling, since inevitably there will be people who end up not being able to use the tickets they bought but don't want to stand outside the venue trying to sell them themselves. But the margins will be much smaller.
- dublinben 10y agoThat limited "market making" wouldn't even be necessary if refunds were allowed. By not allowing official refunds, patrons with unwanted tickets are forced to participate in the shady secondary market.
- skybrian 10y agoSeems like if they sell out, they should give refunds and resell to people on the waiting list.
- chongli 10y agoNo, that's not the only solution. The other solution is to make the tickets non-transferable. Require those at the gate to present their ticket along with a piece of photo ID matching the name on the ticket. Problem solved.
- CPLX 10y agoYes, this is what Louis CK does. And I was so pleased to go see him from the 15th row recently for $50 that I am going again in September. It's not logistically impossible by any stretch.
- wtbob 10y agoSo, in order for me to feel happy about the artist's keeping-it-real credentials I have to give up the freedom to resell my ticket? No thanks. Seats at performances are scarce resources. We have an efficient and fair mechanism for allocating scarce resources: the market. Raise ticket prices to the market-clear price and be done with it.
- powera 10y agoThe reason is because, for political reasons, large events can't charge the "market-efficient" price. Super Bowl tickets cost $850 to $1850 in face value, but resold for an average of about $5000. If tickets cost $5000 minimum the game probably would still sell out at some point (though not immediately), but people would be even more angry about the ticket situation. http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/03/news/super-bowl-tickets-price/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/02/03/news/super-bowl-tickets-pric... Blaming it on "insiders getting tickets first" and "bots" is just a way of hiding the fact that it's very deliberately designed to be the best way of handling things now, it's just that nobody likes scarcity.
- gohrt 10y agoSuper Bowl could charge $5000 for "box" seats (and put the entire lower deck and some of the upper deck in the "box", and earmark a stable of cheaper tickets for "must show ID" sales to fans selected by lottery or whatever.
- xivzgrev 10y ago"If artists are willing to boycott streaming music services to protect the 20 percent of their income that comes from recorded music, why wouldn’t they fix live music, where they make 80 percent of their income?" Because as you yourself pointed out, theyre maximizing income by taking guarantee pay days above face value of all tickets. And by performing fewer shows they drive up value per show. With streaming they actually think there is money left on table. Thus boycott temper tantrum to try to force spotify to cough up more money.
- floatrock 10y agoSomeone told me another trick not mentioned in this article [written by the former CEO of ticketmaster]. Can't find a citation, though, so take it with a grain of salt. It seems odd at first that certain ticket sites are the exclusive ticket dealers for some venues. It would seem that in a competitive market where you can spin up a whole fleet of machines to handle the public sale onslaught that used to be nothing short of a ddos against your ticketing site, there would be competition across ticket vendors and that would drive down those service fees. It's not a competitive market though. Ticket vendors realize the difference between face value and market value is uncaptured consumer surplus. To capture some of it away from the second-hand dealers, they vary the service fees for venue to venue and show to show. That's the expected part. The (admittedly I-don't-have-a-citation-for-it) interesting part is a portion of that service fee is a direct kickback to the venue. Some of it may be to cover the performer's higher-than-the-sum-of-face-value-tickets performance fee mentioned in the article, but some of it is to make sure The Venue deals exclusively with Large Ticket Site and ignores offers from small ticket.ly startup armed with some EC2 autoscaling groups. After all, why go for a more efficient operator when Large Ticket Site offers you a guaranteed percentage of the uncaptured consumer surplus? That's a service you would almost pay a fee for!
- hackuser 10y agoHmmm ... the former head of TicketMaster wants to, 1) Dramatically raise the price of tickets 2) Prevent their transferability, requiring all buyers to buy from TicketMaster (or the equivalent) 3) Incidentally track the identities of all ticket buyers and event attendees. It's for your own good, consumers.
- tptacek 10y agoTicketMaster owns the largest secondary market, so this conspiracy theory doesn't make much sense.
- hackuser 10y agoI disagree. Controlling transferability could give their 'official' secondary market more marketshare, denying other secondary markets access to the tickets (EDIT: e.g., the NFL, for example, controlling transfers, could allow transfers only through certain secondary markets and not others). Also, he's the former CEO, so his interests might not be entirely aligned with TicketMaster. Finally, perhaps you can find a more respectful way to address other people's ideas.
- tptacek 10y agoA non-transferable ticket can't be sold on any secondary market. That's what makes them non-transferable.
- 10y ago
- karzeem 10y agoThe efficient solution is to price tickets at the market price in the first place. Even if primary sales weren't dominated by resellers, "sign on at the exact moment tickets go on sale, and hope you're one of the lucky few who snag one" isn't a fair way of allocating tickets to the fans who want them most. But why set a price at all? Just auction off tickets in the first place. For popular events, don't set a price, just let the market decide. That gets tickets to the fans who value them the most, gives the venues/performers/athletes the money they should have been getting all along, and cuts out the resellers completely.
- DrScump 10y agoIt's still supply and demand, and by withdrawing supply, brokers will drive prices up further regardless. The solution is to go back to the old days: 1) have only live, in-person purchases at authorized retailers and list all sale locations clearly. 2) limit ticket quantities per-person and per-turn-in-line. 3) PDF ticketing must end. It is a HUGE vector for fraud. Not only does it make duplication easy, it makes outright counterfeiting via modification easy. 4) (when needed) earmark the seats with buyer information and restrict entry to the actual buyer (e.g. use the purchase credit card, or photo-ID if cash purchase) Now, brokers could still hire people to get in line, but there is insufficient payoff with a per-turn limit: the broker would end up with a lot of scattered pairs (assuming limit=2) of decreasing quality.
- StavrosK 10y agoHow does that system handle four-five people wanting to go see a concert together?
- DrScump 10y agoThey get in line together to purchase? Or, quantity limits per purchased are relaxed after the initial sale surge is complete.
- karzeem 10y agoCould you elaborate on what you mean by "withdrawing supply"? Are you worried that sellers will hold some tickets back from the auction, or that resellers will buy the tickets that go up for auction?
- dclowd9901 10y agoHere's a way to win: don't play. I see all the live music I want to see (and for cheap!) because I've expanded my horizons past the radio and pop fare. I guarantee you for every Kanye or Kendrick, there's a Chester Watson or Isaiah Rashad or Joey Bada$$ that will just as handily blow your mind. I get the sense that most people go to popular music acts to check in on Facebook. That's not a crowd you wanna fight for tickets. Support small artists.
- fma 10y agoAnd sporting events...the only ones I go to are tennis. I can walk around all day and watch many players...people come and go so you have a good chance of getting great seats if you wait long enough. I hate baseball, football games...you sit in one spot, probably in nosebleeds unless you have a lot of money. You watch one single game, pay out the nose for food. For those other sports I much prefer to watch at home where there are commentators, instant replay, friends and family, and eat and drink to my hearts content. Oh, don't need to fight the crowds!
- tamana 10y agoI don't want to go to 10 concerts of unknowns in hopes of finding one good one.
- erikb 10y agoOkay, so there are more seats than interested people. Someone _will_ end up pissed because they didn't get a seat. That's a given, or am I wrong? In that case you can't have a happy, fair solution. There is always a competition. That is how sharing too limited ressources works. Think about you and your brother sitting in front of the dinner table and there is one piece of the cheese left that you both love. Competition is fair! And honestly I like the competition about relationships, about money, about speed, and about smarts (=who writes the best bots). There are different options. If you are not good at relationships maybe you can find a way to earn more money, for instance. And none of the given options includes opening the head of a competitor with a broadsword, or barbequing him with a flamethrower. Sounds like a good and healthy competition to me.
- vlucas 10y agoWell this explains a lot. I recently bought NBA tickets to Game 3 of the Western Conference Finals (Oklahoma City Thunder vs. Golden State Warriors), and I was absolutely pissed off at the whole process. I went on a small Twitter rampage to vent about it, with a picture that shows NO TICKETS available LITERALLY THE SECOND they went "on sale" (10AM Thursday May 19, 2016), and then beside it another screenshot of ALMOST 1,300 TICKETS FOR RESALE at the exact same time. https://twitter.com/vlucas/status/733315798068953089 https://twitter.com/vlucas/status/733315798068953089 I learned the system was rigged against me the hard way, and it totally sucked. It was painfully obvious that all the tickets were sold out well before the game, and that a whole lot of scalpers were making lots of money on reselling tickets that were not fans, and never had any intention of going to the game in the first place. The kicker is that the system actually seemed designed intentionally for this to happen, screwing the actual fans in the process.
- fredophile 10y agoWhy not do a dutch auction? Tickets go on sale on day 1 at price $x. Every day the price drops until they reach price $y. If you have plenty of money and want the absolute best tickets then you can pay extra to buy earlier in the sales window. As long as $x is high enough, scalpers don't have an incentive to buy tickets because the market has already shown there aren't more buyers for tickets priced higher than the current value. If necessary you could stagger your sales so the cheap seats don't go on sale at all until the price for the expensive seats drops below some threshold.