33 ms·
Why Britain banned mobile apps for government agencies
- witty_username 10y agoTitle needs to be improved, replace Britain with Britain GDS, maybe add "and use websites instead" (but that might spoil the article).
- Joeboy 10y ago"Why the UK Government Digital Service chooses not to build mobile apps"
- jobu 10y agoAgreed. Terrible link-bait title, and the article is mediocre. Please change it to something like : "UK GDS bans apps in favor of responsive websites"
- xufi 10y agoI third that. The article doesnt provide much in the way of explaining it clearly enough.
- flurdy 10y agoYup GDS is not the British Government. And do not represent all of gov.uk. True they are responsible for the main chunks of the new gov.uk. But far from all of it. I should know, as Im involved with the development of a non-GDS part of gov.uk whom do also have some native apps... The use of responsive websites instead of native apps is a good rule though.
- retox 10y agoWhat a dumb title.
- Twirrim 10y agoTo be clear, it's why the British Government banned mobile apps for government agencies. Good article though. This actually goes back to Steve Job's original vision for the iPhone. He didn't intend there to ever be 3rd party apps for the phone, because he saw the internet as being the perfect platform for them.
- dang 10y agoOk, we'll use your phrase in the title above.
- RodericDay 10y ago> This actually goes back to Steve Job's original vision for the iPhone. He didn't intend there to ever be 3rd party apps for the phone, because he saw the internet as being the perfect platform for them. Do you have a link that lays this out in more detail?
- alexbock 10y agoThe most succinct quote from Jobs is: There’s no SDK that you need! You’ve got everything you need if you know how to write apps using the most modern web standards to write amazing apps for the iPhone today. The full quote and the video in which he said it can be found here: http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/21/jobs-original-vision-for-the-iphone-no-third-party-native-apps/ http://9to5mac.com/2011/10/21/jobs-original-vision-for-the-i...
- Marazan 10y agoAnd then you can hear the sucking void of silence of a response from the crowd and a few months later an sdk was out.
- dave2000 10y agoWell he changed his mind more often and quickly than you can say "magical thinking". Still, better to seem certain when speaking to investors, developers and other get-rich-quick types.
- kristianc 10y agoAs a Briton, the idea of having to access government services through mobile apps seems vaguely offensive. Apps are expensive to build, allow rampant surveillance that it's very hard to audit under the hood, and mean that customer information is distributed based on your ability to access a smartphone. The U.K. government also has a poor record of delivering large scale IT projects with complex chains of dependencies (the overhaul of the NHS IT system was cancelled after spending several billions on a Patient Information system that no one ever ended up using). Given the chance, departments would have tried to create the 'Everything App' at enormous expense and with zero interoperability between depts. The decision to push the GDS methodology across the whole of government was hugely unpopular within the civil service at the time but they've been absolutely vindicated in their approach.
- zepto 10y agoI agree with most of this except the 'allow rampant surveillance' and 'very hard to audit'. How are apps special in these regards?
- chipperyman573 10y agoIt is significantly harder to audit the security of an app than a webpage, because with a webpage all the code is visible to you, the end user.
- xapata 10y agoFor a very loose definition of "all the code"
- reitanqild 10y agoAll the client-side code then.
- dave2000 10y agoAnyone vaguely skilled can reverse engineer an android app. Modern versions of android (ie Android 6, which I appreciate only 0.0001% of android users actually have) let you control which permissions an app can use.
- iofj 10y ago> Key to the GDS’ approach is designing for user needs, not organizational requirements, Terrett says. “That is how good digital services designed and built these days. That is how everyone does it, whether that’s google or facebook or British Airways or whoever.” > The problem is that public sector agencies tend not to design with citizens in mind. “Things are just designed to suit the very silos that the project sits in, and the user gets lost in there,” Terrett adds. Amen. Unfortunately, it is very much not how everyone does it.
- csours 10y agoThe Iron Law of Bureaucracy: In any bureaucracy, the people devoted to the benefit of the bureaucracy itself always get in control and those dedicated to the goals the bureaucracy is supposed to accomplish have less and less influence, and sometimes are eliminated entirely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Iron_Law_of_Bureaucracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Iron_Law_of_Bu...
- k__ 10y agoI deeply believe this is the right way. The Web is THE open platform of the Internet and if you don't need special native functionality , always go for web.
- kome 10y agoTrue! Web must stay open, services that are limited to smartphone owners are just classist.
- pjc50 10y agoGDS have done a fantastic job of what you might call "government UX", by getting people with the right technical ethos in charge. HN would approve of their minimalist, functional, responsive approach. Letting govt agencies who don't know what they're doing go out and tender for private sector building of internet services would be a disaster; they'd be oversold six ways from Sunday. Treble the cost to build the same thing three times for the three mobile platforms? Sure. Given that 99% of the stuff is simple secure form-filling, it doesn't need to be more than a web page. I can file my taxes or renew my driving license online. The system works.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoFun fact: The US Digital Service works closely with the GDS to bring over proven strategies to the US government.
- verst 10y agoDon't forget 18F (part of the new technology transformation service). 18f.gov
- chrismealy 10y agoCan you link to some favorite examples?
- baxter001 10y agoThis is pretty representative: https://www.gov.uk/transformation/exemplars/apply-visa https://www.gov.uk/transformation/exemplars/apply-visa Very clean uncluttered forms with clear direction.
- robk 10y agoI just sold a car and it took 120 seconds to do the government transfer. Kudos to that. https://www.gov.uk/sold-bought-vehicle https://www.gov.uk/sold-bought-vehicle
- Faaak 10y ago
- djdelusional 10y agoIt's obvious that they never heard of Hybrid Apps, or just never found them to be secure enough for their applications.
- Kadin 10y agoI'm not sure why you'd use a hybrid app over a minimalist, mobile-friendly website, particularly for something like form-filling. As a user, getting me to install your app is a huge barrier. If I don't need to do something every day, I'm probably not going to download and install your app. So wrapping a webpage in an app seems like a really poor decision.
- ptaipale 10y agoAgree. I intensely dislike having to install an app for a task that could be done by a simple Web page. I don't know what the app does; the amount of flashlight applications that want to access my files, location and call information is depressing.
- valhalla 10y agoDoes anyone live in a city (within the US) that takes a similar approach to GDS? I live in SF and developers usually create their own apps for services (Like MUNI/BART) but the city seems to have a mix of good and bad UX when it comes to municipal services (from my experience, at least)
- kristianc 10y agoNot sure about at a municipal level, but USDS was based on GDS (https://www.usds.gov/ https://www.usds.gov/).
- zeristor 10y agoStrange how it doesn't credit GDS
- kristianc 10y agoIt doesn't, but more detail here> https://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2015/01/16/us-uk-digital-government-partnership https://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2015/01/16/us-uk-digital-gov...
- leobakerhytch 10y agoLink to https://data.gov.uk https://data.gov.uk on that page in fact points to ’file:///C:/Users/mcallister_mj2/AppData/Local/Microsoft/Windows/Temporary%20Internet%20Files/Content.Outlook/5P3C0P9L/data.gov.uk’ Oh dear.
- verst 10y ago18F is also based on GDS. 18f.gov Explanation of the difference between USDS and 18F: http://ben.balter.com/2015/04/22/the-difference-between-18f-and-usds/ http://ben.balter.com/2015/04/22/the-difference-between-18f-...
- intrasight 10y agoI live in Pittsburgh. I don't know if it is a "rule", but none of the municipal applications I've built are apps. As we show how much less expensive responsive web is to develop and maintain, it will only get harder for efficient and competent agencies to propose to build an app. Of course inefficient, corrupt agencies will probably still build apps.
- orf 10y agoI love that our government created GDS, they get a lot of flack but GDS has been an unmitigated success. They've got really great public performance dashboards[1] as well, you can see how many people are using 'gov.uk' right now[2]. Edit: It's a bit disconcerting 'Give up (renounce) British citizenship or nationality' is the top trending content! 1. https://www.gov.uk/performance https://www.gov.uk/performance 2. https://www.gov.uk/performance/site-activity https://www.gov.uk/performance/site-activity
- timthorn 10y agoI think the National Audit Office would disagree about GDS being an unmitigated success: http://www.computing.co.uk/ctg/news/2437392/defra-and-gds-slammed-for-ineffective-collaboration-for-gbp154m-cap-programme http://www.computing.co.uk/ctg/news/2437392/defra-and-gds-sl...
- Spooky23 10y agoWe'll see in a few years if it's an unmitigated success. When mid level bureaucrats are getting significant facetime in the media, you should be very wary. Civil servants are supposed to toil in obscurity -- they exist to glorify King and country. When you see exceptions to that, there's often a real shitshow behind the scenes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tangled_zans 10y agoWhat? Where do all of these conjectures come from? Is there any evidence?
- tn13 10y agoLet us take the whole thing with a pinch of salt as it is highly one sided story. Governments having their services on web is absolutely must but passing a decree against apps does seem a bit odd to me. Isn't it the case that more citizens own phones and have relatively poor connection speeds than other combinations ? Isn't it the case that citizens would be better served by apps that do one job right and do so more efficiently than web ? I can understand the cost part but it appears to me that the government agency has shut down a completely new avenue of innovation for government agencies with this decree.
- mmosta 10y agoGov of Canada has a similar initiative with an open source project titled 'Web Experience Toolkit' [0], focusing on usability and cross platform support. [0] https://wet-boew.github.io/v4.0-ci/index-en.html https://wet-boew.github.io/v4.0-ci/index-en.html
- dmix 10y ago> Most Ministers might want there to be sharing options on websites so that citizens can easily promote government on Facebook and Twitter. But the GDS tested this, and found that only 0.1% of citizens No shit. Every design job I've had ever.
- davewasthere 10y agoEvery client seems to request this... But sharing buttons are crap and always will be... So frustrating!
- tangled_zans 10y agoWhy do you think that sharing buttons are crap?
- flarg 10y agoMeh; for their usual scope of work they don't actually need apps (infrequent desktop use) so it's not a notable decision. Open Society do apps where they are actually needed (e.g. reporting potholes). Their decision to use Google as a home page and having all websites as plain as possible is horrific; with a lot of departments and agencies having lacklustre homepages that anyway aren't even aimed at the general public (e.g. arms-length-bodies). They also made a half-assed job of promoting Agile and UCD through the government, where Agile is now misunderstood and despised. Probably because they never really tried to understand civil service politics. Good ideas; badly executed.
- mark_l_watson 10y ago+1 for that decision: apps can also cause security issues. I only have a few apps installed on my cellphone. Web apps are fine for Twitter, Facebook, etc. Having to install a lot of apps to register to vote, etc. would be maximally irritating.
- gr25 10y agoThis is an encouraging trend. It's inevitable that, within or lifetimes, legislation and regulations will eventually be tailored to existing software, rather than expensive snowflake systems being produced to automate arbitrary processes created by the whims of legislators and civil servants in every jurisdiction in the world.
- known 10y agoSounds irrational :)