8 ms·
Welcome to Magenta – Google music AI project
- simplexion 10y agoI can't wait for the AI pop charts!
- my_username_is_ 10y agoHaving recently spent some time browsing the submissions of /r/deepdream and seeing how far computer generated imaging has come, I have no doubts that one day we will be listening to wonderful sounds that are generated by artificial intelligence. However an intrinsic part of the music (to me, anyways) as an art form, is the humanity of it. A computer can generate lyrics that are relatable on the surface, but knowing that there isn't a person behind those words, feeling what I'm feeling, definitely detracts from the experience of the whole. That being said, this is incredibly exciting to me, and I look forward to seeing how it progresses, and probably challenges my ideas of what music is
- ElHacker 10y ago> but knowing that there isn't a person behind those words, feeling what I'm feeling, definitely detracts from the experience of the whole. It would be very interesting to create a secret fake person profile and publish AI generated music under that fake name and see if humans feel identified with the lyrics and music. See how far it goes, who knows, maybe create the next super star. Then to later reveal the secret.
- SanderMak 10y agoYou should see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simone_(2002_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simone_(2002_film), sounds like you'll enjoy its premise.
- ElHacker 10y agoThanks for the suggestion. Will definitely see it.
- smashthesystems 10y agoThe 'Tunein' test
- thomasahle 10y ago> but knowing that there isn't a person behind those words, feeling what I'm feeling, definitely detracts from the experience of the whole. I recently had a discussion about this with a musician. I said that I didn't like when music was produced (and certainly lyrics written by) somebody else than the performer. I said it took away from the experience of 'getting to know' the person I was listening to. She basically replied, that I was being extremely old fashioned, and that this 'idea' of music was very harmful for the business. She said it prevented people from working together and each contributing what they did best. If she's right, I guess we just have to interpret the music on its own, and not see it as a mental state of some individual creator. Maybe this is related to, when authors are annoyed that people identify them with their main characters. In any case, non-individual art doesn't seem to be going away.
- Ntrails 10y agoI only really care whether the singer is able to convey the emotion behind the song. In reality I don't even know who writes a given song most of the time, only the performer. We can argue whether, for example, Adele is better at conveying emotion because she wrote the song. What we shouldn't do is claim that it's impossible for someone to do so if they didn't write the lyrics themselves. Now, once you abstract that, does it matter whether the original writer was human as long as they produce something a singer can then connect with emotionally and then project? I don't know. I feel like ignorance would be bliss.
- illumin8 10y agoThe way popular music is produced today, the artists performing almost never write their own music. Songs are shopped around by songwriter/producers to music labels, and label executives say "yes, that song properly portrays the slutty image we want to market for Miley Cyrus, we'll buy it." Then Miley performs it and we all cringe... It's sad, but this is the reality of the music industry today. It also means it's highly unlikely that a modern version of the Beatles would ever exist or become successful in the music industry. I guess Coldplay is probably the closest we will come (they certainly write all of their own music).
- dandelany 10y ago
- maroonblazer 10y agoI've not been following the AI-music-making scene in depth so maybe this has already been explored: Instead of (or in addition to) focusing on creating AI that can compose entire works, is anyone attempting to use AI to assist composers/musicians in getting over 'rough spots' in their own music. For example, I often write pieces of music where I can pinpoint very specific sections where the harmonic, melodic or rhythmic choices (separately or in any combination) sound trite or boring/predictable. I'd love to be able to feed the entire song into a machine, point out those specific trouble spots to it, and have it generate alternatives for just those sections, perhaps on a spectrum from 'not-too-far-from-the-rest-of-what-you've-written' (harmonically/melodically/rhythmically) on one end to 'way-out-there' on the other. Even if none of the output on its own was usable it would still have value in stimulating my imagination with ideas that otherwise wouldn't have occurred to me and that I could build on or refine.
- transpy 10y ago> However an intrinsic part of the music (to me, anyways) as an art form, is the humanity of it. I agree with the sentiment. But from a perceptual perspective, it's getting harder and harder to distinguish what is synthetic and what is organic. The trumpets, strings, and keys you hear on a song you like on the radio? It's very probable that they weren't played by humans: they might have been programmed and the sounds come from a massive, hyper sampled sound bank. If we did an experiment, and recruited even expert musicians, and we asked them to classify sound clips in 'played/programmed' categories, I bet they wouldn't get them right. David Cope's experiments showed that: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2010/jul/11/david-cope-computer-composer https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2010/jul/11/david-cop...
- stepvhen 10y agoI encourage you to listen to more music, particularly if "humanity" is intrinsic to the art of it. There is plenty of music made by humans that is rather un-humanlike. Noise, Drone, Chiptune, Glitch, Musique Concrete, Field Recordings, etc all explore the outer limits of music as an artform, and many have no more of a human element than somebody was there to create it (incidentally, most music in those genres doesn't often have lyrics).
- gglitch 10y agoGood point. An experimental algorithmic band called Autechre just released their 12th album this week, comprising over 4 hrs of music produced entirely by Max/MSP algorithms they've spent their entire careers learning to build and tweak. I think it's outstanding, many others will find it utterly unlistenable; but what's interesting is that they've dedicated their lives to making music that carries the flavor of malfunctioning machinery, while in the mean time, computers have been learning to make Muzak indistinguishable from pop nominally made by humans.
- moogly 10y agoWhat about "instrumental" music (I never liked that moniker, myself)? You don't listen to it?
- alimw 10y agoHumans probably have a monopoly on music-with-words for the foreseeable future...
- zer00eyz 10y agoThis is interesting, but it feels a lot like a moonshot, and it isn't even groundbreaking. The approach may be novel but folks have been trying this for a while http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2010/05/ill_be_bach.html http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2010/05/ill_be_... Can code generate a catchy pop tune? Im sure it can. Would I qualify it as music? Probably not. Music can pull from sources that are EXTERNAL to the music: Heres a modern track that does just such a thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvtNS6hbVy4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xvtNS6hbVy4 Music can have some very non traditional structure that most would qualify as "noise" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYaWND9n9h0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zYaWND9n9h0 Hell music can even be "silent" http://rosewhitemusic.com/piano/writings/silence-taught-john-cage/ http://rosewhitemusic.com/piano/writings/silence-taught-john... Ultimately, I think that it is possible for a machine to generate music, but were going to be talking about something that is more or less an AI at that point, after all music has a soul.
- jonknee 10y agoWhat about it sounds like a moonshot? It's using an existing Google open source project and is looking to use it for an artistic purpose along with building a community. Honestly it sounds like a 20% project from a couple of people on the TensorFlow project. Almost 0 cost.
- dharma1 10y agoPlus potential PR value for Google if something meaningful comes out, the press loves AI stories like this. It feels like the effort invested in AlphaGo was at least partially because of marketing, establishing Google as a leader in AI. This will also help attract young researchers to Tensorflow, so a low cost win for them.
- philhartmanonic 10y agoI don't know about that. The whole idea of "having a soul" is so nebulous that it's hard to build a view on top of it. Do we have souls? If yes, is it possible to mechanically replicate a soul? If not, why not? What's a soul? If instead you define art as the communication of things that can't be fully expressed by direct sterile language, that's something I can get behind. Going that route, I think that getting AI to create real art has some pretty clear challenges, but there are also ways whers I could see it being better than humans. Depending on how the AI learns and analyzes it has a chance to have a unique perspective on human communication. From there, it can find new and innovative ways of identifying gaps between primal human experiences and sterile human communication - and with a unique understanding of human communication could come up with fascinating ways of bridging those gaps. This is all spitballing, but I think AI could eventually be the main new frontier in art.
- zitterbewegung 10y agoIf AI generated music works out and becomes popular will people actually optimize for quality of music or instead you would have an Engineering team design the next Pop star which would be optimizing for Profitability and marketability.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- samfisher83 10y agoPop stars are already engineered. You have guys like stargate, dr. luke, etc.
- samfisher83 10y agoThey can just program the AI to use the 4 chords most pop songs already use? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QpB_40hYjXU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QpB_40hYjXU
- tunesmith 10y agoThere's music and then there's music. I'm glad they are at least thinking about long narrative structures. Ultimately I don't think this is a very worthwhile because I personally believe the entire definition of art and music is a production that is filtered through the human experience. The same piece of music would mean more to me coming from a human than from an AI or program. If someone told me it was from a human and then later told me it actually came from an AI, it wouldn't really accomplish anything deep; it'd just make me feel tricked.
- prawn 10y agoAt least leave us humans some of the joys in life - art being one of them. Automate the bland stuff so we have more time to idle away our days mucking around with an instrument or paints or clay.
- vintermann 10y agoWell, look at it this way: The AI is really not so different from us in intelligence (although presently dumber), but it's different in motivation. It's has only one single "desire", namely to understand you and write music that connects with you. It's not trying to fool you, it's trying to understand the human experience itself, and tell back to you what it is seeing. Isn't it OK to let ourselves be moved by its love letters to humanity? Every Monday, there are hundreds of tweets from Spotify users who declare that the Discover Weekly algorithm understands them better than anyone, that they want to marry it etc. (This is a remarkable testament to neural network AIs. Not many people want to marry Netflix or Amazon's recommender system, to put it like that!) Of course that only finds music for you, it doesn't create it from scratch. But given the immense size of the library it searches through, that's impressive enough that many really get the feeling that it knows you, understands you. I hope generative algorithms will be that good one day, and I won't waste time worrying that it's fake once they are.
- cdubzzz 10y agoThat's an interesting thought. I have no idea how complicated this is, but I wonder if a Spotify or Pandora has a chance to some day develop something that can _generate_ music tuned specifically to the listening habits of individual users.
- shams93 10y agoThe problem is the reliance on midi but it shouldnt be hard to build a credible house music generator even with midi byt relying in midi music data for training wont get you something that sounds like a jimi hendrix. But doing automated dance music makes sense.
- fizx 10y agoTo be honest, learning waveforms for interesting tone or timbre sounds a hell of a lot easier than composing a symphony.
- zamalek 10y ago> But doing automated dance music makes sense. This has been done with LSTM[1][2]. Impressively, the NN is generating waveforms and not MIDI notes - at around 3:50 it even attempts some singing. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VTI1BBLydE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0VTI1BBLydE [2]: https://github.com/MattVitelli/GRUV https://github.com/MattVitelli/GRUV
- illumin8 10y agoVery cool! I actually think Jazz improvisation would not be very hard to do: One of the things you realize if you study jazz improvisation deeply, is that it isn't that random. Someone like Charlie Parker learned over 100 interesting riffs or patterns, then learned to play them in any key (transposing as necessary), and when improvising, transposes each into the chord the band is currently playing, and arranges them in a unique and interesting order. Indeed, this is why many great Jazz musicians learn to improvise by transcribing solos of Charlie Parker, John Coltrane, etc, and learning their riffs in every possible key. Transposing is one of the best possible ways to learn to improvise, because it teaches you to listen and hear notes, as well as the patterns/riffs that everyone copies from each other. There is even a great book called "Patterns for Jazz" that captures many of the most powerful riffs used by these musicians. The really interesting thing about this is while most of the listening public assumes jazz is pure improvisation, much of it is copied riffs just rearranged in unique and interesting ways. I don't mean to detract from it; jazz is still a great musical style, but like all styles results from derivatives of previous works. edit: grammar
- julianpye 10y agoKeyboards have been popping out automatic C-maj, A-min, F-maj, G-maj progressions for fourty years now. And with the typical toolset for electronic music, it will be easily capable to create something similar. But the masterpieces of music demand something altogether different. Beethoven's break with consistency by switching keys in the adagio of the 5th piano concerto. Wagner introducing the Tristan chord, Berg using C-major only as a joke in Lulu, when the word money is mentioned. Add to that ingenuity the personal drama behind music. Bach's crisis of faith leading to 'What God does is well done' to Mahler losing so many of his children that he composed the Kindertotenlieder ("Songs on the Death of Children") to the origins of a simple pop song such as 'Tears in heaven' that moves people tremendously... Music is shaped by our biological life cycle, not by that of a computer program.
- anilgulecha 10y agoNot to take away from your point, but none of the above stop an AI from replicating that behavior. It's just a matter of the state-of-the-art catching up.
- hellofunk 10y agoCatching up to past innovations is a different matter from actually innovating fresh ideas. Personally I think AI is so far away from doing anything on a human-like scale that none of us will ever be alive (or our grandchildren) to be fooled by such advances.
- reqctomaniac 10y agoThats a very narrow definition. Music is sound we interpret. There is no reason why computers cannot "compose" meaningful to us music. Of course it will probably be by happenchance, but nonetheless. Also computers are good at finding patterns. There is definitely a chance they (I should write "it" but cant reformulate so it sounds good) can find patterns interesting to us.
- aclissold 10y agoRegarding Kindertotenlieder, he didn't actually lose any children until after he wrote it. Quoth Wikipedia [0]: “I placed myself in the situation that a child of mine had died. When I really lost my daughter, I could not have written these songs any more.” [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kindertotenlieder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kindertotenlieder
- ashleyblackmore 10y agoPeople want and need other people around, doing human things. Even if the musical output was impressive, I can't think of people developing a deep relationship with it outside of novelty. Algorithms are cold, and music is usually very much the opposite - I can see an "uncanny valley" effect cropping up with the imitative forms: people hearing something that is supposed to come across as laden with emotion, instead leads people to revulsion. What do we get out of computers composing songs that are supposed to relate to the fragility of the human condition? Sure, the algorithms, once sufficiently advanced, could probably trick us into thinking that certain examples of generative music were made by a person and then later reveal its algorithmic origin to prove that "the humans are stupid" and "the google algorithms are clever" but what are we actually proving here? Can a computer devise new artistic forms that have some genuine impact on people - can a computer come up with Bacon's Triptych of George Dyer outside of regurgitating fragments of what it already has seen? What do we get out of a computer aping the alcohol-fuelled sweaty anarchic performances of The Black Lips? The interesting stuff will be to see if this goes to other places that music has not yet gone - some new composition method - manipulation of frequency in ways that humans have not yet devised.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alive2007 10y agoI see this sort of application having a lot of use in the kinds of derivative pop music developed by ensembles of songwriters and manufactured purely to generate radio hits. Bacon's Triptych of George Dyer is genius. The average person listening to Taylor Swift just does not care about Bacon's Triptych of George Dyer. In a way, Magenta's job is not besting Bach. By the definition of Bach (a human being who changes the way we view and enjoy music), a non-human being cannot best Bach. Magenta's job is besting a much simpler, if equally challenging role - Max Martin, or the writers of "Let it Go". As it turns out, this kind of music is already pretty formulaic. Much has been written on repetitive chord progressions being spammed across hundreds of famous singles. In a way, artists shouldn't fear the potential of these technologies besting them - they should thank them. Freed now are artists from loading their albums with eye-rollingly generic lead singles that they immediately get sick of ("Stairway to Heaven", "Creep", "Smells Like Teen Spirit") because record labels know that's what will get the most radio play. You can just let the machine do those. Now, an artists' reputation is determined purely by his relative mettle against other human artists.
- larme 10y agoIf their view of music is a sequence of notes (in midi) then the product won't be very interesting. In a lot of modern music genre sound design is as important as composing the note sequence.
- wslh 10y agoNow I see the scifi story: a disruptive future where culture is created by computers so Google doesn't need to pay any creator in YouTube.
- Razengan 10y agoAI celebrities with distinctive personalities will be fun. I can't wait to see a real-life (as it were) Hatsune Miku making her own content. EDIT: And then the inevitable schism among fans about what their base personalities should have been like, and the resulting clones, throwing the AIs into an existential crisis when confronted with their alternative versions..
- kuschku 10y agoThis sounds like a trademark lawsuit waiting to happen. T-Mobile holds the trademarks for T-anything, Magenta, the color Magenta, etc for not just communication and networking, but also music etc.
- annalewiss 10y agoEvaluating the output of generative models is deceivingly difficult.
- hyperbovine 10y agoQuantitatively evaluating them, yes. Qualitatively, they all tend to suck ;-) For art and music anyways.
- vthallam 10y agoIf Google does it, they can as well sneak in some of these to Play Music play lists, see the response on no of replays and stuff and gauge the overall quality and likability. Basically crowd source the reviews.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoStrange, the article doesn't link to the output: https://cdn2.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/6577761/Google_-_Magenta_music_sample.0.mp3 https://cdn2.vox-cdn.com/uploads/chorus_asset/file/6577761/G... I had a listen yesterday. It's okay. Nothing revolutionary. Competent though.
- maroonblazer 10y agoSounds like something you'd hear as a soundtrack to an ad for a computing device.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoYeah it's not too far off from what a generally smart music algorithm would crank out. I get that it's a different approach though. I think it's funny they added drums to make it a bit more listenable, because otherwise I think people would generally tune out after about 1/3 of the tune because it's okay but not really engaging.
- meggar 10y agoFor the generation part, it might be a good idea to separate "music" into its parts (like bass, drums, melody, chord-rhythm, chord-ambient-background, and other stuff like secondary melodies, horn section arrangements or whatever). A unique model for each one of those could learn differently. Each of those parts could be broken down even further too.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- ssalazar 10y agoThe more interesting application of this IMO is not replacing current popular/practicing musicians and artists but enabling non-professionals who have some musical inclination but limited time/skill/etc. Imagine a synthesizer for dance music with knobs for high level parameters like "grimy-ness" or "shine." Rather than auto generate a complete song with no user input, semantic control could be offered using learned models, allowing a rewarding experience with musical creativity without having to spend a lot of time learning the technical intricacies of these semantics.
- 6stringmerc 10y agoMany of the tools you describe are already out in the field. Ableton Live and MAX4LIVE really opens up whole new sectors of tools for those who might be interested. There is a learning curve for music making software though, and it can be rather steep. That said, Instant Haus [1] does sort of what you describe, though it is targeted more for practicing musicians. I'm a fan of GarageBand's "Drummer" as well. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoIcewM8sKY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoIcewM8sKY
- danvoell 10y agoI thought that music and art would be what we were doing when there were no jobs left, hopefully nobody creates an AI bot that travels for us :)
- aaronwidd 10y agoWhat this will change probably isn't pop music, it's soundtracks for TV commercials, video games, shows, movies etc. Currently to put music in something you need to license it somehow, in most cases the generic music you hear in most media is sourced from a company that has a library of royalty free songs that they sell for a pretty hefty license fee. Imagine being able to instead go into some software and punch in some keywords to describe the scene, the duration, track what happens in the scene on a timeline of some sort and let the computer render original music for the score. No middle men, no musicians, no royalties or licenses other than for the software. It would change the industry overnight.. and make being a professional musician even less promising of a career choice than it is today...
- shams93 10y agoThat's a really good point, there's a market opportunity for a soundtrack generator that does a decent job of producing usable generic music for video productions.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoThere is and yamaha (?) owns one, but I can't find it right now. It was like band in a box, but even better.
- aaronwidd 10y agoWell, I just googled around and found my idea is not super unique.. already found 2 teams working on it: https://www.jukedeck.com https://www.jukedeck.com http://juke-bot.com/ http://juke-bot.com/
- Shebanator 10y agoAnd porn.