2 ms·
While most of what you say is generally consistent with mainstream science (including my copy of Cancer by Weinberg, AKA, "the bible"), it neither refutes my po
by dekhn 10y ago
While most of what you say is generally consistent with mainstream science (including my copy of Cancer by Weinberg, AKA, "the bible"), it neither refutes my point, nor provides any support for the parent poster's claim.
Also, "DNA-repair proteins pre-date the evolution of multicellular organisms, so they cannot possibly have evolved as a response to cancer." is not a valid argument. There are eukaryotic DNA repair proteins not found in bacteria, for which evolutionary evidence shows they evolved more recently. A number of such genes aren't just DNA repair, but cell cycle controllers that respond to DNA damage and coordinate complex activity. Whether they are "sole purpose of preventing cancer", is a very deep question, and goes to the heart of the nature of cancer. For example, naked mole rats either never or very rarely get cancer; current thinking is that hyaluronase they produce has a protective effect. Did the genes that make enzymes that produce hyaluronase evolve "specifically to prevent cancer", or did they play other roles and just incidentally provide cancer protection? Those are challenging hypotheses to express and prove either way.
I'm sure you're familiar with the Hallmarks of Cancer.