4 ms·
Stupid/insensitive question: what if cancer were a species "feature" earned through evolution that helps reap people who made it through their reproductive year
by wyldfire 10y ago
Stupid/insensitive question: what if cancer were a species "feature" earned through evolution that helps reap people who made it through their reproductive years without accident or disease but are now more hindrance than help to the species?
- mgraczyk 10y agoMost animals can get cancer, even invertebrates. Not to say your hypothesis isn't close to reasonable, but you'd have to strike the "species" part.
- gww 10y agoI would argue that cancer is more of a consequence of aging, genetics, and environmental factors and not a "feature". Cells have evolved multiple mechanisms to prevent rampant and uncontrolled growth. With cancer these mechanisms are perturbed through genetic alterations due to "bad luck" or the consequences I mentioned previously.
- RosenJD4 10y agoYou can also think of cancer as a consequence of multicellularity. Multicellular organisms need checks on how often and by how much a group of their cells can multiply. A liver must contain a specific amount of liver cells, and cancer occurs when these cells are able to continually divide and eventually activate non liver specific genes. The cells of a multicellular organism become highly altruistic because each cell of the organism gives up its ability to reproduce in order to provide a chance for the organism's gametes to produce a new living organism. So wyldfire's original comment on Cancer being a 'feature' is not necessarily incorrect, however the explanation is. Cancer occurs when the contract that states that the Liver cells, who cannot reproduce, become able to continually divide without checks and balances. You can also almost think of Cancer as Cellular natural selection and evolution within the body. Cancer is a feature and consequence of multicellularity and likely not adaptive in any way such as sickle cell anemia and malaria resistance. An awesome book which touches on this in addition to other history or cancer is The Emperor of all Maladies http://www.amazon.com/Emperor-All-Maladies-Biography-Cancer/dp/1439170916/188-8725093-6146822?ie=UTF8&*Version*=1&*entries*=0 http://www.amazon.com/Emperor-All-Maladies-Biography-Cancer/...
- Houshalter 10y agoBecause evolution doesn't work on a species level, it works on a gene level. Genes that help propagate themselves spread more. A cancer causing gene would almost certainly be selected against, vs a gene that caused you to live longer and have more children - and spread more copies of itself. The reason people die is not because it's better for evolution. It's because evolution simply doesn't care about maximizing life expectancy. Most organisms die long before they get cancer, so the fitness of a gene that prevents cancer is pretty small.
- dekhn 10y agoI take issue with your first statement- evolution certainly works at the species level (in the sense that population genetics is a thing). It does appear there is a population fitness that is selected for when two desirable phenotypes can't be accomodated in a single individual. Also, "Most organisms die long before they get cancer, so the fitness of a gene that prevents cancer is pretty small." ignores the fact that there are genes preventing cancer (tumor suppressors), and those genes are under active selection.
- rcthompson 10y agoThe term "tumor suppressor" doesn't necessarily mean that the gene exists for the sole purpose of preventing cancer. It just means that the protein's normal function happens to prevent cells from becoming cancerous. Many DNA-repair proteins fall into this category, for example, simply because repairing errors in a cell's DNA reduces the probability of that cell accumulating cancer-causing mutations. And yet, DNA-repair proteins pre-date the evolution of multicellular organisms, so they cannot possibly have evolved as a response to cancer. In practice, the term "tumor suppressor" generally means a gene for which recessive loss of function mutations are associated with cancer (i.e. you have to lose function of both copies of the gene in the same cell before there's an effect), while "oncogene" means a gene for which dominant gain of function mutations are associated with cancer (i.e. mutation in one copy of the gene is sufficient to have an effect). Neither term implies anything about how the gene evolved or whether selection due to cancer was a factor in the evolution of the gene.
- tehrei 10y agoThen we bring back gladiatorial combats and require all people over 90 and in good physical condition to participate. I'd rather die on the arena in combat, than waste away in a hospital bed. More seriously, I rather doubt the entire world would reach immortality-from-aging once we manage to slightly improve cancer care. If it turns out to be a species-killer, the most advanced societies will die out first and the ones picking up the pieces will learn from their(our) mistakes.
- cloudjacker 10y agoyou could argue that, most evolution conclusions are based on visible outcomes and the assumption it has utility, rather than actually proving it has more utility over a failed line of evolution that researchers will never see I would like to point out that many mammals have more genetic safe guards than humans do against cancer cells, so my conclusion is that humans have a flaw
- rcthompson 10y agoThe fact that every cancer is different and arises due to the accumulation of random mutations is strong evidence that it is the result of dysregulation, not a regulated process. If it was adaptive to have an age-limiting "kill switch", there are much more direct ways to achieve that. (e.g.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo#Mass_flowering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bamboo#Mass_flowering)