21 ms·
Los Angeles Tries to Prove That It Doesn’t Necessarily Need the Car
- swampthinker 10y agoFunny, the joke used to be that there was nothing to do in downtown LA. Guess that's slowly starting to change.
- bcoates 10y agoIt's not just a change of perception -- in the last decade downtown LA has really blown up.
- josephpmay 10y agoDowntown LA, including the Arts District, is excellent now. Plenty of restaurants, shops, bars, museums, etc.
- exclusiv 10y agoI agree but they need to get a handle on the tent cities and homelessness if they want more people to care and visit more than once in a blue moon.
- josephpmay 10y agoMeh. You get used to the homeless after awhile. They're more noticeable in SF
- exclusiv 10y agoYeah I'm not a fan of SF mostly because of it. If I wouldn't want my wife to walk around by herself, then it's a no go for me.
- mturmon 10y agoFull of the stereotypical things the NY media likes to print about LA. Hollywood openings? Check. Advice to New Yorkers headed to LA? Check. Comparisons of any LA phenomenon with NY analog? Check. Lacking perspective on the city as a whole, beyond Hollywood, downtown, and the west side? Check. Sigh. Yet, some truisms sprinkled among the retreads. Author's about page: A New Yorker at heart (and by area code), I’m currently based in Los Angeles.
- cpncrunch 10y agoWell, in fairness it is the "New Yorker". Looking at the current LA Metro map (http://media.metro.net/riding_metro/maps/images/system_map_2016-0520.pdf http://media.metro.net/riding_metro/maps/images/system_map_2...), rail service is still pretty sparse.
- _delirium 10y agoMost transit users in L.A. take the bus rather than rail, and there's a lot denser bus network. Weekday ridership numbers are about 1m for Metro Bus, 300k for Metro Rail (subway / light rail), and 40k for Metrolink (commuter rail).
- mturmon 10y agoYes, you are right, rail service is (still) sparse in LA -- despite the new lines. But that's not my point. My point is: Why do I have to read anecdotes about New Yorkers transplanting to LA when I'm reading an article supposedly about the new LA Metro line? It's lazy on the part of the author.
- dalke 10y agoIt's the New Yorker. They write for their audience, which is people who read a magazine which famously had "View of the World from 9th Avenue" on their front cover in 1976. Quoting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_of_the_World_from_9th_Avenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/View_of_the_World_from_9th_Ave... > "The work is sometimes referred to as A Parochial New Yorker's View of the World or A New Yorker's View of the World because it depicts a map of the world as seen by self-absorbed New Yorkers." They have a market of potentially millions of potential readers who are interested in the parochial New York world view. Why produce articles for a more general national or international market where there is more competition and less ability to distinguish oneself?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- bcoates 10y agoIn defense of the LA train system, most of the rolling stock on the Expo line are nice new trains, and Hollywood to Santa Monica via Downtown is almost the most pathological route between major destinations you can take in terms of car vs train. I've been taking the Expo lately and it's already standing-only crowded during rush hour and heavily used off-peak.
- tslug 10y agoYa, it's pretty amazing as far as how quickly it gets you from downtown to Santa Monica, and I experienced the same thing. It's already in heavy use. One complaint, tho, is that the cars don't have decent accommodations for bicyclists, which is really annoying. You basically have to stand/sit w/ your bike all the way. Also, you still mostly take it in the bum on travel time in the transfers and many bald-spots of decent coverage. I found that to get from Santa Monica to Silverlake, for example, was more convenient on the 704 bus, because there's a spot for your bike, you can sit and work on your computer the whole way, and it's a closer fit for minimizing your talking time/distance, and it's a more direct route. The train alternative is to find and descend into a red line station, transfer through the greater depths of Union station to the expo line, and then babysit your bicycle all the way to Santa Monica, which is the bulk of the transit time. Gotta give Santa Monica props tho for the treatment they gave that Santa Monica train station and the surrounding area. I really like it. Overall, nice stopgap improvement, and when the world improves and human-driven cars are outlawed, it could be paved over and made a thoroughfare that allows only self-driving electric cars to use it, and they could tap into the electric mains for a recharge along the way. :)
- cylinder 10y agoLast mile cycling (folding bikes perhaps) infrastructure plus trains seems like the best bet for LA.
- honkhonkpants 10y agoBike share at the metro stops and on both sides of the light rail lines would make a lot of sense as a last-mile solution.
- parshimers 10y agoThe new trains and stuff are nice. Some of the other aspects of this "Mobility Plan" are really annoying. The main one I dislike is how some already incredibly busy streets have had a whole lane sliced out for a bike lane. It's usually empty, and not that safe, because of people turning right across it. I get that everyone having a car in LA is not a way to allow greater density, but, it's reality for now and making everyone in that reality suffer isn't a great way to get re-elected. More light rail lines, awesome, making driving a car more miserable than it is, not so much.
- stanmancan 10y agoNot sure how many people bike there, but if they make driving even worse, and people notice an empty bike lane, maybe it will encourage them to try hoping on a bike instead, whenever possible?
- vitd 10y agoQuite a few people bike here in my anecdotal experience. However, LA suffers from the same problems as SF. Certain areas are becoming impossible to afford, so if you work in or near those areas you have to live very far out and commute a distance that's not realistically bikeable. (And also some people have disabilities that make biking unrealistic.) People in my office are commuting from over 30 miles away. In fact, some are commuting from Orange County up to LA's west side.
- Tiktaalik 10y agoPretty much with bike lanes it's a "build it and they'll come" situation. If you don't have protected bike lanes and biking is unsafe, you don't get a lot of cyclists. The bike lanes may look empty now, but you have to build some degree of a complete network for the whole thing to work and for bicycling to become an appealing alternative to driving a car. Looking at it another way, how many people would drive from A to B if the road narrowed to a single lane and became a pothole filled dirt road? It probably wouldn't be an appealing commute.
- 10y ago
- addicted 10y agoThere was the recent article about how ridership has risen, which signaled great public transport stuff in the US. Digging only slightly deeper, it was evident that if you took the massive rise in NYC public transportation out, public transportation in the rest of the US, including LA, actually dropped, despite the money being spent on it. The reason while not established, appears to be because instead of making existing systems more reliable, and better connected, the money has been spent on vanity projects. An isolated light rail here, and a Park and Ride which doesn't connect to anything there.
- vitd 10y agoI work just down the street from the Santa Monica station. It literally opened a week ago or so, and the author's complaining that people getting on downtown don't yet know which line to take. Well duh! It's brand new! As for the complaints of old trains and scuffed up seats - the train isn't new. I've ridden it downtown occasionally for the last 3 years or so. What's new is the part from Culver City to Santa Monica. It didn't used to go out that far. It's like the author didn't bother to check the actual facts or history of the project. This was a stupid article.
- ryan_j_naughton 10y agoI totally agree. I too live in Santa Monica near the downtown station. I took the train on the first day and everyone in my group was commenting "I can't believe there is graffiti already!! Hooligans" them we remembered that the trains have been running from downtown to Culver city for years and this is just a line extension.
- sandover 10y agoThe rail stuff is a bit of a sideshow -- I think in a decade or so the outline of transportation in LA will begin to take shape around 2 modes: 1. 2 wheeled vehicles driven/ridden/pedaled by a person 2. ridesharing cars, shuttles, & vans driven by a computer
- amyjess 10y agoAs a carless person who's considering moving to SoCal -- specifically the San Gabriel Valley -- in about a year or so (only because upcoming legislation next spring is likely to force me out of Texas), articles like these are much appreciated. I've been thinking a lot about how I'm going to get around if I move there. I'm used to public transportation not being super awesome (I'd call the public transit where I live half-decent, emphasis on half, and I get around fine), and worst comes to worst I can take Lyft or Uber everywhere, but more transit is always good, and I'd like to know what I'm getting into if I move. So thanks for posting this.
- warriormonk5 10y agoI wouldn't live in the valley and be carless.
- ikawe 10y agoThe new gold line extension gets pretty close! Try to get within walking distance if you can.
- mturmon 10y agoYes. The Gold Line extension is going to have a huge impact on the SGV. I don't live in the SGV, but the impact of the Gold Line on the Chinatown-Highland Park-Pasadena corridor [which it reached years ago, before the recently-completed extension] has been very significant, including lots of denser housing within Pasadena and sharp increases in house prices along Figueroa parallel to the Gold Line. I expect the extension to have an even greater impact over time.
- tehabe 10y agoI think you have to start somewhere. Since you can't build an extensive light rail/subway network over night. So, I hope Los Angeles will continue to extend it.
- erispoe 10y agoIn California, tax measures like the bond measures supporting transit investment have to be passed with a 2/3rd majority. Yet Los Angeles County voters have steadily supported them. A ballot measure is likely coming in November, raising $120B for transportation. It includes highway funding, but it's a massive contribution to transit investment. Angelenos are massively in favor of transit investment. Now their motive can be ambiguous, maybe they just want other people off the streets to alleviate their traffic. But still, they support massive investments.
- mayneack 10y agoThey're slowly making progress towards the purple line extension from Korea Town west as well. Won a lawsuit against Beverly Hills trying to block it in 2015 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purple_Line_Extension https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Purple_Line_Extension
- tehabe 10y agoBut when I read that taxi companies and parking lot owners prevented the Green line from reaching the LAX airport, I'm like: wow. This is really a weird world, in which we live.
- mayneack 10y agoUber ran a promo recently when the expo line opened to discount uber pool to or from a station. Uber/Lyft has already beaten the taxis opposition to picking up at LAX. They don't seem to think of these transit options as threat like the taxis do. Maybe more public transit enables more people to ditch personal cars and increase both public transit and uber. I know that my Uber use has increased after moving to more bike commuting.
- staticelf 10y agoUS, you guys really need to get your public transportation in order // Rest of the developed world
- angmarsbane 10y agoI love the extension of the metro line. I use it to commute from culver to Santa Monica.