8 ms·
The Immutability of Math and How Almost Everything Else Will Pass
- positivity89 10y agoTrue - you can't go too far in programming without math.
- jordanlev 10y agoI very much disagree. I suppose it depends on how exactly you define "far"... but I've been a professional programmer for 15 years now, and have very little math skills (maybe some algebra? mostly forgotten by now, and calculus always escaped me). As a web developer, most of my skill have to do with designing user interfaces and API's, learning various libraries/languages/frameworks, defining problems, estimating, communicating with other humans, etc.
- prof_hobart 10y agoWithout basic maths, sure. But I've had a 30 year career in software development (covering everything from low level comms software in the 80s through to workflow automation software today) and I never got further than A level maths - which for non-Brits, is the exams you typically do at around 18. I don't feel the lack of a university maths background has ever particularly held me back.
- coldtea 10y agoQueue in the "but I've done decades of CRUD apps/websites without math".
- yxhuvud 10y ago"But is downplaying the importance of math a sustainable message for future generations of engineers?" No, but most programming is definitely not engineering. Math savvy people will definitely be needed - more in some areas than in others, but it is silly to have something most people don't have use for in their daily work as a requirement. The point being is that there is a need for people with engineering skills, but there is also a need for people with craftman skills. Perhaps what we are seeing is the early stages of different education paths to the different roles? As for the different points: "Number theory. If you’re ever asked how one algorithm or data structure performs over another" Err, no. That would be courses in analysis, calculus or numerical calculation courses, or courses in discrete analysis if you can find one. Number theory is what you use to understand stuff like encryption. (Also, the popups was very annoying on the page)
- pjdorrell 10y agoYeah, items 1, 3, 8, 9 and 10 are somewhat nonsensical (3 might need geometry, but it would be more about physics).
- js8 10y ago> The point being is that there is a need for people with engineering skills, but there is also a need for people with craftman skills. I disagree. We don't need people with craftman skills, or better to say, we shouldn't need. Because once you can define what is craft, then computer can be programmed to do it. At work, I still code in (mainframe) assembler sometimes. It's a craft, but it has been largely replaced by compilers. Where it cannot be replaced by compiler (which is definitely not the case of my job), it becomes engineering.
- varjag 10y agoPotentially all of the programming can be, and most likely will be replaced by machines, so it's a moot point. Until then, there are tons of programming jobs that are poor fit for automation but are definitely thin on engineering challenges.
- js8 10y agoIt really depends on what you consider to be engineering. Traditionally, engineering was creation of a "blueprint". Once you had that, someone had to actually build the thing in the real world (the craftsmen). But in software? The blueprint is the final product! Of course there is messiness that was mostly introduced by people, which makes lot of engineering rather trivial, and you can call it a craft if you stretch it. But that's mostly an artifact of doing things wrong.
- varjag 10y agoI would argue with waterfall model (naïve translation of engineering to software) being out of favor for decades now, almost nobody actually makes "blueprints" for software. Agile, XP and TDD is basically "put something together and make sure it doesn't fall apart when we ship it". Now what actually requires engineering is a whole another perspective. I'd argue most software development jobs are closer to "renovate the kitchen" than "calculate building wind load" type of work. Also remarkably in construction, the latter task turned out to be much easier to automate.
- ToddPackerNews 10y agoIs CS a subfield of math or is math a subfield of CS? The graph in this article seems to indicate the latter, but i'm pretty sure that's not right. and how is AI a subfield
- imron 10y agoI did pretty well in math, both in high-school and in university, (Comp Sci degree, with Math a compulsory first-year subject), and when I try looking at a paper describing an algorithm in some Comp Sci related field it's literally all greek to me. I end up spending large amounts of time figuring out the meaning of all the various symbols in the paper and how I can map that to an actual computer program. Thankfully I have enough Math in the back of my mind to work through it, but good luck getting in to the really interesting things (e.g. machine learning, 3d graphics, whatever) without having a good mathematical background. Without it, you'll lose first hand access to almost any paper written on the topic.
- douche 10y agoIs the problem there the actual math, or the obscure, arcane notation that's used to describe it? Combine that with the frequently terrible and all-too-often incomplete source code that's provided as a reference implementation...
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoIt's not arcane notation, it's content-aware compression at work. When a mathematician sees a small greek delta with subscripts ij, they immediately know it's the Kronecker delta. If every paper would explain every convention and notation in the field, all papers would be huge and much less readable for those working in the field.
- nimesh159 10y agoAgree. The term ‘computer’ itself comes from the word ‘compute’ as computer is built primarily to help human compute numbers. Many interesting real life problems can be modeled as mathematics problem - Halim & Halim, 2011
- Animats 10y agoI have all the wrong math. I got discrete math in CS - number theory, formal logic, and combinatorics. Now you need more real-number math - probability, statistics, and matrix algebra.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoMy best advice is to take the fun math, whatever that may be. If a class is fun, you learn it properly, so you will be much more able to adapt the concepts and strategies to other problem domains. So apart from the mandatory calculus, statistics and linear algebra, as an engineer I took functional analysis, operator algebras, group theory, and intro to hilbert spaces.
- slevvio88 10y agoMath is really all the same anyway.
- majewsky 10y agoApparently I'm in a good position with a double major in physics and CS.
- bbcbasic 10y agoIn response to the dead comment "Is CS a subfield of math or is math a subfield of CS?" This is quite an interesting question because I watched a Robert Harper lecture where he argues the latter. In a nutshell proofs can be mathematical objects and in particular they can be seen as programs.
- Qwertious 10y agoSounds a bit like 'declarative vs imperative'.
- agumonkey 10y agoWhen you use information to deduce information about information, you're doing both I guess. Abstract math was elusive to me in college because it was folding over itself, there was no concrete object layer as before. Anything could be reflected about. Sets of applications from sets of applications to sets of sets. After looking at lots of CS ideas I kinda recognize this too. You encode relationships between anything and deduce new relationships.
- marcosdumay 10y agoBoth. CS and Math are equivalent. You can both represent all math expressions in the form of computer programs (what makes programming a superset of doing Math), and can represent all programs as mathematical expressions (what makes doing Math a superset of programming).
- js8 10y agoThere is other big connection between math and programming, which article completely ignores - functional programming (from the mathematical side it corresponds to various lambda calculi). Interestingly, lambda calculus is a different language (syntactically) for mathematics than classical logic, so the connection is not obvious. I think programming will eventually become more mathematical, due to this connection.
- noelwelsh 10y agoNo idea why this is downvoted. If you are a functional programmer you can lean on maths all day, and get wonderful correctness guarantees for your programs. The maths is typically very simple algebra, but it's there.
- eric_bullington 10y ago> functional programming (from the mathematical side it corresponds to various lambda calculi) And category theory, in the case of Haskell. (and yes, to work with Haskell at a basic level, category theory isn't required. But as someone who is learning the basics of category theory, it sure helps understand the "why" behind a lot of things if you move to a more advanced level.)
- arghbleargh 10y agoAs someone who has done a fair bit of both math and programming, I will agree that having some math knowledge has definitely helped at various times when programming, but I don't think these specific instances (e.g. the 10 examples given in the article) constitute the primary reason it's a good idea to learn math. For the purposes of handling those specific situations, I think you would do fine to just learn the math as you encounter the need for it (and 95+% of the time you don't need anything beyond high school). To me, the primary value of math for programming is that it is a pure form of exercising many of the skills that help you write good code. For example: - fluency in logical reasoning - turning vague intuitions into precise statements (translating business requirements into code) - formalizing proofs (covering all cases, establishing invariants) - developing abstractions to succinctly describe relationships - solving a problem systematically You can also learn these skills by programming, of course, but probably not as quickly, because you will be distracted with other tasks such as debugging, setting up your dev environment, waiting for your program to run, etc. So in my opinion, what's important is not so much the immutability of the math itself, but rather the process of doing the math. I would be interested to know if others have had similar experiences.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoThis comment sums up my own thinking better than I could have. Though if the pure functional approach gains more ground, the link between maths will become more direct -- writing a Haskell program feels a lot like writing a formal proof of an algorithm. And all proofs are maths. That said: this might be a reason to teach less maths in schools. If someone can invent a good informatics curriculum for children, then it's OK if it eats into class time for maths, because the (hypothetical good) IT subject will teach them some of the most skills underpinning maths.
- noelwelsh 10y agoAgree 100%. The strong connections between FP and maths make the programming in an FP language very much like doing maths. Usually very simple maths, but that's a good thing. You might like the Bootstrap curriculum: http://www.bootstrapworld.org/ http://www.bootstrapworld.org/ It's developed by the PLT research group behind Racket and How to Design Programs. Very good stuff.
- guard-of-terra 10y ago"you’d be hard pressed to find probability or number theory" When I was interviewing we were always asking basic probability and combinatorics questions. They should probably only talk for themself.
- RossBencina 10y agoMath is good and can be useful. I went back to school after 15 years to study math (currently studying for a Complex Analysis final.) If people are interested, I would encourage them to study math, whether or not they think they are "good at math." However, I disagree with most of this article. Take this breathless assertion for example: > "[S]oftware development is quickly shapeshifting. If you discount mathematics, and in turn focus on learning transitory programming tools, you’ll be left without the skills necessary to adapt to emerging computer science concepts that have already started infiltrating engineering teams today. Without expanding mathematical knowledge, these software engineers are going to risk being left out of the most exciting, creative engineering jobs of the rapidly approaching future." i.e. If you don't know math, in the future you'll miss out! Not really. Adaption is a key skill of developers. Developers will adapt to whatever the future of software development brings. (And if not, there's plenty of maintenance to do!) Mathematical ideas only "infiltrate" software engineering to the degree that software engineering can accept them. It's a continuous process. Sooner or later, software engineering either absorbs a mathematical idea (e.g. relational algebra) or the idea passes out of fashion. On the other hand, it has always been true that mathematics is part of many of "the most exciting, creative engineering jobs," for example: programming the Apollo guidance computer, implementing systems to predict the weather, designing the Page Rank algorithm, programming self-driving cars, simulating music synthesizers, or designing physics simulations for games. So yeah, math is one of the places where the fun stuff is at, but you're not going to lose your job without it. On the other hand, knowing CS fundamentals will probably help you adapt better than knowing CSS and some JavaScript. > "We’re far beyond the point of needing engineers to code simple solutions." I don't think so. The bulk of software development work is in integrating 3rd party components, refining user interfaces and marshaling data between communication and storage formats/APIs. From a coding point of view, this is relatively simple stuff -- but doing it at scale, at speed, with quality and finesse still takes great skill, care, and time. We're not "far beyond" this. > "[A]re we all really still going to be coding web and mobile apps 10 years from now?" Maybe not web and mobile, but there will be an equivalent. One thing is certain, we're not all going to be coding machine-learning predictive data analytics engines from scratch. That is specialized work. If it's important enough to become mainstream, it will become componentised and commodified. Yes, there will always be companies developing the industry-leading "AAA games engine" or equivalent, but this is by no means the only way to participate in the market. A final point: Software that is built on specialised knowledge (e.g. mathematical models, but it could also be physical, biological, psychological or other domain-specific models) often needs to be wrapped in a lot of non-specialised infrastructure in order to make it function as a product. There will always be roles for domain-specialists with software development chops, and these will be well-paid, fun jobs worthy of aspiration, but there will also be plenty of work for people who specialise in software (e.g. infrastructure, UI, networking, operating systems). [edited to fix typo]
- arvinsim 10y ago> In the next 10 years, software engineers aren’t still going to be limited to programming web and mobile apps. They’ll be working on writing mainstream computer vision and virtual reality apps, working with interesting cryptographic algorithms for security and building amazing self-learning products using machine learning. You can’t go very far in any of these fields without a solid mathematical foundation. This is what scared and convinced me to relearn Mathematics. I hated it when I took it up before but I realized that the coolest jobs requires it. However, after a few months of self-learning, I discovered that the hard part is not learning the concepts. It is structuring your learning in such a way that you can retain what you learned after a few weeks. It has been a challenged for me to do. Learning new higher level concepts exposed my gaps in learning the fundamentals.
- mrkgnao 10y ago> Number theory. If you’re ever asked how one algorithm or data structure performs over another, you’ll need a solid grasp of number theory to make that analysis. Um, what? I mean, apart from some fancy/hypothetical cache aligning nonsense, I have no idea how this makes sense. Maybe someone can explain?
- crispyambulance 10y agoTsk, tsk, The author isn't going to make friends of mathematicians by declaring MATH as a subfield of CS in a diagram that looks like an org chart (because it's from a Forbes article? :-)) I was once righteously scolded after saying that logic was "merely" the physics of information. I learned a lesson. We all can do better with more cross-pollination of different fields of study and less categorization.
- CPLX 10y agoThis is more than slightly tangential, but that article led me by two steps to the Wikipedia article on OCaml based prop trading shop Jane Street Capital, which contained this very odd paragraph: "A number of people involved with the effective altruism movement have recommended Jane Street Capital as a place to work at for people considering earning to give, and some of the full-time employees as well as interns have been from the effective altruist community.[7][8][9][10][11] In September 2012, Tim Reynolds, one of Jane Street's co-founders, stepped down from the job to redirect his energies towards the philanthropic pursuit of teaching poor students to master photorealistic painting.[12]"
- nitwit005 10y agoI took a number of math classes, but I've forgotten the overwhelming majority of it. It's hard to remember anything if you never use it for a full decade (my French is gone too). That's not to say I haven't used math, but I just look it up or learn it as needed. The truth is that I found my math education was a strange liability. I removed my math minor from my resume, as it prompted math based interviews. Having a Google interviewer go: "I see you have a math minor, so I'm going to ask you some math questions!", followed by the guy getting frustrated for 30 minutes, isn't a great experience.
- X0nic 10y agoYes I agree, math is extremely important for people who would like to become a Computer Scientist or Computer Engineer. The vast majority of people learning programming in school are not going to do that. Making these people learn these topics and possibly turning off potential students is counter productive. Many people could gain a lot by just having basic programming skills, and those people are scared off by any mention of the word math.