2 ms·
The problem is that a very small number of people are on that $100/month edge, a percentage of them will increase their expenses until they are as desperate as
by 1123581321 10y ago
The problem is that a very small number of people are on that $100/month edge, a percentage of them will increase their expenses until they are as desperate as they used to be, and the increased taxes to pay this money will put others on the edge. When considering BI, or any large money transfer program, you must consider the entire system, not just the beneficial effects on a small number of people for the first few months.
- witty_username 10y agoMoney is correlated with happiness. Sure, people will still yearn for more money, but with the more expenses people will be more happy.
- 1123581321 10y agoThat is the least important point, but please keep in mind then that the decreased expenses (alternately, increased tax expenses) to offset the cost of BI will make others unhappy.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoAt this point we are just being handwavy. This is the problem with discussions like this, there aren't any hard facts to support the arguments. Are people being forced to pay .1 pct more of their income or 10 pct more? etc...
- 1123581321 10y agoIt's not hand-wavy to try to convince BI proponents to at least consider second-order effects. But you're right; better modeling and experiments will be good for future discussions.
- thesimpsons1022 10y agoI agree. just saying that you can't assume the second-order effects will result in a net negative outcome on the whole system
- skybrian 10y agoI agree with you that a proper study would have to take all that into account. But since we're just hand-waving here, I'll argue that the point where you're paying, say, $50/month more in taxes than you get in benefits is likely to be at a high enough income that $50/month doesn't make nearly as big a difference to your life. Also, there is an insurance effect. A guaranteed $100 a month (even if you lose your job or have to move) provides more financial security than a larger amount that you can't necessarily rely on. And folks who aren't good at saving money (for whatever reason) will benefit more from having a bit more financial security during bad times, even if increased taxes means you don't make quite as much money in a good year. Sometimes when people talk about this, it sounds like they think any amount of financial security is bad for poor people - it provides the wrong incentives. But that seems backwards to me; when you're desperate, you're more likely to make decisions you regret later.
- 1123581321 10y agoI am totally in favor of financial stability for low-income people; I just am not in favor of initiatives that have bad unintended effects like harming people and reducing the wealth that makes long-term cash transfers possible. Theoretically, you can only tax people in such a way that they never fall below the $75,000 a year happiness threshold and use the money to bring people closer to $75,000 a year. In practice (and this is not hand-waving, it is the history of the United States) it's so much easier to pay for social programs with regressive consumption taxes (food, fuel) that they end up high enough to cause hardships. $100/month for, say, half the adults in the United States would be $144 billion, about the size of the federal education budget. Re-arranging the tax structure to accommodate this would not be easy, and I think you have to assume that at least some of the additional tax burden would fall on people who need all the money they currently earn, and on the people who receive the benefit. Likely, a high percentage of it would. I don't think an assumption that political capital would be spent to keep the tax progressive, since there are higher-priority proposals in existence that do this for Social Security/FICA/Medicare, and even those have side-effects most don't care to recognize.