3 ms·
> allow people on low income but with lots of land value to defer payment until death. if this is done on land that people live in, it will still penalizes la
by chii 10y ago
> allow people on low income but with lots of land value to defer payment until death.
if this is done on land that people live in, it will still penalizes landowners unfairly. If your land was bought when it was cheap, and the value appreciated, you end up paying tax money that you didn't really "earn" - in other words, it's only fair if you get reimbursed when land value depreciates. Deferring it till death is just delaying the unfair value exchange.
Payment on sale is similar, but slightly less unfair than an annual tax.
- eru 10y agoYes, your tax payment would go down, if the value of the land deprecates. (No, you wouldn't get last years tax back.) This is not about penalizing. This is about two things: first, shift taxation from where it hurts the economy (income tax etc) to where it doesn't do any damage to incentives (land supply is perfectly fixed). Second, making housing more affordable for eg young people. (There's also effect on NIMBYism etc.) The actual tax is supposed to be on the annual land rent. We'd only tax the value of the land as an easy and reliable proxy. (And yes, we'd also tax the imputed rent, ie the virtual rent that is short-cut for an owner-occupier. Not just the rent that accrues to someone who rents to other people.) Switzerland already taxed imputed rent. (Look up Eigenmietwert.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent
- chii 10y agothe imputed tax article has led me to read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax#Real_estate_values https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax#Real_estate_val... - it's quite interesting. The overall benefit to society is good, but to the individual, a LVT is going to (at least, in the short term) be a loss. I guess it's similar to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox regarding roads!
- eru 10y agoOf course any tax is a loss to the party who pays it. Don't think it has anything to do with Braess' paradox. The main thing that differentiates different ways to tax is: - what does it do for (or against) income equality? - what does it do to economic incentives? For things like sin taxes (like on alcohol, CO2, etc) you want to muck around with economic incentives. In general, when you just want to raise revenue, changing economic incentives as little as possible is good. Hence, inelastic things should be taxed. Land in all its forms, eg mineral resources, or straight up parcels of real estate to build houses on is perfectly inelastic, because the supply is fixed. Taxing land does well on the equality score as well: richer people tend to own more land; so it's a progressive tax.
- chii 10y ago> Of course any tax is a loss to the party who pays it. that's not true if you count the thing the tax is paying for - social services, or medicare, etc. There's economies of scale that you cannot easily achieve. A high LVT might encourage better land use, and thus, spur an economy to newer hights, which could vastly offset the individual "loss" on that tax (despite the fact that said individual may not feel like they've gained anything).
- eru 10y agoOh, definitely. I was replying specifically to this line: > The overall benefit to society is good, but to the individual, a LVT is going to (at least, in the short term) be a loss. The nice thing about investing land tax value well is that this increases land value. (Eg a train station increases property values nearby.) Thus public infrastructure investment can pay for itself in terms of new taxes---without blunting any economic incentives. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George_theorem
- kspaans 10y agoAre you saying there should be a 100% capital gains tax on land? What about people who buy houses in an up-and-coming area, don't perform any renovations, and then sell later at a profit? Did they "earn" any of that value?
- eru 10y agoLand creates an economic rent every year---most visible when you actually rent out the land, but also occurring as opportunity costs for owner occupiers. That rent is produced basically by people bidding up for the right to use the land, but not by anything the landowner does. (Things the landowner does, like putting a nice house on top of the land are explicitly excluded from a land tax.) The idea is that you can tax that (imputed) rent without any economic loss---since the landowner doesn't do anything for it, there's nothing to discourage with a high tax. In principle, one could try to tax 100% of the rent. In practice figuring out the exact rent that accrues due to the land is hard---especially for owner occupied places. But, we have a good proxy: the value of the land is (the market's best guess of) the net present value of all future income from the land. So as a proxy, you tax x% of the value of the land every year. If land appreciates in value over time, the tax rises proportionally. But unlike a capital gains tax, one pays the tax on the entire value of the land, not just the gains since the time you bought. Of course, a tax on the land changes the sum of the future income streams. And thus changes the value of the land, which changes the absolute value of the tax payment. Fortunately, solving that equation isn't too hard. In the case of constant interest rates, constant tax rates, constant annual rent: a: annual rent V: value of the property i: interest rate (per year) r: land tax rate (per year) a = i * V + r * V Reordering gives us the impact of land tax rates on price: V = a / (r + i) effective tax rate on the annual rent: (r*V) / a = r / (r + i) That's an increasing function of r, but it never reaches 100% (unless mortgage interest rates drop to 0%) So for your example, people buying a house and later just flipping it, would accrue land tax while holding the property, and would be able to pocket any difference in price tax free. (Ie if one could buy and sell on the same day, there would be almost no tax to pay on any gain.) Of course, the land tax itself would blunt a sharp appreciation of the property somewhat. Not a lot of the above description of the impact of taxes on land prices was specific to a land tax. A property tax has similar effects. A land tax just excludes houses and other things on top of the property from taxation. This in nothing even specific to a tax directly on the property. If for some reason you had a property where any shop on top of it would be excluded from VAT, the value of the property would go up. And if for some reason VAT would be doubled on retail in that area, the value of the property would drop. Because any drop in taxation on other economic activity will lead to higher land prices, people have high hopes that if the government can tap into land prices as a source of revenue, they will be able to reduce these other taxes without loss of revenue (but gains in economic efficiency).