5 ms·
Land tax penalizes retirees is why.
by gaius 10y ago
Land tax penalizes retirees is why.
- eru 10y agoNot really. Two solutions: either rely on the private sector to provide `reverse mortgages'. Or let the government offer the same product, ie allow people on low income but with lots of land value to defer payment until death or sale. In addition, phase in land tax over a decade so that people have time to adapt. If you phase out other taxes at a similar rate, you will even get a great increase in land values. (Basically, land in a jurisdiction that charges less eg income taxes or sales taxes is great for doing business on. So people will bid up its price.)
- gaius 10y ago"phase out other taxes" is the gaping hole in that argument. Property isn't just a market - its peoples homes and communities too - thats the other gaping hole. Why should Grandma need to move away so some Unicorn startup can move in?
- eru 10y agoWhy should some old people who managed to get lucky a few decades ago be allowed to sit on some of the most desireable real estate on the planet and not pay the community for it? Anyway, grandma is a red herring. > "phase out other taxes" is the gaping hole in that argument. See eg http://www.georgistjournal.org/2012/10/16/the-unplumbed-revenue-potential-of-land-part-3-atcor-all-taxes-come-out-of-rents/ http://www.georgistjournal.org/2012/10/16/the-unplumbed-reve... When taxes fall, real estate prices rise by enough to make up for it. Capturing that rise is simple with a land tax. (See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George_theorem for how that's a rather orthodex statement. Nothing outside the mainstream of economics here.) The whole process is very economically efficient. Swap taxes on elastic economic activity like work or investing for taxes on inelastic land.
- lttlrck 10y agoWhy should some young people who got lucky in a unicorn startup get to push out some old people that helped build that community?
- gaius 10y agoRight, this is why gentrification gets people's backs up. You're not just buying property as a physical asset, you're buying into the community that made that area desirable/up-and-coming/trendy/call it what you will. If they hadn't been there, you wouldn't want to be there either. But a piece of community isn't something you can own without contributing back to it, and if you don't, it destroys it.
- eru 10y agoGentrification is awesome for landowners. Makes their investment go up.
- burfog 10y agoMy grandma lives near there, in San Francisco, in a $1.1 million house. She is neither red nor a herring. She's a nice little old lady. Well, maybe she isn't nice by modern San Francisco standards; she is strictly Catholic and rather unhappy with the sexual behavior of most residents. Other than possibly that though, you'd probably like her. She keeps busy with plants, lots of noisy clocks, and a bird. Unlike a herring, she does not eat copepods and doesn't swim. She only managed to spawn 7 times, 1 or 2 at a time. She is mostly beige colored, not red. She is several times longer than the largest known herring. All things considered, I'm certain she isn't a red herring. Look, if she were a red herring, how could she even sign the paperwork to buy a house in the first place? Why would a herring even want a house, especially one that isn't flooded?
- kspaans 10y agoHow do existing property taxes not penalize retirees/Grandma, forcing them to move out? If they start owing LVT, they could defer payment until they sell their property[0]. There are many ways asset-rich, cash-poor people could be accommodated. And I doubt there are that many of them anyway. 0 - http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/a-poor-widow-bogey.html http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/2013/01/a-poor-widow-bogey.htm...
- chii 10y ago> allow people on low income but with lots of land value to defer payment until death. if this is done on land that people live in, it will still penalizes landowners unfairly. If your land was bought when it was cheap, and the value appreciated, you end up paying tax money that you didn't really "earn" - in other words, it's only fair if you get reimbursed when land value depreciates. Deferring it till death is just delaying the unfair value exchange. Payment on sale is similar, but slightly less unfair than an annual tax.
- eru 10y agoYes, your tax payment would go down, if the value of the land deprecates. (No, you wouldn't get last years tax back.) This is not about penalizing. This is about two things: first, shift taxation from where it hurts the economy (income tax etc) to where it doesn't do any damage to incentives (land supply is perfectly fixed). Second, making housing more affordable for eg young people. (There's also effect on NIMBYism etc.) The actual tax is supposed to be on the annual land rent. We'd only tax the value of the land as an easy and reliable proxy. (And yes, we'd also tax the imputed rent, ie the virtual rent that is short-cut for an owner-occupier. Not just the rent that accrues to someone who rents to other people.) Switzerland already taxed imputed rent. (Look up Eigenmietwert.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imputed_rent
- chii 10y agothe imputed tax article has led me to read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax#Real_estate_values https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax#Real_estate_val... - it's quite interesting. The overall benefit to society is good, but to the individual, a LVT is going to (at least, in the short term) be a loss. I guess it's similar to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braess'_paradox regarding roads!
- eru 10y agoOf course any tax is a loss to the party who pays it. Don't think it has anything to do with Braess' paradox. The main thing that differentiates different ways to tax is: - what does it do for (or against) income equality? - what does it do to economic incentives? For things like sin taxes (like on alcohol, CO2, etc) you want to muck around with economic incentives. In general, when you just want to raise revenue, changing economic incentives as little as possible is good. Hence, inelastic things should be taxed. Land in all its forms, eg mineral resources, or straight up parcels of real estate to build houses on is perfectly inelastic, because the supply is fixed. Taxing land does well on the equality score as well: richer people tend to own more land; so it's a progressive tax.
- fma 10y agoThat's why some places have some form of exemptions for retirees...