4 ms·
Why Americans don’t trust government
- timthelion 10y agoI think that the problem of complex laws will only get worse and worse. It is like code bloat when using test driven development. You say, "this interface is too complex, lets tear it out" and all of a suddent 200 tests break. Then you feel a sense of panic, "will the world explode if I just delete these test cases?"
- com2kid 10y agoI went to a very liberal public school, where my teachers taught me to be an independent thinker, and to distrust authority. We were rewarded for solving problems on our own, and for investigating the evidence behind claims. My middle school history course was taught to a backdrop of Beatles music. One of my High School history courses was taught in terms of Monty Python movies, which it turns out have a fair bit of historical accuracy to them. A common refrain was "Why do we do things this way? OLD DEAD WHITE MEN." When I went to college, I learned who funded the American Revolution. I took a philosophy class that taught us how to deconstruct sentences into logical statements. For practice we used political speeches, which amusingly enough, when diagramed out would often times turn out to be equivalent to null. For me, the answer is, I don't trust the government because my government provided education deliberately taught me better. This is also why I get upset when I see people insist that schools are "just indoctrination centers for our youth". Heh. Maybe all my schooling experiences from middle school on up were just serious outliers? All that said, I do think people's relationship with the government in regards to infrastructure investment is a bit... different. Growing up with a father who worked Union Labor, I learned that the men and women who build this country up have a lot of pride and love for their job. I also learned that everything is far more complicated than I could possibly imagine, with far too many moving parts. Working in software I know the overhead cost of communications between different teams, within the same company and across company lines. With the number of suppliers and vendors that come together for any given public works project, I am actually impressed that work gets done at all. To a large extent, I think a huge source of problems is organizational efficiency. Yet the public demands a certain level of accountability and transparency for our public works projects. We want open and honest bidding, and that means dealing with all the overhead of having 20 different vendors win different contracts for different parts of a project. There is an inherent inefficiency there that would not exist if we could just trust "one person" or "one company" to completely execute on a project.
- zepto 10y agoThey were outliers
- startling 10y agoSeriously. My education was nothing like the grandparent describes.
- rayiner 10y agoMine education was like that: We're evil for taking the land away from native Americans and also go around screwing up the rest of the world with military interventionism. Oh the founding fathers were fucking hypocrites for allowing slavery. This was in a DC suburb ironically. Over time I grew to find the mindset counterproductive. Free thinking is good to a point. But it's institutions, not individuals, that get us to the moon. It's bad when the pendulum swings too far in the other direction and we give up on our institutions.
- maxerickson 10y agoBut it's institutions, not individuals, that get us to the moon. It's bad when the pendulum swings too far in the other direction and we give up on our institutions. I agree with this, but I think it is often the case that institutions deserve to be given up on. I don't think we've figured out how to make them resilient against the internal politics of the institution becoming the primary activity of the institution.
- brazzledazzle 10y agoSometimes I think we need to figure out how to rip and replace institutions quickly and efficiently. Every human collective or institution seems to have a shelf life beyond which it gets strangled by its own bureaucracy.
- icebraining 10y agoWhy is free thinking incompatible (or at least in the oppose side of a pendulum) with having institutions?
- officemonkey 10y agoHe missed the big picture. The mayor of Boston took care of the little things because the mayor of Boston realizes that at a municipal-level, the people hold their elected officials responsible. Try to hold your congresscritter responsible. You can't. They blame gridlock for anything that doesn't get done, and stake their position on the right side of popular wedge issues to get reelected. This frees them up to be beholden not to the citizens, but to the party and the donors. It's only at the very top and the very bottom that we even give a fuck at what our representatives are doing. That's why state governments are often the most corrupt. They're doing god-knows what down there in the state capitol, and chances are you don't even know their names.
- Zigurd 10y agoLarry Summers needs a helicopter. The bridge he is talking about is a state/local problem, and while there are problems of trust and efficiency in all the government bodies that touch that bridge, none are readily applicable to "Why don't Americans trust government?" He would not have written this rant if he had a helicopter.
- justratsinacoat 10y ago>Larry Summers needs a helicopter [...] He would not have written this rant if he had a helicopter Can you elaborate? It's not clear to me why he would not have written this rant if he had a helicopter. Are you trying to tie his frustration with the bridge to his commute times?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 10y ago> Are you trying to tie his frustration with the bridge to his commute times? Yes, for starters. He even says so in the article. I also doubt Larry Summers and the people who distrust government can relate to each other. So I conclude maybe there might not be larger lessons to be learned from talking a long time to rebuild an old bridge over the Charles in an area with insane traffic and no possibility of building a temporary bridge, due to the layout of the roads in the area.
- maxerickson 10y agoI don't trust government because it is made out of people.
- HashThis 10y agoThe problem has gotten infinitely worse lately. I think the 2008 recession from a rigged economy was the first half of the problem. The NSA surveillance state uncovered by Snowden broke the last half of trust in government. This is why voters didn't revolt in 2008 or 2012 elections, but they are in 2016 elections (with Snowden's release in 2013). The wrong doing in the 2008 recession plus the illegal surveillance state combined to shatter trust in government. Evidence is seen in the Bernie Sanders voters and non-establishment republican voters in 2016.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoWhat the article is pointing out is the problem caused by the fact that we never repeal anything. Some problem happens, some regulation is put in place to deal with it and now that regulation is permanent. Next year some other problem happens and some regulation is put in place to deal with it. Each seems reasonable on its own but after a hundred years when you put them all together it turns a $5 million project into a $5 billion project. But it doesn't really address why we never repeal anything, and it's in large part because we keep doing too much at too high a level of government. A thousand years ago a population the size of New York City would have been a nation, but now it's a city inside of a county inside of a state inside of a union. And the union is inside of a set of international treaties. It's too many layers of bureaucracy. People keep advocating laws at the highest level where they can get them passed, which both makes them harder to fix because they're further removed from the affected people and more likely to cause trouble because any flaws are amplified by the larger affected population. The flaw seems to be that people think federal legislation is less complex than local legislation, under the theory that uniformity reduces complexity. But in practice what happens is that you end up with 10,000 pages of federal regulations instead of each city having their own 20 pages, and then not being able to fix anything because San Francisco and Houston can't agree which rule one should impose on the other when the sensible choice is to let each do what they want.
- ricree 10y agoYour way has its own set of pitfalls, and I'm not sure that they're less than the alternative. If you do business in New York, Chicago, and Boston, then you have to worry about laws in all three places. The more you lean upon local lawmaking, then the more you risk adding a big layer of legal incompatibility once you start crossing borders.
- kristopolous 10y agoMaybe becoming a giant onerous company should have such barriers...
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> If you do business in New York, Chicago, and Boston, then you have to worry about laws in all three places. Which, first of all, you already do, the county/state/federal laws apply on top of those. But you're also assuming that uniform national laws will be less complicated than dealing with different local laws, which doesn't seem to bear out in practice. California is going to care about earthquakes and Massachusetts is going to care about ice storms but not really the other way. If you do business in both California and Massachusetts then you have to care about both earthquakes and ice storms regardless, and if the relevant legislation is at the federal level then it will cover both. Which means local laws aren't more complicated for companies who do business in both places, they're less complicated for companies who don't, because then if you only do business in Massachusetts you don't have to deal with earthquake regulations.
- PaulHoule 10y agoI think Larry Summers is part of the reason why Americans don't trust government. But yeah, in Ithaca there was a little bridge by the police station that took 9 months to fix. It makes me wonder if the GWB and Tappan Zee bridge were built by aliens, as some have alleged the Egyptian pyramids were. (No, just by Moses... Robert Moses)
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoTappan Zee bridge It's interesting that the article talks about bridges. The replacement for the Tappan Zee bridge demonstrates, in a microcosm, one big problem with today's government. From wiki[1]: The bridge was built on a very tight budget of $81 million (1950 dollars), or $796 million in 2014 dollars. The replacement bridge, to be opened in a few years, costs at least 5x as much (in roughly equivalent dollars): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Tappan_Zee_Bridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Tappan_Zee_Bridge Where the fuck does all the money go? Fix that problem and Americans will start trusting government again. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tappan_Zee_Bridge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tappan_Zee_Bridge
- DrScump 10y agoThe (San Francisco-Oakland) Bay Bridge replacement was first estimated at $400 million ($200 million to retrofit the existing bridge). Actual spending is over $7 billion and counting for the new Eastern Span alone, and it is fraught with defects.
- carsongross 10y agoWhile I find nothing objectionable in this particular light-fair essay, I would also suggest that the reason many people don't trust the government is because people like Larry Summers have such a large influence in it.
- geoffbrown2014 10y agoTop 5 reasons I don't trust the government 1. Many of the regulatory systems which are supposed to protect the populace have been captured or have their effectiveness impaired by special interests, ie. the revolving door between the SEC and Wall Street, the FDA and Big Pharma, and DOE and Big Oil 2. Even when our institutions are not captured there is a perverse logic supporting institutional missions that lead to abuse of power. The Tuskegee experiment makes perfect sense you've got to have a control group in order to better understand the pathology so you can better protect the populace. 3. Poor execution or formation of government policies that would in any other profession be cause for malpractice or being disbarred or worse are routinely foisted upon the populace. 4. Corruption 5. Increasingly your rights and legal protections are seen by institutions as being granted by those institutions instead of being protected by those institutions. Your rights are correctly perceived by the institutions as hindrances to their institutional missions. Better legal policies wouldn't even crack the top 5 reason for me to trust government. We are way beyond wonky tweaks to our legal system. All of the above essentially boils down to accountability. If policy makers and lawmakers could be held legally accountable for policy mistakes, possibly even financially responsible for the mayhem they cause I for one would feel a much closer allegiance to our government.
- jmclnx 10y agoMassachusetts cannot build/maintain bridges or roads period. One example, within 3 to 4 months New Hampshire build a large bridge over the Merrimack to their airport. About 30 miles down river there is a 'temporary' bridge over the river erected around 1986, that was suppose to be replaced by a permanent bridge in 5 years, it is still there and causing massive traffic jams. There are many examples of this, another good one, a 20 foot bridge in Westford MA took 1 year to build. Mass. is the last place to base theories about Government keeping up infrastructure. Anyone remember how "successful" the big dig is :)