6 ms·
systemd has turned Linux into a tire fire. I've spent 20 years with this platform and seriously worry about it being as useful the next 20.
by busterarm 10y ago
systemd has turned Linux into a tire fire.
I've spent 20 years with this platform and seriously worry about it being as useful the next 20.
- zxcvcxz 10y agoHow has systemd effected you?
- busterarm 10y agoIt broke a few of my Arch installs. I had to learn a bunch of new tools which didn't improve my work in any way. The only things that it made easier were things that were already easy. More importantly, I think that some of the systemd maintainers have a track record of not really knowing what they're doing, as exemplified by this tmux issue. I have serious worry about running their process as PID 1. Other than that, totally positive effect: It deepened my interest in OS security and hastened my switch to OpenBSD which was probably happening anyway.
- jamespo 10y agoArch is an interesting choice of distro if you value stability
- busterarm 10y agoFor me, Arch very rarely delivered "omg nothing works" moments on upgrade for me. The only one that I can think of was the systemd upgrade. For every other breaking change, a fix was either easily apparent or well-documented on the wiki. "Stability" in the sense that OpenBSD provides though is something that I valued more over time of running Arch and my experiences with other things on the side (mainly QNX).
- qb45 10y agoArch is largely OK. The only troublesome and WTF-ish upgrades I recall were systemd (which I avoided) and symlinking of /bin and /lib to /usr.
- TelmoMenezes 10y agoSystemd created him?
- iam-TJ 10y agoTechnically I appreciate much of the systemd design and implementation, but what repeatedly annoys me is when it 'takes over' - replaces - existing tooling and doesn't provide feature parity, resulting in regressions. The one that really annoyed me (and is still present) is when it replaced cryptsetup init scripts but did not implement support for root file-system key-files. For release-upgrades this will result in broken, unbootable, systems - it isn't difficult to imagine how this causes swearing and bad feeling! For new installs it means loss of required functionality, and lost time and productivity exploring and implementing work-arounds to counter the regression and return to the status quo. The reason for the lack of key-file support in systemd-cryptsetup? The purist idealism that key-file support patches will only be accepted if they use the Linux kernel's key-ring API (rather than replicate the existing cryptsetup init script behaviour).
- Ace17 10y agoBy making many of my systems totally unbootable after an upgrade?
- chrisper 10y agoI feel the same way about network manager. Maybe it's just me, but I am not a huge fan of nmcli.
- msbarnett 10y agonetworkmanager is a shocking mess, when you look at how simple this functionality is in the *BSDs.
- justinsaccount 10y agoby "this functionality" do you mean things like * connecting to different wireless networks that use wpa enterprise authentication (which I think some of the bsds only recently added support for) * bringing up usb networking interfaces via cell phone tethering on demand * managing multiple different vpn clients and profiles from a single interface Or do you mean things like * Bringing up a networking interface with a static ip address Because I use network manager for the former on laptops, and remove it on servers that only need the latter.
- msbarnett 10y agoThe former. As with many things, yes, it took OpenBSD and FreeBSD longer to get that functionality. The tradeoff is that they delivered a well thought out, consistent, and well-engineered solution, rather than a poorly thought out mess of CADT-driven bloat.
- ymse 10y agoYou can just uninstall it and use something else to configure networking. It's one of the first things I purge on any distro. With systemd it's not so simple.
- chrisper 10y agoWhat do you replace it with?
- pgtan 10y agoGENTOO has sys-fs/static-dev. With some effort I have server running without systemd, without udev, d-bus, pulseaudio ... plus not compiled support for ipv6, nls, ldap, etc.
- justinsaccount 10y agoYou could have saved yourself the effort and installed a linux distro from 1999.
- qb45 10y agoYeah, some 32-bit one that predates SATA and ships with 20 known remote vulns.