4 ms·
> China's economic output likely will surpass the U.S.'s in the next decade. That's not going to happen. China is replicating the Japan scenario. This is not o
by adventured 10y ago
> China's economic output likely will surpass the U.S.'s in the next decade.
That's not going to happen. China is replicating the Japan scenario. This is not only peak fear over China, but it's also peak China when it comes to their partially fake economic boom (fueled by the greatest debt binge in world history).
The US now has an $18 trillion economy. China is nearing $11 trillion.
It makes no sense to do this, but I'll do it for convenience - let's assume China never has a recession or depression (given their economic mismanagement since the easy growth faded, that's laughable, but anyway).
China grows at 4% for 30 years. The US grows at 2% for 30 years. The US ends up at ~$32 trillion. China ends up at ~$35 trillion. That's China's best case scenario, and it takes them three decades just to catch the US. The far more likely scenario is China has 20 years of stagnation as they struggle to claw their way out of extraordinary sums of debt, defaults, bankruptcies, vast unemployment and broad economic mismanagement under a failed central planner system - not to mention China has half a billion subsistence farmers that will never see their standard of living climb meaningfully in real terms because China has no jobs for them (and the robotic / AI revolution will guarantee they never have jobs), those people will not be very happy over the next 30 years.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoI mean, I hope you're right and that China will prove to be a paper tiger, as it were, but I'm not so confident that it will be so, and it therefore seems prudent to spend the money needed to have a military capable of containing them.
- hackuser 10y ago> I hope you're right and that China will prove to be a paper tiger Realize that hoping for that is hoping for hundreds of millions of people to be mired in poverty for generations more. What I hope is that China achieves political reform and becomes a democracy, and all those people have freedom, self-determination, and prosperity. Despite China's protestations, many countries of many different cultures have done it with great success: Japan, S. Korea, Taiwan, and Hong Kong are examples right on and even within China's borders. All the most prosperous, secure countries in the world, almost without exception, are democracies.
- GunboatDiplomat 10y agoA democratic China is still a threat. China is only safe if it's impoverished, broken up into manageable chunks, or hopelessly outclassed.
- hackuser 10y agoTrue, but I'm not going to starve the rest of the world so that I feel safe. That seems like a definition of evil. Democracies almost never go to war with other democracies; it's not much of a threat. Also, liberty and self-determination are Western values; what you describe is the antithesis.
- hackuser 10y ago> The US now has an $18 trillion economy. China is nearing $11 trillion. That depends on how you measure it, and especially on how you convert Chinese currency, renminbi (RMB), into dollars so you can compare the two economies on the same quantifiable scale. There are two widely used methods with much different results for the size of China's economy: * $11 trillion: That number is yielded The "nominal" method, which is based on how many RMB you can buy with a dollar on international currency exchanges, such as if you did it at your bank (and they gave you a fair rate without exorbitant fees). * $19 trillion (already larger than the U.S. economy): That number is yielded by the purchasing power parity method (PPP), PPP calculates the RMB-to-dollar conversion based on how much it would cost to purchase the same set of goods locally in each country. (For example, if a gallon of milk cost 10 RMB in China and $1 in the U.S., the PPP conversion rate for milk would be 10/1. Needless to say, economy-wide PPP is far more complex.) Goods generally cost much less in China, a much poorer nation, so money goes further. Which method applies better to funding a military? I suppose it depends on to what degree transactions are local, such as paying troops and making military assets locally, and to what degree components and goods are purchased from other countries. Certainly China has large domestic military industry. Also, both numbers depend on how much you trust Chinese government economic statistics, which are widely suspected of being overstated. > That's not going to happen. China is replicating the Japan scenario. I've heard some say that, but nobody can predict these things with anything like the certainty in the comment above (which I'll take as hyperbole). China certainly has economic problems, and a government whose legitimacy was based on economic growth for 30 years. Now they are shifting back to ideology (communism and nationalism) and raw oppression.