3 ms·
> The Edison phonograph cost $20 at the end of the 19th century; an iPod Nano costs about $145 today. It's also worth remembering that an edison phonograph wou
by dnautics 10y ago
> The Edison phonograph cost $20 at the end of the 19th century; an iPod Nano costs about $145 today.
It's also worth remembering that an edison phonograph would have probably been useable for about 60-80 years if kept in good condition. Good luck getting 5 out of the Nano. But yeah, collecting a billion prices and forgetting about each after a pairwise collection is a brilliant choice.
- chris_va 10y agoWell, $20 in 1891 isn't exactly $20 in 2016. Also, you aren't likely to go for a jog with your phonograph, and I suspect if you left the nano in a box for 60 years it would probably be fine (minus maybe the battery).
- dv_dt 10y agoI think the flash memory might have trouble with data retention over 60 years - all the electrons defining your bits will have leaked away.
- xenadu02 10y ago$20 in 1891 is ~$500 today. I'm sure the iPod nano could be an heirloom-quality device if you were willing to pay $500 for it. The photograph was certainly not maintenance-free so for equal comparison we have to assume even with a massive over-subscription of flash you'd need to replace the memory every 10-15 years. The battery probably every 5. It's a difficult problem to reason about because our own perceptions are anchored to what we know. You couldn't have had a modern home air conditioner at any price in 1891. Ten billion dollars couldn't have bought you the computing power of a MacBook Pro in 1950. The quantitative and qualitative gap between successive generations of computing technology is many orders of magnitude beyond what any other technology has ever experienced in human history, and the generations themselves have happened orders of magnitude faster too. I don't even know how you compare these things in economic terms because the baseline equivalence between products is nonsensical to start with.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dnautics 10y ago> the baseline equivalence between products is nonsensical to start with. That's exactly my point. Nonetheless, traditional econometric analyses do exactly that, arbitrarily creating multipliers (hedonic adjustments, e.g.) which normatively make assignments as to what a consumer "should" value in a product. These assignments often throw out important considerations, merely because they're 'difficult to calculate'.
- stvswn 10y agoA wheelbarrow can be used for 100 years or more, because it's a simple mechanism. Why the focus on reliability? With an outside view of the past couple of centuries -- an iPod Nano is basically magic. My point being, I think we're often not amazed enough at everyday technology. I can't imagine Edison seeing a Nano and saying "well, what about durability?"
- adventured 10y agoYou're confusing the central focus of importance. Why would anybody care about the audio playing device in terms of 60-80 years? Especially in this age, in which technology is rapidly improving. I very specifically do not want to be using a 2005 iPod in 2050. My digital music files are good forever in theory. They're made of bits. All I need to do is occasionally move them to new cheap hardware and maybe back them up in the cloud for practically free. I could store ten copies of my music library for $50 on usb sticks or similar, and replace it every year just for fun, without being concerned for the expense. Lots of ways digital files can be lost or destroyed? Sure, and they're still radically more secure (go make a dozen copies of your record albums) and easier to keep than physical records. The sole annoyance with digital media, is that I have to re-back it up very rarely, which takes a matter of minutes.
- LgWoodenBadger 10y agoIt's funny that you mention that. My refurbished iPod Nano (4th Gen) has been in continuous usage as my cars' music device (hot summers, cold winters) since March 2010. The only time it's not in there is when I sync it with new music. Still works great.
- ars 10y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- snowwrestler 10y agoWhat breaks on the Nano? It's a solid state device. If you treated an iPod Nano and an Edison phonograph the exact same way, the Nano would outlast the phonograph easily.
- bostik 10y agoIt's a miniaturised electronic device. Over time components rot. Materials oxidise, capacitors leak, connections squeak and break. And the NAND cells? The storage mechanism is the result of an electro-chemical reaction. In time the charge potential between the storage states will succumb to entropy. So what breaks on the Nano? Everything. And what breaks it? Time.