4 ms·
- spam free, virtually limitless storage free email - free video delivery channel, that has created its own industry - communication tool that has changed new
by kasey_junk 10y ago
- spam free, virtually limitless storage free email
- free video delivery channel, that has created its own industry
- communication tool that has changed news delivery & how people organize protests
- free chat communication (with e2e encryption) for nearly everyone in the world (including some of the poorest)
- on demand data center infrastructure at ridiculously low cost
- instantly freely searchable data set of most of the worlds written information
- self driving cars
- ubiquitous hand held computers
- free easy to use video conferencing
- a social network that connects a gigantic part of the planets population (if you are into that sort of thing)
Just some of the mind boggling technology at least partially funded by internet ads in the last 15 years.
Are there issues that have arisen? Of course, what sort of funding model doesn't have downsides? Acting like working for pay from advertisers constitutes some sort of modern Gallipoli is such a vacuous argument in the face of the staggering amount of tech it has at least partly helped bring about, I'm shocked that the comment hasn't been down voted more.
- vthallam 10y agoThis! It's a great example of what users get as a trade off for having to see relevant advt on the Internet.
- daxfohl 10y agoPfft give me back a 20th century existence, pre-internet, pre-computer, 19th century, Middle Age, Roman, Greek, Egyptian, Mesopotamian, Stone Age, neanderthal, monkey, worm, bacteria, whatever. A bunch of junk we're pouring money into and wasting talent on now.
- astazangasta 10y agoI deeply disagree with this on a level that will be difficult to capture in an Internet comment, but I will try: What you're describing is the advancement of technology, which has occurred at the institutions that have accumulated the most power. Yes, Facebook, Google and others have hired some of the most talented people in the country, and these people have continued to produce useful technology while ensconced at these companies. Previously the same people could be found at AT&T, Xerox PARC, various DARPA-connected institutions, etc. All you're describing is the shift in the center of power. In the 50s and 60s it was the government. During the 70s, as power began to shift more and more away from government towards private capital, we saw more and more technologists moving into the employ of monopolists. It is a mistake to confuse this transfer of power, and the corresponding ability to purchase talent, with the output of that pool of smart people. Moreover in Silicon Valley these people are deeply connected to a much broader community of intellectuals (e.g. through HN) - I'd argue that this culture, of which many members currently sojourn in the arms of large corporations like Facebook, is the real productive unit. Facebook found a money faucet and connected these people to it; but this money faucet could have been anything. It could have been something of real social value, except we have largely destroyed the mechanisms that direct productivity on the basis of social values and now direct it purely based on the interests of private capital, which is currently enamored with data accumulation and targeted advertising. I'll end here, but I'd also like to point out that a lot of the stuff you've listed here existed long before Facebook and Google were a twinkle in anyone's eye. You're taking things that were literally developed in the 60s and giving credit to them for the private concentrations of power that were built on top of that work.
- kasey_junk 10y agoI was talking more about the idea that we've somehow wasted developer minds on the pursuit of non-valuable advertising. Which clearly isn't the case. Advertising might have paid for a part of it, but the benefits clearly exist. I'll also stand by my argument that every model of financing these technical improvements (at least that I can think of) have downsides. Compared to the war machine of the 20th century, I find the ads pretty tame. Not to mention that advertising is a lot less coercive than tax based defense spending or government granted monopolies.