3 ms·
[ed: apologies if the first section come off a bit hostile, that wasn't/isn't my intention - also see my sibling comment. I appreciate all feedback!] A) I don'
by e12e 10y ago
[ed: apologies if the first section come off a bit hostile, that wasn't/isn't my intention - also see my sibling comment. I appreciate all feedback!]
A) I don't think you read the encoding bit correctly: the secret is the first two letters, the extension to words is just a mnemonic device - a crutch for the human brain. Typing a (full) paragraph blindly will be too error prone. While one could argue that it would increase the entropy, the basic idea is to have a trivially obvious lower bound on the entropy a password encodes.
B) let's say we change the method to just generating a random 0 or 1. Would you feel comfortable using this password as a Base to derive a 128 bit aes key, and telling the world about your password scheme?
[ed: I'm not sure if a good work-factor+a decent salt would be a reasonable basis for deriving 128bit keys. You'd want it to be hard to "walk the keyspace" that your 64 bits + salt extend to. In the trivial case of passwords "0" and "1", you'd need a long salt - but you'd also have to do all that work yourself every time you need your key. As I understand it, 64bit is still "quite big" -- I'm just not sure if it's big "enough" in this case. I'm thinking no - but I'm not certain.]