9 ms·
Josh Marshall, from John Gruber: It all comes down to a simple point. You may not like Gawker. They’ve published stories I would have been ashamed to p
by madeofpalk 10y ago
Josh Marshall, from John Gruber:
It all comes down to a simple point. You may not like Gawker. They’ve published
stories I would have been ashamed to publish. But if the extremely wealthy,
under a veil secrecy, can destroy publications they want to silence, that’s a
far bigger threat to freedom of the press than most of the things we commonly
worry about on that front. If this is the new weapon in the arsenal of the
super rich, few publications will have the resources or the death wish to
scrutinize them closely.
http://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/05/25/marshall-thiel http://daringfireball.net/linked/2016/05/25/marshall-thiel
http://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-huge-huge-deal http://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/a-huge-huge-deal
- forgotpwtomain 10y ago> But if the extremely wealthy, under a veil secrecy, can destroy publications they want to silence, Is there some method of 'destruction' that isn't reported on here, other than Peter Thiel financing Hulk Hogan's lawsuit? I think you are going to be hard-pressed to find people that think Gawker should be able to publish a 'sex tape', ignore a court order to take it down, because it's 'journalism'.
- zardgiv 10y agoThey specifically dropped the part of the case that would allow an insurance payout. Typically, people who don't want to destroy an organization will prefer to get the more assured money from insurance.
- saint_fiasco 10y agoShould Gawker be able to publish a 'sex tape', ignore a court order to take it down, then pay a slightly higher insurance premium which to them is just 'cost of doing business' at this point, just because they are 'journalists'?
- zardgiv 10y agoI don't know, should they? What if they had a billionaire secretly funding them ;-)
- Natsu 10y agoHogan is the only one who could approve that, as its arguably against his interests. So if you're going after someone for vengeance here, it should be him.
- darawk 10y agoThis is a poorly thought out argument. He isn't doing anything under-handed or illegal to destroy Gawker. He isn't fabricating evidence against them or paying off cops. He's simply financing a non-spurious lawsuit, which the courts have decided was legitimate. This is exactly what I want the billionaires in our society doing. He may be acting in his own self-interest, but it also happened to align with the public interest. And if the courts had decided against Hogan, it all would have been for nothing. There is no grand problem here. He isn't "destroying publications he wishes to silence", he's augmenting the resources of someone with a legitimate legal claim against the newspaper. If you are putting forth the argument that merely financing a lawsuit is a corruption of the public trust, then we have much more serious problems with our legal system than Peter Thiel having it out for Gawker. Anyone should be able to fund any lawsuit that they want, and then the courts will decide if that lawsuit has merit. That's why we have courts in the first place.
- dopamean 10y ago> but it also happened to align with the public interest. That is debatable and also the problem. What if it didn't align with the public interest? Is it ok then?
- darawk 10y agoYes. It is always ok to finance a lawsuit. The premise of our legal system is that optimal adversaries debating in front of an impartial judge produce the best possible outcome. If Hogan wasn't able to finance the lawsuit on his own, that would be the perversion of justice. But if our court system operates as it should, and there is no indication to my knowledge that it has not in this case, then billionaires funding legal teams should only enhance the level of justice available to all. If the above is not true, then that is a problem with the court system, not a problem with people funding each other's lawsuits.
- zardgiv 10y agoIt's not to say that this is what happened here, but our legal system disagrees that it's always OK to finance a lawsuit (see SLAPP).
- shard972 10y agoMan John is just a little dramatic sometimes. Financing a lawsuit which so far seems to be legitimate under US law is equated with destroying publications? The fact that gawker is online after losing the trial pretty much illustrates the point.
- aeb0 10y agoBecause they are appealing the award. The 147M or whatever it is is thought to be enough to wipe them out, which would be no great loss.
- madeofpalk 10y agoMind you, Gawker is the organisation that revealed the Facebook Trending News... 'scandal'.
- threatofrain 10y agoPeter Thiel is not directly damaging Gawker with his money. He's doing so via the intermediary of the justice system, where for whatever reason money has relevance. Peter Thiel is just incidentally throwing his money in this direction, but that money has a matter in justice is not the doing of Peter Thiel.
- newjersey 10y ago> Peter Thiel is not directly damaging Gawker with his money. He's doing so via the intermediary of the justice system, where for whatever reason money has relevance. It is there that we should find danger, not that Peter Thiel circumstantially decided to send his wrath in the direction of Gawker. I felt the same way reading this thread. I also thought about an h3h3 video I saw earlier today https://youtu.be/fEGVOysbC8w https://youtu.be/fEGVOysbC8w where they talk about fair use and how a lawsuit can cost you $100k in legal fees if you prevail. The question to ask should be: should our legal system be a game of chicken? or a sick twisted game of poker where you can't call "show" but just keep raising stakes? I hope we have not forgotten that the attorneys responsible for Aaron Schwartz's case are still in charge of things. I am by no means endorsing what Mr Thiel is doing. I think it is in extremely poor taste (even though I hate gawker). I simply agree that our attention should be more focused towards fixing our broken "justice" system. edit: no, the winner getting reimbursed for legal cost by the loser is not a fix
- schrodinger 10y agoIf "scrutinize them closely" means leak private sex tapes, then I'm happy to see few publications willing to do so.
- hackaflocka 10y agoGawker proudly published Hulk Hogan's sex tape (while shaming him for it), while also shaming websites for publishing J.Law's nudes. I can't see anything redeeming about such an inconsistency: http://imgur.com/gallery/CQ5qgvu http://imgur.com/gallery/CQ5qgvu
- MBCook 10y agoAnd they owned ValleyWag which tried to out Thiel as gay.
- FireBeyond 10y agoThat seems to me a very retroactive justification. Thiel being gay was probably one of the worst kept "secrets" in the Valley. He had social media profile pictures of himself shirtless on a gay cruise, let's face it.
- sergiotapia 10y agoGawker wasn't some bastion of journalism - it was a libelous rag, good riddance.
- Camillo 10y agoA: "Thiel financing the lawsuit against Gawker is a thread to freedom of the press." B: "Twitter, Facebook etc. 'curating' political viewpoints is not a threat to free speech because it's not the government." The intersection of people arguing A and people arguing B.
- MollyR 10y agoI noticed this too, but I'm not sure what it means.
- acheron 10y ago"Evil corporation revenge porns a working class hero, gay vigilante ensures justice is served, and the left sides with the corporation?" https://twitter.com/elidourado/status/735659959455756288 https://twitter.com/elidourado/status/735659959455756288
- Chris2048 10y ago> But if the extremely wealthy, under a veil secrecy, can destroy publications they want to silence for their illegal actions... maybe it's unfair that the companies that piss off a billionaire are more likely to be called on their illegal actions, but the solution is more focus on legal aid, not fewer legit lawsuits.