8 ms·
> For a young adult in the current economic climate, the only way you're living in one of these cushy homes is if you're living with your parents. This is a ve
by majormajor 10y ago
> For a young adult in the current economic climate, the only way you're living in one of these cushy homes is if you're living with your parents.
This is a very coastal/urban-centric view, IME. The large majority of my social circle growing up in suburban Dallas (a) still lives in suburban Dallas and (b) found a detached home before age 30 (if not 25). I moved away from the suburbs, and to a big coastal city, and so did almost "everyone I know" out here (with a lot of selection bias), but judging from that and housing prices in those crazy markets doesn't work for extrapolating to the country as a whole.
Of the ones still living at home, I don't know anyone thinking "it would be just as cool to have my own place, so might as well save money." The causality is reversed: "I'm broke, so might as well save as much money as possible, and my parents' place is big."
"Not cool" starts being a lot less relevant pretty quickly after getting out of college for most people, IME. Suburban houses are bigger than apartments. They're less noisy. They're more pet friendly. You have a garage for storage/workshopping/whatever. You have more space for starting a family. All those reasons still apply as much as they ever did, the big change from ten years ago to today is economic, not around coolness.
- Rumudiez 10y agoKeeping in mind that a large portion of these people live in areas outside of Dallas, with the average home price only several hundred grand above $150k[1]. In the greater Seattle area you'd be stressed to find a back alley condo for that cheap. My rent in the outskirts of Redmond for a 3 bedroom apartment is more than my mother's mortgage for her 5 bedroom house in Bellevue, which, despite being a 70 year old split-level home with low ceilings and a hill for a lot in a forgotten neighborhood without so much as one sidewalk, was appraised two years ago for over $750,000. I can afford to live on my own, but hell if I can afford a reasonable down payment on a house within 25 miles of where I work. 1. http://www.zillow.com/dallas-tx/home-values/ http://www.zillow.com/dallas-tx/home-values/
- dionidium 10y agoWell, right, which is why the parent said it was a "very coastal/urban-centric view." What he's describing about Dallas is true for the nearly 200 million Americans who live in the Midwest and the South. Cheap housing is the norm in the United States. I'm not bothered by people on the coasts complaining about housing costs, but you look foolish when you make generalizations about your generation that don't apply to the majority of the country.
- vasilipupkin 10y agoIs it cheap relative to incomes in that area ? Sure, lots of cheap houses in areas with low incomes. So?
- dionidium 10y agoThe discount on housing is far bigger than the discount on salaries
- majormajor 10y agoHow much higher do you think the incomes for most jobs are in big coastal areas? It tends to be "very little."
- vasilipupkin 10y agoHie much do you think it costs to live in far parts of Brooklyn? Relatively little. Yet you are 1 hr away from the heart of NYC
- treehau5 10y agoAs my friends who recently moved down here (Charlotte) from Brooklyn who worked in NYC tell me: still way too much, especially to have to deal with that traffic every day. Rent in Brooklyn got them 12 acres 40 minutes away from Uptown Charlotte, and a house to boot.
- randallsquared 10y agoI've lived in a bunch of US places, including rural Colorado and the Atlanta, Boston and DC metro areas, and I will say that Charlotte is a special case. People here complain about housing costs and traffic, and I just smile quietly.
- tropo 10y agoYes. You're getting 1.5x the income (usually with longer hours) and paying 5x for the house. You're also paying more for other random stuff like groceries, eating out, gasoline, electricity, etc. You're also paying lots more for taxes. Some states have no income tax. Some states have no sales tax. Some have neither!
- DougN7 10y agoFly-over country has many nice large homes for $200K with 1/4 acre or larger yards. And there are tech jobs, though obviously not as concentrated as the coasts. And the 15-30 minute commute is very typical. It all depends on priorities.
- serge2k 10y agoPriority number 1 is not living in a place referred to as "fly-over country".
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoYour choice. But if you choose it, don't complain about the consequences.
- madengr 10y agoShh.. Don't let them know I make the same tech salary in flyover country as in SF, but have good schools, and a 3600 ft^2 house for 1/5 the price.
- DougN7 10y agoBoy, no kidding! About 12 years ago I moved from the west coast to the midwest to a place I never thought I'd live. I can't believe the quality of life and work-life balance out here. My friends wondered if I'd have access to the Internet :) It's really perception more than anything else.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>but have good schools Is that why the vast majority of "school decides to teach Creationism in science classes" type stories emerge from flyover country? http://arstechnica.com/search/?ie=UTF-8&q=creationism http://arstechnica.com/search/?ie=UTF-8&q=creationism Sort by date, then check the states. Ohio. Mississippi. Kansas. Idaho. No sir, you do not have good schools compared to the rest of the country.
- angersock 10y agoThe problem with the DFW Metroplex is that walkability is kinda garbage. Also, the burbs (Grapevine, Colleyville, Arlington, Euless, Irving, etc.) are soulsucking tracts of aparments and housing subdivisions. Walking around is hard, biking difficult (getting murdered on large streets and highways), and the only non-chain stuff tends to be overly-face folksy town centers that people are moving towards (see Southlake, but even then it's a lot of big chains because of how much it costs to be there). And that's before you even go into the shittiness of commuting around Dallas.
- kevin_thibedeau 10y agoHome prices in the Dallas burbs have doubled in the last 15 years. Wages haven't. That alone locks many people out of the market at current rates.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIt varies. If you go back 30-40 years into the housing stock, prices are flat. Only the big McMansions have the higher price. When last I checked on the last house sold in the area ( in 2004 ) it had appreciated very little.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- treehau5 10y ago> "Not cool" starts being a lot less relevant pretty quickly after getting out of college for most people, IME. Suburban houses are bigger than apartments. They're less noisy. They're more pet friendly. You have a garage for storage/workshopping/whatever. Amen! You get tired of living in basically a post-college dorm scene really quick, all the meanwhile paying 1000-2000 for the "luxury" when you can turn around and put that same money into 4x the space, and be actually building equity in the process.