3 ms·
This isn't really about tax loopholes. It's about France being uncompetitive and unwilling to change. Google advertisers sign contracts with a company in Irela
by mike_hearn 10y ago
This isn't really about tax loopholes. It's about France being uncompetitive and unwilling to change.
Google advertisers sign contracts with a company in Ireland because Ireland decided to effectively not apply corporation taxes (i.e. use a low rate and allow a variety of schemes that reduce the real rate even further). They did this fully knowingly ... the policy has been popular with voters ... because they wanted to attract international investment and employers to a place that otherwise wouldn't have much to offer, and as a strategy it worked amazingly well. Even during the financial crisis Ireland did not back down on that.
This upset other countries in the EU but none moreso than France which has notoriously high taxes and a notoriously stagnant economy, combined with a population that routinely mounts protests against any attempt at reform.
France is very powerful in the EU and thus instead of trying to make itself competitive has spent the last few years coming up with a variety of political solutions to their competitiveness problem:
• Pressuring low tax jurisdictions to charge more tax
• Getting the VAT rules for online businesses altered so now instead of paying VAT where the sale takes place, you have to pay to the country of the buyer ... woebetide you if you don't speak Hungarian or Croatian. You're gonna have to find someone who does and get them to file a tax return for you.
• Now, apparently, simply harassing rich companies in an attempt to extract more money directly.
Google hires very competent accountants, I seriously doubt they have actually made mistakes or lied on their tax returns. Instead France is going to exploit the existence of a Paris office to try and present Google with a giant bill. This would strongly incentivise Google to simply leave France entirely, I don't think the Paris office is very large compared to the others it has in Europe.
- tomp 10y agoIt's completely within the right of Ireland and Irish citizens to promote investment by lowering the tax rates, as it is within the right of France and French citizens to tax companies that earn profits in France according to French tax law. I really don't see a problem.
- stuaxo 10y agoAnd yet Ireland has harsh austerity that has pushed many into poverty, so it wouldn't seem to be making much difference to citizens. http://www.irishexaminer.com/viewpoints/analysis/irelands-austerity-success-is-no-model-for-greece-340662.html http://www.irishexaminer.com/viewpoints/analysis/irelands-au...
- ptaipale 10y agoFrance doesn't have austerity... yet. But Ireland is already getting over it.
- soneil 10y agoI honestly think the two aren't linked. At least not as cause and effect, at least. Multinational investment drove the growth, but it was property madness that drove the bubble. So when the global economy faltered, there was a downturn in foreign investment - but it was the property bubble that burst. I can still say that almost everyone I know here works for a multinational. So while they seem to artificially expand GDP (a huge amount of our GDP isn't actually domestic, and doesn't benefit us the same way domestic product would) - for us little folk on the ground, they still mean a lot, lot more jobs than we'd have otherwise. How we actually domesticate this investment so it's not at risk of just flitting off to the next cheap destination, I have no idea. But I think that's the real long-term risk & challenge, not the stupid amounts of imaginary money people had pinned on the property bubble.
- weberc2 10y agoIf the article is to be believed, the problem is that France is prosecuting law-abiding companies, presumably because they're doing business in rival nations.
- Xylakant 10y agoThat's not what the text says. Googles spokesperson is quoted as saying they're complying with the law - but well, what is Googles spokesperson supposed to say? The whole paragraph starting with "accused of" is not about "legally being accused of breaking the law" but about the fact, that this (seemingly) legal tax structuring is under increased scrutiny. One part of that is testing if that's actually really legal because scholars can hold different opinions and it's never been tested in court, another part is changing the laws to make this actually illegal and close loopholes. This has been going on for a while in europe and it's not a problem, France or otherwise. The fact that Google did pay up in a similar UK case indicates to me that matters are not obviously and 100% legal.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoDidn't Google avoid the case in the UK by paying an amount of their own choosing? Basically giving them a headline that looked like they were being altruistic whilst still avoiding paying a 'proper' amount of tax? (I may have misremembered??)
- weberc2 10y ago"Several have been accused of using legal methods to minimise their tax bills. In Google's case, its tax structure allows it to pay tax in the Republic of Ireland, even when sales appear to relate to the UK." I took this to mean Google was among the companies accused of using "legal methods". Am I misreading?
- yardie 10y agoIreland got hit really hard during the GFC they were in a big deficit like many other countries and couldn't pay their creditors. They went to the ECB to ask for more money. The ECB called it and said you aren't charging enough taxes to sustain the government. So they did. * Taxes are paid wherever you do business. If you're a EU-based company doing business in the US guess what you don't pay VAT. But you'll certainly pay US taxes on that transaction. * Those accountants are going to have to show that taxes were paid somewhere. Whether it be in France, Ireland, or the UK. They've been closing loopholes like the double-Irish sandwich and I'm fairly sure the accountants knew this day was going to come. Unlike Ireland and the UK, France, Germany, and Italy have been very aggressive about going after big companies as a public spectacle. Even if they don't find anything. It keeps smaller companies that may be doing the same inline.
- Xylakant 10y ago> Getting the VAT rules for online businesses altered so now instead of paying VAT where the sale takes place, you have to pay to the country of the buyer ... woebetide you if you don't speak Hungarian or Croatian. You're gonna have to find someone who does and get them to file a tax return for you. This is a consequence of amazon and apple (and probably others) all "shipping" their digital goods from Luxembourg or Ireland and paying basically no tax at all - the Luxembourg government is accused of actually helping companies to exploit that loophole. This worked for Luxembourg or Ireland because they leverage that a little tax on many sales translates to still fairly high earnings per capita if you just have a small enough population. Basically both countries were siphoning off taxes from the higher population countries (france, germany, poland, GB, ...) in the EU. This used to be legal, but was clearly a loophole - and one that unfairly was only available to larger companies. So that one was closed - rightfully so - by stating that the sale for digital-only goods takes place in the country of the buyer. (as it's always been for services rendered to companies btw, look up reverse charge). Things are now a bit harder for everybody that sells digital goods to Hungary obviously, but there's no need to speak Hungarian or pay somebody that does. Any company will have some sort of tax accountant and cross border tax affairs are their bread and butter. Small-scale businesses can register their foreign tax at their home tax/revenue service. It's certainly a nuisance, but please blame the ones that are responsible: The larger corporations that try and exploit every possible angle to save money.
- mike_hearn 10y agoCountries charging different tax rates is not a loophole and that's the entire problem the EU has: some countries can't compete with the lower tax areas for cultural reasons. Unless you think Luxembourg is some sort of anarchist hellhole, of course.
- Xylakant 10y agoArtificially changing the point of sales for digital goods is a loophole. It used to be legal, no question, but there's no particular reason why sales for digital goods should be treated differently from sales of physical goods. That was clearly not intended. It's also not only about cultural reasons: It's the size of the population that matters. Luxembourg has about 500k inhabitants. If they collect all sales digital good in the european union and charge a mere percent of vat on it, they'll increase their tax base significantly. In contrast, if Germany does so it has a more than two orders of magnitude less gain on that. That's why it pays of for Luxembourg, even if they damage the rest of the EU in the process. It's like Washington DC collecting all sales tax for digital goods in the US. Basically some small countries are freeloading at cost for the whole community. (See also the British Tax Havens, or Canal Islands)
- hvalika 10y agoI don't entirely disagree with your post but I generally avoid calling these loopholes. It is all about finding the mismatch between two countries -- For example, if a little kid asks his dad if he can go to the movies, and dad replies "go ask mom, do what she says" and the kid then asks mom and mom says "whatever dad said" it doesn't mean that you are necessarily finding a loophole. Either party is essentially deferring and the benefit is caught in between. Works out well for the kid but at the end of the day, the parents probably should have had better communication and figured out what to do.