5 ms·
"Far right" has become a synonym for racist/anti-immigration, but it's important to note that many of these parties aren't actually right wing parties in any ot
by mrweasel 10y ago
"Far right" has become a synonym for racist/anti-immigration, but it's important to note that many of these parties aren't actually right wing parties in any other sense.
Parties like "Dansk Folkeparti" in Denmark is pretty much Social Democrats, except they are harder on immigration. Leaving out the anti-immigration part, I would say that most of these parties are still to the left of both the Republican and Democratic party in the US.
- golemotron 10y agoIt's a question whether many of them are actually racist too. People use 'racist' to marginalize discussion of cultural preferences.
- kristopolous 10y agoPeople aren't careful with the word racism. Claiming an inherent inferiority of a group of people or advocating for a seperate set of laws to be carved out, that's racism. For instance, police profiling or apartheid are real world, dictionary defined "racist" things. Using offensive language or mentioning someone by they're physical description is not. It's at best rude, but it's not a "racist" act. On the contrary, racism often comes on the backs of calm language with charts and graphs.
- ninjin 10y agoThere are many issues with the one-dimensional left-right scale, but it is undeniable that they are right-wing in their strong social conservatism and nationalism. Note that there are also differences within these parties. An excellent example would be the Sweden Democrats, where a portion of the party is very much like what you describe, somewhat social democrat. While their youth organisation recently had a hard split due to its leader ship being essentially neo-fascist, which proved to be anathema for the main party.
- coldtea 10y ago>There are many issues with the one-dimensional left-right scale, but it is undeniable that they are right-wing in their strong social conservatism and nationalism. The USSR was conservative socially and nationalistic. Those are by no means a sign of being "right wing".
- AimHere 10y agoStalin was considered right-wing by other communists, and the mainstream Communist Party would often be described as such by those who lived in the Soviet Union. I'm not sure if Orwell actually used the term for the Stalinist Communist Party but he definitely had a problem with their anti-revolutionary stance in, for example, the Spanish Civil War.
- andybak 10y ago> There are many issues with the one-dimensional left-right scale I think you've rather reinforced this point. A common 'improvement' is to have a two-axis system: http://www.politicalcompass.org/ http://www.politicalcompass.org/ But even this is problematic. In some cases it's purely a historical accident that certain views have been bundled together. There's no innate coherent ideology at work - despite attempts to construct one.
- varjag 10y agoUSSR was not nationalistic, it was trying to stomp out any signs of nationalism in fact. Up to 1940s the party viewed its population as mere expendable material to jump start world revolution; only after WW2 Stalin wound Komintern movement down. Social conservative is questionable too. The churches were burnt down and the old elites massacred. At the earliest period abolishment of family was seriously discussed (per the tenets of the Manifesto). The shakedowns arguably settled only after 1960s.
- ptaipale 10y ago>USSR was not nationalistic It sure was. It tried to play down internal factions of course, but it used to the full such terms as Вели́кая Оте́чественная война́ "Great Patriotic War" or РОДИНА "Rodina", and if you look at the propaganda posters, they look remarkably similar to those of the Nazis. http://www.rferl.org/media/photogallery/24934238.html http://www.rferl.org/media/photogallery/24934238.html Soviet leadership destroyed churches as the church was a competing power base. But otherwise the Stalinist system was in many ways socially conservative. Look at its attitudes towards homosexualism, or ethos of work morale.
- toyg 10y agoThe original Fascism (as well as National-Socialism aka Nazism) was quite hot on certain forms of socialism -- Mussolini was originally a socialist. They advanced welfare, were not shy about nationalising industries, and were in fact quite good for large sectors of the population -- hence their popularity in spite of violence and otherwise appalling beliefs. The establishment in both Italy and Germany originally built alliances with these movements only because they were seen as "better than the reds", because of their nationalism and belief in strong hierarchies (whereas socialists and communists were internationalist and against hierarchies back then). They didn't necessarily like a lot of their social programs. Leaving out the anti-Jewish thing, Hitler and Mussolini were very much on the left of both the Republican and Democratic party in the US (today as well as yesterday).
- MrBuddyCasino 10y agoExactly. Nazi stands for "national socialism", exploiting our tendency towards ingroup/outgroup thinking combined with financial advantages and a strong feeling of belonging and purposes for the members of the ingroup, at the expense of some minority. Its historically interesting though that the capitalists were generally supporters of the nazi party, even before the times of slave labour and war time profits. I guess social darwinism was a good match for the capitalist competition mindset.
- pluma 10y agoInstead of elaborating why the tired "Nazi stands for 'national socialist'" meme is irrelevant I'll just link to the early history of the DAP/NSDAP (the Nazi Party) on Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_Party#Origins_and_early_existence:_1918.E2.80.931923 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_Party#Origins_and_early_e... To summarize: they were initially just called the "German Worker's Party" and had a strong basis in the middle-class. They weren't interested in socialism (i.e. social ownership of capital) but merely in profit sharing (i.e. paying workers better). Their leaders were nationalist, anti-Semitic and racist pretty much from day one -- which is also why they were categorically opposed to communists and other (anti-national or non-nationalist) socialists. The entire party can be explained as a radical reaction to the fallout from WW1 in Germany: economy in ruins, political lack of power, basically Euro-crisis Greece but significantly worse because everybody hated them and there wasn't an international union trying to fix them. The reason capitalists liked the NSDAP was that there literally wasn't much capitalisting to do in Germany without first re-asserting Germany's political (and military) power in Europe -- and that's one of the main things the NSDAP tried to do. Though I'm sure Jewish or non-anti-Semitic (remember: before WW2 anti-Semitism was socially acceptable) capitalists weren't too thrilled about the rampant anti-Semitism.
- vlehto 10y agoAlso most of these "far right" parties currently getting media coverage, seem to be more left than average european politician.
- mrweasel 10y agoI don't know about the eastern European one, but it's certainly true for some those in northern Europe.
- doppel 10y agoI cannot speak for right wing parties in general, but "Dansk Folkeparti" is very much like social democrats on paper, but their votes reveal a different, right-leaning agenda (to the detriment of a big portion of their voters who are voting for someone to take care of the "little people").
- adrianN 10y agoI think racist and anti-immigration are two different things. Most racists probably are against immigration, but not everybody who is against immigration is racist.
- TorKlingberg 10y agoThese parties are definitely socially conservative. Just check what they think about same-sex marriage. Dansk Folkeparti is also against the separation of church and state.
- IshKebab 10y agoWhen you really look at it, it's about greed vs empathy. I think most left-right political beliefs fall nicely on that spectrum, even if they don't seem to at first. On the very far left everything is totally fair and each person does what they can to help everyone else (in theory). Then you have the more reasonable left, where welfare systems help the less fortunate, because it's the moral thing to do. As you move toward the right you start to see people wanted to keep what they have for themselves, hence low taxes, and no spending state money no helping others (e.g. Obamacare). Finally in the very far right you have people who don't even want to share their country. They were born there thank you very much and fuck you if you weren't.