8 ms·
Grandparents raising children is in line with human biology
- smegel 10y agoHow do you write an article like this without some level of cross-cultural analysis, especially regarding Asian and Chinese culture in particular? Bizarre.
- jessaustin 10y agoYou don't find the Hadza colorful enough? It's not as though contemporary Chinese culture contradicts TFA's hypothesis.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoIndeed! I think there's a valuable lesson to be learned here: among the Hadza studied by ... every nursing mother is supported by a post-menopausal helper, nearly always her mother or mother-in-law.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoRather the opposite. 妈妈生,外婆养,外公天天菜市场, 爸爸回家就上网,爷爷奶奶来欣赏。
- zhemao 10y agoHaha, I haven't heard that piece of doggerel before. Where's it from? It sounds like my cousin. She just recently had a kid but it's mostly my aunt who takes care of the baby. Also similar to what my early childhood was like before we moved to the states. Except my maternal grandfather passed away shortly after I was born and there was no internet back them. I think the funniest thing is that it suggests that the modern Chinese family is uxorilocal when it's traditionally been virilocal.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoIt was told to me by a Shanghainese woman. The same woman said that often the grandparents will move in with the parents to care for a child, rather than the other way around.
- zhemao 10y agoAhaha, I knew it. My family is Shanghainese, and I was born and spent the first three years of my life there, so that makes sense.
- Turing_Machine 10y agoIt's also suggestive that human grandparents are famously concerned with the well-being of their grandchildren. This is, I think, about as near to a cultural constant as there is. Yeah, there's probably some weird culture where grandparents don't get involved, but I can't think of one offhand. Certainly it's true for all the European and Asian cultures with which I'm familiar. I can't think of another species where grandparents take a special interest in their grandchildren (as opposed to, say, a generic interest in the young of the herd as a whole). Are there any?
- oh_sigh 10y agoSure - bonobos and other chimps for example
- jonmc12 10y agoIn a recent article "Why Aging isn't Inevitable" (http://nautil.us/issue/36/aging/why-aging-isnt-inevitable http://nautil.us/issue/36/aging/why-aging-isnt-inevitable), the author suggested that the the "Grandmother Hypothesis" sounds reasonable, "but a number of demographic researchers have found that when they do the numbers, it’s hard to make it work". He suggests an alternate theory: "An older, “retired” segment of the population, we argued, serves to keep the population stable over cycles of feast and famine."
- sunstone 10y agoFor those who are skeptical consider this. Human females (and males) are reproductively capable at 15 and yet who would consider them mature and capable parents at that age? On the other hand women have a difficult and increasingly difficult time getting pregnant from late 30's onward. And yet most women of that age would be very capable parents. What is the evolutionary explanation that the optimal physical age of reproduction is so skewed compared the optimal emotional age of reproduction? It just doesn't make sense unless young parents are not the primary caregivers to their children.
- Erik816 10y agoConsider that modern life is very different from the vast majority of evolutionary history that framed how we developed. In a modern, affluent society, a 50 year old woman would have little problem successfully raising a newborn. On the African Savanah, would that same 50 year old woman do just as well? Or would she on average find that she could not raise her children as well as the 20 year old mothers? I'm guessing the latter. Life was not as easy and it was likely much shorter on average. In a more primitive society, if a newborn's mother dies, that newborn probably has very low survival odds. Older women could definitely still have played an important role in raising children in the context of the family/tribe, but I see clear evolutionary advantages to having your children while younger, because you are simply more likely to be alive to raise them.
- LionessLover 10y ago> it was likely much shorter on average The average includes a huge number of deaths of children and of mothers though - not counting those risks (childhood, especially the very early one, and giving birth) it's higher than most people think. In a lecture on microbes (http://www.gresham.ac.uk/lectures-and-events/return-of-the-microbes-how-infections-are-once-more-taking-over http://www.gresham.ac.uk/lectures-and-events/return-of-the-m...) the professor mentions as an aside that a late Victorian British citizen after excluding those risks actually had a slightly longer life-expectancy than a modern British citizen! While that is fairly recent it still is long before modern medicine and antibiotics. Quote: > And what is interesting, if you take out the childhood mortality, the Victorian person between 1850 and 1880 lived slightly longer, if he was a male, than you do today. ("if he was male": giving birth was very risky) So it seems that good food (variety plus enough of it) and hygiene did most of the job of extending life-expectancy outside the above two risks - and modern medicine very significantly lowered childhood and birth (mother) deaths. In the light of such evidence modern medicine does not seem to have had a great effect on life expectancy once you made it past childhood. We can't do anything against "aging".
- galois198 10y agoI've always thought that grandmothers babysitting their grandchildren is somewhat unfair - in effect they're raising kids twice. They should have a rest in their later years.
- mchaver 10y agoWouldn't the biological assumption be that the grandmother was raised by her grandmother?
- andyjdavis 10y agoThat logic doesn't hold if every generation of parents has their parents raise their children. You get to have your kids and have your parents do a lot of the hard work. Then when your kids have kids you become the primary caregiver. Regardless of whether everyone has their parents act as their children's caregiver or whether they act as their own children's caregiver as long as every generation does the same you are only primarily responsible for raising one round of children. Its just a matter of whether you do it when you are younger or older.
- golemotron 10y agoMany enjoy it.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- golemotron 10y agoI find it exquisitely humorous that the article title is "What Good Is Grandma?", it speaks only about grandmothers and female biology, yet it is posted here as "Grandparents raising children is in line with human biology" That's one level of PC beyond the site's addition of the subtitle: 'The growing role of grandparents in raising children is right in line with human biology" for an article that, again, is solely about female biology. When will the reality of sex-based differences be presented unapologetically?
- i_cannot_hack 10y agoIt is taken right from the subtitle of the article, probably as that was a lot more descriptive than "What Good Is Grandma?". It also had to be shortened to fit within the 80 character limit. It was probably not carefully constructed to eradicate the notion of sex differences. Furthermore, the current trend the article refers is a trend where more and more grandparents are raising children, not solely grandmothers, which explains the wording. It's funny how paranoid people get when it comes to political correctness. But you don't need to worry Golemotron, I promise you there's no feminist under your bed.
- golemotron 10y ago> I promise you there's no feminist under your bed. Actually, there is one. He's very noisy.
- SolarNet 10y agoAnother solution, besides the natural one of bringing grandparents back into the equation, for solving overworked parents, could be larger mixed age family units, e.g. polyamory (to preempt, you use the same incest rule as for existing parents, no marrying your children).
- known 10y agoExperience is the name everyone gives to their mistakes.
- SlashmanX 10y agoThere's actually a situation in Ireland at the moment where grandparents were looking after their grandchild for the past 4 years or so due to the mother having mental issues, but the foster system took the child away because the grandparents are too old (60 year age gap). This is despite school principals and doctors etc saying they were perfect for the child and moving him away from them would be severely detrimental to his development. Really sad to see.
- baldfat 10y agoIn the States it is based first on biological lines. If the parents are capable to take care fo the children and are in their late 70s the state will keep the children there with them.
- w__m 10y agoI can totally agree. Humans are most fertile around early twenties, but as a young (23) parent I'd say it is not the best age to actually raise children. We're impatient. We have much "explosive" energy, the kind not really suitable for watching a newborn for hours. We can now have beautiful and very healthy babies easily, but Grandma is way better sitter than us for most of the day - more experienced, more calm, comfortably retired by now :) And I do belive it is the natural way. Better than kindergarten.
- pbhjpbhj 10y ago>not really suitable for watching a newborn for hours // Traditionally you'd put the baby in some sort of sling/papoose/carrier and do pretty much what you'd normally do but with extra breaks for feeding etc.. Children learn by seeing and imitating, in a few years they can be productive parts of the family/tribe. IME children need lots of energy put in to their upbringing. My kids ages span a decade - I'm far less able to give the youngest the active upbringing I feel he needs than I was for his older siblings. Mind you in this sort of scenario there would be much shared responsibility and lots of people to carry/teach/feed/entertain/etc.. What's not better than kindergarten?
- baldfat 10y agoFoster / Adoptive Parent here: > Today’s grandparents are doing exactly what their biology has prepared them for. Prepares for them to take care of their children's child due to their inability to care and protect their own child? This paper/article doesn't talk about the biology/evolution influence of how so many people don't care for their own off spring. I have had children who's grandmother took a knife to her (Her mom was off in the world of drugs), while I had my future son (He had terminal cancer) the father beat the biological mother to death with a baseball bat, and I have had a biological uncle one block from my house and he never once came to even see his nephew (The father (his brother) was less then 200 miles away and never saw his son past year 4). I get the argument but there is plenty of reasons of equal importance in asking why so many parents are giving way to grandparents in child rearing. We have a Foster System due to the inability of Grandparents to take care of the children. If they could the system would be 10% of what it currently is today.