9 ms·
The Dark Art of Mastering Music
- amelius 11y agoI personally think we should be able to buy music in its pre-mastered form. Yes, that will be a lot of data, but nowadays that is not really an issue anymore. The experience will be so much better than our current option, which is basically only the EQ settings on our amps.
- dcacaac 11y agoIt would be nice for me to get individual master tracks for sampling purposes. I would pay for access too, but I've never even seen that as an option.
- discohead 11y agoThis is exactly what the Stems music format is all about: http://www.stems-music.com http://www.stems-music.com
- programLyrique 11y agoStems is only four tracks. That certainly works well for "standardized contemporary music for DJ" but it doesn't sound it is a universal format for all kind of music.
- ssharp 11y agoMight just be a terminology thing, but I don't think mastering engineers work off of tracks. I think they're given mixdowns and adjust from there. There are some fascinating isolated tracks out there, but I wonder if knowing that stems will get released will push things in the studio even deeper into the territory that every recorded note must be perfect. Making a record already produces a lot of self conscious anxiety that affects your decision making, so knowing that people will also be listening to and analyzing your individual tracks is even worse!
- SyneRyder 11y agoThat's something that indie bands could consider, and would be an easy addition to a Super Deluxe fan edition of a release. I also wish more bands would release instrumental mixes of their albums, like Imogen Heap, Celldweller & Blue Stahli have done. Sometimes I want to listen to an album while I work but the vocals are distracting. I've been happy to pay a few dollars extra to get the instrumental versions when available, it's an easy way for indie bands to make some extra money from fans.
- cr1895 11y agoYou'd prefer no mastering over well-done mastering?
- blackhole 11y agoSo, from the comments here, it seems that people are under the impression that mastering engineers work off of the individual instrument tracks (the stems). This is not true. The article itself explains that a mixing engineer takes the individual tracks and mixes them. The final mixdown is then sent to the mastering engineer. It's called "mastering" because this stage of processing happens on a single track - the master track. Buying music in a pre-mastered form would still be a single lossless file, which is no different from Bandcamp allowing you to download the final lossless mastered version. The pre-mastered tracks will just sound worse and have wildly different volume levels depending on how they're normalized. If you want the actual stems of the song, that would actually be the music in it's pre-mixed form. It wouldn't even be mixed at that point, let alone mastered.
- whatok 11y agoYeah, there seem to be very definitive statements in these comments without a basic understanding of the recording process. I wonder if these are the same people who swear they can tell the difference between various playback formats or when they use gold XLR cables.
- Sephiroth87 11y agoApart from the misunderstanding, I think it would be actually interesting if you could buy the un-mastered version, plus "mastering" files to use depending on your setup (e.g.: crappy headphones, car stereo, home stereo), but that would require multiple mastering sessions and wouldn't probably be very cost effective... Or you could crowd-source them but then it might go against the creators intentions...
- BugsBunnySan 11y agoIn a different field (digital cinema) the above is being done for color, lookup the ACES colorspace and workflows... (Very) Basically the camera's recording goes through a process to make it into a standardized ACES colorspace. It will then being processed by editing, VFX, grading, etc... and then there's output transforms from ACES for each output device, like a cinema projector, a home TV or a mobile phone. And yes, AFAIR, that does need grading for each targeted output device, because of how we see and perceive color depending on the environment we're in... It would be awesome (EDIT: to have something like that) for music as well
- whatok 11y agoI don't understand how unmastered tracks would be a lot of data. Can you explain? Also, I cannot imagine wanting to mess around with EQs for each track on an entire unmastered album. That sounds like a huge burden.
- 21 11y agoMaybe he meant pre-mixing instead of pre-mastering, ie - having all the individual tracks. But that would require special playback software, more akin to a DAW.
- whatok 11y agoEven given that misconception, I don't understand how that would equate to a better listening experience.
- 21 11y agoThere are some songs where I hate a particular instrument, or I would like another one to be louder. So I can see why this would appeal to some (limited) group.
- programLyrique 11y agoWhat you want is a kind of multi-track audio format. Some exist: http://news.traxsource.com/articles/1754/stems-announced-at-wmc-2015 http://news.traxsource.com/articles/1754/stems-announced-at-... only four tracks dedicated to designated instruments. I've also heard of iklax http://www.iklax.com/ http://www.iklax.com/
- ssharp 11y agoIt would be fun for other recording professionals and hobbyists, to deconstruct a record, and maybe some super fans, but overall it seems like something people wouldn't care that much about. But how granular would that get? Would I be able to listen to one of 50+ layered distorted guitar tracks on "Siamese Dream"? Would anyone want to do that?
- cr1895 11y agoRelevant: the Dynamic Range database http://dr.loudness-war.info/ http://dr.loudness-war.info/
- austinjp 11y agoThis is great, thanks. Handy write-up on what "dynamic range" means in practice here: https://www.soundonsound.com/sos/sep11/articles/loudness.htm https://www.soundonsound.com/sos/sep11/articles/loudness.htm
- radiowave 11y agoMastering is a subject about which a great deal of mumbo jumbo is talked, but a very important point that this article does put across well is the necessity of making sure the music sounds good across a wide variety of playback environments. Unfortunately, this kind of "optimizing for all cases" comes at the expense of how good the music can sound in any one environment. (For example, a lot of people will have heard recordings that produce incredibly detailed spacial perception, but only when listened to on headphones - and which sound pretty poor on loudspeakers.) We got into this situation because of the economies of mass produced physical media, but we largely don't have those constraints any more. Since the cost of digital distribution is basically a rounding error, we could be producing different releases optimized for different settings and letting the listener choose which is the most appropriate for them.
- mbenjaminsmith 11y ago> Unfortunately, this kind of "optimizing for all cases" comes at the expense of how good the music can sound in any one environment. Sorry, but that's not the case. The reason music gets mastered poorly today is because of poor mastering engineers. I've had this conversation numerous times with an engineer that has designed some of the most well-received studio equipment (including analog compressors) ever made. Listen to The Dark Side of the Moon. Regardless of your like or dislike of Pink Floyd that album sounds good regardless of how you're playing it (car stereo, single speaker boom box, headphones). Now why there aren't many good mastering engineers left (or properly equipped studios) is a separate, lengthy conversation.
- radiowave 11y agoI'm certainly not claiming it's the reason why music gets mastered poorly today, only that things like representation of space, dynamic range, audibility of fine detail vs. making the music sound too cluttered, are and always have been trade-offs. As far as why things are worse lately, mastering engineers are working for hire. If people think they're producing bad work, it's probably at their client's behest.
- forgetsusername 11y ago
- dunk010 11y agoThere's a good article from 2001 which explains this in depth: http://www.cdmasteringservices.com/dynamicrange.htm http://www.cdmasteringservices.com/dynamicrange.htm
- 21 11y ago> Professional audio engineers operate out of carefully calibrated rooms designed to eradicate odd resonances and echoes, and their speakers cost more than your car. That is not exactly true. I've seen many pictures from studios and most engineers use professional speakers (called studio monitors) in the $5K range. However you can spend a lot more on acoustic treatments, they make a massive difference. I like to think that color-grading, another mysterious dark art (to me at least), is the visual equivalent of mastering.
- krenoten 11y agoPitchfork is not a publication that is targeted at software engineers.
- jdietrich 11y agoDecent nearfields cost $4-5k a pair. A proper pair of main monitors from the likes of PMC or Quested cost $50k to $150k. It's easy to overlook the main monitors, because they tend to be recessed in the walls. http://vintageking.com/pmc-loudspeakers-qb1-pair http://vintageking.com/pmc-loudspeakers-qb1-pair http://vintageking.com/quested-hm415-active http://vintageking.com/quested-hm415-active
- kowdermeister 11y agoDefine decent. You can buy a pair of Mackie from the MR series from about $500. That good enough for a long period till you learn what you are doing. Audio gear has the tendency that the value you get with more bucks decreases exponentially.
- spdustin 11y agoIf you haven't learned what you're doing, you're not the professional audio engineer referred to by TFA :)
- kowdermeister 11y agoThat's true, all I'm saying is that you don't have to pop $4k on a monitor speaker, you can buy decent ones for 1/10th of the price.
- bvm 11y ago> Traditionally, the “marketplace” has been radio, where a well-mastered song hits that sweet spot where you feel immersed in the music but not battered by it. If your song is poorly mastered, the logic goes, people won’t want to buy your album. Part of the problem here is that many radio stations will run incredibly aggressive limiters/maximisers across their output bus anyway, for the exact same reasons given in the following paragraph. Your average pop track is being compressed to hell and back at three stages: mixing (gotta make that synth subgroup 'pop'), mastering (gotta be louder than my rival pop-group) and transmission (gotta be louder than my rival station).
- ssharp 11y agoTo be fair, almost all cases where you're listening to FM radio, you're listening on a crappy device. I remember having Sirius in two of my previous vehicles and not noticing it being that poor of sound quality from low digital compression rates, compared to CD's or what I'd get from my iTunes on my phone. However, in my current vehicle which has a pretty solid factory system, the digital artifacts are exceptionally glaring. When you're on a bad system, some of the compression or limiting happening to the track is either a positive or not noticeable.
- bvm 11y agoHave heard some arguments that the UK's (world's?) digital protocol, DAB is actually a worse experience for listeners than a decent FM station, but I'm not all that well informed on that. Quick clarification on digital versus the kind of compression discussed in the article: with the former you're making the file size smaller and losing a little bit of quality in the process (sometimes leaving artifacts), whereas with the latter you are seeking to make the loud bits quieter, meaning you can make the whole lot louder without distortion. Another thing worth noting is that for the vast majority of users, the car will be the best listening environment they are exposed to. When I had a very minor foray into the recording world, I remember the mix engineers trying out bouncedowns around the car park.
- ssharp 11y ago
- neilh23 11y agoIt's hard getting something that sounds consistently good in all listening environments - I've seen cases where music is offered in digital format either as 'play anywhere' loud .mp3s or 24-bit high dynamic-range .flacs for DJs, but most commercial music is mastered for the poorest environments (in the car, over the radio). Getting a good master is very important - I'm reminded of a story I heard about an album that was mastered by the artist, and pressed to CD with a high-pitched whine over the top which the artist hadn't been able to hear - like Aphex Twin's Ventolin, but unintentional.
- Nav_Panel 11y ago> most commercial music is mastered for the poorest environments (in the car, over the radio). One thing to consider (at least, that I consider when mastering my own music) is what processing might be applied in the future. I helped out at the radio station back in college, and you can see the signal chain for audio coming from the studio onto the airwaves. Radio stations often add at least 9 dB of gain via compression, sometimes more. So, if you want a quick and dirty "how does my track sound on the radio?" toss on a master limiter and give yourself 12 dB of gain, then see whether it sounds as you intend (then don't forget to remove the gain after you've made your tweaks). > a story I heard about an album that was mastered by the artist, and pressed to CD with a high-pitched whine over the top which the artist hadn't been able to hear Funnily enough, this was common in albums recorded in the 80s and 90s. Reason? CRT monitors were used in the studio, and the high-pitched sound of the screens would get picked up by the microphones. A little discussion here: http://forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/high-frequency-tones-on-songs-or-albums.235050/ http://forums.stevehoffman.tv/threads/high-frequency-tones-o...
- disantlor 11y agoCertain models of SSL consoles could produce a ~15khz ringing in the master output. I had this exact thing happen to me, and eventhough my hearing good enough to hear it clearly once I was paying attention, in the middle of working I didn't notice it at all, until I got home. I heard that it happened on some Peter Gabriel records (he was famously a fan of SSL consoles). Probably wouldn't be too hard to remove in mastering, incidentally.
- 11y ago
- tacos 11y agoThere are online mastering services and the results are tragic. Take a couple devs who are into music and maybe have some math chops but no actual mixing/mastering experience and no access to real equipment either. A little open source software and some headphones will do. Now throw in a music industry "endorser" (these guys are always investing in the wrong companies!) and spew out some automated schlock. http://promasterhd.com/ http://promasterhd.com/ http://landr.com http://landr.com "Pro" this and "industry" that. The desperation is palpable. And often plainly visible in their faces: http://blog.masterlizer.com/index.php/2015/12/14/re-imagine-online-mastering-ready-to-masterlize/ http://blog.masterlizer.com/index.php/2015/12/14/re-imagine-... Regardless people always prefer "the louder one" so you can immediately see where this is headed. Generate a "mastered" .wav file using open source tools and a couple Python rules, convert it to MP3 without paying the license fee, then charge people $9 if they want the "higher quality" .wav. $14 if they want all 24 bits instead of you running it through ffmpeg a second time. Meanwhile SoundCloud streams 128k MP3s like we're stuck in 1992. Imagine if Vimeo or Flickr limited stuff to an equivalent lossy compression quality. People would not stand for it. But with audio it's somehow okay. Now all we have to do is combine the two. Say... robo-mastered junk being served up as a SoundCloud MP3. Coming soon!
- cr1895 11y ago>Meanwhile SoundCloud streams 128k MP3s like we're stuck in 1992. Imagine if Vimeo or Flickr limited stuff to an equivalent lossy compression quality. People would not stand for it. But with audio it's somehow okay HD screens are pretty much ubiquitous. Headphones (or speakers) that aren't trash I would guess less so.
- thebigspacefuck 11y agoGood headphones are essential. I've had a number of tracks/albums where I've listened to them on my computer with nice headphones, then gone to the gym with my portable headphones or driven home listening over the speakers and the songs sound terrible. I've often wondered if the rise of some genres has been due to shitty mp3 quality and even shittier earbuds.
- rudolf0 11y agoVery true. I've also had the opposite experience. Bad speakers/headphones can hide flaws. On good headphones, sibilant frequencies, compression artifacts, and muddy bass can all become really apparent and annoying.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoA neat read I think, even touches on LANDR, a new-ish and pretty compelling service. I've only tried it once but it worked as intended - tweaked a file, made a difference. Improved? Too subjective, but a tentative yes. I do take such an article with a grain of salt though, because a lot of the "tightest" sounding music since 2010 - in my PERSONAL opinion - is in drum & bass and, more than likely, not run through too much outboard gear like is romanticized here. Smart routing in Ableton and into iZotope isn't outside the reach of intelligent, determined artists and producers of many stripes. I just tend to think "Oh, yeah Grimes sounds pretty good, so does Radiohead, but compared to what's happening in a Netsky or Camo & Krooked track, just different ballparks altogether." Like I said, that's me and my ears. Having great outboard gear can truly make a difference if the source material is great.
- kowdermeister 11y agoAs a bedroom producer, I have to add that good mixing (carefully tuning each audio channel to remove frequencies that interfere with another channel) is more important than mastering. Mastering adds the finishing touches, but can't really fix mixing errors. Also don't get fooled by opinions like this: “When you only use computer stuff, everything starts smearing together, and a whole other mechanical aspect that isn’t musical creeps in. But the better the quality of your gear, the more the thing will sound real.” Obviously high end gear sounds great, but that doesn't mean that digital plugins and emulations can't sound equally good. The only part where I see an advantage on the whole audio - digital debate is modulation, but that's a different stage of making music.
- patrickbolle 11y agobedroom producer here too ! the greatest thing about making music all in the box (or majority of it) is being able to mix on the go. majority of my tracks sound great (imo) before I even touch a limiter/mastering chain. lots of advice online says 'make the track and mix after' which is good if you are in the flow and can bust out a track in a day.. but if I make a synth sound I immediately mix it into the song and then start playing with chords
- kowdermeister 11y agoI also blended it into the workflow. It's really fast to add a high pass filter, set the gain and remove artifacts if needed. Part of sound design is mixing also for me. Before exporting I revisit all channels, but usually not much work left. It probably helps a lot that I do electronic music mostly.
- rudolf0 11y agoEveryone works differently. My problem is that if I start mixing as soon as I introduce a new synth, I get really obsessive and perfectionist over it and lose the big picture. At the moment, I try to just do some light sound design and mixing while building the track, then do the full mixing at the end.
- louthy 11y ago
- Benjamin_Dobell 11y agoThis is a long article that starts off stating that mastering is difficult to explain, and then proceeds to not explain mastering. They're implying that poor mastering was to blame for Metallica's album. Weren't people complaining it was over-compressed? That's mixing not mastering! Mastering is a matter of making sure that listening to an album from start to finish sounds consistent. That's why songs that go on compilation albums are mastered once on the original album, and again on the compilation - they most certainly aren't mixed again. Mastering may involve a small amount of compression across all components of the song (although it really shouldn't), but it's mostly controlling loudness, and loudness at different parts of the audio spectrum (more low-end, more high-end). Mastering is effectively something you could do yourself with your stereo's settings (if you were constantly adjusting the settings through-out the song), mixing is fundamentally different and consists of combining "tracks"; vocals, guitar, harmonies, drums, sound effects, adding samples over drums (i.e. mix in a better sounding drum, or hit there-of, over the drumming recorded for the song). EDIT: For clarity, me stating: > Mastering may involve a small amount of compression across all components of the song (although it really shouldn't) is my subjective opinion. Master-bus compression does happen regularly enough during mastering (in addition to during mixing), but as stated, it is typically only a small amount, compared to what a Mixing Engineer can get away with on a per "track" basis.
- disantlor 11y agoThat's a good explanation of the process and is true in theory/how it should be, but an inexperienced mastering engineer or a clueless band will limit the shit out of a recording. And that could absolutely result in a tinny, over-compressed product. I don't know what happened in Metallica's case, probably failures at different points of the chain.
- radiowave 11y agoIt's a good point that in general we can't know whether the problem lies (solely) with mastering, because we can't know what state the material was in when it was passed along from the mixing engineer.
- TylerE 11y agoOver compression usually happens at the mastering stage, not mixing. One of the few exceptions is Rush's Vapor Trails, which was recorded so hot there is clipping on some of the instrument tracks.
- diydsp 11y agoThis is just a one-time reminder that this whole magilla is about one kind of music: the recorded, mass-produced consumer object. Although it may seem large and important due to its ubiquity and market value, there's really much more to music than this. Music can sound good and be valuable 100% live with no mics, outdoors with no special architecture. The mastering engineering in the article espouses the virtue of unique equipment, but in a live band, nearly every instrument and every performance quickly becomes a unique one. Ask yourself, who does it really serve, to experience music as a lithographic impression rather than a unique experience? I'm not even arguing about musician's pay or anything like that. I'm talking about qualia of richness: diversity, local character, dynamic range, interplay with your mood, involvement, movement. My comment here is really to just break up the spontaneous hierarchy of dollars + equipment + mystery -> ideal studio product. Now that technology has empowered us all to make more music faster on our own I feel it's especially important to ditch the last century's mindsets of scarcity and monoculture with respect to music.
- SyneRyder 11y ago"Ask yourself, who does it really serve, to experience music as a lithographic impression rather than a unique experience?" A recording allows me to share a specific performance with someone else. It's like a painting, but in audio. I can tell someone how much I like the song Heart Shaped Box on Nirvana's In Utero album, and introduce them to that particular version I like. If my only option is to introduce them to the song at a concert, then they might end up with something like the version on Muddy Banks Of The Wishkah, which is a different experience. (In my opinion, an inferior one.) Live & unique performance of music has value too, and it's nice to have those fleeting moments that are only shared with the people who were with you at the time. But recording can be a great way to appreciate and enjoy the art itself.
- goldbrick 11y agoI seldom see such hippie bullshit espoused on HN outside of Bitcoin/Ethereum threads. Music can sound good and be valuable in any setting: it can sound better with good audio engineering. It serves everyone to have a high quality artifact. > technology has empowered us all to make more music faster on our own That's not what I want; that's not what any of us wants.
- alistproducer2 11y agoI see the "loudness wars" are still raging. Way back when I was a recording engineer (early 2000's) I remember reading about it for the first time. I had this "a ha" movement. Until then, I couldn't put my finger on why I got fatigued listening to certain albums: even one's where I liked the content of the songs. Now if a record is over-compressed I don't even bother(sorry Foo Fighters, get your shit together). Also, stay away from "remastered" version of old albums. That really means they've over compressed it and killed all of the dynamic range of an album you previously loved.
- golergka 11y agoFor a bedroom producer/DJ, LANDR is a godsend. When you have 10 2-minute drafts, each of which was complete in an hour or two, and want to take them for a test-drive in your next gig, before LANDR you had to spend an additional 20-30 minutes per each of them, to get them into a reasonably compressed and loud shape, so you won't have to desperately ride levels and eq from track to track in front of the crowd. And $15 per month for unlimited demos and drafts is a very sweet price point compared to even the cheapest mastering engineers.
- rudolf0 11y agoSure, but you get what you pay for. In both cases.
- SyneRyder 11y agoCouldn't you do much of that just by using presets in mastering software like Izotope Ozone 7? I don't really understand the benefit LANDR offers, unless there really is some secret sauce in the settings LANDR chooses automatically. But if that's the case, I imagine Ozone will features similar functionality soon.
- golergka 11y agoFirst of all, Ozone costs a lot more. Second, every time you're using a tool with a lot of settings you find yourself reaching to tweak them — which is one of the reasons why in making music it's often better to use minimalistic tools that don't offer too many options. And finally, judging by the results I'm getting, LANDR is more "intellectual" that Ozone and tweaks it's settings depending on many properties of the source track.
- _greim_ 11y agoMastering is like buying good wine. There's a lot return for your buck at the low and medium end. The returns begin diminishing steeply in the high end. Above some point, it becomes purely a game of audio engineers impressing other audio engineers.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoEdit: Whoops wrong thread. :)
- SyneRyder 11y agoI think you might've posted in the wrong thread, and actually meant to post here instead: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11754414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11754414
- giancarlostoro 11y agoThank you for catching that.
- riprowan 10y agoI always tell my clients that mastering is the final step in mixing: it's the part where the mix engineer gives the mix to a different engineer in a different studio with a different system and different ears and different gear and different opinions to put the final touches on the 2-track mix. The tools are almost always various flavors of EQ and compression, but the most important part is all the "different" stuff. The loudness wars of the late 1990s and continuing somewhat today I believe are a relic of CD (and FM) audio and will pass now that we have ubiquitous volume leveling playback devices. It's well understood in audio (and demonstrable in ABX testing) that "louder sounds better." If your CD is mastered a little louder than the other guys, then when you change it (or when your CD jukebox changes it) then your CD will "pop out" more, be heard better, and sound better. Enter volume leveling. When the playback device matches the playback volume of two songs, the one which is overcompressed will sound quieter and yet be more fatiguing, while the one which has better dynamics will actually feel louder and punchier yet be less fatiguing. Volume leveling actually stands "louder sounds better" on its head: louder will not sound better. In a strange way, iTunes / Replay Gain is helping to bring back audiophile mastering into vogue. And you can tell - mastering has definitely changed for the better in the last five years. There's a lot more attention to dynamics, especially with artists learning about having to master their digital audio for vinyl, and how that changes things. I wrote about the loudness war in 2002 in "Over the Limit"[0] and about the end of the loudness war in 2009 in "Over the Limit 2"[1]. In OtL2 I predicted it would be another decade - until 2019 - before the loudness war finally could be declared over. From what I've seen I think I'm on track to hit my prediction. I'm glad. [0] http://riprowan.com/over-the-limit/ http://riprowan.com/over-the-limit/ [1] http://riprowan.com/over-the-limit-2/ http://riprowan.com/over-the-limit-2/